Book Bans Have Tripled in the Last Year! | Episode 115 | Book News
PEN America has uncovered a disturbing trend in our latest findings: more than 10,000 instances of book bans in U.S. public schools during the 2023-2024 school year, nearly tripling last year's number. These bans predominantly target stories about LGBTQ+ characters, people of color, and books addressing women's sexual experiences or sexual abuse. With this surge driven by new state laws and "parental rights" advocacy groups, PEN America is raising urgent alarms about the chilling impact on students' freedom to read.
DISCLAIMER: Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with the links that I provide I may receive a small commission. There is no additional charge to you!
Casey Mian welcome to the bookaholic
podcast thank you so much for having
me yes glad to have you here and today
we are talking about a very important
issue in America today um that seems to
have just Amplified itself so let's just
go ahead and dive into it last week
September the 22nd through the 28th was
National bamboo book week and we are
here to address the book Banning and why
and the how and what we can do about it
today um I think the pen America came
out to say that they saw um how many
thousands of instances it's tripled
since last year of book Banning
incidences that's exactly right so we
have been tracking book bands in public
schools um since 2021 and and we just
recently put out our report that is a
preliminary you know kind of a a
preliminary um memo we'll have the full
report later in November but the prelim
preliminary memo was able to show us
that um during the 2023 to 2024 school
year so officially you know last school
year um over the entire year we've
recorded over 10,000 book bands which is
triple what we had recorded the prior
year the 2022 to 2023 school year wow
that's astounding information so before
we dive into the book bands let's set
the tone for the audience to let them
know why and why pen America has the
authority to do so so first tell us a
little bit about pen
America sure so pen America is a
100-year-old nonprofit um our mission is
to sit at the intersection of literature
and human rights and defending free
expression in the United States and
worldwide um I am the program director
for our freedom to read program which is
one of our um one of several programs
that pen overseas that defends free
expression in the United States um so
for us the freedom to read program is
really defending the right to read it's
defending and protecting access to
diverse and inclusive literature in our
Public Schools primarily um but
certainly we also do some work in public
library systems as well oh wow so this
is very very very important and your
your title your job title you're the
director of the freedom to read program
so what do you do daytoday uh in in
protecting our rights to read yeah so
our freedom to read program is a
national advocacy campaign um that again
focuses on ensuring um you know lit
access to literature is is maintained
for students across the country in our
public schools and also for communities
in our public libraries um so our
program does a few things but um you
know kind of foundational to all that we
do is our research and this is what um
we just recently put out a memo in
September and then we have more work
following through November but within
our research we track every instance of
a book ban in public schools so this is
an immense amount of work it's quite
comprehensive um but we look to put we
look to quantify you know this movement
what's happening um and by by you know
tracking how and where books are being
banned um whether it's through you know
local groups that are putting pressure
on districts or state legislation um
that's causing districts to remove books
in Mass you know we put we were able to
quantify it um and and follow some of
the trends around what types of books
are being challenged what's the rhetoric
behind the book Banning movement and
then who or what are the drivers and the
pressures behind um book band so kind of
foundation is our research work and then
um we also have a pretty robust like
Communications advocacy strategy so this
is when we speak out on very specific
cases of book bands or um use you know
National focusing weeks like National
band Book Week to raise awareness um
about what's going on and continuously
you know communicate why this is an
issue and why we're seeing this threat
to the freedom to read playing out
across the country and then call folks
in to you know respond and stand up
against the um removal of
books wow wow wow well I'm so glad that
you exist first of all and so with that
said uh we've seen book Banning through
history I seem to remember back when I
was in school which was a uh Public
elementary and middle school and high
school which was about a thousand years
ago I seem to remember we covered uh
book bands you know throughout history
um maybe when we were studying the rise
of Hitler and the the they were burn
burning books at that time you know so
it's it's not new the Banning of books
it's not new but why do you think all
and I won't say all of a sudden why do
you think it's so pronounced why do you
think the jump uh and statistics last
year why do you think it's so pronounced
right now yeah so I mean you're
absolutely right we have and and Pen
America being a hundred-year-old
organization you know we always say
actually one time I was on a podcast and
I Ed the term unprecedented and a
historian kind of checked me and was
like it's not necessarily unprecedented
because we've been here before so you
know that's it's a very valid point we
kind of have these cyclical moments in
the United States where and nation and
you know internationally um where you
know the the um the call to suppress
become stronger um and certainly we we
see that and you know I think there's a
few reasons why uh this current movement
is is quite escalated um you know a lot
of this started quite locally but
because of um you know like social media
and the way in which we can all connect
with each other quickly we saw the way
in which tactics that we were that were
being applied in one District were then
mirrored and copycatted in like not even
another District nearby like another
District in a state across the country
um so there has been this this very
coordinated system of kind of this local
pressures that have been put on school
districts that I think have been um you
know kind of Amplified by the use of
social media and the the ease of which
we're able to share you know lists of
books to get challenged the reasons why
you might approach a school and
challenge a book The excerpts that are
pulled out of context that Challengers
can use um to see a book banned and you
know the way in which kind of these
tactics are shared rather quickly
because of the way in which we all share
information so easily now um I think
that's one piece of it and then the
other piece is that we have seen uh
increasingly legislation have a role
here so there are several states that
have enacted legislation um that bend
sensorial that have um the likely impact
of seeing Books banned and removed from
access um so that that kind of
accelerated what we had seen as really a
local movement to these Statewide
responses where districts across the
state may be responding now to
legislation and that takes a little bit
more time to undo you know those effects
as
well well I we're in an election year
that's an
understatement so you know and you just
kind of shed some light on um on this
subject matter about who we elect can
also work within this spectrum of what
we see leg legislatively of course um so
you know what is pin America doing while
we're in this you know legis when the
when this um whole voting you know um uh
cycle here whether it's local or
national we're in a big big uh voting
error right now and so what is pin
America doing right now before the
election to maybe counteract some of
this
yeah I mean I think a big piece of our
strategy is um you know we do
issue-based advocacy so you know part of
what we try to do is just raise
awareness that this is happening um you
know we need folks to know that books
are being removed and we're not you know
and that there's tons of um misused
rhetoric that's being applied that we
can all begin to debunk um so the more
we kind of debunk this this rhetoric
that's being tossed around the more we
can um acknowledge that this is an issue
that there are um threats to to students
Educational Learning and to their you
know right to access information that
are playing out nationally I think
that's you know that's a big piece of
our strategy to raise um awareness and
then you know to your point I mean I
think um we encourage everyone to
register to make sure you're to register
make sure you're registered and then get
out there and vote um and be sure to
vote up and down the ballot like we have
um we certainly have a sense you know
that school boards are um you know more
probably more political than they ever
have been before like often in the past
school board members were not actually
connected to a political party but we
see that how that has changed in recent
years um so just being aware that your
school board can have real implications
on again access to books and the type of
content and and learning um that your
student may have access to within a
public school same for your you know
County Library System all the way up um
to our highest offices so just really
engaging you know up and down the ballot
in our election season this year yes
most definitely now before I go back
into the um voting uh information that
um that I want to continue talking about
does do representatives from pen America
do you all Lobby do you all Lobby um
elected officials um do you all come you
know make an impact back locally and
visit uh libraries or school systems and
speak uh to the officials in those
capacities we are um so we are a
nonprofit
nonpartisan um organization so we do not
lobby but we certainly do Advocate on
behalf of again the freedom to read and
learn and and the areas in which um you
know we have identified as Mission
aligned in in defending and protecting
free expression in the United States um
so that looks like several different
things we certainly are are you know in
touch with legislatures and have um
endorsed different bills that we have
seen move through at the federal and
state levels that would protect the
freedom to read um we have opposed
legislation publicly that has been
harmful and restricting you know access
to books in public schools and public
libraries um and then perhaps most
importantly we work with so many other
organizations at different levels um so
we have really incredible coalitions
locally that we partner with to kind of
support and amplify what they're doing
at the you know district and state level
and we work with you know tons of
national organizations who are you know
likeminded in their defense of the right
to read and in their defense of free
expression um again in in raising
awareness and advocating for you know
positive legislation that protects the
freedom to read for repealing
legislation that is harmful um and
leading to book bans and you know
galvanizing you know local communities
at the you know at the loc District
level state level National level to um
you know stand up and oppose the
censorship of books right right exactly
exactly well going back to the election
cycle last night I was a volunteer at a
candidate forum and so we had
Representatives local Representatives uh
who were running for various office
whether it was our state senate uh or uh
state senate or Representatives or our
register of deeds and of course there
were two uh School Board uh
representatives there people who were
running for school board now School
boards as we all know is usually it's of
course a group of people probably an odd
number of Representatives varying from
uh County to County City to city and so
it was only two that showed up who were
running I don't know uh why the others
weren't present um it could be that
power was out because we've been
affected by Hurricane huland who knows
but anyway two people did show up who've
not been on the school board and are and
are running and so um the question and I
wish I would have raised this question
last night myself now one asked about
book Banning but to your uh just like
you said a little bit ago um that the
school board has become a very robust
there's a lot of people gunning for to
say to use a phrase to be on the school
board um because a lot of people were on
the school board who a lot of them who
children were are like total adults but
they're on the school board helping to
Pro uh prevent you know certain books
being read certain histories being told
and so I think that caused another group
of people to say oh we've got to be on
the school board so it is a very
competitive uh School Board which was
used to be such a boring thing is now a
very very serious serious matter uh for
people running for that office and um
you know definitely you know we need
that engage M but it came at a price of
you know a lot of disinformation a lot
of rhetoric and that's why we're we're
in this space what do you think about
that yeah I mean I think we have seen
the way in which school boards you know
have shifted a little bit and I can
imagine you and many of your followers
have even seen kind of the you know the
conflict moments that have shown up at
school boards over the last four years
certainly related to books but you know
lots of other topics have kind of come
to head um in school boards and yeah
school boards like many elected leaders
across the country have you know have
have um you know can be part of a
process that either protects the right
and freedom to read and freedom to learn
and ensures that um The Learning
Materials in a school are diverse and
representative of student body or they
can you know restrict and suppress and
take a more narrow ideological view of
what should be um available for students
so I mean even you know what you did
last night that's incredible to you know
show up to these kind of events and even
consider running you know for your
listeners consider running for your own
school board or just even get a sense of
who is on your school board right like
those are little things that we can all
do to just stay um engaged in in what in
what's happening across our Public
School Systems most most definitely well
now let's talk about the B the books
that have been banned and typically B
books that have been banned tell other
people's stories so people of color uh
lgbtq plus books um what other types of
books typically are
banned yeah I mean I think we see those
those two content areas as um sort of
overwhelmingly the target of attacks
when it comes to book Banning so books
that feature characters of color um
books that talk about race and race
racism as well as books that feature
lgbtq plus people or have themes of um
sexual identity and you know gender
identity and sexual orientation so those
tend to be you know kind of our two
biggest camps but um over you know since
this movement continues to progress we
do see like the swath of literature
that's getting caught up in this grow
larger with the movement so
increasingly um books that have you know
any depiction of violence but um
certainly violence against women so
sexual violence is a is an area that is
often targeted for removal as well um
books that have any sort of depictions
of sex um or you know sexual experiences
those often get targeted for removal too
um and then books that you know can also
talk about like sexual health and
well-being or um drug abuse and you know
sometimes when we step back and look at
like you know the the content of all
these books that are being challenged
challenged I mean kind of like the
through line is like this things that
make some people uncomfortable I guess I
don't know so um but we certainly see
you know kind of like overwhelmingly and
disproportionately attacks on certain
types of um content in in our school
libraries um and also important is of
course is you know when we think about
representative education you know books
that have you know storylines that
predominantly feature and put the you
know the that Center characters of color
and lgbtq plus people those have been
under represented in our Public Schools
so it it comes at a time where you know
schools are having um are bringing more
diverse and inclusive books into school
library systems to only be met with this
backlash to see those books removed
again yes most definitely now when I was
a little person in school I Remember My
Librarian Mrs Ashworth may she rest in
peace she just passed away this year and
uh she was like my grownup friend
because she was always recommending
these books to me and one of the most um
my favorites that she recommended to me
was are you there God it's me Margaret
by Judy Bloom and I love that book and I
was pleased to see that they made a
movie about it I did have not seen that
movie but the book is golden and it
taught me at that time a lot about
myself and I could identify in many ways
with that character so that book has
consistently been on a book band list um
because the girl is coming into her own
she's growing up you know she's she's uh
finding out about her body you know and
all of these different things and so
again consistently on the book Banning
list but tell us Casey if you can give
us an example of three books that people
don't realize you know that seem
perfectly okay and innocent but they
don't realize that they consistently
been on the book Banning
list sure oh I mean I could Pro I could
give more than three but you know I do
think Judy Bloom time yeah Judy Bloom I
think is a great example um are you
there got it's to me Margaret and then
her um you know her a novel that came
afterwards forever um um which is has
kind introduces sexual experiences
through the lens of um a young woman um
you know those two books and I've heard
Judy Bloom talk about it I've seen her
documentary but you know she too can
recognize like when and how her books
suddenly are being banned again this is
you know I think those books also
represent the books that so many
generations have read and yet we're
still seeing them challenge but we read
them we love them we have seen ourselves
in them and have learned from them um
and yet you know 20 30 years later they
continue to be um challenge books so
definitely those are those are two that
I think are worthy of calling out um you
know I love or I don't love I mean I
love picture books and I love books for
young people and I think when we look at
the picture books that are being
challenged I find that it really
illuminates you know what's happening um
in this at a larger scale around the
censorship of books and um this is
pretty well known by now but there's a
anango makes three is a book about two
penguins it's a true story about
penguins um that met at the New York
public the New York Zoo um adopted a
baby penguin and these two male penguins
like raised this baby penguin um and
that book is removed because and has
been banned all over um because of the
you know assumed lgbtq Plus or you know
orientation of the male penguins that
have adopted the baby penguins but it's
a picture book again it's a true story
it's sweet as pie it's about family um
it's about you know just just being in
community with others it's really and
it's about penguins um so that's always
one that you know you just it's just
shocking um wow yeah I miss that I
missed that totally first of all when
you said picture book I was like a
picture book band so my so I was not
thinking about picture books being
banned first of all the second thing is
that uh you said it's a true story so um
I mean if it if it's obviously saying it
was a true story I mean I can't
understand why it was banned but I have
to get my hands on that picture book
it's a good one you I have my stack
behind me so it's always a helpful place
to
reference wow I have to get
there have been um part of like the
early movement around the book bands uh
we saw the hate you give by Angie Thomas
yes band um and there been you know I
think I feel like that's always a good
one because so much of us like needed
that book at that time to kind of
understand and make sense of the world
around us and certainly young people did
um it also became a movie you know it
became it it was a such an accessible um
storyline for so many in a way in a time
that was that was quite necessary so you
know I we see kind of that also play out
like there are so many of these very
contemporary books that are directed
towards young people that have young
people as the main characters that are
often um you know sometimes are like
memor from authors themselves who are
telling their own stories that they feel
like they needed when they were growing
up um and to see those books band is
always you know shocks me as well most
definitely so let's wrap it up with
saying and you correct me if I'm
wrong Pan America wants to protect the
freedom to read
overall but you as a parent ultimately
can work with your child on what you
think is
appropriate in your home to read
correct correct even in schools I mean
one of the things that we point to all
the time is and Librarians will say this
in any opportunity they get there have
always been sensible systems for parents
to engage with their kids educator and
librarian to make sure that the
materials that they're accessing that
they're accessing in school are
appropriate are culturally um sensitive
like you know all there have been that
has been you know in place and
increasingly you know there have been
pretty robust systems in place to help
facilitate that exchange um um but we
have stopped having conversations like
we're not you know parents aren't coming
to talk to their educator librarian more
you know books are being challenged at
the district level and then access to
that book is being removed for all
students across a district um and that's
where we have you know issue and that's
also where you know it becomes more than
just a conversation around what is good
for your kid or not and more of like
well now we've suppressed literature on
a much larger scale for many families
and and students and you know even
Educators who might want that book as
like a resource for them um so yeah and
what what can uh what can parents or
what can individuals what can cat ladies
you know they they say cat ladies don't
you know have anything going for
themselves and they don't have kids but
cat ladies often engage into things
because um they have the time to do so
so what can anyone cat ladies parents
anybody do to protect protect our
freedom to read yeah I mean I think um
you know understanding what's happening
in your local community is a good place
to start so is this something that's
affecting your school board can you show
up can you provide you know open
comments and defensive access to books
um that's a great place I think for all
of us I mean we talked a little bit
about debunking some of the rhetoric
just you know looking at the list of
books that have been banned reading them
kind of challenging whether um the book
is what you know it's being said it is
on a much larger scale um I think that's
a great activity for all of us and you
know even in my own neighborhood I like
to you know put a book in a little Free
Library where I can and when I can just
to make sure that there's other ways
that you know we can continue to promote
access while we battle um the removal of
access to to good books in our public
schools now yes yes wow such a big
subject very serious issue to think
about Casey thank you so much for
joining me today I appreciate it the
thank you so much for having me and
thanks to the bookaholic listeners for
tuning in for this one yes yes and we'll
have information about pen America in
the podcast show notes as well as the
YouTube video description read on people
read on thanks for joining me today
great thank you