Ottoman Turkish Armor: Part 4 Shields (Difference between the legend and reality)

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
8 Video Views·Jul 10, 2025
Ottoman Turkish Armor: Part 4 Shields (Difference between the legend and reality)
Bede Dwyer (Razmafzar Australia) and I discuss Ottoman Turkish armor sets that can be found in the following museums: the State Hermitage Museum (St. Petersburg, Russia), Musée de l'Armée (Paris, France), the British Museum (London, UK), the Palace Armoury Museum (Malta), Airport Museum Istanbul (Istanbul, Türkiye), and Schloss Braunfels (Braunfels, Germany). This video series will help reenactors and SCA participants to base their Ottoman armor on real historical pieces.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Now let's go to the shields. Ah, love the shields.
Okay, this shield, our colleagues from Russia said about these Ottoman empires from the North
African era, from Egypt, this one they say is Ottoman Empire itself. But anyhow, both of them
are Kalkan shields. You see that, Pete? Yeah, I think the manufacture of Kalkans was very widespread.
It may have had an underlay of Turkmen tribal equipment, but I mean, this is palace level
equipment. That's the reason it's in SAR collection, right? Yeah, yeah. Well, you look,
the number of rows are probably up around 40 or something of spirals. The more valuable they are,
the smaller the rattan spiral is, because you put more and more silk in there. I mean, the cheap
ones, like in Karlsruhe, they've got ones that are actually bound with wool instead of silk,
and obviously, you know, ordinary soldier's ones. But see, these are really beautiful. As I say,
I did a limited experiment at how strong these would be, just with
eighth-inch rattan and silk thread, and it was remarkably strong.
Because the thread, I mean, if you imagine you've got your rattan piece here, the thread crosses
over and comes up on the other, and the next piece, and the next piece, and the next piece.
So it's totally woven, like cloth. It's got a warp and a weft, except the weft is axial,
going out from the centre, and the warp is a spiral coming from the outside to the inside,
to the inside, to the outside. So again, it's interesting. The patterns are typical Ottoman
patterns. I mean, you see similar patterns on Iznik pottery. I mean, they're a bit abstract,
and they're really quite attractive. I'm looking at the, it's difficult to say,
the bosses seem to have been completely gone, which, if the rivet that the ring's attached to,
that goes through to the boss on the top, if that rusts, then they just fall off, and there
wouldn't be any marks, hardly. I mean, they're, to give you an idea, I'll hold this up. So that's
like a little split pin to hold a loop on. This is for a saddle. Now, if you put that tightly into a
hole, and then you have a boss on the outside, and you cut it flat and hammer it down, that's,
I mean, they usually made them so that instead of a split pin, you know, like that, it was a solid
piece with a hole in it, and then the whole thing's forged together. This is an easy way to do it,
and you can buy them in saddle restores. But really strong, but when they fall out,
there's hardly any trace. So it's quite difficult. I mean, I think I can see some
evidence for where they were, but I wouldn't bet money on it.
But look at the next one. The ones for the center can be straight into the wooden base
in the center. This one is intact, look. Oh yeah, it's got everything, hasn't it? And see,
they follow that pattern. So you've got two on each side of the middle, then you've got two
towards the rim that are far apart, and two towards the other rim that are a bit closer together.
So one's for grasping, one's for putting your arm through. Let me just translate this for
our viewers, because then they're going to ask me all the time, excuse me. My apologies,
there we go. In the middle, it says, Allahu Akbar, God is great. Then it starts from the
Quran, from here. Nasru minallahi wa fathul gharib wa bashir al mu'minin. God help us in
the upcoming victory and give good tidings to the believers. And here it says, Ya Muhammad,
O Muhammad, Prophet Muhammad, Ya Ali, O Ali. Excuse me, I didn't want to interrupt you,
because then they're going to ask me again and again. One of the things that I and my friends
always want people to do when they show you a picture of a sword or a shield or anything that's
got an inscription on it, is to translate the inscription, because not all of us can speak
as many languages as you can. Also, what I was going to say was that above and below,
diagonally, you've got two more mounts or rings, which are for the strap that goes over your
shoulder to hold the shield. Very useful. It's interesting that the inscription isn't oriented
to where the straps are, which makes me wonder whether that's moved or being moved. It's in
really good condition. The inscriptions are written to the outside. I'm thinking about the
in the middle. It's oriented that way. It's quite correct. It's like this. Let me just put the lines
for you. Can you see the cursor? Yeah. This and this. Oh, sorry. This and this. So I need to turn
it a bit so we complete this. To me, it's about 30 degrees out. That's just nailed onto a wooden
thing on the inside of the shield, and there's a cushion over it. They could have taken that
off to clean it, and when they put it on, it got one hole out of the right.
This could have happened 200 years ago, 300 years ago. Imagine they're doing this before the
invention of photography, and someone forgets to notate which rivets or nails go into which holes.
You're completely ruined. In my opinion, it is one of the most beautiful Kalkan shields I have
ever seen. Oh yeah, it is. I love the flower designs, the four sets of wreaths or whatever
they are. Beautiful. And then you've got cartouches. The whole thing is beautifully made.
I'm just looking at that. Yeah. So yeah, my understanding, it's about, let me count the rivets.
I'm very obsessive. Two, four, six, eight. So one-eighth of 360.
It's about 45 degrees off. So I think that's what's really happened, because that's all been
cleaned and polished, and you wouldn't want to do that on the thing. I'd say they've taken the
rivets out, cleaned and polished it, maybe like in 1710 or something, and put it back on, but
they're out by one rivet hole. This is speculation. It may not be true, but it's a lot of fun to think
about. But it is beautiful. Look at the flower heads that the rivets go through for the straps
on the inside. So they're like a chrysanthemum kind of design. Everything is really, I mean,
when you look at the patterning on the surface of the kalkan itself, not the metalwork,
that looks very much like tribal art, doesn't it? Like you see it in carpets and things like that,
which makes me think that these were probably made by nomads, or settled nomads,
rather than in imperial factories, whereas the metalwork is all very high standard,
and that comes from... So maybe you've got your... I'm talking about the army. Maybe the army got
these things manufactured in pieces, like you get the arc and the backing,
you know, the dome and the backing, and then you get the centerpiece and the fittings,
so that one part's done by one workshop, another part's done by a different workshop,
because it does seem to be... That's really a very tribal Turkman type design, isn't it?
Whereas the beautiful calligraphy is... Oh, the calligraphy is one of the most beautiful ones.
Yeah, I mean, you know, it's a standout. So I'd never thought of this before, but it's quite
logical to have this made by piecework, as you'd call it, where one group of people makes one
thing, and then they go to the goldsmith, and he puts on the metalwork, and then they go to
somebody who's an expert in harness, and he puts all the straps on. There's no reason one person
or one, you know, family working together would make the whole thing in one place,
and the Ottoman economy was quite complex. See, that's another one where you can see...
That one, though, the designs are more metropolitan. They're more sophisticated
than the other one, but not as lively. But the thing that strikes me is, look at how
they've made a decorative motive by having one spiral done in alternate colors, and then right
at the edge, another spiral done in alternate colors to make a boundary to contain the design
in. And the boss is incredible. I mean... The boss is incredible. Look at that.
Yeah, that's stunning. Okay, those guys who are wondering, Istanbul Airport Museum, you know,
that's the largest museum, sorry, got airport, and it's very beautiful. So part of the Turkish
government to promote is they made a museum there, and then they have this shield on loan,
but it's on permanent display now from Topkapi Museum. So look at this. That's why it says Topkapi
Palace Museum. So in case people wonder why it says there, and down there, Istanbul.
The whole concept of having museums in airports, which are the most boring places in the world,
is brilliant. It is, yeah. I've seen it in several countries, and you just, it's just,
you step off a plane, you walk along and there's all these exhibitions and that.
It is so uplifting compared to just dreary corridors or duty-free shops, which are not
very exciting. The boss is beautiful, isn't it? It's remarkable. Is that Kofgari or is it inlay?
It looks like Kofgari to me. It's Kofgari, yeah. Yeah, because Kofgari, you can get those wider
expanses where the inlay is really good for very fine detail. So beautiful. Interestingly,
it's a pattern of three medallions around the center. Usually there's four, but it's medallion,
little circle, medallion, little circle, medallion, little circle. So to make a,
see that, that goes to show again, design was individually thought out on these. They're
not just following a pattern. Okay. If you talk about this, this one is really beautiful
in Germany. Yeah. Very old painting on it. I'm of two minds whether the painting is,
I think the painting is European. Not because the horse has turned his head to face the viewer,
that you do see in Ottoman painting as well. It's not a thing that they couldn't do. It's just the
shield is held. I mean, I could be wrong. It could be Ottoman because there were paintings
done in Istanbul that had European influence, but somehow it really looks 17th century European,
the painting. The shield itself, see that looks like it was originally covered. I mean,
and they've, as the covering deteriorated, they've cut it into a star shape. It might have
originally been a star shape, but it doesn't look like it because it's the points of the stars
aren't sewn down. They're just laying there. And that makes me think of maybe the whole thing was
originally covered and it's old and it's a bit decrepit. And maybe they, see every time I look
I see something different. This was a, this collection of Braunfels, which belong, it's an
old family in Germany. And for centuries, then they made now a museum and dedicated this museum.
So this was in private hands. This could even go back to the second siege of Vienna. Yeah.
Very old family in Germany. That's why it's very nice. I really appreciate that this family did
that so we can go and see. I mean, it's great that things like this, you know, families have
kept them for so long. And I mean, it's really interesting as I say, I'd really, I'd really have
to see a really big lot of that painting to make any firm decision. I will go there again. And I
made lots of pictures. We will talk about the European arms and armor. They have lots of it
there. And they have also excavation, excavated swords from Germany, from ancient time. Oh yeah.
They're beautiful. They're really, yeah. Scientific excavation, right? Yeah. Oh yeah.
Oh, these are these shields from Malta again. Remember those shields? Yeah. So the two, two
ones at the bottom look like a Tombak. So the parade shields. Tombak is a hollow. So it's not
very strong, but it's like a brass. It stays golden for endless amounts of time. And it really
is, it works very nice, but they've got all the bosses in the right places. So it's not,
it's not simply a parade shield. It's a, it's a very, very careful copy of an actual fighting
shield. The shield above. Well, you could see one of those in Iran or. Yes. The thing is these
Ottomans, when they attacked Malta. So this is the San John order. They took lots of them as booty
as well. And interestingly, many swords which were on board by, used by Ottomans were of this
type. Yeah. Well, the, the, the commander, the real commander was Torgut, but Dragut in, in
European things. He was killed when a cannonball hit a rock near him and splinters of stone
kind of, you know, punctured him. The, the accounts of the great siege point out that the,
in close combat, in climbing the walls and that the Europeans did better because they had full
plate armour, whereas the Ottomans didn't. And they, and the Maltese used to make these
hoops of wood and cover it in sticky stuff and set them on fire and throw them over people
who were climbing ladders and then that would set their clothes on fire. And
it was, it was very fierce siege. But yeah, so a lot of the sailors on the ships were North African.
Yes. And, but there were janissaries and regular Ottoman troops as well. But a lot of the sailors
were from North Africa because a lot of the Navy, I mean Torgut was a protégé of Hayreddin Barbarossa
and his family. So the, these are often they're Turkish or sometimes converts to Islam with Greek
background or something like that, who got into naval work, ended up in North Africa.
And then when this big siege happened, the North African Baliks or whatever, how they were
provided manpower for the Ottoman fleet. And they were really good sailors.
Yes. And they have all these, and they have all these North African
swords, but we will talk about them later. But we will talk about the swords.
That's what made me think of it when I saw the hilt and the swords and the plate shapes too.
Yes. So, and the last part for today from Istanbul Army Museum, what they were,
wore, sorry, under the armor, a victory shirt.
So this is one of the talismanic shirts. Yeah. I've seen a couple of these in the flesh.
They're really quite extraordinary. There's a huge amount of embroidery and painting and whatever on
them, all to create protective prayers and spells and whatever, to protect you from injury. Of
course. Interesting. The calligraphy is really quite good on the, in the semicircular areas.
Yeah. I mean, you know, they've got somebody important to write that.
Very beautiful. So that was our discussion for today. I hope you enjoyed it. God, it was long.
It's really good to see these things because I mean, you know, they're absolute, they're beautiful
in themselves, but they show how people were working out how to do things. We get the,
you get the impression as I, as a Westerner, that, oh, you know, there's this linear evolution of
armor, but there's not, there's all different branches of how to make armor and what you're
trying to protect yourself from. So once effective guns came in, armor was no longer designed to
protect yourself against missile weapons. So therefore you could concentrate on protecting
yourself against swords and lances. Yes. And therefore you didn't have to make the armor as
heavy. Yes. So I think in areas, see it's funny, in say Turkey and Iran, bows were really powerful.
So armor had to be relatively strong. In England, bows were really powerful,
but there was a whole different tradition about armor for knights. Yes. And it went considerably
in a different direction because most of the people, say in Turkey, that wore armor, I mean,
were mostly horsemen, which is pretty much the same in Europe for heavy armor, complete armor.
But their interest was in being able to travel long distances. So they didn't want armor that
was so heavy that their horses were worn out. You'd die. Yes. Yeah. I mean, you know, so you
kind of, they made design decisions into what's the most effective for what we want to do. And
so sometimes when we look back at things, we say, oh, why didn't they do this? Or why didn't they
do that? But the reason is they had different priorities than we have. And we can use their
armor to work out what they thought was important, to see what they're protecting and what they're
not protecting, what they thought they could dodge with and what they didn't think. Because
it's very hard to dodge with the middle of your body, but it's quite easy to dodge with your head
because it's on the end of the, you know, which might be the reason that Turkish armors have more
protection around the, from the waist to the bottom of the rib cage, because that is a really
difficult part of the body to get out of the way of a spear or a sword or even a javelin.
You know, studies early on in this field, and there's a lot of scope for people doing their
PhD thesis on historical things to actually look at this interest, to recover it. I weighed a
couple of shields the other day of mine, the buffalo horn one, sorry, the buffalo hide one
and the steel one, and then I compared the weights to shields in collections where they published the
weights. And shields of roughly the same size in steel and leather and calcams as well, they're
all about the same weight, like 1.8 kilos to 2.4 kilos. They're all in that weight,
varying from 48 centimetres to 62 centimetres in diameter. This was a real thing. I was really
pleased my tourist shield turned out to be the right weight for a real shield. That was a bit of
luck. But it's interesting, you know, when you, if you've got information like that, so curators,
if you're watching, your next publication, put the weights in as well as the full dimensions.
Thanks a lot, Viet. It was lovely talking to you, and we're going to continue our
discussions in the next sessions then. Thank you very much. Have a nice day.
Bye.
