Materials and Molecular Sciences Conversation COFAS 2021 CT1B
What I would like to do is turn it over to Mike at this point for the
invocation. Yeah, thanks Keith. Actually for the invocation this morning I wanted
to read from Psalm 111, and I was reminded of this psalm actually reading
Professor Briggs's book and being reminded that the inscription above the
Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge quotes from Psalm 111 too, and I thought it was
very appropriate for our discussion. So as an invocation, Psalm 111. Praise the
Lord. I will give thanks to the Lord with my whole heart in the company of the
upright in the congregation. Great are the works of the Lord, studied by all
who delight in them. Full of splendor and majesty is his work, and his righteousness
endures forever. He has caused the wondrous works to be remembered. The Lord
is gracious and merciful. He provides food to those who fear him. He remembers
his covenant forever. He has shown his people the power of his works in giving
them the inheritance of the nations. The works of his hands are faithful and just.
His precepts are trustworthy. They are established forever and ever to be
performed with faithfulness and uprightness. He sent redemption to his
people. He has commanded his covenant forever. Holy and awesome is his name. The
fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. All those who practice it have
good understanding. His praises endure forever. Father, Son, and Spirit, bless our
discussions today and encourage us through the love of Christ. Amen.
Amen. Okay, with that, we're going to jump very quickly into our speakers. I should
mention that the biographies of our speakers are posted, and so eminent
speakers, and I encourage you to look at those. But we've got a very busy program,
so I'm going to jump very quickly into this right away and introduce our
speaker, Professor Colin Humphreys. Colin, again, welcome this morning. Thank you
very much, Mike, and it's a great pleasure to be here, and also to be
interacting with Arizona State University. So I must have visited ASU
maybe five or six times, and I spent three months there, one Easter, which was
wonderful, joining John Spence in the physics department, and I'll talk a bit
more about that later. When my younger daughter was eight, my father gave her a
book called Great Men of History. On each page, there was a particular great
famous person. So one page was Julius Caesar, another page was Christopher
Columbus, another page, Alexander the Great, and another page, Jesus Christ. And
on the front page of this book, it gave the list of the people in the book, and
it gave their dates of birth and death. But against Jesus, it said, Jesus Christ,
born 4 BC, question mark, died AD 30, question mark. And my daughter said to me,
Daddy, why don't we know the dates when Jesus was born and died, but we
know the dates of all these other people when they were born and died? Did Jesus
really exist? And I thought, well, that's a really good question, which I'd
never thought about before, and I decided to try and find out. And is it
important? Well, of course, it's not important, in a sense, for becoming a
Christian, but it is important, I think, for our Christian faith, because our
Christian faith isn't composed of just some vague beliefs. It's based on
historical events, and in particular, it's based on the birth, life, death, and
resurrection of Jesus. And the more we can pinpoint when these events
happened, the more we improve the historical basis of our faith. So Jesus'
death is not recorded, and that's not surprising, because he died as a
common criminal, and the deaths of common criminals were not recorded at
that time, just the deaths of famous people recorded at that time. But on the
other hand, can we link his death with the dates of famous people? And we can do
this. And this is the first clue, as it were, to try to date the death of Jesus.
And Tacitus, a Roman historian, certainly not a Christian or a Jew, Tacitus wrote
in what's called Annals, his histories, Christ, and I'm quoting from this,
Christ had been executed in Tiberius' reign by the governor of Judea, Pontius
Pilate. And the first clue, therefore, is that Christ died when Tiberius was
ruled as emperor, and Pilate was ruling Judea. And we know when these periods
were, because they're recorded in Roman history of the time. And this period was
AD 26 to 36, so that's the first clue of when Christ died, in the years AD 26
to 36, and it's also recorded in all four Gospels. So all four Gospels agree with
Tacitus, and it's really nice to have this external testimony to when Jesus
died. The second clue is that Jesus died on a Friday. And all four Gospels say
Jesus died on the preparation of the Sabbath. The Jewish Sabbath was on a
Saturday and still is, and the preparation is the day before, so that's
the Friday. And the third clue is that Jesus died at Passover time. So the last
supper of Jesus was a Passover-type meal. And Passover time in the Jewish
calendar was at full moon time. So that's the third clue, that Jesus died at full
moon time. So we can now ask a specific question, when did full moon
fall on a Friday in the period AD 26 to 36? We don't have any historical records
of the calendar at that time, the Jewish calendar. So I calculate, I asked an
astronomer, Graham Waddington, if he could reconstruct the first century
Jewish calendar, because the first day of the month was the first observation
of the Lunar Crescent. So Graham calculated using the latest
astronomical equations, he calculated and reconstructed the Jewish calendar in the
first century AD. And then the question that we asked was, from this
calendar, when did full moon fall on a Friday in this period AD 26 to 36? And
using a few more clues, you can precisely say the crucifixion was on Friday the
3rd of April AD 33. And that's the only possible date calendrically, and from the
biblical clues and also Tacitus, only possible date for the crucifixion. Well
the story doesn't end there, because as I said before, I was visiting ASU for three
months to visit John Spence, and that was in the physics department. And one day I
was reading my Bible at home in Arizona, in Tempe, Arizona, and I was reading from
Acts chapter 2, and it's Peter's Pentecost speech, and Pentecost, the Jewish
festival, only seven weeks after Passover. And we remember the
events that the disciples of Jesus were being filled with the Holy Spirit, and
they were exuberant about their faith, and they were accused of being drunk. And
Peter starts off by saying, these men are not drunk, it's the third hour of the
morning, and you count the three hours from sunrise, so it's just 9 a.m., and if
we are speaking today, look, the pubs aren't open, these people are not drunk,
they're perfectly sober, they're filled with the Spirit. And he says, this is the
fulfillment, what you're witnessing is a fulfillment of a prophecy by Joel, several
hundred years ago in the Old Testament. And I'll read again what Peter said, and
he's quoting from Joel. God says, I'll pour out my Spirit in those times, I will
show wonders in the heavens above, and signs in the earth below. The sun will be
turned to darkness, and the moon to blood, before the coming of the great and
glorious day of the Lord, when everyone will be saved. And Peter is saying, this
prophecy has now been fulfilled, it's a remarkable occasion. And so if you go
through this prophecy, then the filling of the Spirit was at the time of Pentecost,
the great and glorious days since when people will be saved was the
resurrection, the sun darkened was the three hours of darkness at the
crucifixion, and the moon turned to blood would have been that evening. I've just
lost my, okay, I lost my signal. And there's two other
references in early literature to the moon turning to blood, one in the
Apocrypha, and one in a commentary, an early commentary on the crucifixion. So
we've got three references on the evening of the crucifixion, the moon
turned to blood. And I was wondering what it meant. And I went into ASU physics
department, and that day I decided to walk around the department, which I
hadn't done, go to other floors, and I went upstairs to the astronomy floor, the
astronomy group, and along the corridor there were pictures of astronomical
events. And I passed this picture, and it was of a blood-red moon, and underneath
it said, lunar eclipse. And I said, of course, when the moon is eclipsed, then it
often is blood-red. And that's because of a scientific phenomenon called
refraction. So when there's a lunar eclipse, when the moon and the
sun and the earth are aligned, then the light from the sun geometrically
doesn't hit the moon at all, but it's refracted through the earth's atmosphere,
and the red light's refracted the most. So only the red light hits the moon in the
lunar eclipse, and then it's reflected back to earth, so we see the moon as
blood-red. So I thought, gosh, can this be referring to a lunar eclipse that
happened on the evening of the crucifixion? And I went to ancient
literature to see if this phrase, the moon was turned to blood, did in fact
refer to a lunar eclipse. And what I found was the earliest reference was
about 300 BC, and it went on to about 500 AD. And writers use this as a
standard phrase to describe a lunar eclipse was, the moon was turned to
blood. And so I thought, well, you know, that's Roman history, Babylonian
history, this is recorded there. So I went back to Graham Waddington. I didn't
tell him this story. I said to Graham, Graham, can you calculate lunar eclipses
visible from Jerusalem in the 10-year period, AD 26 to 36, at Passover time?
Was there one? And Graham came back and he said, Colin, there's a unique
solution. There was one eclipse visible from Jerusalem at Passover time in AD
26 to 36, and only one, the date was Friday, 3 April, AD 33. So there was a
lunar eclipse on the date of the crucifixion, which we can determine
using other techniques, as I described. So it's just a remarkable event. And in
fact, we wrote this up for Nature, so managed to publish it in Nature. And at
the last minute, the overall editor of Nature, John Maddox, who was an atheist
tried to stop it. But it was too late. It's all gone through the proof. So we
had this published in Nature. And what the calculations of Graham showed is
that the moon was actually eclipsed when it rose, and it rose over the Mount of
Olives. So a lot of people have seen it at moonrise. It's this blood red moon.
So really rich in symbolism, as well as being a historical event. So it could
have been, of course, a chance event, lucky chance event, if you like. But I've
also dated other events. I got really interested in this. So the Star of
Bethlehem, I've looked at, and there's no time to talk about that at the
moment. But just to say, it was a really bright comet, long tail comet
recorded in the Chinese records of the times. So we have a bright comet at the
birth of Christ, and a lunar eclipse of the crucifixion. And, you know, these are
remarkable occurrences, and I think illustrate the cosmic significance of
the birth and death. And just to finally conclude, I think the only way, if you
like, the mechanism is, these are normal eclipses, normal comets. God didn't alter
the orbits of the earth or sun or moon to get these eclipses. So it's something
you can calculate. And so I believe when the Bible talks about Jesus being
sacrificed before the foundations of the world, what it means is that God's
salvation plan was built into the Big Bang, if that's how everything started.
But he also built into the Big Bang, that there would be a comet coincided with
the birth, and a lunar eclipse coincided with the death of Christ. So this is
really, I think, a remarkable story. And I should also say, it's a story for our
generation, because calculating the orbit of the lunar eclipse, you know, 2,000
years ago, you have to be very, very precise. And the correction of facts is
necessary. This eclipse was not visible from Jerusalem, if you try to calculate
the 100 years ago. It's only in the last 40 years that we've got the accuracy of
the calculations to say this really was visible from Jerusalem. So this is
something, if you like, revealed to our generation. So science has worked with
the Bible, and the Bible's worked with science to produce these remarkable
conclusions. And I found no discrepancies between science and the
Bible in my detailed investigations. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Professor Humphries. As Mike, for those of you who've joined us a
little bit later, as Mike told us, biographies of both of our speakers are
available at the Whova website. We are trying to maximize their time and the
time for you to have questions later. So we're going to move immediately. I'd
like to introduce Professor Briggs, whose presentation is next.
Thank you, Keith. I've often been to ASU. I wish I could be with you today. But
anyway, I'm glad I can join you by this technology. Last year, the Astronomer
Royal, Lord Martin Rees, sent me a draft of a piece that was later published in
one of the national newspapers, in which he gave two reasons why science should
feature strongly in everyone's culture. The first is that it's a real
intellectual deprivation not to understand the natural world around us.
And the second is that we live in a world where more and more of the
decisions that have to be taken, need science to inform them. And I would go
even further than that and say it's not only an intellectual deprivation, but
it's a spiritual deprivation not to understand the natural world around us.
And it's not only governments who have to make decisions that involve science,
but religious leaders do, other people in leadership positions, and in a sense,
each of us in our lives and in our professional work have to make decisions
that involve science. And therefore, if there's to be informed debate going into
these things, that's not just polarisation. Everyone needs enough of a
sort of feel for science to avoid becoming bamboozled by propaganda and
bad statistics. I do experiments on small things in the lab. The minute we're
looking into how the sort of thermodynamics that was developed in the
19th century for very large numbers of water molecules in steam engines and so
on. How do those work when you make it very small? So we use the world's
smallest guitar string, it's about a billionth of a metre in diameter. And we
look at what happens when you have only one object instead of an Avogadro
number. And it can be in only one of two modes instead of a vast number of
modes. And now the magic of the quantum world comes in because it can be as it
were, here and there, at the same time in a way that's way outside our normal
experience. And for me, that's how I pursue curiosity about the material
world. I read a book with an artist, this is perhaps Mike, thank you for
mentioning the inscription over the Cavendish. And someone in the chat has
said it's both on the old Cavendish and the new Cavendish. So the last picture in
the book is the new Cavendish. And the cover of the book is cave paintings from
about 38,000 years ago. So more than twice as old as the conch shell that you
may have read about this week that people have discovered it could be played
as a musical instrument from about 17,000 years ago. And after we'd written
the book, we jumped into a plane, I'm a pilot, with a film crew in the back and
flew around the Mediterranean to places where we'd identified where there'd
been significant advances in curiosity. And what we discovered is, this
incidentally is the expensive edition for well-paid professors, there is a
paperback edition for impoverished students, so you can choose the edition
to suit your status in life, you know. What we discovered was that where you
have a culture or a community or, oh look, well done David, have you got the
professor's edition or the student's edition? The professor's edition, well
done. That you have a culture or a community or it could be an
individual who's interested in the really big questions about truth and
purpose and meaning and why are we here and what is God like and how can God be
known? Time and again that has proved conducive to the sort of curiosity about
the material world that we would now call science. And that because it follows as
it were in the slipstream of this ultimate questions, we called that the
penultimate curiosity. When I was a student, I was given a scholarship
to go and spend a month based at St. George's College in Jerusalem, studying
the geography and archaeology of Israel. Towards the end of that month, we were
given a sort of retreat for two nights in a monastery on the top of Mount
Tabor, which is a candidate site for the Mount of Transfiguration. And the day
between, there was no program, we were just given a day to reflect on what we'd
been seeing and learning. And as I sat there looking out over the plain of
Megiddo, it came to me with a new kind of insight, a new kind of force
that I had to hold together what I read about in the pages of the Bible. This is
a Bible that was given to me when I was baptized as a baby by my godmother. I
still have it. What I read about there is inseparable from the physical material
world which I'd been walking in and learning about for the previous few
weeks. It's what a former Archbishop of York called you, you have to approach it
with an undivided mind. And so for me, that's why, for me, science is this
amazing, God-given resource for engaging with the material world in which we live
our embodied lives. And it's a gift. It's a resource for the life of faith. And
it's a two-way relationship because the voice of faith is needed for wise use
of science and the technologies that arise from it in order that they're
deployed to make the world a better place and to enable humans to flourish.
Thank you, Andrew. I'm assuming we're finishing up. We are trying to coordinate
the question and answers for both of you. A lot of them are coming in, but they're
coming in in two places right now. They're coming in in the chat area and
they're coming in in the question and answers area. We're trying to get
them all into the app and the question and answers period so we have one group
of questions we can look at. And Sylvia is trying to do that for us. But I
grabbed one that came from Colin Humphreys' discussion. There was a great
interest because you mentioned the comet that accompanied the birth of
Christ. People are interested, well, what date does that comet come and what was
then your best guess for the birth date of Christ? So maybe you can elaborate on
that comment for us. Right, well, no, thank you very much. So yes, this comet is
recorded in the Chinese records of the times and they're called the Han Shu. So
it was the Han Dynasty and these are the records of the Han Dynasty. And the
Chinese astronomers, they were extremely good observers of the sky and they just
recorded everything. And they recorded an extremely bright, long-tailed comet
visible for over 70 days, which appeared in the spring of 5 BC. And they give the
month. So we know the month. And perhaps we can refine that because you have to
ask the question, why was there no room at the inn in Bethlehem? And a possible
reason is it was Passover time. Because at Passover time, people, you know, flocked to
Jerusalem and they came to all the neighboring villages and so on. And I
think Bethlehem was just two miles away from Jerusalem. So if it was Passover time,
we can calculate that. And so we can get a possible one or two week period. And I'm
speaking from memory now, but I believe it's two weeks in April in 5 BC. And just
a final quick comment. People may think, the spring? Why not Christmastime? And
the reason is given in Luke's Gospel that there were shepherds out in the
fields watching their flocks by night. And we know in Bethlehem it snows over
Christmas. I've been there. And the sheep are actually kept indoors. We know
that from records. So the shepherds wouldn't have been there with the
flock by night. But the shepherds would have been there in springtime
because of the lambing season. So Luke's Gospel also fits the spring. There's a
question that Frasier Fleming posted to both the chat room and to Whova. I
thought we might take that one next. He wrote, I am extremely interested to know
where the speakers believe creative inspiration comes from. So this is a
question for both. He goes on to say, how do Christians navigate between a
separate spears approach, a kind of retroactive fatalism, and the spirits
leading in discovery? Andrew, maybe you could take a stab at that one to begin.
I love it. I love it. I had a fascinating discussion in, it was actually in Los
Angeles. It was at Chapman University with Roger Penrose. We did a discussion
about where does inspiration come from in science? And I told a little
story from my PhD when I was wrestling with all the data. It was my third year of
my PhD. I had all this data. And I was convinced that it all depended on one
variable. Sorry, it all depended on a mechanism. And yet I couldn't find any
dependence on the variable describing that mechanism in my results. And it was
Boxing Day, and I was watching Der Freischütz on television, Weber's opera.
And so the inspiration came to me during Der Freischütz. I don't know what that
tells you about me. Which was that I could see that in the calculation, that
variable would have to appear on the top and the bottom of the fraction and
therefore cancel itself out, you see. And that's why it didn't appear in the
results. So Roger Penrose then told a story about how he got inspiration for a
brilliant idea as he was about to cross a road. And he saw something he'd been
thinking about for a long time. But then he turned to look at the traffic, and he
crossed the road safely. And he got to the other side, and he couldn't remember
what the idea was that seemed so brilliant to him. So that's inspiration in
science. It's so elusive. Where does it come from? How do we get the ideas? The
best I can think of is that we're randomly generating lots of ideas in our
mind, and the real creative process is not in the generation of the ideas, but
the filtering out of the ones that are worthwhile. So I don't know if that's how
it works for scientific inspiration. I'm still trying to understand. And time and
again, I think that in the life of faith, we find that we get insights into how
things work in faith from how they work in other walks of life, including
scientific observation. Just in my morning reading this morning, you know,
Ezekiel is looking at a scientific observation about the uselessness of wood
from vinewood, you know, from a grapevine. It's useless for anything except
growing grapes, you know. And he'd noticed that, and if you like, that's a
scientific observation about material science from the exilic period. So I'm a
bit nervous about sort of clever, simple answers to this, just as I am about
clever, simple answers about inspiration in science. I think it's a complex
process, and I'm very happy if—the question seems to have got hidden. Is it
the one that's hidden? Is that the one we're looking at? I'm very happy for
people to describe this as inspiration of the spirit, and I'm very happy for that
to coexist with trying to think about how the mental processes work, which I
think is still elusive and rather exciting, actually.
Thank you, Professor Briggs. Professor Humphreys, additional thoughts?
Thank you. Thank you very much. You know, I find that inspiration sometimes
comes to me at 4 a.m. in the morning, and I think—this is really true—and I
think what's happening is that when you're sleeping, your brain is turning
around all these ideas, you know, subconsciously, and suddenly things come
together, and you wake up and you think, gosh. And so, you know, in a sense, the
committee of sleep has been working on things, and so the brain is actually
trying out different combinations subconsciously, and it pops up with the
answer sometimes. But I also do think that God does interact with us to
produce inspiration, as it were. So the example I just told about ASU, that I
was there that day. I'd read Acts chapter 2 and about the moon turning to blood,
and I also decided, in quotes, by chance, to wander around the physics department,
which I'd never done before. I'd just stuck to one floor. So I went up and, you
know, went along the astronomy department. There on the wall was this blood-red
moon, and I think that's God being inspiration, really, and guiding us in
small things of life as well as in the big things of life. As Andrew says, it's a
complex process, but I'm sure God does inspire us in our lives.
I'd love to tackle this question about scriptures written in the exile, unless
you've got others that you'd like to talk about before that one.
Take it away.
Do you want to read it out, Mike, and then everybody will know what the question is?
Yeah, yeah, if we can do that. Can you hear me?
Can you hear me, Colin? I mean...
Yes, I can. Yes, yes.
Thank you. Contemporary scholars of ancient literature suggest the ancient Jewish
texts, for example, the Torah, were written during the Babylonian exile to give the
Jewish people a history and identity as a captured people, of course, in Babylon.
How have you reconciled this view with your view of the value and the veracity of
scriptures?
So, the reason I love this, Mike, is that if I'm trying to think about how the Old
Testament informs the way that we use science now, I love the prophets, the exilic prophets,
as a good way of getting started. I find it a much better way of getting started than
the early chapters of Genesis for the reason that they are explicit about why they're
inviting us to look at the physical world.
And if you take, for example, Isaiah 40-55, scholars, you know, have a field day discussing
when they think it was written. But I think whenever it was written, it has a very obvious
application to the Babylonian, you know, the exiles in Babylonia. And if you take the first
two chapters of that section, chapters 40 and 41, there's a sort of overture to what
you're going to get in all 15 chapters. And it is that God is addressing, or the prophet
is addressing, three fears. There's a fear that God's unloving, there's a fear that
he's unreliable, and there's a fear that he's incompetent. And the fear that he's
incompetent. And of course, you know, the opening bit, comfort ye, comfort ye my people,
speak ye comfortably to Jerusalem, you know, is trying to give people the courage to return
to Jerusalem. And the journey from Jerusalem to Babylonia was a pretty painful one. I mean,
think hooks in noses, you know, that's the sort of way to think about it. And so it was
pretty scary. And they sort of got themselves a rather comfortable existence. Some of them
have settled down to a sort of comfortable sort of lower middle class existence, you know,
as little shopkeepers and things like that, tradespeople. And so to go back sounded rather
scary. And how, you know, was God really up to the job? And so what he's saying is,
look at this material world around you, you know, look how big it is.
Can you measure the volume, how many litres in the oceans of the world, you know?
Can you, how many kilograms do the nations weigh? This sort of question. And get a sense of how big
it is and how great it is. And that will encourage you to put your confidence in God. Now, I think
once you begin to see it like that, it gives you, then, a healthy approach to lots of other places
in the Hebrew Scriptures where observations of the material world are talked about,
like in Genesis, like in Job, like in other parts of the wisdom literature, and like in the Psalms.
Colin, did you have any further thoughts? I know that at times you've really enlightened
certain chapters, like in Exodus, for us with the connections and the plausibility of many
of the miracles. But, you know, have you thought about the connection to the original writings?
Yes, thank you very much. Yes, I think, I disagree with a lot of modern scholars,
I must say. It's extremely difficult to date ancient texts. Someone who I trust a lot is
Alan Millard, who works on comparing the language, comparing the language of ancient
biblical texts with documents outside the Bible, and there's not much to compare with.
But he reckons the final form of the first five books of the Bible has the language of the 8th
century BC, which is before the exile. But that's the final form that we have, and I believe there
were earlier forms. And what happens is you have early manuscripts, and they're copied by scribes,
and the scribes copy precisely except that they update the language. And we know this from
ancient Egyptian texts, ancient Babylonian texts. So the scribes are updating the language,
but they're very careful that they do update the language. And so, when you get something
that seems to be the 8th century BC, that's the final form. And there will be earlier forms which
have been lost, and we don't have them. So I think that I see no reason why some of the texts don't
go back to Moses as an author of some of the texts. Now, there's some evidence that I say this.
Why do I say this? Because if you look at the names of the first months of the Bible,
then in Genesis, I think it's actually called the first month, and then it goes on to the month of
Abib, A-B-I-B. But in later books in the Old Testament, it's the month of Nisan, the first
Jewish month. Why Nisan? Because that comes from the Babylonian Nisanu, and so the Jews adopted
the Babylonian calendar when they were in Babylonian exile. But it's only the later
books which are called Nisan. The first five books of the Bible don't mention Nisan at all.
That first month is Abib. And so I think they were not written in the exile, although they
would have used Nisan, which is used in the later books in the Old Testament. So that's evidence
that I think they were written earlier than the exile. And I think the original editions could
have been very early indeed. Thank you. Keith, you have some questions that you feel?
Well, I think there's a question that actually you asked, Mike, that I think would be excellent
at this point, because it's gotten two votes, so there are some other people interested.
And this is how it reads. Professor Humphreys connects extraordinary natural phenomena
with remarkable timing to achieve God's purposes. The asteroid 66 million years ago caused the
extinction of the dinosaurs. If this impact were seconds earlier or at a different angle,
there would not have been mass extinction. So finally, here comes a question. Might we see
in such events God's providence? More challenging, does God use calamity to bring about
his purposes? So I think we'll direct this to Professor Humphreys.
Right. So really good question. Thank you. All the questions are really good. Very good question.
Yes, absolutely. I think the extinction of the dinosaurs allowed the human beings to come
through, because before that, the dinosaurs were really dominant in the Earth. And so their wiping
out was a key factor in allowing humans to come through. So a key part of the emergence of human
life. And I would see this as part of God's providence, so that I think many of us believe
that God chose evolution as the way in which he created the universe and life on Earth. But this
was an actual key part of it to allow humans to come through. So I would say God's providence.
Second part of the question, does God use calamity to bring about his purposes? Absolutely. And the
most striking illustration, of course, is the crucifixion. The crucifixion was a calamity.
I mean, the disciples were fearful in locked doors and everything, and then the resolution,
and then the resolution, then the resurrection came. And so God used, God used the crucifixion,
that calamity, to bring about the resurrection, which is this marvelous event. And so, yes,
God uses, and also another wonderful text, all things work together for good for those who love
God. All things. The calamities and the non-calamities. So God does indeed use calamities
to bring about his purposes. Andrew, did you have something to add to that? Well, I mean, I think,
I think super question. I think Colin's, Colin, I love your answer. I think it's very thorough.
I think that, fortunately, science is being liberated from a sort of Laplacian kind of
determinism that we used to have definitively by, you know, some of the unsolved problems in
quantum foundations. But even without that, others are recognizing the radical uncertainty of life.
There was a book of that title last year by two of Britain's most distinguished economists
who were talking about uncertainty in economics and in economic forecasting. But it's,
it's true in life that, that life is subject, first of all, to randomness. You know,
stuff happens in life, whether it's external, whether it's choices we make, you know,
sometimes the choices we make, we easily could have made another choice. And life is highly
non-linear. So a tiny, tiny change in something that happens or in a choice that we can make
changes everything. In the D-Day invasion of France, my father was on a vessel that he, he,
he had to shuttle backwards and forwards in the army medical corps with, with wounded soldiers.
And he went over three times and he was about to embark to go the fourth time when he had orders
to stay behind. And the, the vessel went over and it was hit by an enemy shell and all lives were
lost. And when I learned about this as a little kid, I thought, well, who would I be then? You
know, if he'd gone over a fourth time, which he easily could have done, who would I be? Well,
there's no answer to that question, but a tiny change in circumstances led to the difference
seen me existing and me not existing. And I'm sure all of us can think of gazillions of examples of
things like that in our own lives. So I think we, we need to get away from this feeling that
everything is, you know, if only there was a super demon, like Laplacian said, who knew the
position and momentum of every particle, then it's not like that life isn't like that. Life is full
of uncertainty. John Templeton, you know, whose, whose money helped to fund this meeting had a
thing on his desk saying, um, um, trouble is opportunity. And, uh, I have, I didn't actually
have it on my desk, but I have in my mind, a thing saying uncertainty is opportunity.
And I think, I think God works with uncertainty and I think he expects us to work through
Thank you. So I'm, I'm looking at the clock and it's, uh, our 45 minutes, um, has actually flown
by quite rapidly here. Uh, I first, I want to thank our audience for, uh, showing up and
participating and, and I most certainly want to think, thank rather Professor Humphries and Briggs,
uh, for their enlightening conversation this morning. Uh, I, I'm going to put a plug in that,
uh, in about 15 minutes, uh, Professor Briggs is going to be in one of the, uh, uh, the lunch,
uh, talks, if you will. He's going to be speaking on human flourishing, scientific insight,
and spiritual wisdom. So I certainly would encourage you to, uh, uh, make contact with him
once again. Uh, any parting comments, Mike? No, again, I'd echo your thank, uh, your, uh,
your thanks to our speakers and I'm just very excited that this is being recorded and for
a lot of students that haven't been able to tune in or were able to tune in and some of
the other speakers and, and now will want to come back. So this is, uh, very excited about that.
And Keith, if I could just tell you that the reason for that, um, session, what's it called,
Lunch and Learn, is because, uh, that's, that's my next book, which is coming out this fall
and it's currently in production at Oxford University Press,
but you've got the opportunity to hear about it here first. Excellent. Thank you. Well, again,
I want to wish everyone, um, a good rest of the conference and thank you for attending this
session. Thank you, Keith. Thank you, Mike. Thank you, everybody. Yes. Thank you, everybody. And
wonderful questions. Thank you very much.

