Welcome to the Bookaholic Podcast! In this episode, Deirdre sits down with Susan Shapiro Barish to discuss her latest nonfiction book, 'Estranged: How Strained Female Friendships Are Mended or Ended.' Purchase the book here: https://amzn.to/45dSJVK
They delve into the rarely addressed topic of female friendships that fall apart, the societal expectations placed on women to maintain these bonds, and the emotional complexities involved. With insights from over 150 women aged 20 to 80, the silence is broken. The conversation touches on various types of toxic friendships, the impact of life changes, and the difficult yet empowering process of ending friendships. This episode provides a deep dive into the emotional landscape of female friendships and offers valuable perspectives on navigating these relationships. Don't miss it!
00:00 Introduction and Welcome 00:07 Exploring Female Friendships 03:10 The Concept of Toxic Friendships 03:48 Examples of Toxic Relationships 05:43 Impact of Life Changes on Friendships 08:34 Political and Social Divides 09:43 Jealousy and Betrayal 10:40 The Wayward Friend 12:33 Sororities and Lifelong Bonds 16:28 Personal Stories of Friendship Breakups 23:39 Grieving and Moving On 26:34 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
This video is an author interview about her book. This book is a female friendship book. Subscribe to my channel if you love to read books.
Susan Shapiro Barish, welcome to the Bookaholic Podcast.
Thank you for having me on.
Yes, I'm very excited to talk about today's topic because I think it's one people don't
really talk about or maybe don't even really exist and your latest book, your latest nonfiction book
is called Estranged, How Strange Female Friendships Are Mended or Ended.
So delving into that because that's a very important subject.
It really is and because we're raised to be good girls, stay best friends forever,
we overlook it. We can leave a bad marriage or we can leave a bad romantic relationship
but we're not so geared to really leave these friendships.
Exactly and I'll get into more of the comparison a little bit later in the interview but it is
very important that we address this subject. This is the first time I've ever heard it
professionally really addressed because again, like you say, people expect women to be friends
forever. It's perpetrated in books. It's perpetrated in movies. So it's all over the
place and we're best friends or friends until we're not. And first of all, you've written a
lot of different books on a lot of different subjects but why did you want to write this
book at this time? This is my 18th book and it's just out now and I've written four novels
and this is a book that I wanted to write for a good seven years and I have the nonfiction,
the 14 nonfiction books. For those books, I've been investigating how women feel for real
compared to the faces we're supposed to wear and how many hats do we wear and how do we feel
as wives and single women, mothers, daughters, mothers-in-law, daughters-in-law. How do we feel
as rivals and foes and why do we keep secrets? And a book on sisters. So all these investigations
are a way to give us the truth about how we're positioned in contemporary American culture.
And for each book, I interview at least 150 women, all different ages. This is 20 to 80
in this house. I'm looking for a very diverse group. So all across the country, different race,
religion, ethnicity, level of education, social strata, big cities, rural areas,
suburbs. What do we feel for real? And what's so interesting is it really doesn't matter
if you graduated from an Ivy League or you didn't finish high school. If you're having a problem
with a friend, you're having a problem in a relationship with a child, with a mother-in-law,
with any of it. We're all really feeling the same emotional need and longing about friends.
I had written a book in the early 2000s called Toxic Friends. And now what I was hearing was
that women in my new research, especially the last two years, I was hearing of women able to
leave the toxic friendships. Not how to deal with it, but to be empowered by leaving,
which is really a new trend and it's a different click, if you will.
Yes. Let's dive into that because that will set the tone a little bit for what your book is about
today. So let's give us two to three examples of what a toxic female relationship looks like,
because this is what I was alluding to earlier, that the toxic female relationships can also
mimic some of the toxicity that we have in our romantic relationships, i.e. narcissism,
narcissists. So just real quick, give us just three quick examples of the toxic female
relationship. First of all, you're completely right that it really is like a romance that
goes back. So we see a friend who is very close to you until something breaks you up.
Could be another person, another friend. It could be a romantic where it becomes very triangulated
and now you're in a romance and your new partner doesn't like your friend and you're willing to
really push her to the side. We're looking most recently in the last two elections,
we're looking at women who are absolutely divided over politics or back things, which is really
something that was never so dire before. There was a lot more respect for the other side and
now it's really a deal breaker. And then we'll always get back to a very age old topic and that
is jealousy. So I have a chapter called The Green-Eyed Friend, because if your friend is jealous
and you can feel it and you've witnessed it and endured it, you end up at some point just hitting
too big an event in your lives to stay with her. So the jealousy is just too strong and there's
just too much tension. And then I have, each chapter is a different type of person with whom
we might do better to estrange. I find that, go back to your first example, and it's not
always that maybe the new romantic partner of your friend does not like you. It's sometimes
some female friends, once they get a romantic alliance, a romantic partnership, that person
becomes their best friend. And then they just leave their girlfriends in the dust. Have you
found that? It's very hierarchical and I look at that too. Sometimes women will be, you'll have a
very close friend. And let me interrupt myself to say, this book is only about our closest friend.
This isn't about your walking buddy or your Pilates friend or colleague at work. But these
are really where we share secrets and intimacy is great. Trust is supposed to be at the center of it.
So yes, when something comes between you, whether it's a friend or maybe you move away,
I interviewed some women who said, my friend just started a new lifestyle and there was no room for
me in it. When there is either an event or a change or a person that breaks you up, it really becomes,
and this again leads into another chapter, hierarchical. I'm important, but I'm not as
important as her new life or her new squeeze. And that's very painful. It can be, especially if the
dynamics are the one person is in a strong and or new or by contract married to a new best friend
and a partner. And the other person, the other friend is single. Sometimes it balances out if
both friends are married, let's say, and they can understand, I've got a, I've got my partner,
I've got my husband or whatever. I got my wife or, and I have to put that first for now. And then we
can go back to our friendship. But sometimes it's really totally imbalanced if there's a friend who
is single and not in a relationship and tends not to be in a relationship when the other person is
married. That can also. Yes. And for women of all ages, what happens is we're together and we're
having parallel lives and it's very reflective. You're like this, like mine. And then you're like,
it's not like mine. Can this relationship, this friendship sustain itself without it? Or is it a
deal breaker? And it's so much depends on the two people involved. But many women said she left me
behind or she has no time for me because she has kids or she has no time for me because she's single
and I'm stuck at home looking for a babysitter. Yeah, it works that you're no more, you're
desperate and no longer on the same page. Absolutely. And the latest blow is the dynamics
of politics and social cultural things like you said, anti-vaxxing or vaccine. People just,
I remember there was a time where, you know, Hey, you just a Democrat or you, Hey, you're just a
Republican and you just vote and then that's it. And now it's a deal breaker. It is a serious deal
breaker. People can't even have Thanksgiving dinners with families. No family. Yeah. How about
some of the women who said, Oh, and that, let me intro myself again. In the book, I have one sister
interview per chapter because sisters having done a study in an earlier book on sisters often say
we don't need as many close girlfriends because we have each other. But what about when sisters
break up? Absolutely. Yeah. And for that, I've heard a lot of that was over politics and not
having the same values. Oh, wow. Okay. Hold it right there. Then of course we know the third
thing, jealousy. That's an easy, we can always expect that. But sometimes it's not just, I don't
know. It's just the way sometimes that jealousy comes about. I've had friends and you break up
because of the wedding. Oh, I have a few wedding stories in the book. Yeah. Because of the wedding
and all of a sudden I had a few breakups because of a wedding. Yeah. No, second wedding.
I interviewed a woman who said, this is my second wedding, but it feels like it's my first. They're
the same jealous friends and then the ones who say I shouldn't marry this guy and feel their
opinions more important than my choice. So really what happens is that a very meaningful
event or behavior gets in the way of the friendship. Another chapter that I have in the
book is called the wayward friend. And that's important because that's when we're with a friend
who we're pretty devoted to and the relationship really is reciprocal in terms of caring. But one
of them has either an addiction, a drinking problem, a drug problem. Do you become the enabler? How long
can you be the enabler? And what does it do to you and your family? And so how do women navigate
that path? And are you really helping your friend? Those were very touching stories because all the
caring and love is there, but it's a very troubled friendship because of this.
Absolutely. Absolutely. And sometimes I would think in that respect, you'd have to make the
hard choice to tell your friend while you are in this space, even though I love you and I'll pray
for you, I will support you in any positive directions that you're making. I have to step away
until you go in a more positive direction. While you're in the negative direction, I have to step
back and I have to step away. And possibly that's the only way to really get your friend to do the
right thing and get the help she needs. But the enabling part is difficult. And then I also
interviewed a lot of women, all different ages, who said that the betrayal was so great when it
came to a friend. This is the leaving friend category. A boyfriend, a husband, a very important
colleague, another friend. And they said, wow, my friend saw no boundaries, no respect, and it's
ruined my life. And so those stories are also very serious. Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. You did
interview a variety of women. And I will say one aspect for African American women
of friendship are our sororities. And we join our sororities like a force in college. So it's in
as past that first grade buddy. It's just that high school buddy. It's our college friend and
sorority sister, or soror, as we say. And we're expected to have those friends for life and be
dedicated to them under our various woes in our various sororities. But did you come across any
stories about any African American friendships where another sorority sister has to break up
with another sorority sister? I did. I spoke with African American women. And the other aspect that
I heard a lot in these relationships is D'Amelio. Our grandmas knew each other. Our mothers were
friends. We grew up in the same church. We had the same community. We are part of a circle of friends.
So yeah, a sorority and two college stories. Yes. But what about coming from the same town and the
same background, but very much invested in the history. So that makes it hard to break up. You
feel like you're breaking so much more than just the two of you. Absolutely. And then how about
the mothers who, for the younger women, when they would ask their mothers in different communities,
what is best? And what was so interesting is how much the mothers wanted it to work out.
It was something really reprehensible that happened. Absolutely. I can see that. Maybe this
is in some novels that I've read, but maybe girls from, let's just say, a southern background and
they go off to some all-girls school. Oh, I can think of an all-girls school I know of in Virginia
and one in Winston-Salem. And you're supposed to be, that's another form of sisterhood. It
might not be a sorority, but that's another united thing, a whole school. And you're supposed to be
bound to your all-girls school friends forever and ever, but not everybody is coming from that same
direction. There was one interviewee who told me that the sorority sisters weren't really supportive,
that they feigned support, but they were jealous. She was a great student. She was
really attractive. The boys liked her. So we see this so much. Based on my research for a book I
wrote called Tripping the Prom Queen, the truth about women and rivalry, I think a lot of what
happens with these friendships is the cultural message for us is almost greater than the
connection we have. So we're raised in a culture, sadly, of limited goods, not enough pie. So you're
always set to compete in the workforce against other women. If your best
friend gets engaged, you say to yourself, what about me? With this magical theft concept
that maybe there's no one left because it's such a limited goods life that we lead. And that has to
change. They have to be authentic. We have to support our friends' choices and happiness,
because if not, who are we? Correct. I understand 100%. Now I'm going to give you an example,
and this is from my own personal files. I had a friend that I met through an African American
group. And so through that, though, we had to do various things in the group. But she and I became
best friends, and then close friends. And she has two children. I have two children.
We were just really good friends. And she was one of those friends who I shared a lot with.
I could let my hair down with, et cetera. But every time we have our two sons, our oldest
children, her son was a little older than mine. And I would say something to the effect of
in front of her husband and her, and my husband might be present in some of the instances,
oh, these two guys are the same, or they got a lot in common. And this friend would kind of
not smirk, but draw back. And you could just tell by her body movements, her facial expressions,
that she was thinking, no, our son is much better than yours. Much smarter, much better,
but whatever. And that used to really irk me. And I never did address that with her.
But as time rolled on, there was something that happened between us. And I just can't really,
I can't really pinpoint it, but we were friends until we were not. So this happens, right? But
that was really me falls into what I write about respect. If you're not really treating each other
as equals, and there's not enough respect, the friendship can't really sustain itself. And then
it sounds to me like you just grew apart. Yeah, yeah. And I know what happened. I know what
happened. I, this particular friend had moved to another state. And so my husband and youngest son,
we were vacationing, maybe a spring break in that particular state. And she, I had always envisioned
that I would visit her somehow, some way, when I was down there. And that particular time was
not a good time. It was not a good time in my family. Well, in the dynamic of my family that
I was traveling with, there was a major thing, catastrophe that happened while we were on the
trip. So I had told her, I said, I can't come see you. I cannot come see you. And I said,
there's a lot of things without revealing everything that happened. I said, I just can't
visit you because it's not a good time for me and my family to come visit you. Like from our side,
not from anything that had to do with her. And she never understood, she never understood it. She
never got it. She just, she was just only concerned about me coming to visit her. She wasn't thinking
about what has happened in my friend's life. What is she talking about? She never gave me grace or
anything. And that catastrophically broke our friendship. And so when she came back to my state
to visit for a function, for the group that we have been in, we didn't sit together. Normally
we would have sat together and she, she was hanging out with somebody and she didn't even
tell me she was coming. She didn't even tell me. She did it as a surprise to everyone. But when I
saw her, I was like, well, you didn't tell me that you weren't coming. And she made some kind
of a snide comment in front of a group of people. I said, okay, I'll be letting her go.
So you really estranged from her?
Yes, I did.
In the book, I have estrangers, which is what you were, the person who estranges any estrangee
who is the one who is at the receiving end of being estranged. And for both people, but sometimes
in my study, women, even both sides said maybe it's for the best. But this friend really,
to me, with just hearing it briefly, sounds like the stories that I uncovered where women felt that
they really weren't treated fairly and that the friend really didn't understand the predicament
that the friend was in. And what we're looking for, because remember, Jared, in this book,
in estranged, what we're looking for is not family, because that's assigned to us,
but the way we choose. So we choose these friends. So because we choose them, we hold the bar very
high. And we say to ourselves, the men, they come and go, the children grow up,
even the grandchildren grow up, women would say to me, and women would start with new friends at
every stage of their lives, and yet make the same miscalculations at 70 that they did at 35.
Because we present a certain way, often women, for our friends, just as we do in a love relationship.
True.
But the idea, remember Golden Girls or Sex and the City? So we're looking for solace and comfort
and understanding. And what you told me about your friend, it's really a situation where she
didn't understand your side of the story. Right, absolutely. She did not understand.
As hard as I tried to make her understand, it's like she refused to. She just took it as a
personal affront. And then you ghosted her. Yeah. That's something I also found in my study,
in my book, is that women don't really like confrontation. And it's often very hard to
tell with a friend and say, look, here's what you did. And then she says, here's what you did.
And often instead, there's what I would call an inciting incident, which is like you just
described at that point, where you didn't even know about being there. And then after that,
you were almost stronger for leaving it. Yeah. And that's the new spin, that you didn't say,
oh my goodness, I found, what could have gone better here? What did I do? But instead to say,
enough. It's enough. The system's building up, and I'm ready to estrange. Yeah. It was seeming
like the relationship was becoming one-sided. But anyway, yeah. I will tell you, I will tell you,
for the two female relationships that I've actually had, that actually came to an end,
it's very painful. It's so painful. I found in listening to these women, and I also did a
questionnaire at the end of the book, that there's really a grieving process. This is really grief.
It's a form of grief. So the question is, what am I getting from this friendship? And would I be
better off without her? So it's like any breakup in our lives. To be estranged is very painful.
If you miss the person, and women talk to me, again, all different women spoke to me about
wanting to belong. Women love to belong to a group. Women love to congregate and say,
this is our cause. This is the reason we get together. This is our sorority when we're young.
So that really prevails throughout our lives, for every different stage of our life. So to lose
that friend, and the time, and the shared yearnings, and secret, is really like having a hole
in your life. Or it's like it's a pie for women. It's a slice that's gone. And as I said in the
beginning, these are really about, this book is about very close friendships. Yeah. Really the
ones that count the most, where we say, what would we do without her? And then end up without her.
Let's go into mental health, because we all need friendships as part of having good mental health.
How do you handle a breakup of these friendships, as far as mental health is concerned?
Many of the women with whom I spoke, said that they felt they had learned a great deal from
the friendship, and how it went awry. And so they felt more discerning and careful with
new friends, and felt that they would know the red flag. They felt that they had learned
enough. And then some said, I didn't learn anything. Look, another, I've had two terrible breakups,
or three. But for the ones who really learned something, it meant that they were evolving
by leaving the friend. And there's also, as we talked about it before, something kind of
calming in knowing that you grew apart, or that you no longer look at the world the same way.
Or that what she did was a very serious betrayal. So in terms of mental health,
we factor in when we miss the friend, what really went wrong. And in doing so, we learn,
we learn more about ourselves, and we're stronger. And we also hopefully know what to look for.
Absolutely. Susan, I really appreciate you taking out your time today to come and talk to me about
this very important subject. Again, as I say that it's rarely addressed ever. And I just thank you
for taking an interest in writing this book. And it is called Estranged, How Strange Female
Friendships Are Mended or Ended. We will have links to this book in our podcast sharing notes,
and in the video description box on YouTube. Susan Shapiro Barron, thank you so much for
joining me today. Deirdre, it's been a pleasure. I really had fun talking to you. And you know so
much about this too. I've had friendships for a very long time. I'm experienced. Thank you. Thank you.