$3 VS $60 Colored Pencils | CHEAP VS EXPENSIVE! Which pencils WIN?

Coloring Art
30 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Colored pencil sets can vary massively in price,
with cheaper sets costing only a few pound
to more professional brands
with pencil sets that cost hundreds.
But are expensive pencil sets actually worth it?
I'm going to put one of the cheapest
and most expensive colored pencil sets to the test
to see just how big of a difference there is
between the cheap and luxury colored pencils.
Hey everyone, my name is Kirsty,
and my channel is all about helping you
improve your drawing skills
so that you can create art that you are really proud of.
For this challenge, I'm going to be comparing
the Crayola 24 set of colored pencils,
which costs around three pound 50
to the 20 set of Caran d'Ache luminance pencils,
which retail for 50 pound.
So this means that the Crayola
only costs about 14 pence per pencil,
whereas the Caran d'Ache actually cost
a massive two pound 50 per pencil,
which is like 17 times more expensive than the Crayola.
Let's take a closer look at these pencil sets.
The Crayola pencil set just comes in a thin box,
which means these pencils have very little protection
to stop the pencil leads from actually breaking.
The build quality of these pencils looks pretty decent.
The wood casing at the end is exposed, and so is the lead,
but for this price, you really can't expect much more,
and the pencils do look fairly sturdy quality.
The Caran d'Ache comes in a much stronger box
and has a foam insert that really helps protect
each pencil from damage.
The pencils straight away feel really high quality.
The lead looks thicker and creamier.
The wooden casing is thicker and smoother,
and the end of each pencil is even nicely concealed
with a cap of the color of each pencil.
One of the big reasons these pencils are so expensive
is because of their lightfastness.
These pencils actually have the highest
lightfastness ratings possible,
which basically mean that their colors won't fade over time.
This is especially important if you're a professional artist
and you don't want the colors to get dull
after just a couple of years.
This is definitely one of the big reasons
for the high cost of these pencils,
but isn't necessary or important
if you are a beginner just starting out
practicing using colored pencils.
So this pencil set is definitely targeted
towards more advanced colored pencil artists.
The first thing I did with both pencil sets
is swatch the colors.
To make this comparison fair,
I will be using 20 pencils from the 24 Crayola set
to match the size of the Luminance set.
I will be really interested to see
how these pencil sets perform against each other
because even though I've used both of these before,
neither of them are the pencil set
that I actually use for most of my colored pencil drawings.
And if you do want to know the supplies I use
to create my realistic colored pencil drawings,
then I have got a free colored pencil supply guide
that I will leave a link to at the top of the description.
I go through the must-have supplies
for anyone starting out with colored pencil drawing
and some tips for choosing the best pencils,
paper, and everything else you need
to get started with colored pencils on a budget.
But anyway, let's start to get a feel for these pencils.
I start by swatching the first half of the Crayola pencils,
and the Crayolas definitely had a hard lead,
which meant that it was easy to be more accurate
with my coloring and stay within the borders of each box,
but it also meant that it took a long time
to fill in each swatch of color.
I also found that with the Crayolas,
I had to apply quite a lot of pressure to the pencils
to create a heavy application of color
and to actually get the colors to look vibrant.
I like to work using lots of light layers,
so the fact that I had to apply lots of pressure
to get an intense color could be a problem.
Now I am swatching the first half of the Caran d'Ache pencils
and I tried to get as many matching colors as I could
so that I had similar colors to work with from both sets.
Swatching these pencils definitely felt
a lot different to the Crayolas.
The Luminance pencils were much creamier,
so it was a lot quicker to lay down
a smooth swatch of each color,
and I didn't have to apply a lot of pressure
to get really vibrant colors
and to fill in all of the paper surface
and remove all of the graininess.
One of the biggest differences I saw
with the Caran d'Ache swatches
is the colors were really rich
and they were actually a lot more vibrant
and deeper in value than the Crayola pencils.
It was definitely a lot harder to get dark colors
with the Crayola pencils,
but it was easy to achieve those intense colors
with the Luminance.
Now moving back to swatching the rest of the Crayolas,
as I continued swatching,
it became really clear that this set did lack darker colors.
All of the pencils were very bright
and more of a mid-tone value.
Only the brown and black were dark in value.
There wasn't anything like a dark blue or dark green.
This pencil set just really didn't have
the darker versions of each color.
But one thing that I did really like
about this pencil set though
was all of the colors felt the same
when I laid them down on the paper.
The quality of these pencils felt very consistent
throughout the set,
and I knew what to expect when I shaded with each pencil.
Whereas with the Caran d'Ache pencils,
I found that there was more of an inconsistency
to how the pencils laid down.
Most of the pencils were really smooth
and buttery to lay down,
but others like the Manganese Violet,
the Russet or Perylene Brown felt more scratchy
and the shading actually looked a bit more bitty and chunky
rather than creating that smooth, even coverage
that the other pencils did.
Also, because the Luminance pencils are so soft,
it was harder to be precise with these pencils
and get really clean, crisp edges,
which could cause problems
if you want to add lots of fine details
to your colored pencil drawings.
Now, all of these swatches were done on white paper,
but sometimes you might wanna use toned paper
or even black paper.
So I thought it'd be useful to test
how both these sets perform on different types of paper.
When I swatched on the black paper,
it became obvious the difference
between these two pencil sets.
The Crayola pencils just didn't show up very well at all,
and the colors looked very dull,
whereas the Luminance definitely were a lot more opaque
and looked very vibrant on the black paper.
Especially the white pencil,
which really showed up well on the black,
compared to the Crayola white pencil.
I also tested the pencils on toned tan paper.
Now, the Crayolas did show up better than on the black paper,
but they still didn't have that same color payoff
that was as good as the Luminance pencils,
especially the white Crayola pencil.
It just didn't show up very well at all.
Next, before we dive into a full drawing,
I wanted to do a few quick tests
to get a feel for these pencil sets a bit more.
First, I wanted to practice and experiment
with shading with these pencils,
and I'm not trying to be perfect with these drawing tests.
This is just a way to get a feel for these pencils
and learn more about what does and doesn't work
with each pencil set.
I practiced shading in a sphere with the Crayola pencils,
and I liked that I was easily able
to achieve lighter versions of each color
just by reducing the amount of pressure
I applied when shading.
This can be harder to do with more expensive pencils
that have such an intense color payoff,
even with less pressure.
Now, the harder lead made it actually pretty easy
to get smooth shading because the fine point
was able to get into more crevices of the paper,
and so I didn't actually get a very grainy result
like softer pencil leads can give,
which is good because it means that I wouldn't always
have to burnish everything out to get a smooth result.
The shading can look smooth
even when you just apply light applications of color.
Now, drawing the sphere with the Luminance pencils
was a whole different experience.
The pencils were faster to lay down
and blended really easily to get a smooth result.
These pencils definitely feel a lot
like oil pastels to work with.
They really are super smooth,
which is nice if you are doing really smooth drawings
with very little detail, but it could cause problems
if you're trying to create more textured drawings
like drawing animal studies.
Next, I wanted to test how easy it was
to layer multiple colors together,
and I found that both pencil sets
did a really great job at this.
Often when I draw skin,
I have to layer lots of different colors,
so I thought it would be good to test
creating a skin color with both pencil sets.
I was really easily able to layer the Crayola pencils
on top of each other.
I layered yellow, red, brown, and pink,
and the colors just meshed together beautifully
and created a really realistic skin tone.
I even layered the white on top
to blend the colors together a bit more,
and the paper just took the Crayolas so well.
The Caran d'Ache also layered really easily together.
I layered those same colors
and achieved a similar result as the Crayolas.
For realistic drawing, it's also really important
to be able to gradient and transition
between different colors seamlessly,
so I wanted to create a color gradient with each pencil set.
I tried to create a gradient from green to blue to purple,
and found that both pencil sets
really did perform very well.
They created beautiful color gradients,
and I just couldn't see any issues with either set
that would stop you from creating smooth color transitions.
Now, burnishing is the most common method
of blending color pencils,
so it's very important that you can burnish easily
with your pencil set.
So first, let's burnish with the Crayolas.
Burnishing is just applying more pressure to your pencils
to blend and mesh previous layers of colors together
to achieve a smooth final color
without any of the paper grain showing through.
The Crayola pencils burnished
to create a really smooth final result,
and all of the white grain of the paper was eliminated.
But the white pencil wasn't very effective at blending,
which could be a problem,
as often white is used to blend out
and burnish colored pencils.
Also, I found that when I burnished the darker areas,
I ended up with more of a patchy result.
The Caran d'Ache pencils burnished really well and easily,
just like we'd expect,
because of those super soft cores.
It just makes the Luminance pencils perfectly designed
for the burnishing technique.
Now, the white pencil was really effective
at burnishing as well,
but the white pencil is so opaque
that you can't really use it to burnish darker areas
without washing out the colors too much.
But personally, my favorite way to blend out colored pencils
is using solvent blend.
So I wanted to test this out,
and I started laying down some shading
with the Crayola pencils,
and then I used the solvent and a brush
to blend out that shading.
And the solvent was really easily able
to blend out the Crayola pencils
and remove all that graininess
to give a really smooth, vibrant result.
And after the solvent had dried,
it was also really easy to add another layer
of colored pencils over the top.
The solvent also blended the Luminance pencils
really easily too,
and made the colors look more vibrant
and almost like a painting.
It was so easy to layer other colors on top
after the solvent had dried as well.
Testing how effective the white pencils were
really did show the difference
between these two pencil sets.
I was really disappointed with the white Crayola pencil.
It just was really useless.
It barely showed up,
whereas the Luminance white was so impressive.
It really easily showed up on both blending methods,
and it was really opaque,
and it lightened up that first layer of shading so much.
So whether you buy the Luminance set or not,
it could be worth just investing in that white pencil.
And one of the final things I tested
was the ability to create fine details with the pencils.
The Crayola pencils held their sharp point really well,
and was able to draw in lots of fine details
and crisp lines without the pencils going blunt
or needing to be sharpened.
But the Luminance pencil was just so soft.
And even though I was able to create some fine details,
the soft lead was just wearing down so fast
that I would definitely need to sharpen these pencils
really, really often if I was doing detailed work.
And sharpening pencils can be a headache in itself.
So having pencils that sharpen easily is crucial.
I tried sharpening the Crayola pencils
and found that the wooden casing
just really easily cracked and split if you weren't careful.
And it just didn't feel smooth
when I was sharpening the Crayolas at all.
I could tell that I was sharpening cheap pencils.
In order to actually get a good point on these pencils,
I'd need to use a higher, more expensive pencil sharpener
rather than a handheld one
because they're just so temperamental
that you can't really use a handheld sharpener
like this one.
The Luminance pencils, on the other hand,
were just really easily able to sharpen
even using a cheap sharpener.
The wood felt smooth and the pencil didn't break.
And actually sharpened to a very sharp point.
These tests definitely revealed a lot of pros and cons
for each pencil set.
But just how well will the sets perform
when used for a full drawing?
Let's find out.
For this final drawing, I'm going to work on a portrait.
And I've actually drawn a line down the middle of her face
so that I can color the left side with Crayola
and the right side with Caran d'Ache.
I thought it would be really fun to be able
to actually directly compare the colored pencils
in one drawing to see if I could make it look
like one consistent artwork
that has just been done with one set of colored pencils.
I'm going to start by drawing the left side
with my cheap Crayola pencils.
I'm working on building up the skin tone first
by overlapping lots of light layers
of yellow, red, and brown.
I definitely found working with the Crayolas very relaxing.
They layered really well and weren't too soft.
So I actually did feel like I had a lot of control
over how the shading turned out.
And I was really happy that I was able
to get the brown shading as dark as it needed to be
to match the reference.
Because in the test, the values of the Crayola pencils
were a bit light in comparison to the Caran d'Ache.
Now the left side of the reference
is actually more shadowed than the right.
So this made it even more challenging
for the Crayola pencils.
But I was just so pleased
with how the Crayolas worked in this drawing.
I'm going to take a break from drawing the skin
and actually start to add a bit more definition
and detail to the facial features,
like the eyebrow hairs and shadows on the lips.
Once again, the Crayolas worked really well
for the details because they have such a hard lead.
I didn't have any problems with fuzzy edges
and all of the details looked really crisp and sharp.
And I hardly ever had to sharpen the Crayola pencils.
Once I did the eyes,
I realised I needed to go darker with some of the shadows,
especially the shadows around the eye.
So I used my brown pencil with more pressure
and started to actually burnish the shadow areas
of the skin to create a smoother result.
I even managed to add a few more layers
of yellow, orange and red
to increase the vibrancy of the skin
as it was looking a bit dull.
And I was just so surprised
at how many layers of Crayola I could add to the paper.
And with each layer,
the shading was starting to look smoother and smoother.
I then used the white pencil
to burnish out the rest of the skin.
And I had to press really hard on the white
to get it to work at all.
But it did do a nice job at smoothing out
the grainy shading
and did produce a realistic looking skin texture.
Because the white pencil isn't very opaque at all,
it really didn't change the colours much.
And it kind of acted more like a colourless blender,
which worked really nicely for this section of skin
that was a darker value,
but wouldn't be very helpful
if you wanted to use the white to lighten your shading
or to add highlights.
Once I was happy with the skin,
I added in the eyelashes using the black pencil
and found that the black
was able to achieve a really dark value
and create a nice level of contrast in the face.
I also used the black and brown pencil
to fill in the hair
and add some loose bits of hair over the face
and by the ear.
And that finished off the face for this drawing.
So the final thing I wanted to work on
was the flower crown.
And there was a lot of intricate detail
in the flower crown.
So I decided to take it slow
and start off by using my brown pencil
to create a value sketch
to make it easier to see where the light
and dark areas of each petal were.
It was definitely really easy
to create light and darker values of brown
just by adjusting the pressure I was adding to the pencil.
For the really dark shadows,
I did use the black.
It would have been nice
to have some other darker tone pencils
to use for those dark areas.
But because of the limited dark colours
in the Crayola set,
I had to use brown and black
to darken all of the colours.
Next, I layered some light pink,
deep red and even purple
to start to make the flowers look more 3D
and give them more of an accurate colour.
I found it hard to make the black shading
for the shadows look natural
even though I did layer deeper reds
and purples over the top.
And it was definitely easier to do the yellow flowers
because the yellow, orange and brown
work together really nicely
to create those different values for the flowers.
I filled in the green leaves
and then used the white pencil
to burnish the lighter areas of the flowers.
I think this drawing definitely shows
that you can create really realistic looking drawings
with even cheap supplies
and that you shouldn't let your cheap supplies
limit you because what is more important
is your skill, not your materials.
If you practise drawing with colour pencils
and get confident with the different techniques,
then you will be able to create really realistic drawings
even if you don't have the best supplies.
Okay, let's move on to the Caran d'Ache side
and I'm going to start in the exact same way
by layering lots of different colours for the skin.
The main difference I saw when using the Luminance
is that because they are so soft,
the pencil lead wasn't able to easily get
into the tiny nooks and crannies of the paper
like the Crayolas were.
And so the first layers of shading
actually did look quite grainy.
I used the brown a lot to map out the shadows around the eye,
the structures of the eye and to block in the eyebrow.
The right side of the face has a lot more light hitting it
so it just wasn't as dark
and didn't have as many dark shadows.
I also used the black to establish the really dark details
like the nostrils and centre part of the mouth
and could see that this black
was a bit darker than the Crayola.
Next, I filled in the colour of the iris
and because the pencils are so smooth,
I was able to blend the colours together
really easily and effortlessly.
And when I used the white to blend,
it was able to really lighten the shading
and works great for adding highlights.
I continued to layer more yellow to the skin
and I didn't really like how grainy the shading was looking
and that in order to get a smooth result,
I'd have to burnish the entire area.
Now the shading would definitely look smoother
if I was using a really smooth paper
instead of a vellum paper
and that is the paper I would usually use
for these luminance pencils.
Next, I used the white to burnish out the skin
and it became clear that the two sides
had very different skin tones
and were not looking consistent at all.
And so I continued to tweak the colours,
layer and blend until the skin tones
looked a lot more similar to the Crayola side.
And this process just made it clear
how flexible and workable the luminance pencils were.
I was easily able to add lots more layers of colours
even after burnishing the entire skin.
I was then able to burnish the area again
and still get a smooth result.
It definitely felt like I had more room for mistakes
with the luminance pencils compared to the Crayola
and this did make the process very enjoyable and relaxing.
After finishing the skin,
I moved on to working on the facial features.
The Caran d'Ache pencils were able
to get the details I needed,
but it was harder and I definitely had to be more careful
if I wanted fine details like eyebrow hairs and eyelashes.
The white pencil was really great
for adding texture to the lips as well,
like the little creases and the shiny areas on the lips.
I filled in the hair in the exact same way
as I did with the Crayola pencils,
but found that the luminance black looked darker
and the shading was a bit more of a solid colour
and not as patchy when I used the Caran d'Ache pencils.
And I was easily able to add the tiny individual hairs
onto the skin with the Caran d'Ache.
And I think it was definitely easier to add crisp details
on top of a burnish layer of shading
than when I used the pencils directly on blank paper.
Finally, I'm working on the flower crown
in the same way as I did with the Crayola pencils,
but found that this side turned out way better
because the colours looked more natural
and the black and brown was able to actually blend
with other colours more seamlessly.
Also, the white is so opaque
that it was brilliant for adding tiny highlights
to the flowers.
I'd even say that the reason the flowers and skin
turned out so well with these pencils
is mainly due to the white pencil.
It really gives the flowers an airbrush look after blending
and you can easily add more colours over the top of the white
to add more vibrancy or deepen the shadows.
The flexibility, colour intensity,
and blendability of these pencils
really do set it apart from the Crayolas.
And another thing that my husband actually noticed
is that you can clearly see
where these two pencil sets were used
because when you turn them to the side,
you can clearly see the difference between the shine
that is produced from these two pencil sets.
The Crayola side is really shiny,
but the Caran d'Ache has hardly any shine,
which is definitely a positive of the Luminance pencils.
But overall, you can see from the final drawing
that you can't tell that this drawing was done
with two different pencil sets,
which really does go to show
that you can get great results
with any pencil set you want.
And to be honest,
I equally enjoyed working with both of these pencil sets
and it was nice that they both had pros and cons
and worked well for different things.
But like I said earlier,
neither of these pencil sets
are what I use for most of my Colour Pencil works.
So if you do want to know
what my favourite all-round pencil set is,
then remember to check out
my free Colour Pencil supply guide
where you can find out all of the supplies I recommend
for getting started with Colour Pencils on a budget.
You can find a link to that free guide
at the top of the description
and I'll see you in my next video.
Bye everybody.
