There's a NEW Ninja SLUSHi exclusive to Costco. Is it better than the original?

Drink Recipes
69 followers
There's a new Ninja Slushy machine on the block. This one is bigger. This one is better.
We'll see about that. But this one is also exclusive. The Ninja Slushy XL Professional
Frozen Drink Maker is currently on sale for $329.99. It's only available at Costco. You can
also find this at Costco.com. This new Ninja comes with a larger tank holding 96 ounces
compared to the original Ninja's 88 ounces. That's 8.6% larger, meaning that you can serve
one more cocktail per batch. Now, keep in mind that this is the total capacity of the tank
and not the fill line. The new Costco version can accommodate 74 ounces of mix,
where the original one is 64 ounces. It also claims to create a longer lasting slushy,
which I am skeptical about. And most importantly, it comes with two insulated bubble cups with
straws. How kind of them. Are these machines different on the outside? Yes, but just a little
bit. They share the same looking body, but different colors, same drip tray, same auger,
seemingly the same evaporator, same buttons and layouts, but the Costco version is actually just
a little bit taller. The tank on the older model does not fit the new machine. And the tank from
the new machine kind of fits the old machine. I did a leak test for this too. It didn't leak,
but it doesn't really fit. And now my old one doesn't really fit very tight. So I wouldn't
advise trying that if you have both tanks somehow. So technically the body is different.
Okay. Why do I have this machine and why am I making this video? Well, those are very good
questions. Let's start with the problems I've encountered with the original Ninja slush machine,
the machine that I first got my hands on in July of 2024. The biggest problem I've come across
is this just can't live up to what they're selling. Ninja claims the original slushy
can make cocktails that are 16% ABV that's alcohol by volume. And it cannot, it can't
really even do 13%. And oftentimes it can't even do 10% ABV slushies. So is that specific to the
machine I have, or is it just all ninjas? I know from many of you in the comments that oftentimes
you have trouble with the cocktail recipes that I share for the slushy machine that are 10 to 11%
ABV. So hopefully this new machine can clear up whether it's something wrong with my machine,
your machine, or just all of these machines. Another issue that's come up for me is that
it's annoying to fill and refill, not a major issue, but it's annoying. When I make a slushy,
I like to pull a little bit out of it to test and then I refill it into the tank.
But the design makes sure that no pieces of ice or solids can get into the machine safety first,
but it's kind of annoying because it takes forever and you have slushy kind of sitting
up there at the top of the machine. This new machine seems to have addressed that at least
a little bit with a deeper opening where the machine is filled. The last problem that everyone
that has had the original ninja slushy comes across is that you cannot clean it. It is uncleanable.
The way that the back of the tank is designed is flawed. This hard plastic is folded over,
but where those panels meet is too tight for anything to fit inside. Sponges,
bottle brushes, and even toothbrushes cannot clean this. And because of the location of this fold,
you can't get a faucet or a correct sort of spray nozzle in there to attempt to spray water
to clean it. Is this residue from a Mai Tai made 10 months ago? Probably. The new model appears
to have solved this problem. But the real reason I bought this was I was duped. I read the website
description. Superior frozen drink experience. Smoother texture. No dilution. Longer lasting
slush vs Ninja BN800. Now this is on me, but I just assumed that when comparing this new ninja
to something else and saying it's longer lasting slush, that would mean the machine gets colder
than the older model. But I messed up because I didn't actually check what Ninja BN800 was.
It's not a slushy machine. It's a blender. So this slushy machine creates drinks with longer
lasting slush than their blender. Which is cool, I guess. And this is not just a ninja issue,
but really a marketing problem with all slushy machines. No ice. All of these machines love to
tell you that no ice is required or no ice is needed. No ice. Well, yeah. It's literally an
ice maker. It makes ice. That's what it does. And then it scrapes that ice off of the thing
making the ice. That's how a slushy machine works. No dilution. I don't even know what they're
talking about. It's basically all dilution. You have to add water. And yes, a regular drink with
ice will have that ice melt over time and dilute your drink. This does the same thing. Your slushy
will melt over time, making the drink more diluted, adding more water to your drink, diluting your
drink. Now, they may also be trying to make the argument that if you use these cups, your slush
will last longer. Which, yeah, no ****. If you use an insulated tumbler to serve your drinks,
it will keep it colder than a different kind of cup.
I want to see if this is different, if it is better, and if it was worth my money.
This video is not sponsored, obviously. And I bought this machine myself, just as I did the
original machine last year. But this Ninja is from Costco, which means it also comes with the
best return policy in the game. Pretty much lifetime returns for any reason. That's one
benefits of shopping somewhere, where you have to pay for the privilege of spending your money
there. If you've been following along with me here, you'll know I have an entire second channel
devoted to all things slushy. That's make and drink frozen. And the truthful reason I am sharing
this video here and not there is because this audience is bigger. This cost $329.99. And I
love to one day recoup those costs. So, we'll run a test on this machine
side by side with the original Ninja. Is it better than the original, or is it the same?
I made up this mix that is 16% ABV and 4% sugar. If you look at the machine's manual,
it will do a max of 16% ABV and requires 4% sugar at a minimum. I can tell you,
this will not work on my original machine, and I am guessing that it will not work on the new one.
But we will see. Keep an open mind, they said. In the event that this machine does not get a
drink to slush, which it won't, I will empty each machine and add enough additional water
and sugar to lower the ABV by 1% while keeping the sugar at 4%. I will keep doing this as long
as needed. Each machine will start with 50 ounces, and I will start and run them at the same time.
After 21 minutes and 19 seconds, both machines told me at basically the same time that they
were ready. These are slushies now, but they're not. It's still all liquid.
So, I bumped it up to the highest setting, still on the spike slush setting, and let them run.
After 7 more minutes, I got the alert that they were ready. And while I don't consider either of
to be a slushie, I was surprised to see that there was some ice. Not much,
but more than I anticipated and more than I have experienced in previous testing.
So, I lowered the ABV to 15%, keeping the sugar at 4%, and ran them again.
After 10 minutes, I was alerted that we now had a slush. Once again, we did not. Super close,
but not a real slushie, not quite yet. So, I adjusted them down again,
now at 14% ABV and 4% sugar, and ran them again.
What a slushie is and is not is very subjective. I'm okay with a little loose and melted liquid
on the edges, but it needs to be mainly a slushie. It needs to have some body and texture.
After 17 minutes, we got some decent slushie. It's not perfect,
it's kind of a technicality here, but I want to give some credit to the Ninja,
because these usually don't work. 14% ABV and 4% can work, but it also might not work.
Not just because you have a different machine, but because if I ran this test again,
I don't think I would get the same results. It seems like there's software involved in
all of these decision makings behind these machines, and why this told me it was ready
when it was at 16% ABV when it wasn't, and why just yesterday, a recipe I made with 12%
gave me a high alcohol alert, that's just completely unknown to me. It doesn't make any
sense. The mix that I used today, I colored red, but one of the first things I did when I got this
machine, was I used a mix that was also red, but it was just water and a little simple syrup.
I didn't even measure the sugar, but for that intro that you watched, I just needed something
to slush. So I just used water, red food coloring, and simple syrup. The problem was that it didn't
work. It gave me a low sugar warning, which I'd not really experienced before, and that's fine.
I didn't even measure the sugar, so I added more sugar. I got another low sugar warning. I added
more, and I added some syrups I had in the fridge. Again and again, I kept getting a low sugar warning.
I was following the directions. If you get a low sugar warning, add more sugar. Finally, I knew that
there was no possible way that it was under 4% sugar, so I tested it in a refractometer, and it
was 15.9% sugar. No alcohol, just a sweet mix that should slush easily. We know this machine can slush
at, but on this particular day, at this particular time, it wouldn't do it. So I turned it off, gave it
about an hour, came back, and then it worked. Now if you follow this channel, and especially follow
the Frozen channel, you know that I pick on Ninja a lot, and it's not because this machine is bad,
but because I have the most experience with it. I've used it dozens and dozens and dozens of times,
so the frustration has just built up over time. I can't do what it says it can do,
but really, none of them can. Having said that, I would still recommend these to anyone,
because it's the best brand that makes these, and if you have a problem with it, you know that you
can talk to customer service and hopefully get it handled. Can you do that with the other brands?
I don't know. I have a much larger video coming soon testing all eight slushy machines I have,
and while I will spoil it and say that the Ninja performs at the bottom, it's still good.
And if you have a Costco membership, it seems like by far the best deal. You get the biggest
tank, you get some amazing slushy cups, and guess what, guys? This will keep your slushy colder
longer than a plastic cup, and you can return it at any time, really, for any reason.
So it's not the only slushy machine that I would recommend, but if someone was like,
hey, I want to get a slushy machine, I would tell them they should consider the Ninja slushy.
So if you're interested in more recipes for the Ninja slushy and any other home slushy machine,
check out my second channel, Make & Drink Frozen. I'll still be posting videos here
occasionally on slushy machines, but much more there, including slushy cocktail recipes.
I just did a zombie, we did a porn star martini, I also just posted a margarita showdown on the
new Ninja, where I made three different margaritas, the Costco Gold Margarita Mix,
the Margarita Man Margarita Mix, and my updated Make & Drink Margarita,
and I'll give you those recipes, and I'll give you a rating for each one of those as well.
Please like and subscribe if you have not already. Otherwise, I'll see you on the next one.
