Florida homeowners are going broke

Housing Market Breakdown
1 follower
Jul 10, 2025
Folks, in today's video, we're going to talk about property taxes and just how much they have gone up across America.
And I'm also going to talk about a new strategy Florida has to deal with that.
They might be eliminating property taxes in Florida over the next year and a half.
That's right, the governor of Florida wants to eliminate property taxes and the state legislature is now talking about how to get it on the ballot next year.
If the property taxes were to be eliminated, could we see Florida's housing market re-enter a boom?
And just how realistic is the idea of property taxes being eliminated?
I'm going to talk about all those things in this video.
But first, let's talk about the realities facing Florida's housing market right now.
And that's declining values.
According to data on ReVenturap, values in Florida are down 3.8% over the last 12 months.
And in markets like St. Petersburg, where I am right now, they're down 6-7% over the last 12 months, which are very big annual declines.
And on a monthly basis, these declines are getting worse.
So the Florida housing market correction is accelerating, especially here in West Florida.
And one of the reasons it's accelerating is due to property taxes.
The property taxes for many owners in Florida have gone way up over the last 3-4 years.
And that is now resulting in a lot of owners being forced to sell.
Like the owner of this house behind me, everyone.
Take a look at this house.
It's on the market for $424,000.
Now, the owner bought it for $505,000 back in 2022.
So this owner, in 3 years, is taking an $80,000 loss on this house.
A sign of just how big this downturn is starting to get here in Florida.
What is really interesting, everyone, are the property taxes on this house.
I went to the Tax Assessor website and looked it up.
If you're going to buy this house, your tax bill is going to be at least $7,200 a year for a 3-bed, 2-bath house that's 1,450 square feet.
That's absolutely insane.
Those are property tax rates and levels akin to states like Texas and even some states up in the Northeast.
No wonder we have owners in Florida selling and losing money.
As a result, the governor, Ron DeSantis, wants to eliminate property taxes or at least reduce property taxes.
He's floated several ideas to do that.
His main argument is like, why should you as a homeowner, just because you bought your house and it went up in value, be forced to pay a higher tax bill next year?
His argument is that other assets don't work like that, like stocks or crypto.
So why should you as a homeowner have to pay way higher tax bills just because the assessed value of your home went up?
He also makes the argument that he says, you know, they don't really reduce the taxes when the values go down.
So he thinks it's basically renting from the government when your property taxes go up.
And so on the ballot in 2026 in Florida for the voters, there will likely be some type of amendment to the Constitution on the ballot where people can vote on some change to bring the property tax bills down or maybe to eliminate them completely.
The Florida state legislature over the next year is going to deliberate on some ideas that can reduce tax burdens for homeowners in Florida.
Because right now, everyone's owners of homes almost feel kind of like trapped in their houses down here in Florida because the market is correcting.
The values are dropping in most cities and counties in Florida.
You know, in an area like Pinellas County, values are down 6% over the last year.
Down in Sarasota County, they're down 8%.
Down in Punta Gorda, they're down 10%.
Down in Naples, they're down 7% to 8%.
Even now in Orlando and Lakeland, values are dropping.
And values are also dropping in Miami now officially year over year.
So we have price corrections spreading across Florida.
And a lot of these homeowners, everyone, they bought towards the peak in 2021, 2022.
A lot of the owners who are looking to sell now, they bought towards the peak.
And when they go to sell, something is happening that they're not prepared for.
You know, they think their house is worth $450,000 or maybe they think it's worth $400,000 what they paid for it.
They go to list it and the realtor says, no, it's worth $350,000.
And that conversation is shocking a lot of the potential sellers in Florida's housing market because it basically means to sell your house, you need to write a check.
And I want you all to think about that concept for a second.
And this is something that is now discouraging a lot of sellers from coming to the market in Florida because the cat's now out of the bag.
The market here is declining and many homeowners and sellers now know it.
And some of the recent data is actually showing that the new listings onto the market is starting to decline because homeowners are like, I don't want to stroke a check to sell my house.
So if I don't need to sell my house, maybe I'll wait three to six months to list it.
I think some of these homeowners who are waiting to list are going to find out that the values are going to be even lower in three to six months.
But this is a trend we are now starting to see is that some sellers in Florida have become wise to the fact that the market's declining and some of them are stepping out here in Pinellas County.
The new listings, according to Redfin, are down about 14, 15% year over year.
Down in Naples, the new listings are down 23% year over year.
So we'll have to watch that data over the next couple of months to see if there's a rebound in new listings.
But I think there will be because the property taxes are just a real problem for a lot of owners, especially investors.
And this is the key point about the property tax story that you all need to understand that almost no one is talking about is the fact that there's really two different types of owners in Florida.
There's people who live in the home, what they call primary residents who claim homestead exemption.
And then you have investors and second and third homeowners who don't claim homestead exemption.
These two different parties have a very different experience in terms of their property tax situation.
And I feel like it's very important for you all to understand that difference because it's going to have a big impact on the Florida housing market.
It's going to have a big impact on whatever legislation Ron DeSantis in the Florida legislature passes.
Because the reality right now, everyone, is that if you actually are a primary occupant in your home in Florida and it's like the place you live and you claim homestead exemption, you get a lot of tax benefits.
Number one, you can reduce your tax assessed value by $50,000.
So if the value of your house for taxable purposes is 400 grand with homestead, it becomes 350 grand, which means a lower tax bill.
But number two, probably even better than that, is that if you claim homestead exemption, your annual tax assessment can only go up 3% a year.
This was based on a bill signed in Florida many years ago that was meant to make sure that Florida homeowners didn't have to pay higher taxes just because the values went up.
So if you have actually lived in your house, say, in Florida over the last 20 years, your assessed value has only gone up 3% a year.
It hasn't gone up with the market surge that occurred during the pandemic.
And so actually there's a huge difference in the property tax bills that houses pay even on the same street.
I showed you a house over there that the investor was selling that they're paying $7,200 a year in taxes.
Meanwhile, there's another house for sale just up the street.
It's a bigger house, four bed, two bath, 2,000 square feet.
The tax bill on that house is only $1,600 a year.
And it's because the owner of that house has lived there for over two decades claiming homestead exemption.
So their assessed value is only $180,000 when they're listing their house at over $500,000.
So it really is a tale of two worlds in terms of Florida property tax.
If you claim homestead in Florida, it's actually a pretty generous program where you can keep your tax bills really low.
And it's actually a big disincentive to sell your house and move.
Whereas if you're a new homebuyer in Florida, you don't get the benefit of that up front.
And what I mean by that, everyone, it's important you all understand this if you're looking to buy in Florida.
Because I know a lot of you are looking to buy and you might be looking at the MLS sheets with the tax bills for previous years for your houses.
Understand, if the previous owner and the seller of your house was claiming homestead and has a really low tax bill,
you are not going to get that benefit when you buy it.
You are going to be a new owner.
And while you might claim homestead for yourself and get that $50,000 assessed value right off,
you are going to be marked to market on your assessed value and will only be able to cap it at 3% from there.
So don't be deceived if you buy a house in Florida, you look on the MLS sheet at the open house and it says,
Oh, tax bill is only $2,000. You think that's great.
Make sure to check if that owner has homestead and what the actual assessed value is with homestead compared to what it would be when you buy it.
Because in some cases that tax bill could be going up 2x, 3x, 4x from what the previous owner had.
And I've heard some stories of homeowners in Florida buying houses, thinking that the tax bill was low and then getting a rude awakening a year in
when they then get assessed at that market value.
And, you know, in a place here, like in St. Petersburg, the tax rates can be as high as 1.5%, 1.8% of market value.
So multiply that by $400,000, $500,000, you get a pretty big tax bill.
And this is an area, everyone, where I think the values are going to continue to drop, particularly in this zip code here on the west side of St. Petersburg.
We can take a look at the data on the inventory here.
The number of listings on the market has shot up to 209 homes over the last couple of years.
That's an all time record, at least going back 10 years in the data on ReVenture app as far as listings go.
In addition, in this zip code, 53% of sellers are cutting the price as of May 2025.
So when you see those two data points, everyone, inventory and the price cut rate, both at record highs for your area for the last decade,
that's confirming to you that there is a housing correction going on.
I know some of you out there, you know, you're looking at buying, you see different things on the news, you see different people say different things,
and you're unsure maybe of where the market's heading or how much values might drop in the future.
I would implore you guys, take a look at those two data points, for sale inventory and the price cut rate in your city and zip code.
Those are going to tell you a lot about the market dynamics and if prices are more likely to go up or down in the future.
But just how realistic is it to eliminate property taxes, everyone? And are we going to see that actually happen?
There's this news story in Florida about eliminating property taxes. It's getting a lot of coverage. A lot of people are asking me about it.
And so I'm going to tell you now about like my expectations about what I think could reasonably happen here.
And my first thought is that eliminating property taxes in totality is not realistic.
Florida generated about $40 billion in property tax revenue last year.
And that $40 billion was a huge chunk of revenue for school districts, counties and cities.
So it was about 60% of school district revenue from property taxes and 18% of revenue for city and county from property taxes.
So if you just eliminate that, it's going to leave a huge hole in your budget. It also might impact other local services like firefighters and police.
So if you're going to talk about eliminating property taxes, you probably need to come up with some other way to raise money.
One thing they've floated is increasing the sales tax to compensate. I don't personally think that that's a good idea.
Because increasing the sales tax just ends up hurting a lot of people who live locally, especially people who don't have as much money and income.
Increasing sales tax is a big relative tax increase on people who have lower to middle incomes, which there are a lot of here in Pinellas County and a lot of in Florida.
So I would be against increasing the sales tax.
Now another option is that not to eliminate property taxes in totality, but to increase the homestead exemption further.
So if they were to increase the homestead exemption from $50,000 to $75,000 or $100,000, that would have the impact of lowering the tax bills for Florida homesteaded homeowners without necessarily destroying the budget.
And that would definitely help Florida homeowners. It would help the homeowners who have been here long term.
And it would help newer homeowners buying in the market because it would help them have a lower burden up front.
But I would tell you actually what I would do, everyone, is finding a way to lower the tax burden on homeowners, but offsetting it by increasing the tax burden on investors and second and third homeowners.
Because I think the best outcome here is to lower costs for local Floridians. That's the best outcome.
But we don't want to just completely ruin the budgets for the local municipalities by doing it.
And maybe the way you could do that is by having some state level override tax for anyone who is a non-owner occupant.
Could just add an additional layer of taxes, put it into a state fund, and then disperse that fund to local municipalities.
And it actually drives down the assessed values further if these counties mark to market on their tax assessments, further decreasing property taxes.
So I think that's the win-win situation here that the governor and the Florida State Legislature need to consider.
Increase homestead exemption, find a way to make it cheaper for homesteaded buyers, but jack up those taxes even further on the investors and second and third homeowners.
You are going to really help rebalance the housing market here and get rid of the excess of people who don't live here that own real estate and put more real estate into the hands of those who've lived here for a long time but can't afford to buy.
Now, some people aren't going to like that suggestion.
I know a lot of realtor agencies aren't going to like that suggestion.
I know a lot of investors aren't going to like that suggestion, but it's really the best suggestion for Floridians.
So I really hope the governor and the state legislature consider that.
But really, a good question to ask if you're a prospective buyer in Florida or a seller is, you know, where is this market going, right?
And if they pass this property tax legislation, what's it going to do to the market?
And I think net-net is not going to change things too much.
We might see a marginal increase in home buyer demand if they lower the property taxes for Homestead, but I don't think it's going to change the calculus too much.
I think we're going to need to see prices drop by more to bring more buyer demand back in because the affordability just still isn't there.
The average Florida local needs to pay almost 40% of their gross income on mortgage costs right now.
That's just not going to work.
The only other time we saw that was the 2006 bubble before the big crash.
So it's still way too expensive, but it is getting cheaper.
And like I said, in this zip code, we're forecasting a 9% decline over the next year, which would mean about a $35,000, $30,000 savings in your purchase price over the next 12 months if our forecast comes to fruition.
So what some of our users on ReVentureApp have been doing, everyone, is they've been taking these forecasts and they've been bringing them to sellers and realtors who are representing sellers and saying,
Hey, here's some objective forecast to say this market is declining and will decline more into the future.
You've had your house on the market for four or five months.
Let's agree to a price below list so you can sell the house and I can save some money on the purchase.
So if you see like in this zip code, the prices are going to drop 9%, well, then scale your offers down 9% below ask at least.
And bring that to the seller, bring the data to the seller and say, Hey, this is what I'm seeing.
Let's agree to a deal.
Conversely, if you're in a zip code where we forecast values to go up, say four or 5% over the next year, like we do in a lot of areas in the Northeast and Midwest.
Well, then if you're a buyer, it makes more sense to get in the market.
Now, if you're really trying to buy, don't go through this process in the dark, not understanding what's going on in the market.
ReVenture app is here to help you.
So go to www.reventure.app and sign up for our premium plan at a cost of $39 a month.
This forecast is actually very accurate compared to other forecasts.
In 2024, it had 73% accuracy in predicting prices in metro areas across America with the population over 100,000 people.
So this is quite literally the best forecast you can access on the housing market at a low cost of only $39 a month.
This is ultimately a no brainer for you guys out there.
If you're going to buy or sell a house in the next year.
So go to ReVenture app and type in your zip code and unlock that forecast for your market today.
