LUXURY FOES! -- 2023 BMW X5 vs. 2023 Mercedes GLE: Comparison

Cars Arena
18 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 5, 2025
What's going on YouTube? As you may know, some of the very first luxury crossovers in the world
were the ancestors of these two models, the BMW X5 and the Mercedes GLE, formerly known as the ML.
These two have been duking it out since the 90s and the competition has only grown stronger with
these new versions. So the question remains, which of these two is the best option? That's what we're
about to find out. Now even though money probably isn't the main consideration for those shopping
between these two, we will start off by breaking down the pricing. Beginning with the BMW X5,
we have the xDrive40i model, which is the mainstream version most people pick.
As German automakers are known for, there are still tons of a la carte options you can pick,
so that makes for an additional $14,300 including destination. The total is just over $79,000.
The GLE does offer a four-cylinder engine with the GLE 350, but today we have the higher-end
GLE 450 model. That makes it equivalent to the BMW's inline six-cylinder 40i, and after adding
in the equivalent options as well, we arrive at a steep total price of $84,770. We will evaluate
this $5,500 price difference a little later in the value section, but for now let's start out by
checking out the exteriors. Before we get into this, I do want to acknowledge that both the X5
and GLE will receive some minor exterior and interior enhancements for the upcoming 2024
model year. We will revisit this with an updated comparison later in the fall, but for now these
two are rocking their brand's signature designs. The GLE continues with a modest and elegant
Mercedes design, while the BMW also rocks the brand's normal kidney grille that hasn't been
supersized like it has in the latest BMWs. As far as lighting is concerned, both luxury SUVs
are rocking bright and advanced full LED lighting that is also adaptive. Now heading to the sides,
both have nice rear-wheel drive proportions and look sporty with their M Sport and AMG line
packages, respectively. Standard wheel options are 19-inch alloys, and both models today are
showing off attractive 21-inch alloy designs, but the BMW does have painted brake calipers,
unlike the Benz. Moving to the rear designs, both look expensive and carry on the same themes from
the front and sides. The taillights are of course fully LED, and you also have exposed wipers and
dual exhaust outlets. The tow ratings are similar to one another, although the Mercedes can tow
about six and a half percent more than the BMW, at 7,700 pounds versus the Beemer's 7,200 pounds.
Now heading on to some of the other features, both of them have heated power folding auto-dimming
mirrors with blind spot monitoring, and both of them also come equipped with all the latest active
safety systems, including automatic forward emergency braking, lane-keeping assist, adaptive
cruise control, auto high beam headlights, and highway driving assistance. Finally, when it comes
to warranties, both have four-year 50,000 mile basic and powertrain warranties, but only the BMW
comes with three years of complimentary maintenance. So far, this has been neck and neck, but the real
important things are inside the cabin and out on the road, so let's move on. Walking up to the
both of course have smart entry and high quality key fobs, and once we actually open up the doors
and view the interiors, they both have a lot of wow factor. Materials and colors are very rich
looking, although surprisingly, both models have synthetic leather seating. The BMW's is finished
in the cognac color for its 16-way power adjusting seats with memory, heating, ventilation, and massage.
The Merc also has 16-way adjustment via the door controls, and the same features minus the massage,
which requires another $1,100 package. Now that we've climbed inside, we can discuss the major
point of cabin materials. Unsurprisingly, both of these two use top-notch selections throughout,
including real wood, aluminum elements, plus beautiful detailed metal speaker grilles in the
BMW. After firing them up, we are first greeted by 12.3-inch digital gauge clusters. Both are
bright and have good graphics with tons of customizability, but only the X5 includes a
head-up display as standard equipment. And coming back to the steering wheels, both are nicely
finished, power adjusting, and heated, along with the armrest as well. Okay, so next up let's dig
into the major area of interior storage. Neither is overly generous in this regard, and the console
arrangements are extremely similar. You also have wireless phone charging pads located up in the
front. I already mentioned the lovely glass shifter in the BMW, and the GLE also has an electronic one,
just column-mounted. When you reverse, both are equipped with 360-degree camera systems,
but only the BMW allows for the cool and helpful 3D view. Now let's go ahead and check out the audio
systems. Overall, both sound great, but Mason and I have a slight preference for the sound of the
Burmester. Checking out the climate systems, both have physical controls, for now at least. The
temperature adjustment buttons are quite small on the BMW, but our X5 has quad zones and the GLE has
dual zones without another package. But focusing in on the infotainment systems themselves,
we have a 12.3-inch display in both the bins and the beamer. Both have great graphics,
speedy performance, and built-in navigation. Both also have Apple CarPlay and Android Auto,
but wireless support hasn't been added to the GLE yet. Finally, the last things to mention up front
are the auto-dimming mirrors and large panoramic sunroofs.
Now a lot of the times, the idea behind having an SUV is to bring family and friends with you
places, so let's check out how comfortable they're going to be. As you can see visually
and with the numbers, the GLE has a legroom advantage of about 9%, while the headroom
numbers are very similar to each other. Now for luxury features, I already talked about the climate
controls, and both also have heated rear seats. Additional features include USBs and vents,
but the GLE has a couple advantages here. It has power sunshades, and the rear seats are
power adjusting in pretty much the same number of ways as the front seats. Let's move on to
the third row next. Yes, you heard me right, the GLE actually does have an available third row
for those of you who might need it every now and then, but don't need to upgrade to the larger GLS.
While not spacious, this is something that BMW doesn't offer with the X5. Heading around to the
tailgates, both models have hands-free power ones, and once they open up you'll find good amounts of
space. They are extremely similar, with the GLE having a small maximum advantage that is less than
the 5% threshold to score point. That's it for the interiors, so now it's time to take them out on
the road and see who will pull ahead in this tight race. German automakers are notorious for
trying to match each other tit-for-tat, and the engine situation is one of those places.
Both are using 3-liter turbo inline-6s, paired with 48-volt mild hybrid systems. Power outputs
are in the Mercedes' favor, but only by about 7% in horsepower and torque. What's really impressive
is that these two accelerate to 60 miles per hour in under five and a half seconds.
Nice! And as quick as that, you're above 60 miles per hour in the GLE 450.
So, this comes in a wide variety of engine choices, which I think I mentioned at the
beginning of the video. Because of that, you're going to have a wide range of horsepower figures.
I think the GLE 450, though, is probably the most popular variant in terms of sales.
That's what we have, and that is kind of the second step up the ladder. So, what is powering
this is a 3-liter turbocharged inline-6 cylinder. This is paired with Mercedes' EQ Boost, which is
a mild hybrid system, and total output is going to be 362 horsepower, 369 pound-feet of torque.
All right. So, there's a quick jolt of acceleration in this X5. So, we actually
have the standard engine option, the low-powered option, even though this still has plenty of power,
as you just saw. So, what we have underneath of the hood of this xDrive40i model is a 3-liter
turbocharged inline-6 cylinder paired with their 48-volt mild hybrid system. Altogether,
it's going to be making 335 horsepower and 330 pound-feet of torque. Yeah, and this motor, we've
said in previous X5 reviews, is just so refined. I mean, truly, the acceleration is just effortless.
Despite surprising speed, both were designed with smoothness at the core. Their eight and
nine-speed automatics are some of the best in the business, with imperceptible shifts
and dual personalities that awaken when using the sport modes.
Both have all-wheel drive as equipped. Speaking of gears, let's talk about the transmission. So,
we do have an eight-speed automatic transmission on board. It is a fantastic transmission, as it is
in many other BMW products. Smooth as silk when you're driving at a subdued, regular pace, and
really fast responding when you want a lot of power. Yeah, as we kind of work our way through
some traffic, let's go ahead and talk about the transmission. So, this does have a nine-speed
automatic transmission. It is imperceptibly smooth. Put your foot down, it'll give you,
you know, quick response and get you into the right gear. But as far as just cruising around,
which is what most people do in this type of model, it's very, very smooth and you just don't
notice it at all. Let's also talk about ride quality. There really is nothing bad to say
about either model, with a spectacularly comfortable ride and that typical solid Germanic
feel. Both these testers have adaptive dampers that can change characteristics based on the drive
modes, and air suspensions are also available. Guys, as we're finally getting out of the city
and just starting to cruise along, I want to not delay this conversation any longer than need be
because the GLE average owner is going to really just be using it for cruising along and comfort
and this model does a fantastic job. The whole powertrain combination, the ride quality,
the sound level, which we'll get an official reading here in just a little bit, it all just
works in combination to give you a phenomenal ride experience. It's one of the best ride
qualities that money can buy, regardless of your price point. And, you know, speaking of
the comfort level, let's go ahead and discuss how this BMW X5 rides because that's, you know,
of course, a mission with this vehicle is to be comfortable. And like Drew said earlier,
it's definitely tuned for that comfort until you really start hustling it around. And this X5 is
incredibly, incredibly comfortable. For having 21 inch alloy wheels on this particular model,
you would never guess it sitting here on the inside. It soaks up the bumps like nothing else.
And honestly, it's surprising to me that this does not have an air suspension on this particular
model, just because it rides that smooth, guys. Now, as far as other driving dynamics,
both have some German athleticism baked into them as well. Even though comfort is still the
primary mission, the X5 comes across as a bit sharper in handling response and steering.
Now, this is a BMW after all, so I do need to mention our driving dynamics. For a bigger SUV,
it definitely handles nicely. We've gone into the sport setting, so it firms up the steering nicely,
firms up the dampers a little bit as well. But this is still, at the end of the day,
more of a luxury-oriented product, like Mason was mentioning. You know, if you want
purest sport experience, then BMW has a full line of products that you can get.
I also want to talk about their auto start-stop systems, which are powered by the mild hybrid
setups. Both manufacturers have done a great job here. But, that being said, the seamless Mercedes
EQ Boost system is still the industry leader in our experience. Now, let's talk a little bit about
EQ Boost and the mild hybrid setup. If you were looking at my tachometer, you'll notice before I
even come to a stop, the system allows it to go ahead and turn the engine off, which is really
nice. Helps you not to notice the on-off switching of the engine. And, you know, EQ Boost does help
the power ever so slightly off the line, but the main thing is that advanced auto start-stop system.
It just allows it, like I said, to shut down before you even come to a stop, and it is just
so smooth. We've said it in a lot of Mercedes reviews, but this is the smoothest auto start-stop
in the industry. A few are getting closer. The Germans are getting close. They're getting closer,
but Mercedes still has the prize in our view, for sure. High-end luxury vehicles also need to be
quiet, and they both deliver library quiet cabins, even at highway speed. The X5, however, delivered
one of the quietest sound level readings we have ever captured. Now, that is impressive. 52.3
decibels is our sound level reading. That's some of the best sound level readings we've ever gotten,
and I can certainly just hear that inside of this cabin. I'm incredibly comfortable,
and also it's incredibly quiet. It just sounds like a librarian here.
55.6 decibels is what we're sitting at. Finally, as far as fuel economy,
their similar powertrains deliver nearly identical fuel economy ratings.
But before we conclude this comparison, let's revisit the price difference between these two.
Because money matters less at this price point, the $5,575 gap will equate to a quarter point per
thousand, or 1.25 points. So, that's it for another super close comparison between two
super close rivals. Ultimately, both are spectacular luxury SUVs that largely match
each other on the most important things, and it's easy to see why each sells so well.
A lot of the choice will come down to personal preference,
which we want to hear from you in the comment section below. Which one are you driving home
if you had the $80,000? While you're down there telling us which luxury SUV you prefer, go ahead
and click the subscribe button as well, since that helps us show you guys all the latest vehicles
hitting the market. We are already looking forward to the 2024 rematch coming this fall,
and subscribing will make sure you don't miss it. As always, we appreciate your support,
and we'll see you next time as we sample more of the latest automotive delicacies.
