Art historian Andrew Graham-Dixon and Sotheby’s specialist George Gordon delve into the work of two extraordinary female Baroque painters, Artemisia Gentileschi and Clara Peeters.
Gentileschi’s dramatic David and Goliath captures the moment after victory, with David exuding youthful confidence and pride as he sits over the severed head of Goliath. The painting is a masterclass in light, shadow, and psychological nuance, from the intricately foreshortened limbs and billowing sleeves to the tension between David’s heroic pose and the brutal evidence of violence at his feet.
Clara Peeters’ rarely seen still life, painted around 1610, offers something even more unusual—a fully realised self-portrait embedded within an exquisite arrangement of objects and flowers. Known for her meticulous technique and reflective goblets containing miniature self-images, this work stands out as the only secular self-portrait in her known oeuvre. Peeters’ composition reveals not just technical brilliance but a conscious act of self-presentation, making a bold claim for her place in the artistic canon.
Both works are highlights of the Old Master and 19th Century Paintings Evening Auction taking place at Sotheby’s London on 2 July.
I think that's what's interesting about these painters is that we can't ever quite know what
their story was. George, it's a great pleasure to be back at Sotheby's, thank you for having me.
Now, perhaps somewhat inappropriately, here we are, two men, and we're going to be talking
about two great women artists who have created two of the great highlights of this summer
old master sale. Tell me a little bit about them. Well, it's not so difficult because both
these artists, Clara Peters and Artemisia Gentileschi, were truly great painters in
their own day. Clara Peters was one of the greatest still life painters of the 17th century
and Artemisia Gentileschi stands the test of time as a great Italian Baroque painter.
So we don't have to make a case for them being great artists because they are women artists.
They are women artists who also happen to be truly great painters. Absolutely. There's
an increasing interest and an increasing readiness to acknowledge and bring out these
great female artists from the past. I have a good friend who collects nothing but the work of women
artists and finds the most remarkable things. And the more you find, and Artemisia is a good
case of this, the more works you find the easier it is to see how extraordinary her story was
and how she sort of propelled herself to stardom in the most unlikely way
in a number of different cities, Rome, Florence and then London. Artemisia, at her very best,
a mature painter. She had escaped from the shadow of her father, Razzia, also a superb painter.
We can compare the two of them and Artemisia stands up as good a post-Caravaggesque
painter in Europe as any other. And she raised the challenge here, it's a vertical picture,
it's a powerful picture. Your eye is drawn to that huge sword, much bigger than the figure
of David, and then the head, Goliath, is right down at the bottom where he belongs.
It's utterly distinctive. It's not like a Caravaggio, it's not like a Feti, it's not
like an Orazio Gentileschi. It could only have been painted by her. It's Artemisia again,
appearing as the hero or the heroine of her painting, this time as David. But it's also,
for me, deeply melancholic. She hasn't got the sort of the hubris of the young David who's
just killed Goliath and is exuberant in his victory. There's a death that's occurred.
It was a necessary death, but there's a kind of regret. There's almost this feeling that
the figure who's done the killing has crossed a certain threshold, will never be innocent again.
I can't think of another picture like it. I find it deeply, deeply moving.
One of the things I love about it, from a just purely technical point of view, is the way that
she's painted the drapery, which seems to me to be so similar to the drapery in Caravaggio's
self-portrait as Goliath. You see the same drapery there, and of course Artemisia would have been
quite likely one of the very few people ever to see Caravaggio painting a picture.
She may well have gone as a little girl with her dad, Orazio, and actually been in the room.
And I get a little shiver down my spine when I see that detail in this wonderful picture.
It's a really magical painting. We should talk about Clara Peters. Artemisia is such a star,
she often sort of somehow draws the limelight. But this Clara Peters is really something,
isn't it? Do you think it's a self-portrait? I think it is self-referential. She is portraying
this figure as an emblem of vanity, and I think she intends for us to see it as her,
beautifully dressed, covered in jewellery, looking well across, which I think actually
goes well with the Annatar's theme. It's interesting the way in which Clara Peters
has almost depicted herself. Do you feel as if she's just another object? It's not a portrait
in the sense that she takes a great deal of interest in expression or character or the
attempt to really capture likeness. It's almost as if that's part of the Vanitas message. We are all
just the same as these other objects, all destined for death and putrefaction and an end to all
things. Exactly. The female figure, which I think refers to herself, is an object in a still-life
painting, a painting with that static, permanent appearance. Do you think that there's a little bit
of a sort of wry smile going on in the painting? We're not entirely meant to see it as all gloom
and doom and vanity, that she's having a little game with the idea of it, inhabiting the figure
of vanity as if to say perhaps she doesn't really believe that she is that vain.
There might be some other element to it. Absolutely. We have clear evidence that she
had a sense of humour, a sense of fun, was mischievous and liked to confuse her public,
her viewers. I wonder if it's not almost as if she's saying to us, well, if I really were vain,
would I portray myself in the persona of vanity? So she's really sort of,
there's almost this hide-and-seek, where is the real Clara Peters? Is she this vain woman that
we see before us, or is she the person who painted it, who's not vain? I feel like I don't
quite know where I am, I'm in a hall of mirrors, she's beguiling me. You can see in this painting
that she's not just content with painting still life. No, I mean, it's a narrative work of art,
she's pioneering still life painting, but in the very act of doing that, she's reaching higher,
to higher genres, as if to imply perhaps, well, next stop history painting, if I'm allowed,
or if I can. I think that's what's interesting about these painters, is that we can't ever
quite know what their story was. There's no biography of her, so we know very little really
about Clara Peters. Artemisia we know a great deal more about, because of her
tempestuous story and her connection to these very famous individuals, and the fact that there's
journals, and men fell in love with her, and left letters, and so on and so forth. But with
Clara Peters, it's really like, where is she? There haven't been many occasions in which you
could see either of these. The Artemisia is a discovery, it was lost until very recently,
and the Clara Peters was hidden from view in private collections. It's a rare and wonderful
thing to be able to see them both in the same room, you know, on the same day, at the same time
too. It seems to me a fabulous, a fabulous thing to have happened, and well, we look forward to
the sale. Thank you, George. Thank you, Andrew.