The hosts are joined this week by Claremont's Vice President of Communications and Beck & Stone co-founder Andrew Beck to recount Vice President JD Vance’s speech at Claremont’s 2025 Statesmanship Award dinner, shining a light on the contradictions of liberals—wealthy, yet vehemently anti-billionaire; white, yet self-deprecating—and discussing the conservative mission to build and unify. Roiling also beneath the surface of the Left is an incendiary concoction of mental illness, confused gender ideology, and a propensity toward violence, most recently exposed in a series of attacks on ICE agents in Texas. Plus: Center for Renewing America CEO and Lincoln alumni Eric Teetsel drops in to discuss the passing of Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill, noting its successes and reactions to it from within and without the Right’s coalition—and joins the media recommendation wrap-up! #claremontinstitute#trumpbill#iceraids
------
Chapters 00:00 Introduction 02:32 J.D. Vance Speech at Claremont 11:26 Leftist Violence 24:15 One Big Beautiful Bill 44:03 Media Recommendations 52:14 Conclusion
Coming up on this episode of the round
table. I do think it is kind of a
remarkable achievement when you look at
it and think about it. You're talking
about a bill that brings together the
priorities of Jim Banks and Chip Roy and
Lisa Marowski.
Hey, that's remarkable.
It's a mly crew. It's first and foremost
a testament I think to Donald Trump and
to the recognition that he is the center
of political gravity and dictates the
agenda and people can push and bob and
weave and try to advance their own
agendas within that context but at the
end of the day he's the leader he's
going to get what he wants and he did
and he got a lot of help from from Mike
Johnson and John Thun and others to get
it there but they listen to him and they
take uh direction from him and it's very
reflective of of him in so far as it's
the priorities that he set out to
achieve in this bill.
[Music]
Welcome everyone once again to the
roundt the editors and publishers
podcast at the American mind at the
Claremont Institute. I am your host Ryan
Williams, president of the Claremont
Institute and publisher of the Claremont
Review Books and the American Mind.
Spencer is out this week having just
hiked up Mount Whitney. We can ask him
all about it next week. So, I'm joined
by managing editor Mike Sabbo, who's
back from his own vacation over the
fourth or the week of the fourth, and
Andrew Beck, a new voice here on the
podcast. Many of you know Andrew from
his work at Beck and Stone, where he's
founder and principal. He's also our VP
of communications on loan while we uh
revamp some of our comms and marketing
uh in the coming year or so. Have been
doing it for a year. Andrew is a man
about town in DC and New York. Those of
you who've been out at events have
probably met him doing great work. Has
built a lot of the websites that we all
know and love, including the American
Mind, First Things, well built or
redesigned, I should say. First things,
new criterion, and many others,
corporate clients included. So, it's
it's good to have Andrew. We wanted to
start today with a bit of
self-promotion. We uh I don't know if we
teased this last week or not maybe, but
on Saturday in San Diego at a now I can
disclose the location, a beloved uh
place for me, having grown up playing
golf there, the Ranch of Santa Fe
Country Club, we honored Vice President
JD Vance with our statesmanship award
and he gave about 35 minutes of remarks
and then uh he had to go cuz he's a busy
man and was there with family on
vacation. So we we ate some dinner and
then Charlie Kirk who was our master of
ceremonies and myself and Mike Anton had
a bit of a roundt conversation. It was a
great event, very small for an annual
gayla for us given the time constraints
and having to book book a decently
elegant venue in San Diego on a on a few
weeks notice. Um so it was about 135
people. So everyone was really in the
action. Uh Vance Vance's speech is now
up at Blaze and linked on our social
media stuff if you guys want to check it
out. Some of you may have by the time
especially this recording drops
tomorrow, Thursday, you'll maybe have
seen it. Um I I commend it to you all.
Uh Vance, you know, talked about he
while he framed his remarks at the
beginning and end with mom Donnie. Uh
this is a raging debate in the Williams
household about whether it's worth
talking about mom Donnie or whether we
should just be depriving him of oxygen
and ignoring him. I think it's a
phenomenon too interesting and important
to ignore, but the good Mrs. Williams
disagrees. We'll see if he's in the next
mayor. She can just claim she was right
and we should have froze him out. But
we'll see. Vance wanted to talk about
the odd left-wing
kind of progressive populist coalition
in contradistinction to Trump's and
Vance's coalition. Theirs being uh
multithnic working and middle class
among other things. and Mam Dani is
being drawn predominantly from white
liberal under 40 maybe under 45 enclaves
in fancy well not fancy but in various
segments of the five burrows of New York
New York City and uh then he talked a
bit about the importance of building the
importance of western civilization and
American civilization and the positive
vision that we ought to advance going
forward and then ended with a kind of
rousing and passionate denunciation of
Donnie, a recent citizen of 6 years or
so who came to America with his family
fleeing violence and now he has the
timmerity and the ingratitude is how
Vance pitched it to give a pretty
ambiguous Fourth of July statement about
the unc incomplete work of America, the
contradictory nature of American justice
and all the rest. So, it was a great
privilege and honor for us to get a bit
of the VP's time. Again, please go watch
the speech. Let us know what you think.
What do you think, Andrew? You were
there.
The speech itself, I think, may turn out
to be quite historic because of what you
described. JD is firing a shot across
the bow of this really a Marxist
coalition. These are various agrieved,
yes, they are white liberals, but many
of them are also recent immigrants who
have come here and have not quite got
the life that they thought they were
going to get. Maybe some went through
college and they uh were anticipating
really being the beneficiaries of this
sort of activist industrial complex that
so many of our institutions federal or
state and local level really embrace
particularly in blue states. Now, once
federal funding is cut off, once the
markets correct, inevitably, as as
happens with all uh socialist wealth
transfer schemes, the people that were
counting on that for their uh
sustenance, they're now very upset.
They're agrieved. And so what what used
to be this sort of uh Fabian
champagne socialist
steady march to a socialist utopia now
turns into a bolevik revolution. And I
think that is why JD is wise to get out
ahead of it. And it is good for us to
talk about it. And and the bottom line I
think is what he brings up that the
gratitude that we should have for this
nation that we have something that is
very special that is unseen in other
parts of the world to this day let alone
the rest of history that we should be
thankful for it and we should be
grateful that we can be part of it and
then we must actually participate in it.
And I loved how he ended with that that
this is something about participation.
That being in America, being an American
means participating in the project. It
means assimilating. It means becoming an
American. It means loving this country.
And it means being part of the work that
we feel that we have to do now to to
truly make it great. Not just for
ourselves. He he brought up his
children, right? He wants this America
for his children and for his
descendants. We we we all need to be
having that type of mentality. And this
is not the mentality that this Marxist
populism that is coming out of the left
is about.
Yeah. I mean, and echoing um some of
Anz's comments, Aness Steman's comments
from last week's podcast, Vance was um
echoing them in the sense that this is
really a movement to a certain extent,
as you point out, not completely, but to
a certain extent of white, young white
liberal resentment in a way of where
they think they should be and their
level of comfort uh and where they are.
And Vance went out of his way just
briefly to say, you know, we shouldn't
in turn resent them or criticize them
for feeling like they haven't really
gotten what they were bargained in the
whole mix of things. So, we have to
understand the roots of their resentment
if we're going to do anything about it.
But it is nonetheless a big driving
factor of the mom phenomenon. I don't
know, Mike, what did you think? No, I I
think Andrew points out an important
problem, which is you contrast, you
know, how Vance came out very strongly
um to how the Republicans ever since AOC
stepped in, how they've kind of treated
her kind of a sideeshow, kind of a joke,
you know, not really to be taken
seriously. And I think we're seeing that
that probably was not the right approach
that I think you really need to head
this off. you know, you need to get the
Hydra right now um before it really
sprouts, you know, many more heads and
that because there is real resentment
out there and and there is a grain of
truth in that. I mean, the economy, you
know, has changed in some fundamental
ways that I think we still need to
grapple with. The bureaucracy is out
there stifling self-government. And so,
and I even kind of go back to the new
left where you like you read Tom Hayden,
you read some of these guys at Berkeley
and it's like, okay, you know, there's
something there. I mean they did
identify that there are some issues with
the kind of you know corporatist
liberalism of of that time of the 50s
and the early 60s like there is a
problem here but what they want to
replace it with at that time was some
LSD romanticism that that was absolutely
going to go nowhere I mean just kind of
a fig leaf kind of covering nihilism um
now you're almost having you know the
the the inroup you know the actual
billionaires and Vance pointed this out
one of the contra contradictions of
liberalism is they're really kind of
critiquing themselves. So, and and
that's just an interesting phenomenon
kind of all the contradictions within
liberalism, you know, attacking a
billionaire class that's actually pretty
much mostly on the left. I mean, you
look at the money, the left has far more
money and far more billionaires, you
know, railing against white people. when
you look at say the Democratic party
basically run by white people and it's
really this kind of idea of
self-abnation of hatred
and it it's like they have to but put
that vicariously through kind of the out
group and that's how they express it. So
I think that there you know he's
highlighting some very important
animating principles of the left and
then in contrast saying look you know
statesmanship is not just about tearing
down um and identifying the problem
which is important that's the first part
but it's actually about building it's
about you know what Trump is doing
actually trying to create you know some
semblance of of greatness trying to kind
of call the American people back to what
they once were um try to reinstill and
reinvigorate some sense of
self-government that allows us to thrive
and that look at what the left has done
but look at what we need to do. There
are so many frontiers still there. The
spirit is still there. So I think that
that forward-looking message is is
extremely important. I think will serve
them well um in in the years ahead
especially in 2028.
Yeah. Speaking of white well-educated
liberals, I just wanted to transition
here to discuss a bit or tie some
threads together on the left at the
moment. They may seem desperate, but
we'll we'll land this plane. First, just
flagging this piece that Blaze media put
out drawing on an Axios piece. The Blaze
headline is white well-educated
Democrats are demanding lawmakers get
quote get shot to prove they're
anti-Trump as deadly violence rises. Let
me just read you the opening graphs so
you can get a flavor of this. While
President Donald Trump continues to
deliver big wins for the American
people, the Democrat base is becoming
increasingly desperate. Several Democrat
lawmakers have expressed concerns as
their constituents grow increasingly
frustrated with what they view as
inaction. "We've got people who are
already desperately wanting us to do
something. No matter what we say, they
want more." Democrat Representative Brad
Schneider of Illinois said, "Some of
them have suggested what we really need
to do is be willing to get shot."
Another Democrat said, "These lawmakers,
most of whom spoke to Axios on the
condition of anonymity, also said most
of these voters were white, well
educated, and live in upscale, suburban,
or urban neighborhoods. What I have seen
is a demand that we get ourselves
arrested intentionally or allow
ourselves to be victims of violence, and
a lot of times that's coming from
economically very secure white people."
One Democrat said, "Not only would that
be a gift to Donald Trump, not only
would it make the job of Republicans in
Congress easier if we were all mired in
legal troubles. We are a group that is
disproportionately people of color,
women, LGBTQ people, people who do not
fare very well in prison." Democrats are
growing increasingly concerned that the
grassroots base is expecting bloodshed
as penance for Trump's historic victory
in November 2024 and all his
administration has accomplished since
then. Our own base is telling us that
what we're doing is not good enough.
that there needs to be blood to grab the
attention of the press and the public.
One Democrat said, "It's like the Roman
coliseum. People just want more and more
of this spectacle." Another Democratic
lawmaker said, "Well, actually, there
are some members, perhaps fringe members
of that left-wing base who are uh
perpetrating bloodshed themselves."
Recent headline, which a lot of you
caught sight of, I'm sure. Uh this is
just from the Guardian. It's been
reported elsewhere, of course. 10
charged with attempted murder after
allegedly ambushing Texas ICE agents. Uh
federal prosecu prosecutors described
planned ambush with intent to kill ICE
correction officers on 4th of July in
Alvarado, Texas. And then the 10 people
that have been charged, uh if you look
at their mug shots, there are four women
allegedly in this photo, but it appears
to me that at least three of them are
male to female trans quote unquote
women. Uh, and it ties to this other
insane story. It's not too far a field,
but it's worth just referencing that and
then commenting and we'll we'll get
rolling on this. But this is a piece
about the Zizians, which we had brought
up a while back. It's probably been a
year or so or a year and a half. This is
definitely a Pulos beat, a James Pulis
beat. Uh, you'll not be surprised to
learn he was tracking this thing. The
headline from the New York Times over
the weekend, a somewhat you know medium
long piece is she wanted to save the
world from AI then the killing started
and it's about this male to female trans
Ziz Loda and her cult of sorts who
started referring to themselves as
Zizians. Here's just a little color from
the middle of that piece or the middle
beginning. Anyway, Ziz, who grew up in
Alaska as the oldest of three siblings,
was homeschooled for some of her
childhood. As a pre-teen boy, Ziz grew
depressed. She saw puberty as evil. She
later wrote on her blog sinceriously and
was horrified at the idea that she would
be killed overwritten by a new self.
That's a quote. She began to feel like
the world was a hypothetical. A key
epiphany was realizing that even if she
couldn't fix her own problems, she could
make things better for others. One of
the happiest thoughts I've ever had, she
wrote. in the early 2010s while
attending the University of Alaska
Fairbanks where her father taught
instructional design. She studied
computer science. Uh she's very worried
about the risk posed by AI and they're
followers of some of these AI doo
doomers who think that as soon as we get
as soon as we cross the the threshold of
fully intelligent uh AI that AI will
wipe us all out. Skipping a little bit
for a time Ziz found a community in the
rationalist scene. She attended house
parties. This is a group of AI skeptics
in uh San Francisco Bay Area. Uh
attended house parties, meetups, and
workshops organized by the Center for
Applied Rationality. She posted on less
wrong, weighing in on topics like
logical paradoxes and optimizing
decision-making. Soon she started taking
hormones and posting under the name Ziz,
a villain in an online fantasy story.
Often wearing a black cape and
addressing people with names like Master
Jedi. She claimed her religion was Sith,
the Darth Vader aligned order in Star
Wars. Ziz stood out. Anyway, it's a it's
a story of her and a few compatriots
first stabbing their landlord who wanted
to evict them after the moratorum on
evictions was up postco. Then they
traveled to Pennsylvania and one or two
of them. It's unclear they the police
weren't able to charge any of them.
Although the the gun um gun ballistics
matched or the ammunition anyway matched
uh the guns in the possession of uh one
of those members of the Zizians. they uh
one of them or a group of them or who
knows killed that that person's parents.
They later another one associated with
the group later went back to that same
landlord that they'd stabbed and
finished him off because they were
worried he might testify. Anyway, this
they're all under trial or Ziz and a few
others are under trial in Alageney
County and Pennsylvania for murder and
other things. I I just wanted to tie all
these things together to say, you know,
something sort of dark is brewing on the
left. It has been for some time for
those of us observing 2020 and its
aftermath and the um Trump derangement
syndrome that has possessed a lot of the
left-wing base, but the the very it
seems like a portion of the very young
left-wing base. Uh and you see this in
Greta Tunberg and some of the doomers on
the young left on the question of the
climate. You see it here with AI. you're
seeing a real turn to violence. And if
you look at analyzers of domestic stages
of civil war and conflict, we're well
along into the mercenary kind of
assassination phase. And I suspect now
that ICE has a budget that's larger than
the Marine Corps and they're going to
ramp up deportations. Unfortunately,
this I think will be a pretentious of
things to come. We'll see. This has been
a theme for us for weeks, including the
discussion of Madani. We'll see how the
left is going to deal or at the center
left anyway, the mainstream of the
Democratic party is going to deal with
all of this, this kind of witch's brew
of mental illness uh somehow tied to a
certain uh view of gender and transness.
I don't want to freight too much with
that or make too much of a causal
connection, but the takeaway really is
that the youth on the left, the kids on
the left are not all right. And uh it's
uh it's rippling out into our politics
and culture.
And this kind of reminds me again just
to go back to the new left. I remember
reading Brian Burrow's book uh days of
rage where about the 60s and the 70s and
the weather underground and the bombing
of the Pentagon and the capital and all
the kind of desperate splinter groups uh
and cells that were out around that time
on the left that were doing real
violence, setting bombs, you know, Bill
Ays, Bernardine Dorne, many many others.
um you see, you know, the Manson's um at
that time and kind of what they did uh
best captured by uh Quentyn Tarantino's
uh latest movie. So, this is really in
the left's kind of DNA. You really see,
you know, the assassination of of John
F. Kennedy. Yeah. Like you said, Ryan,
you don't want to go too far, but I
mean, there definitely some seems to be
just some kind of connection at some
point to if they don't get what they
want, they're obviously dispirited. You
know, Trump Trump has won again. Um you
know, we'll talk about this in the next
segment. the big beautiful bill has
passed. No matter how many missteps or
whatever you think, you know, Trump is
making, you know, at the granular level,
I mean, he is winning. He he's kind of
FDR and his opponents don't really know
what to do. So, of course, their foot
soldiers are, I think, just going to get
more and more radical and it'll be like
you said, I I can see, you know, people
like Andrew Sullivan, you know, calling
this out, some people on the center left
who obviously are going to be horrified
at this kind of thing. But, you know,
you really wonder all the huge network
of groups, Antifa. Um, that's, you know,
I think this was an Antifa cell in North
Texas in uh, one of the attacks on uh,
ICE facilities. I think there were two
actually over the weekend and the
seventh and then the fourth. Um, one of
them was a North Texas Antifa cell. So,
this is going to be something I think,
you know, we should be investigating
more and more and more. The Trump
administration, you know, should
certainly be aware of these things. I'm
sure that they are because, you know,
without kind of a pressure valve, you
know, we'll see what happens with the
2026 midterms, but I don't think that's
really going to pacify these people. I I
mean, the GOP map looks pretty good for
the Senate. You know, the House may be
up for grabs, but that's not going to be
enough for these people. So, I think
just, you know, watch out and be
prepared. The the great irony of all
this, Ryan, has been the level at which
the media has for years said that
violence is a right-wing tactic. And
there is this panic that they try to
start over these various groups who are
espousing violence. And we've we've been
victims of some of those smears before.
But violence, at least political
violence, is the tool of the left. And
ultimately, anarchy is what these folks
want because they believe that the
system and really the entire Western
civilization is corrupted, is bent
beyond measure, and only its destruction
and rebuilding upon it is going to fix
it. And so yes, Mike, if they don't see
that progress happening in this in this
nice slow march through the
institutions, they are going to tear
down the institutions themselves. And
they will freely admit this from inside
these institutions, from inside these
universities, from even inside private
companies that it is our responsibility
to take these resources and to use them
for the cause of social justice. But
really this is what what we are
describing is this sort of global
communist project. And yes, the federal
government, what should the federal
government be doing? You brought up
Mike. Let's not forget that the FBI was
created in the early 20th century in
order to deal with and respond to and
prevent assassinations
by anarchists. Th this this was a big
thing in the turn of the 20th century.
We we need to be on our toes about this
and it is really our government's
responsibility and the agency that has
been tasked with this responsibility to
fulfill it. So yeah, that's that's
that's what I would say with this. I
would say yes, people who love America
should should be on guard. Yes, we
should absolutely be talking about this
and be aware that these folks will not
get the same treatment from the media as
they gave us though we did did not do
anything. Luigi Manion just the the
sloppy French kiss that the media gave
him I think encouraged just like we said
it would a lot of copycats and it signal
that you will not be a pariah for
committing assassinations and violence.
You will actually become a hero. You
will become a martyr for the good cause,
comrade. And this is something that the
FBI should be dealing with very harshly,
very swiftly in order to write the ship
and bring order back so that it is
communicated. You will not be able to do
this and be celebrated. You will be
prosecuted hopefully if and and if you
have indeed done these acts, you will be
executed summarily.
Well, some harsh words for Mr. Beck, but
I think they're warranted. These are
serious times and we ought to be
cleareyed about uh what exactly they
are. It's why I flagged a couple of
these things just for folks to get a a
gauge of the temperature of the leading
left-wing Antifa, etc. movements. And
with that, we're going to talk about
something more positive. That is the big
beautiful bill that passed over the
weekend and was uh signed into law well
signed into law really on Friday. So we
wanted to get someone who knows a lot
about it. uh Lincoln alum of the
Claremont Institute, Eric Titel. He's
the CEO for the Center for Renewing
America, the excellent organization that
was founded by Russ Bat, who Russ is now
running OM for the Trump administ
administration for the second time. And
uh Eric was uh working with Russ there
and took over for him. And Eric has a
long career in legislative affairs and
the think tank world, chief of staff to
Senator Josh Holly, among other
experience. So, Eric, we thought we
might get you on here to talk about the
uh the to the extent that you want to or
or this extent you want to highlight
stuff, what's uh what's the good, the
bad, and the ugly of the of the OBB as
it's been
the OB.
Yeah, the uh
Well, thanks Ryan. Uh it's great to be
with you and uh great to see my friends
uh Mr. Beck and and Mr. Sabbo. Uh hope
y'all are doing well. Uh thanks for
having me. I'm happy to talk about this
and I'm happy to talk about it in as
much depth or uh or as little sort of
like wonky nonsense as you and and your
listeners would prefer. Um I'll just
start with a little bit of framing and
then let you take it from here. We'll
talk about whatever you want. The
process of reconciliation has become one
of the very few ways that
unadministration can actually move the
ball forward on their agenda outside of
executive action. There are a couple of
what what we on the hill would refer to
as vehicles that you can rely on to
move. That's a legislative vehicle in
any given year. An appropriations bill
would be an example. In some form or
fashion, we have to fund ourselves every
year and that always gets complicated
largely because people recognize it's
one of few opportunities that they can
attach their priority to. Another one
would be the National Defense
Authorization Act, the NDAA, um, which
has been done every year uh, reliably
and becomes a a sort of a Christmas tree
that you can hang your priorities on.
Both of those processes, however,
require bipartisan agreement to get 60
votes in the Senate to move them
forward, and that's largely why they're
terrible, because of the the process
that's required to do them.
Reconciliation is unique in that it can
be done in the Senate with just a
majority, 50 votes plus the vice
president breaking a tie. So you don't
need Democrats in order to advance your
agenda or if you're a Democratic
administration, of course, you wouldn't
need Republicans to advance your agenda.
It is cabined. There's only so much that
you can do through reconciliation. And
we can talk more about those details,
but there are fairly wide parameters and
uh therefore it's a unique opportunity
to move the ball. And President Trump
knew that coming in. He knew he'd have a
Republican majority in both the House
and the Senate and that reconciliation
was going to be a major major
opportunity to advance the ball on a
number of fronts. Pretty early on in the
process, the administration said, "Here
are our priorities. We want to fund
border security and deportations. We
want to renew the 2017 tax cut plans,
the tax cuts and jobs act, and do some
other work on the sort of taxes and
deregulation front. That was a priority.
They wanted to move some defense
spending into the mandatory side of the
bucket. And I can talk more about that.
And then fourth, they wanted to raise
the debt ceiling, knowing that that was
going to be something that would have to
be done one way or the other. And better
to do it in a partisan fashion in
accordance with conservative priorities
than to have to cut a deal with Chuck
Schumer in order to uh avoid violating
the nation's debt ceiling. So those four
priorities were what they started with
and this bill delivers on all four of
those primary objectives. It's a huge
win on all of those fronts. It does
other things too. And this is where you
get into the priorities of other members
of Congress, namely the Freedom Caucus,
um, and some Senate Republican
conservatives as well, who wanted to use
this as an opportunity to cut spending.
they successfully got to a place where
this bill eliminates about $1.5 trillion
dollars. Some numbers put it a little
bit higher than that in federal
spending, which is far and away the
largest single cut in federal spending
that has ever happened um in the history
of America. Uh I was in a meeting the
other day where someone pointed out that
the uh Medicaid reforms alone in this
bill are three times the size of the
Medicaid reforms that were famously done
by Nuke Gingrich in the new Republican
Congress in the mid '90s. That's the
size and scope of the accomplishment
that we're talking about. Um now it is
also true that um in this case as in
every case there's the world of what
could have been done potentially right
and there are certainly those in our
movement who are saying rightly we have
potentially a catastrophic debt and
deficit crisis on our hands and cutting
$ 1.5 trillion is really good but you
know what would be better cutting $2
trillion cutting $2.5 trillion um
they're not wrong I agree it would be
better to do that um it'd be better to
go deeper into Medicaid reform. It'd be
better to do a whole host of things. Um,
and they fought to get those things
done, leading us to the point where the
Overton window was moved to to where 1.5
trillion is what is accomplished. And
it's a landmark achievement. And I think
they should be very proud of where we
ended up in this while at the same time
getting some rest, gurning up their
loins, and coming back to get the rest
on the next one.
Could you talk a little bit, Eric, about
the the nature of those Medicaid cuts?
Uh the left of course is demagoguing
this as they have since at least the
80s. You know, it's it's always it's
always the same. Republicans pass
legislation and uh women and children
will die. But my understanding, and you
can uh sort of embellish or correct me
if I'm wrong, is a lot of this is
cutting back on this ratchet effect that
has happened in recent years with the
rise of especially disability under
Medicaid and uh the growing sense in
which the these health care provisions
from the Great Society have bloated into
really sort of welfare for plenty of
able-bodied Americans through fraud or
fibbing or just lack of any incentive to
get off of them. Yeah, I'm happy to talk
about this. Um, not my area of absolute
expertise, but um, I've I've had to try
to get smart quickly, and some of you
all may may know more than me. Let's
start with Obamacare. So, the AA is
passed, uh, 2008,
2008, 2009, uh, 15 years ago. And in
hindsight, the, uh, the shortcut
understanding of what Obamacare does is
a massive expansion of the people who
are eligible for Medicaid. So, um, you
had this population, the traditional
population that we would think of who
would be in need of medical care due to
their impoverished state, uh, single
moms with multiple kids, right? That
that's the Medicaid population
traditionally understood. Um, what
Obamacare did is it said, "We need to
expand that. We can't get Medicare for
all done. We can't get universal federal
health care done. So, let's just creep
Medicaid out until it eventually covers
more and more of the population. Namely,
that population was ablebodied working
men. A population that most of us,
especially conservatives, would say,
"Why are these folks on Medicaid? Why
don't they have a job?" And uh and
nevertheless, that's not the view of the
left. It wasn't the view under
Obamacare. And so, they expanded the
population to cover those folks. And
then they incentivized states to play
their part in the expansion of Medicaid.
Medicaid's a program where the federal
government covers a large portion of the
medical costs for people who are covered
and states cover the rest. With the
traditional population, the federal
portion that's covered is between 50 and
70%. With the expansion population after
Obamacare, it's 90% federal coverage. So
the federal government, just to so we're
clear about this, covers a much higher
percentage of the cost of care for the
people who should be on Medicaid the
least, right? And that's the expansion
population. One of the things that
conservatives wanted to do in this
reconciliation bill uh that the left, as
you point out, Ryan, is is crying is
going to kill women and children was
simply to lower the matching rate for
the expansion population so that it was
the same as the traditional population.
That's the egregious error that they're
claiming is going to kill people, that
working age, able-bodied men would have
their health care subsidized by federal
taxpayers at the same rate as single
moms with kids. That's one of the
reforms that saves hundreds of billions
of dollars. I've got another one that
they wanted to do, work requirements,
which we which we alluded to already.
They expanded the requirement that those
who are eligible for Medicaid be
required to do some work in the hopes
that we are lifting people up and
putting them in a position to experience
the joy and the dignity of eventually
being able to provide for themselves
again. Right? That's the goal. Uh
especially for that uh working age male
population. And then there's a third
piece, and I'll stop rambling, which has
to do with something called provider
taxes. Are you all familiar with with
this at all? Um, it's basically a giant
moneyaundering scheme that states use uh
to underscore their budgets. So, you
have this match, right? The federal
government pays a certain percentage,
the states cover the rest. What states
figured out is if they tax Medicaid
service providers and then add the cost
of that tax that they've applied to the
bill they send to the federal
government, they can juice the amount of
money they're getting from the federal
government. And so they've been jacking
up the tax rates that they charge on
Medicaid providers in order to bolster
their state budgets. And then they send
some of that money back to the Medicaid
providers uh as a sort of hat tip. Thank
you for being a part of our scheme. One
of the things that conservatives wanted
to do in this bill was simply to cap
what that tax would be. Not to get rid
of it, not to eliminate it entirely as
the moneyaundering scheme is that it is,
but simply to say fine, you can juice us
for the money, but only at a rate of 3
or 4%. Not the six or eight or 13% that
states might otherwise charge. And
again, this just leads to the howls and
cries from folks who say that we want to
kill children as a result. It's been
typical of modern programmatic
liberalism, right? All quote unquote
progress which has been made on social
service provision by the federal
government, which the left seems to
define as the feds spending more of that
pie. Any retrenchment on it through
normal legislative processes is somehow
per se illegitimate. Uh it only gets to
get ratcheted up. It never gets to get
ratcheted back. Uh well, thank you,
Eric. You know, you weren't you weren't
rambling at all. That's very helpful.
I'm going to get Mike or Andrew to jump
in on this. Ask you anything they want.
Yeah, Eric, uh it's great having you on
the uh podcast. And so I've been looking
at it looks like some of the polls
suggest that this bill might not be
hugely popular. Obviously, I think I saw
one poll that said, you know, 2% of
Democrats were in support of it, but it
said only 67% of Republicans and it
said, you know, even a majority, you
know, might be underwater in terms of uh
Medicaid, what they did there. How do
you kind of do you see that more as like
a a comms issue? Do you see some of the
priorities maybe not meshing exactly
with what you know the new rights
looking for that some portions of it
don't seem to be as concerned with you
know making tons of fiscal cuts and
making kind of the the Thomas Massie
Rand Paul kind of fiscal stand. Um what
are your kind of thoughts on on
navigating you know those fissurers?
Yeah that's a great question Mike. I I
think that it probably does boil down to
a communication question on the one
hand, but but also partly to to the
substance of what it is that was
attempted to be accomplished, right? On
the tax side, which is central to this
whole thing, most of the benefits are on
sort of the business side, right? We're
talking about R&D expensing stuff and
deregulatory stuff, stuff that is going
to benefit Americans widely, but not in
the absolute direct way that the sorts
of like direct cash payments we were
doing under CO would have affected
people in a direct way. There is some
personal side stuff that's included in
this. It expands the child tax credit,
for example, and makes it permanent at a
rate of $2,200 a kid up from 2,000 and
tied to inflation. Um, people will
experience that and they'll probably
appreciate it. There's the uh the Trump
baby accounts uh that are part of it
where the federal government's going to
put a thousand bucks in basically a 401k
for everyone who's born uh that people
can contribute to tax-free and grow as a
nest egg for people. I think in time
that will be seen as very popular. But a
lot of that's probably just lost in the
messaging and then crowded out by some
of the bigger picture elements of the
bill. So maybe this is just me, Eric,
from having been in this movement in
these circles in when it when it comes
to both conservatives, libertarians, and
of course the moment that I came into
10, 12 years ago was this more of like a
postfusionist environment, right? And
you kind of thought that fusionism was
over. It was sort of flash in the pan.
And now there's just been this
irreconcilable divide now between the
more fiscally minded libertarians and
the more socially minded conservatives.
It seems to me that both with this
administration and with the inclusion of
folks who are new to this coalition and
then this bill, it feels like we're in
this moment of this sort of fusionism
2.0, I know the sort of 21st century
fusionism and that the OBBB is maybe a
triumph of that fusionism. And so for
one side in this case it is more our
libertarian friends to be saying that it
either doesn't go far enough or it still
includes some things that we don't want
in there but have been included for
political expediency. I mean would would
you agree? Would you say that we should
be messaging this as a as this as this
triumph of a coalition of various folks
from from different camps that have
different priorities and we have created
something that is going to be both
reducing waste that is going to be
improving the quality of life of people
here in America and is going to be
giving everybody not everything what
they want but much of what they have
wanted for quite a long time.
Yeah. Uh, it's well said, Andrew, and I
I do think it is kind of a remarkable
achievement when you look at it and
think about it. You're talking about a
bill that brings together the priorities
of Jim Banks and Chip Roy and Lisa
Marowski.
Yeah, that's remarkable.
It's a mly crew. It's first and foremost
a testament I think to Donald Trump and
to the recognition that he is the center
of political gravity and dictates the
agenda and people can push and bob and
weave and try to advance their own
agendas within that context but at the
end of the day he's the leader he's
going to get what he wants and he did
and he got a lot of help from from Mike
Johnson and John Thun and others to get
it there but they listen to him and they
take uh direction from him and it's very
reflective of of him in so far as it's
the priorities that he set out to
achieve in this bill. There's already
talk, I should say, of a second and a
third reconciliation bill. And uh it's
not quite clear yet exactly what those
might entail, but suffice it to say, a
lot of people feel like there are
priorities, myriad priorities that were
sort of left on the cutting room floor
from this process, and they're going to
pick those back up and drive them. I
could see them being in a number of
areas. uh the personal side of tax
reform, more on entitlements and
Medicaid and on and on, education
probably.
Yeah. I'm I'm curious, Eric, and I don't
know how much you know about this
process, so if you if you're not that
familiar with it, feel free to punt, but
I I'm our our one of our friends, a
mutual friend of ours, and a former
Lincoln fellow himself, James Brad, runs
the Office of Legislative Affairs at the
White House. What is James' life like
now? Hopefully, he's getting some rest.
But what is the day-to-day work of that
office when they're in the pressure
cooker of this kind of thing?
Non-stop. I mean, it's just a real We
should all be grateful to James and the
rest of the team there who have been
working 18our days for months probably
to try to get this thing over the line.
and uh the sheer number of relationships
that they're trying to manage, um
priorities that they're trying to
balance, communication that they're
trying to facilitate, getting the right
voices in the right rooms at the right
times to move the thing forward so you
can get it across the line is hard to
fathom. And there are a lot of voices
who who played a part of that. I'm I'm
proud to say that Russ who you mentioned
who's a friend of all of ours was an
integral part of this largely in
speaking to some of the more libertarian
sort of traditional spending fiscal
conservative types in the especially in
the Freedom Caucus but in the Senate too
and reassuring them how these numbers
add up and what the broader context
outside of reconciliation is that should
give them confidence that we are doing
things to tackle America's spending
problems even if not to the full extent
they might have wished. within the OBB.
Yeah. Do Mike asked the question of
politics and polling. Do you think I
mean I get the sense that uh at the very
least even if some of the tangible
benefits are a little longer tale as you
mentioned for some of the constituents
involved that I mean something had to
have passed to pass nothing would have
been a disaster that would have been bad
very bad for the midterms coming up. So
just the fact that you got a lot of
priorities advanced in a big bill
completed is in in and of itself a
victory and should be politically
salutary as we head into 2026.
100%. And there were absolutely moments
where I and others wondered and feared
that we were heading into sort of an
intractable breakdown where you had uh a
coalition of between three and 25 House
members who were just going to be a no
and uh a small handful of Republican
senators at the opposite end of the
spectrum uh pulling in the opposite
direction. And it was not at all clear
how you were going to break that log
jam, but they were able to do it and
overcome. Many people thought that doing
one big reconciliation bill was a
strategic error uh early on for
precisely that reason. The risks were
just so great. We were arguing do a
quick one out of the gate. You know, get
get some wins on the board and then come
back to the rest. But, uh, that much
credit to the team, people who are
smarter and more strategic than me, who
who saw the possibility and were able to
get this thing over the line by their
self-imposed deadline. It's, uh, pretty
incredible,
right? Yeah. They didn't even have to
delay the July 4 deadline, which, uh, I
was, you know, I, we mentioned on a
previous segment that we honored the
vice president on Saturday in San Diego.
And, uh, my worry for the two weeks
leading up to it was that he was going
to cancel because he had to fly fly back
to break a tie in the Senate. So,
well, I'm glad they could do that for
you, Ryan. Me, too.
Well, good. Well, uh Well, thanks, Eric.
Well, we wanted to wrap up with what we
usually do, which is to ask everyone for
some recommendations, what they're
reading, watching, or whatever. Uh what
are are you uh enjoying right now to
take your mind off the grind of DC?
Yeah. Oh, thanks for asking. So, um and
I'll share a lesson that I've learned
that you all might enjoy. um uh and
inspired in part by my Lincoln
experience because I made stickers as a
result of this uh which I I I learned
from you all. Um so I'm reading this
book about eagles, bald eagles, and it
starts with kind of the story of
America's founding and and getting to
the point where the bald eagle was our
national symbol. By the way, it's never
been in statute that the eagle is our
national symbol. I keep waiting for some
uh congressman to pick this up and and
and push it as their agenda and just win
re-election and with no nothing at all.
But of course, people famously know that
Ben Franklin hated the eagle and and
advocated for turkeys as a more noble
bird. And there's some argument for
that. But but the the the best anecdote
I got from this is the Declaration of
Independence gets done and they
recognize, you know, we're a country
now. We need a seal. you know, real real
nations have seals on their documents.
So, of course, they created a
subcommittee to come up with America's
national seal. And it was Thomas
Jefferson, John Adams, and Ben Franklin.
And these guys bat around ideas
ultimately completely failed. Congress
is like, "These are terrible ideas." It
wasn't until four subcommittees later
and 11 years later that they finally
settled on the seal that we have today.
But Ben Franklin's first proposal was an
image of Moses looking over the Red Sea
as the Egyptian army drowns. And around
the outside of the seal, it would say,
"Resistance to tyrants is obedience to
God."
Incredibly based.
Oh, I love that.
Uh, so I went ahead and asked uh chat
GPT to draw that up for me and and uh
I've got some stickers I'll send your
way.
Oh, nice.
What should have been America's national
seal.
I I I think that is kind of
provoking our British friends, right?
You are the Egyptians that are trying to
keep us in slavery.
Better for diplomacy that we we we just
pick an eagle.
Yeah.
Yeah. Well, the eagle is now our one big
beautiful bird and has been for a long
time.
Amen.
Uh, what about you, Mike?
So, I saw the New York Times. They put
out I think it was like the top 100
films of the 2000s, I think. And I, you
know, kind of read through them, was
curious about the number one. It was the
movie Parasite, uh, that came out, I
think, a few years ago now, if I
remember correctly. So, I hadn't watched
that. Finally watched that. Definitely
should not have been number one.
uh you know not surprising though I mean
some of these movies were were in there
and were ordered the way they were. I
mean some of the directors they they
went over were stam that they didn't
mention was astounding. Tetus Terara
who's a I think he was a Lincoln fellow
with us. Um he yeah Publius. So he had
actually at his Substack postmodern
conservative had a great kind of
critique of that list and then offered a
bunch of alternative films and things
that he thought were far better than
especially some of the top 10. So, I'm
actually going through his list right
now and uh yeah, so far I mean it's
really embarrassing kind of where we are
as a culture uh especially high culture
at the New York Times supposedly. So,
it's uh great to see him, you know, do
do important work in film and I'm going
through that list and I'll definitely
report back uh any other good movies
that I see.
Parasite was that Korean film about
class warfare and yes, psychological,
you know, darkness, right? Basically,
that's right. That's exactly right.
Oh, good. Thanks, Mike. What about you,
Andrew?
Yeah, so I am uh watching sci-fi
animations of the Warhammer 40k variety.
What What if I can channel my boomer in
the audience, what is Warhammer 40k?
Okay.
Or Warhammer 40k. War Warhammer 40k or
Warhammer 40,000 is a tabletop board
game really of various figurines that
you purchase and you paint and then you
play this very complicated board game
with. However, it sort of expanded as
things that become popular with young
men uh increasingly older men um
famously now now um Henry Cavill uh they
they uh really turn into these media
franchises as well. And so there's a
bunch of books that have explained all
the different lore and there is now even
these uh animated films that come out.
They also have video games that have
been very popular. the the Warhammer
universes is one where you have these
various factions, the Imperium of Man
and all these other uh Xenos or sort of,
you know, alien factions all sort of
fighting in this endless conflict across
the stars. It is very uh dark. It is
very nihilistic and it's also just
incredibly awesome. And so, um, highly
highly recommend, uh, at least, uh,
checking out Warhammer, both the
computer games and particularly this
series called Hammer and Bolter, which
you can watch on on various places is
something that I've been I've been
looking at. And yeah, like the stories,
you know, the animation are of course
good. They're relatively short skits,
but I think what draws me to Warhammer
and maybe many people uh who who are
sort of in our circles is the the the
future it's showing you is one where we
win, but we win without God and you win
without uh being tied to and building
upon the civilization that you have. It
is one where technology is woripped and
where uh war is the uh norm and the only
way in in which you get your way is
purely by force. there there is no
reason there is no religion other than
the religion of uh force and of uh war
and and so it's you know one where I
like to hold it up not as you know
something either that is idealistic or
completely unrealistic either it's it's
actually something where if you put us
on a far enough timeline and we forget
God that you know ultimately guided us
and guided our civilization that's ultim
ely where we are going to uh fall. So
yes, there's there's me revealing I'm a
I'm a bit of a dweeb when it comes to
Warhammer and and then also the maybe
maybe some cautionary tales in it for
us. Yeah, I should anyone who's in North
Texas, there's a in Grapevine, not too
far from the Claremont Institute
offices, or at least the Texas offices,
uh there's a a Warhammer 40k cafe and
also some sort of official headquarters.
I've not peaked my head into either, but
uh you got to go do some reconnaissance
there, Andrew.
Now that we have talked about it on the
podcast, Ryan, we're going to have to go
down there and be like, "Hi, yeah, we're
from the Claremont Institute. We're a
think tank. We've been promoting you on
our podcast.
Uh, good. Well, uh, we're right up
against the time limit, so I'll just say
quickly, and this is kind of ho at this
point. It's old, but I'm just
re-watching The Wire, which
grows grows better every time I watch
it. And I will still maintain that the
first breakout HBO prestige TV show is
better. That is The Sopranos. I know
some of my friends disagree vehemently
and like either The Wire or FX's
Breaking Bad, but uh they're all good
and I'm enjoying The Wire. Just the
writing, the characters, the acting um
and the the sort of tapestry of the
whole story uh holds up pretty well. I
will warn everyone who hasn't seen it,
it's pretty profane and there's a lot of
violence in it. So definitely not a
family show. Well, with that, I think
we'll wrap up and thank you all once
again for listening to the roundt. If
you want to follow our work, go to
www.claremont.org.
I will put in a plug. Also, if you want
to follow all the things that Eric and
his team at the Center for Renewing
America are doing, go to americaing.com
and check out their work. It's it's
excellent. One of the few effective and
principled kind of postTrump think
tanks. Not that they endorse candidates,
none of us do, but uh sort of trying to
carry the conversation forward. Uh as
always, you can find all of our stuff at
americanm.org. org as well and
claremontreviewbooks.com.
Go to dc.claremont.org for what we're
doing at our center for the American way
of life. And please rate us and review
and spread the good word of the roundt
podcast. Thanks to the production and
engineering team, the brothers Ganon,
Ryan, and Jake. And thank you all for
listening. We will talk to you next
week.
[Music]
[Music]
Heat. Heat.
[Music]