Đằng Sau Sản Phẩm - Made In China ....?

Cửu Bình T&V
114 người theo dõi
25 Lượt xem video·7 thg 7, 2025
www.vn.minghui.org
An SOS letter, not in a bottle but in a package of Halloween decorations,
traveled 5,000 miles from a Chinese labor camp to the USA, drawing international attention.
Sir, if you occasionally buy this product,
please kindly resend this letter to the World Human Rights Organization.
Thousands of people here who are under the persecution of the Chinese Communist Party's
will thank and remember you forever.
I was shocked at first that they were able to sneak this letter out.
In labor camp, they forced us to work overtime to produce military cloth and export goods.
China's booming economy continues to increase through the use of slave labor.
If I have choices, I really don't think I want to buy those products because
it could be made with blood and tears.
Shoppers in the Western world.
Very few of us think about where the goods we buy come from.
Most of them are made in the Far East, under tough conditions, and many come from China.
In October 2012, when an American woman, Julie Keith in Oregon,
opened a Halloween decoration box for her daughter's birthday party,
she didn't realize what she was going to see would come to be known around the world.
A handwritten letter from an inmate at a Chinese labor camp fell onto her lap.
It was a plea for help.
Sir, if you occasionally buy this product,
please kindly resend this letter to the World Human Rights Organization.
Thousands of people here who are under the persecution of the
Chinese Communist Party's government will thank and remember you forever.
I was shocked at first that they were able to sneak this letter out.
I know that, you know, they can suffer death if they get caught.
People who work here have to work 15 hours a day without Saturday or Sunday breaks or any holidays.
Otherwise, they will suffer torture, beatings and rude remarks.
Nearly no payment. Ten yuan per month.
I immediately went on to the internet and googled the name of the labor camp and,
you know, what seemed to be what they were saying in the letter was true.
Yeah, I was saddened. I had some knowledge of the way things were in China.
But to really have it brought to my attention like that,
it made me sad that people are treated that way.
People who work here suffer punishment one to three years on average, but without court sentence.
Julie posted the letter on her Facebook page
and contacted human rights organizations and the press.
I just want people to know and, you know,
remain aware that this is a continuing problem in China and that these people really do need help.
According to the letter, the box was made in China at the Masanjia labor camp,
where many of the imprisoned forced laborers are members of Falun Gong,
a banned Chinese spiritual group.
There, they often suffer more punishment than others.
Li Yang, a Falun Gong practitioner in the UK,
imprisoned in the Masanjia labor camp in 2001, says the claims made in the letter are genuine.
Around 1,000 inmates were imprisoned there. They were all Falun Gong practitioners.
I did not see any other criminals, and they were forced to twist artificial flowers by hand,
very thin tree branches and little plastic snowmen as well.
During shipping due day, they have to work until 12 p.m., sometimes until 2 a.m.
They were not allowed to sleep if the quota was not finished.
Some senior practitioners were too exhausted to get to their bed.
In 2008, Li Yang obtained asylum in the UK.
Now, every day, she goes to the Chinese embassy in London
as part of a 24-7 vigil held by Falun Gong practitioners in London
to draw attention to those held in Chinese labor camps.
Falun Gong is a Qigong discipline combining slow-moving exercises and meditation
with a moral philosophy centered on the principles of truthfulness, compassion and tolerance.
It was first introduced in China in 1992.
Although the practice initially enjoyed considerable support from Chinese officials,
by the mid to late 1990s, the Chinese Communist Party
increasingly viewed Falun Gong as a potential threat due to its size and spiritual teachings.
On 20th July 1999, the Communist Party leadership initiated a nationwide crackdown
and launched a propaganda campaign intended to eradicate the practice.
Falun Gong is persecuted in China primarily because of the numbers.
There were a hundred million people practicing in the country
and the Chinese regime, some people in the Chinese regime
were nervous about that many people doing something outside of their control.
But there's also the aspect of what Falun Gong is.
It represents the essence of traditional Chinese culture
and the Chinese regime has spent the last 60 some odd years
trying to stamp out Chinese culture.
It's an atheist regime and so there was an ideological factor as well.
The government decided to frame Falun Gong as an enemy.
Some of the most obvious ones are that it had become already larger
than the Chinese Communist Party in terms of its membership, those sorts of issues.
And I think those are true.
And I think from a Marxist perspective,
seeing the spread of Falun Gong through the different class levels and occupations,
rural, urban and all the way up to the Chinese Communist Party itself was terrifying.
This is the way Marxism is supposed to spread,
not Falun Gong.
So from their perspective, that was something terrifying.
Ethan Gutman, an investigative journalist and the author of the book
Losing the New China, carried out many years of observation and research on Falun Gong.
I don't doubt that the Falun Gong values are quite real and they're quite attractive.
They actually represent the whole side of China
which has been completely suppressed for many years.
It's a side of China that most Westerners never see.
It may say, Falun Gong says, well, we're not political.
Well, no, it's not.
But the point is everything in China must be subordinate to the political
in the Chinese Communist Party's mind.
It must be either harmless and innocent and frivolous
or it must be, if it is to have any seriousness, then it must be subordinate.
Human Rights Watch and other foreign observers
estimate that since 1999, hundreds of thousands
and perhaps millions of Falun Gong practitioners
have been detained and re-educated through labor camps, prisons and detention facilities.
Adherents in detention are subject to forced labor, psychiatric abuse,
torture and other coercive methods of thought reform
at the hands of the Chinese authorities, sometimes resulting in death.
In some facilities, Falun Gong practitioners were the substantial majority of detainees.
I estimate that probably up to half a million Falun Gong are in the Lao Gai system right now.
Enormous numbers.
But that's also because the Lao Gai system itself has been underestimated grossly
by the West and by Amnesty International
and by many other groups that ought to know that.
Jennifer Zeng, a Falun Gong practitioner who survived the persecution in China,
said Falun Gong practitioners in detention
consistently received the longest sentences and worst treatment.
On the first day we were there, the police made it very clear that
the only purpose for us to be sent there is to get us reformed.
All sorts of methods of physical torture, including electric batons, beating knobs
and sometimes very shocking methods to female Falun Gong practitioners, sexual assaults
and also sleep deprivation.
And also we were forced to watch those propaganda materials.
And they also forced other criminals to torture us
in order to reach their quota.
And if the criminals do a good job for the police, they can be released ahead of time.
And if they don't reform Falun Gong practitioners, they may also even not be allowed to sleep.
So they turn all the other criminals against Falun Gong.
Jennifer Zeng was imprisoned for 12 months in a labour camp before she fled to Australia
and obtained asylum in 2001.
In 2005, she published a book Witnessing History
about her experiences regarding the persecution of Falun Gong in China.
China's re-education through labour is a system of punishment
that allows for detention without trial.
Under the current system, police can send people to labour camps for up to four years
for a variety of vaguely defined offences.
China began using the system in 1957.
In 1957, when Mao Zedong's class struggle and the campaign against the anti-revolutionaries,
at that time Mao believed that he needs a system without legal trial to put people away.
In 1957, the re-education through labour was established.
It was not a law.
It didn't pass by any legislation body, not passed by the People's Congress.
The system was originally used to detain accused counter-revolutionaries
or other critics of the communist government.
But it was later expanded to punish prostitutes, drug addicts and other minor criminals.
Now the system is also used to imprison people regarded as a threat to the government,
such as Falun Gong practitioners, Muslim Uyghurs in Xinjiang,
members of underground churches and petitioners who had committed no crimes.
Detainees in re-education centres will undergo brainwashing study sessions
and are required to write daily thought reports.
Detainees are often kept there until they change their thinking.
China also uses state-run mental health hospitals to keep political prisoners.
However, in practice, it has led to the creation of a vast network of prison labour camps
known as Laogai across the country.
Chinese state media said China has 310 labour camps
holding about 310,000 prisoners and employing 100,000 staff.
According to estimates from the Laogai Research Foundation,
there are 6.8 million people incarcerated in China's 1,100 labour institutions.
Masanjia labour camp is one of the most notorious labour camps in China
for the most violent, forced deprogramming used by the government to suppress dissidents.
Stories of torture at Masanjia first came out 13 years ago in overseas media.
There's been well over 8,000 reports of torture and abuse of Masanjia labour camp
over the last decade, coming mostly from people who have been detained there
and suffered the abuse themselves.
One case that came out in 2000-2001 was a case of 18 female detainees
who were stripped naked and put into a male jail cell
where they were gang-raped very violently.
This caused quite a stir among the China Watcher community, the human rights community.
In particular, Masanjia.
So I've interviewed, I think, six people, all women I believe,
all fallen god, who were in Masanjia.
And the descriptions, after this case came out,
after this letter dropped out of this women's graveyard pack or whatever it was called,
kind of a Halloween fan myself,
I went back and started listening to those interviews.
And they're quite complex.
There's a lot of information on Masanjia.
It was notorious.
It was the crucible, the most difficult place for a fallen god.
Like many labour camps, the other common criminals,
rapists, murderers, thieves, drug addicts, were at the top of the pyramid.
They were given control of the labour camp in a sense.
Underneath the guards, they were given control.
And they always had high status.
At the same time, a fallen god has a code of non-violence, a code of passive resistance.
And this made them very vulnerable to the conditions inside their individual cell blocks.
Masanjia labour camp, it's very specific.
Set up a women's labour camp in 1999.
I think it's October 29th.
Established by the central CCP and the Minister of Justice.
And they established this special women's labour camp
to brainwash and transform Falun Gong practitioners.
And design different torture techniques.
And then they used this technique and the transformation and the brainwash method
to promote nationwide all China's different labour camps and prisons.
So that's why this is most notorious.
All the techniques were designed in this labour camp.
In April 2013, the Chinese magazine Lens published a story about former inmate Liu Hua,
whose diary recounted the torture carried out in Masanjia women's labour camp.
Liu Hua, a petitioner who was imprisoned at Masanjia on three separate occasions,
said in Masanjia every day they faced long hours of brutal treatment with little sleep and food.
The violent oppression pushed some detainees to suicide.
Our local government paid the labour camp 60,000 to 100,000 Chinese yuan to imprison us.
In labour camp, they forced us to work overtime to produce military cloth and export goods.
Coats for Italy, shirts for South Korea, no tax towards the government and no payment to us.
If anyone could not finish their quota, they would be badly beaten.
On the 22nd of June 2011, a criminal slept on the top of my bunk bed.
She could not tolerate any more and cut an artery on her right arm with small scissors.
Liu Hua was imprisoned, along with her husband, not for any association with Falun Gong,
but for exposing corruption in their local village party.
In prison, she witnessed the treatment handed out to Falun Gong practitioners.
So in Masanjia, there were over 400 inmates.
80% were practitioners of Falun Gong.
The practitioners' workload is much heavier than ours.
If Falun Gong practitioners refuse to work, they will be tortured with extreme methods.
One Falun Gong practitioner told me the police bundled four toothbrushes together
and turned it around inside her private parts to torture her.
The head of labour camp told me there are 36 different torture methods in Masanjia.
If we don't follow their order, they will apply any of them to us.
Liu Hua also said, because there's no legal process in operation,
the term of their detention could be shortened by paying money.
Sometimes, if order quotas were too large to finish in time,
Masanjia would buy inmates from other camps.
The head of our squad told me that if we pay between 80,000 to 120,000 yuan,
we can be released right away.
There's no serial number on our labour camp release form.
For such a report to be published in a mainland Chinese magazine is rare.
It shocked China, and the story quickly spread around the world
before it was censored by the authorities and covered up.
Shortly thereafter, the Chinese government ordered to stop all republication
and reporting on the issue.
After 10 days of a so-called investigation,
the authorities in Liaoning, where the labour camp is located,
denied the claims made in the Lenz report.
Liu Hua said that no representatives of the authorities
have ever asked her and other victims,
but harassed and threatened them not to say anything.
Members of this investigation team
actually are those people responsible for what happened in Masanjia.
The education through labour bureau,
the head of this bureau was former Masanjia labour campus head.
The same person investigated himself.
There won't be any results.
So the results they published denied all the accusation is predictable.
China's booming economy continues to increase through the use of slave labour.
Inmates are used to produce cheap commodities,
which although officially prohibited to go for export,
are often indistinguishable from factory goods
and continue to find their way into the global market.
The US Customs and Border Protection website
states that most cases of products found to be made with forced labour are from China.
Common everyday products ranging from artificial Christmas trees,
Christmas tree lights, bracelets, tools and foodstuffs,
according to a 1998 House Committee on International Relations report,
companies which reportedly have or have had products made in Chinese labour camps
include many major international companies.
Nestle was accused of having some of their products made in Chinese labour camps.
Jennifer Zhang confirmed they made fluffy rabbits for Nestle
when she was detained in a labour camp.
And a special order we received or labour camp received
was 100,000 rabbits, promotional rabbits for Nestle.
So if you buy their products, they give you one for free.
So this rabbit, you know, each one needs at least 10 hours
and more than 30 procedures to make.
And the labour camp only received some five US cents.
And we received nothing.
So the police actually was very proud of the fact
that we can produce products for Nestle
because it's a so huge international company.
Nestle denied the company's business has any links with the labour camps in China,
but did admit it had two companies in China
producing the rabbits for a marketing campaign.
Frederic Koller, an investigative journalist
from the Swiss-French-language daily newspaper Le Temps
found Beijing Michi Toys Company Limited
is one of Nestle's Chinese companies
located just 500 metres away from the labour camp
where Jennifer Zhang was detained.
I went back to Daxing and just to look around the company
to check out if there were no labour camp near this Michi Toys company.
And I easily found out that maybe 500 metres far away from Michi Toys,
there is actually a labour camp called Tiantang He
and that was the labour camp.
Mrs Zhang was detained.
I had other testimonies actually of people saying that
they knew that some toys company
because there are many toys company there as well
used to work with labour camps.
The Michi company denied it had subcontracted the production to a labour camp.
Nestle later introduced a new clause against forced labour
and for its future contracts in China.
As for the product, usually they don't admit
they use this labour camp to produce the product export to Western countries.
They denied, openly denied all the acquisitions.
But actually, when the Western company tried to produce product in China,
they were subcontracted to a Chinese company
and then this Chinese company will subcontract to the forced labour camp.
This way, the company in the United States or other countries
won't be able to know their products were made in the labour camp or jail.
In the U.S. and Canada,
it is illegal to import and sell any products manufactured in the labour camp.
Scott Flipsy, a specialist in American foreign policy
has been tracking Chinese slave labour products issues for 20 years.
He said it is hard for the U.S. to enforce these laws.
Because it requires Chinese cooperation
and China doesn't give that cooperation.
It doesn't freely admit that products are made with prison labour.
And so the way forward here is to expose,
for journalists and activists to expose the camps that are doing this,
to sort of accumulate stories with specific details
about which prisons are the ones that are producing the goods
and then to sort of expose these type of things.
That will do, I think, a lot of good to sort of try to stop this practice.
Now, China is the world's biggest exporter and trader.
Every year, China exports 2,050 trillion U.S. dollars worth of goods all over the world.
In 2012, China exported 376 billion U.S. dollars worth of goods to 27 EU countries,
exported 352 billion U.S. dollars worth of goods to the U.S.
and 54 billion U.S. dollars worth of goods to the U.K.
Currently in Europe, it is still not illegal to import prison-made goods.
The European Parliament has called for a total ban on Chinese goods
produced through forced labour,
which members of the European Parliament say
are still imported into Europe in sizable quantities.
Two and a half years ago, we asked the Commissioner for Trade to really undermine
that those products can be imported in the European Union
because since Laogai Research found out what kind of cams produce what kind of products,
the U.S. already did forbid the import and the EU did not up to now,
and that's really a blame for Europe.
It's frustrating because we asked several times,
we are going to ask again.
It was in March of this year and the Commissioner responsible for trade,
he should be the one who really comes forward with an improvement
and we hope that he will do it one day.
The European Commission says it's too difficult to identify the origin of such goods
and has therefore preferred to opt for dialogue with China rather than an import ban.
It's entirely and totally unacceptable from our standpoint
and I'm not trying to make any excuses for the Chinese authorities.
They must shoulder the responsibility of the way they are involved in this process.
But at the same time, we have to be clear that you can create legislation,
but if it's not enforced, perhaps that's not necessarily the best route,
although we're open to ideas and we are always in contact with MEPs
and members of the European Parliament.
But like I say, right now we feel engagement is delivering results
in the human rights dialogue across the board
and this is an element that we are always raising with the Chinese at every opportunity.
If you are unknowingly taking advantage of those innocent people,
you are part of this crime.
And number two, because Western companies cannot compete
with those low-cost, cheap labour in the labour camps,
maybe hundreds of thousands of them.
And the Westerners, their factories were closed, they lost their jobs.
Tony Caldera's cushion business has been ruined by cheap Chinese imports.
Today, his Merseyside factory stands deserted.
It's just hard to believe that this used to be full.
It was a hive of activity.
There was hundreds of people working here.
They all had jobs for life.
You know, we were the number one cushion maker, probably in Europe.
It was all made here.
Everything was made in England and life was great and we were all happy.
All of a sudden, China's come along and we just can't compete anymore.
I've got no choice.
I've got to go to China.
I've got to try and make it work over there.
Otherwise, that's it.
It's finished.
The products made in labour camps are produced by people who are forced to work
and are in unsafe and unhealthy conditions.
Because of malnutrition, sleep deprivation and stress,
detainees in labour camps often contract lice, scabies and other ailments.
SIG detainees are still forced to work.
Many are not allowed to take showers for long periods of time,
allowing all manner of bodily substances to come into contact with the items they manufacture.
These products are then shipped all over the world.
Sophie Liu, a Falun Gong practitioner and a Chinese labour camp survivor,
said she was kidnapped by agents of the Chinese Communist Party four different times.
She was forced to endure three horrifying years inside of a Chinese labour camp,
producing chopsticks and cotton swabs in very dirty conditions.
The hands got hurt reading, but they had to work.
The chopsticks were very dirty.
I stayed there for 30 days, but we never took a shower.
It's July in Beijing.
It's very, very hot.
They said it's for exporting.
There is water there.
It's sanitised.
But it's very, very dirty.
So I said to them, we can't do that.
It will hurt people.
Then they beat me.
Sophie Liu was granted asylum and now lives in the US.
If I have choices, I really don't think I want to buy those products because
it could be made with blood and tears by those innocent people in a labour camp.
Why can they be so cheap?
You really don't know.
And they work to death without being paid any money.
Julie Keith took the box and letter to the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement's
Homeland Security Investigations.
The Homeland Security Office of Public Affairs confirmed that the case is being looked into.
In June 2013, the New York Times reported they had found the man who wrote the letter
and tucked it into the box of Halloween decorations that was found by Julie Keith.
According to the New York Times, the 47-year-old former inmate
was detained at the Masanjia labour camp for his faith in Falun Gong.
He wrote 20 similar letters over two years
and hid them inside products he believed were to be shipped to the West.
He was released from the labour camp in 2010.
The article says the man's account of life in the camp
matched those of other inmates who say they produced the same Halloween-themed items.
For Julie Keith, the news came with a feeling of relief.
Julie Keith now checks the label of everything she buys.
Her friends, she said, do the same.
I really try to not buy made-in-China products.
I understand that not every product made in China is made under these conditions.
But I always think, I don't go to the dollar store anymore
because everything there is made in China.
So I really try to be more careful.
I hope it helped.
There's a lot of people that said they would really try to change their shopping habits,
really be careful about the items they're purchasing.
If people can change the way they think about their purchases,
maybe it'll make a difference.
