PLEASE FOR ANY COPYRIGHTS ISSUE CONTACT US FIRST ON : [email protected] ---------------------------------------------------------- New Videos Everyday .. Stay Tuned... ---------------------------------------------------------- Like all new technologies, DNA testing has a good side, a bad side, and, as author Margaret Atwood said, a “stupid side you hadn’t considered.” Eight years ago, 72-year-old Washington native Alice Collins Plebuch made a decision that would change her life forever: She sent samples of her saliva for a “just for fun DNA test.”
the dark side of dna tests
woman uncovers centuries-old family
[Music]
mystery
like all new technologies dna testing
has a good side and a bad side
and as author margaret atwood said a
stupid side
you hadn't considered eight years ago 72
year old washington native alice collins
plebik
made a decision that would change her
life forever she sent
samples of her saliva for a just for fun
dna test
seeing as both her parents were devout
irish american catholics
alice thought she had a good idea about
what the dna test results would say
but when the test results came back
alice was shocked
she wasn't who she thought she was this
revelation sent alice and her siblings
on a years-long journey
to uncover the mystery surrounding their
identities
questions about her family had
preoccupied alice for years
her mother who was also named alice was
into genealogy
she kept an old family book with the
handwritten names and births
and deaths of their relatives alice
found her mother's side
easy to follow even before genealogy
records were available online
her mother was irish on one side and
scottish and english on the other
some of her relatives had even been in
america for as far back as colonial
times
and alice was able to trace some of her
mother's ancestors back to the 1500s
but with each update to her mother's
lineage alice felt guilty because her
father's side of the family was a
different
story my dad had nothing he had no
history
she told journalist and author libby
copeland
her father jim collins was the son of
irish immigrants
he knew little of his family's history
his mother had passed away when jim was
just a baby
and his father was unable to care for
him and his older siblings
so he gave them away to a catholic
orphanage
for most of his life jim didn't know
what year he was born in
believing he was a year older than he
really was
as her father grew older alice decided
that it was time to dive into his
lineage and discover where he came from
before she began the project she had
already known some of the details of his
childhood
she knew that living in the orphanage
had been hard
alice knew that her father had most
likely been malnourished while living
there because the doctor later told him
that this most likely explained his
small build
she also knew that he had left the
orphanage in his teens and was a rebel
before he joined the us
army corps of engineers and married her
mother
she also knew that her father had a
sister who had died when she was younger
and a brother he was not close with
jim was also a devout catholic who
cooked a wicked corned beef on st
patrick's day but what alice didn't know
was where he came from and what happened
to his parents
when her father died in 1999 alice
couldn't really tell him more than he
already knew
in the years that followed however alice
was able to find some sort of paper
trail
jim was born in a working-class
neighborhood in the bronx new york
his father joseph worked as a driver and
his mother katie passed away at the age
of 32
when jim was only nine months old
she also found the name of the orphanage
where he grew up it was the saint agnes
home and school
and although the school was no longer
around she was able to find the names of
some of the sisters who worked there
alice wrote them a letter asking if they
had any helpful information about her
father
besides jim's admission and discharge
dates the orphanage couldn't provide
alice with any other helpful information
years past analysis research came up
fruitless
then in 2012 at home dna kits became
available
alice was elated she had just discovered
what she thought was her father's family
village in ireland
and she was considering a trip overseas
to see where her grandparents had come
from
alice knew that an at-home dna test
would make her research a whole lot
easier so she put her name down on the
company's waiting list
when the tests finally arrived she and
her sister jerry swapped their cheeks
and sent in their tests
but when the results came back a month
later alice and jerry were more than a
little confused
only less than 50 percent of the sisters
dna results were of irish scottish and
english descent
the other half of her dna was an
unexpected combination
of european jewish eastern european and
middle eastern
this was odd alice thought because both
her parents were from the british isles
surely someone at the testing lab had
messed up for results or accidentally
switched them with someone else's
alice wrote the testing company a letter
explaining their mistake
she decided to take the test again but
when the same test results came back for
a second time
alice knew that the report was correct
several questions popped up in her head
who were her parents did her mother have
an affair
alice was determined to get to the
bottom of whatever family secrets had
been kept from her
if her parents weren't who they said
they were that meant that alice by
extension wasn't who she thought she was
the dna test results were only the
beginning as they provided alice with
the what but not the why while intense
research and analysis
might intimidate some people alice was
not thrown off
she had worked as an i.t manager at the
university of california before she
retired
i did data processing most of my life
and at a fairly
sophisticated level she said in 2017
alice likes to find patterns in chaos
and answer
big questions with complex answers after
getting
over her initial shock alice got
straight to work
maybe her mother had an affair or her
grandmother
but this scenario seemed unlikely
cheating was out of character for
alice's mother and all of alice's
siblings shared her father's eyes
still the question lingered in the back
of her mind my father he was in the army
and he was all over the world and it was
just one of those fears that you have
when you don't know alice told author
libby copeland
alice and her sister had a gut feeling
that the lineage came from their
father's side
especially since he was adopted where
her father's grandparents secretly irish
jews
or maybe eastern european jews who said
they were irish when they immigrated to
america
as a precaution alice had two of her
cousins one from each side take the dna
test
the results from her maternal cousin
came back normal
the two shared 12.5 of the same dna
meaning that they were first cousins but
the test results from her paternal
cousin
was peculiar the tests show that alice
and her cousin
whose mother was jim collins's sister
shared no dna
in other words the two were complete
strangers genetically speaking
and weren't actually cousins this also
meant that alice's father's sister
wasn't actually his sister
alice was frustrated with the results to
say the least
not only was she back to square one but
she was scared of being rejected from
her dad's side of the family
since they weren't biologically related
with the data results in front of them
alice and her sister jerry came to the
conclusion that their father jim was not
related to who he thought
or his biological parents i really lost
all my identity alice said in 2017
i felt adrift i didn't know who i was
you know
who i really was but for jerry the test
results confirmed a feeling she had had
for a very long time
for years jerry had thought that jim's
father bore no resemblance to anyone in
her immediate family
and when she traveled to ireland in the
90s she realized that no one looked like
her 5
foot 4 dark-haired father jerry carried
this feeling around with her for years
but with the dna test results in front
of her
her hunch turned to fact with their
father
and his parents long dead alice and
jerry knew they had to unravel their
father's mystery by speaking with the
living
did their father have any biological
siblings did those siblings have any
children
was there a chance that alice and her
siblings had long lost first cousins
by 2013 the collins children were
finally getting closer to solving their
father's mystery
they had their father's birth
certificate and they had also learned
that jim had been sent to an orphanage
by the new york society for the
prevention of cruelty to children
maybe alice wondered her dad had somehow
been confused with another child
when he was taken from his home maybe
the orphanage mixed up her father and
another baby
going on this hunch alice sent a
forensic artist pictures of her father
sitting on his father's lap when he was
just under a year old
along with photos of jim when he was an
adult alice wanted to know if the people
in the photos were the same people
but again this line of thinking was a
dead end the forensic artist ruled that
it was
in fact the same person meaning that the
orphanage hadn't confused her father
with another baby
so alice began thinking of a different
idea maybe she thought her father was
switched at the hospital
was there a chance that the hospital had
made a mistake alice decided to take a
closer look at all of the babies who
were
but it also was not ordered by date nor
did it differentiate between home and
hospital births
after carefully scanning through the
file alice was able to narrow the list
down to the names of children born
around the same time
as her father that sounded either jewish
or ethically neutral
alice's list totaled 30 babies
her hope was that one of those babies on
her list had living relatives who shared
the same dna as alice and her siblings
alice went through all 30 baby names but
again
nothing came up allison then combed
through more than 6 000 people who were
tagged as potential biological family
members
according to the dna's online database
she searched for two and a half years
but couldn't find a match
alice began to lose hope but all she
could do at this point in time was to
wait for someone to reach out to her
then on january 18 2015
alice's life changed forever
it was a sunday morning and she was
feeling particularly down
she decided to write to her cousin whom
she wasn't biologically related to
to update him on her stalled search
after sending her cousin an email
alice randomly decided to check his list
of dna relatives on his genealogy
account
this was something that alice rarely did
especially since new relatives rarely
showed up
but on this day alice decided to check
her cousin's genealogy
account anyway much to her surprise
there was a new person on the list of
relatives
a stranger had sent in her dna sample
and her results showed that she was a
close relative to alice's cousin
alice then decided to message the
stranger to ask if the test results were
what she expected
i was actually expecting to be much more
ashkenazi than i
am the woman wrote back the stranger
whose name was jessica benson
took a test on a whim hoping to learn a
bit more about her jewish roots
instead jessica said she discovered that
i am actually
irish which i had not expected at all
alice felt chills going down her spine
she immediately wrote back to jessica
that her grandfather was born at fordham
hospital
on september 23rd 1913. had anyone in
jessica's family been born around that
date
jessica quickly replied yes her
grandfather philip benson was born
around that time
alice began to cry she had a feeling
that she knew what had happened
but first she needed proof so she combed
through new york city's birth records
from 1913
there was no benson born on that day in
the bronx
but a few hours later alice finally
found what she was looking for
there was a philip bamson born on the
same day
and at the same hospital as her father
jim
this had to be philip benson alice knew
in her bones what had happened to her
father
there was no family mystery buried by
shame
someone at the fordham hospital had made
a mistake that day
a mistake that could only be uncovered
with new technology
somehow a jewish baby had been sent home
with an irish family
and an irish baby with a jewish family
the two women were stunned
they compared the birth certificates and
discovered that jim and philip were
processed one after the other
and signed by the same doctor alice then
began to research how hospitals used to
keep track
newborn babies and what she found
shocked her
alice found that hospitals didn't really
have a system at all
most of the newborn babies were kept in
the same cart or crib
making it very easy to switch a baby by
accident
when jim was born in 1913 hospital
births were
still pretty unusual at the time most
hospitals had yet to come up with a way
to identify
babies some hospitals kept newborns in a
crib next to their mother's hospital
beds
but others kept newborns in nurseries
this meant
that families had no way of tracking
their newborns
while it's hard to know for sure the
type of practices that were in place at
fordham hospital
because it was closed in 1976 it's safe
to assume
babies were kept in nurseries in fact it
wasn't until the late
30s that hospitals gave mothers and
their newborns
identifying bracelets back in 1913
nurses typically relied on the nurse's
memory or the mother's recognition of
her newborn
can you imagine not knowing if the baby
you took home was actually your
biological newborn
either the hospital didn't think mix-ups
could happen or they just didn't care
after the truth was revealed the benson
and collins families
exchanged pictures which made the entire
situation very clear
jim collins looked much more like
phillips five foot four father
and four foot nine mother than six foot
phillip did
my grandfather came to my dad's
shoulders
phillips daughter pam benson said the
collins sisters
also had their own explanation about why
their father wasn't as tall as his
siblings
they always just assumed that jim had
been malnourished while growing up in
the orphanage
after all that is what the doctor told
them never in a million years did alice
think that her father wasn't
biologically related to his brother and
sister
it's a mystery that only dna technology
could have uncovered
alice soon discovered that she had a
biological first cousin named phyllis
pullman
who was the daughter of the sister jim
never knew he had
in 2015 alice decided to fly to florida
to meet her
sitting on opposite sides of the couch
the two women could have been mistaken
for sisters
they definitely shared the same dna
phyllis shared
a story about when her tall uncle philip
was dating his first wife
her observant jewish parents didn't
believe that he was jewish
he had to bring his birth certificate
phyllis told author libby copeland
little did we know it wasn't his birth
certificate the two families have kept
in touch over the years
but neither of them can shake the
what-if questions that linger in the
back of their minds
on the other hand the two families are
happy that they found each other
but on the other hand the revelations
feel like a loss
how could alice and pam come to terms
with the fact that their fathers
weren't who they thought they were and
then there were the questions about
religion
was jim collins jewish because he was
born that way
or irish because he was raised that way
and what does that mean for his daughter
alice
alice and her sister agree that if their
father was still alive
it would have been the right thing to
tell him but they consider it a blessing
that jim wasn't alive during the era of
at home
dna testing my dad would have lost his
identity
alice said he's been kind of spared that
alice and her siblings also think about
what would have happened if their father
had gone home to
his biological family as the bensons and
collins families exchanged photos
alice felt a sting of jealousy jim
wasn't supposed to end up in an
orphanage
alice wondered what kind of life her
father would have had had he been raised
by the bensons
his biological family well for starters
alice thought
jim would have been raised in a solid
home he would have graduated high school
and definitely done something with his
gift for mathematics
instead jim dropped out of high school
served in the army and later worked as a
california prison guard
at the end of the day jim made a decent
life for himself
but alice and her family can't help but
grieve for their father as a child
in the orphanage my father got an orange
for christmas
alice said yet had the switch not
happened in 1913 then alice and her
siblings would not have been born
the collins children owe their life to a
simple mistake
with complex consequences made by a
nurse's lapse in attention
it was a terrible mistake but how can
alice resent what happened
and yet were it not for what happened in
1913
alice collins public would not exist
the collins children owe their lives to
administrative oversight
or nurses momentary lapse of attention
now this next man's world was turned
upside down when he went looking for his
biological parents
little did he know that he would find
them in the most unexpected of places