Legalism: Crime & Punishment in Qin Dynasty China | WooKong

Spring and Autumn Period (China History
14 followers
53 Video Views·Jun 30, 2025
Explore the rise and fall of the Song Dynasty, a transformative era in Chinese history. Known for its economic prosperity and cultural advancements, the Song faced internal reforms, northern threats, and, ultimately, the Mongol conquest. Discover how this remarkable dynasty shaped China’s history and faced immense challenges before its decline.
The Qin Dynasty was not only the first dynasty, but lasting 15 years, it was also one of
the shortest.
King Yingzhang, or Qin Shihuang, was the first emperor of China.
He destroyed all rival kingdoms, constructed the terracotta warriors, built much of the
Great Wall, and established an empire.
He achieved all this through a powerful army and the rule of law.
But the life of an ordinary Qin Dynasty citizen was mostly unrecorded.
That was until one day, when a group of diggers in 1975 stumbled upon a tomb.
It was the resting place of Judge Xi.
While not a famous man, what makes him remarkable is that he was buried with an entire library
of legal documents detailing the crimes and punishments of the Qin people.
This is a brief look at Legalism.
Before we begin, we should understand what exactly Legalism is.
Belonging to the 100 schools of thought, it was created by Lord Shang and further refined
by Han Fei.
Legalism is a philosophy which is almost the exact opposite of Confucianism.
Confucian theory believes that we must observe traditions and diligently respect the past.
It also promotes that all men are essentially good, and that through correct cultivation
and by listening to his advisors, a leader can become a sage.
Legalism on the other hand promotes that all men are born evil and can only be encouraged
to do good through reward and intense punishment.
It also states traditions are not useful for the running of a modern society.
Western Legalism is generally viewed as the creation of law by the people for the people.
Chinese Legalism is viewed as the creation of laws for the good of the king and the kingdom.
For the first time in Chinese history, clearly defined and written law was distributed to
the common people.
This was achieved thanks to the simplification and standardization of the Chinese writing
system called the Lesser Seal Script.
Everything from currency to road width became standardized under the Qin rule, and as everyone
now had access to the laws, they were expected to not only follow it themselves, but also
make sure that those around them did too.
The court cases showed that people who did not report suspicious activity were punished,
and those who falsely reported a crime would receive a punishment equal to the reported
crime.
For the people during the time of the Qin, it was a life of unease, having neighbors
and family members being required to spy on each other or face severe discipline.
Police work and forensics of this time were also surprisingly advanced.
In one case, a thief tunneled into a house to steal some clothes, but was ultimately
captured thanks to witness profiling and his footprints left at the scene of the crime.
It wasn't a perfect system though.
All crimes required a culprit, and many people were tortured into confessing, even if they
didn't actually do it.
Even suicides required someone to be punished.
But what's more interesting than the crimes are the punishments.
The lightest punishment is of course a fine.
This would usually be paid in armor, rather than money, to help support the Qin's huge
army.
The next penalty would be demotion and loss of land.
After that was mutilation, which involved blinding, getting tattooed, castrated, or
having one's nose cut off.
Mutilated and crippled criminals were sometimes sentenced to the job of palace watchman, where
it was their job to secretly open doors and curtains and remain hidden from sight.
Unsurprisingly, one of the most common penalties was execution, which came in a variety of
flavors.
Beheading was the vanilla of executions.
After that, it was being cut in half, and then it was being drawn and quartered, and
finally there was dishonorment, which involved receiving all punishments before finally being
executed.
For serious crimes, the criminal's entire family or even whole community could be sentenced
to death.
But we cannot forget about slave labor.
Countless criminals and captured enemies were sent into the deserts and snowy mountains
to spend the rest of their lives working on structures like the Great Wall of China.
While the punishments were extreme, for the first time in Chinese history, they were equal
and applied to everyone, regardless of rank.
It was a meritocracy, meaning you had to earn your position.
In the past, feudal lords would receive taxes from their peasants and then give a small
percentage to the king.
Under the Qin rule, lords were replaced with government officials, and all profits went
directly to the kingdom.
However, poor citizens could now earn a plot of farming land by joining the army and help
conquering new kingdoms.
These two changes helped fund the Qin expansion and cement the emperor's power.
The Qin dynasty is truly a remarkable time in history.
On the one hand, it was one of the first bureaucratic societies.
On the other, it was cruel to the point of fascism.
But it was under the Qin rule that China, for the first time, became united.
The Qin dynasty was quickly followed by the Han dynasty, which pretty much copied the
legalist system word for word, while future dynasties tried to follow more traditionalist
philosophies and demonize legalism.
The truth is that much of their government structures were based on legalism.
Even in modern history, Mao Zedong was an avid admirer of Qin dynastic power, proudly
stating,
So regardless of where you stand on the issue, the Qin dynasty is an incredibly fascinating
period of history.
And for better or worse, its influence in China and throughout the world can still be
felt to this day.
So thank you for watching another one of my videos, don't forget to like, comment and
definitely subscribe.
If you liked this video, why not check out one of my more recent ones?
As always, thank you so much for watching, I'm Wukong, and goodbye.
