How Much Car Insurance Do I Actually Need?

Liability Insurance
3 followers
3 Video Views·Jun 28, 2025
How Much Car Insurance Do I Actually Need?
Dan is with us in Illinois.
Hey Dan, welcome to the Dave Ramsey show.
Hey Dave, thanks for taking my call.
Sure.
What's up?
Um, just, um, I went to Vander and I'm looking at auto insurance and it looks
like I can save a good amount of money.
Um, they're just, I'm good with like the deductible and the premium and everything,
but I'm looking into like the bodily injury, property damage, like uninsured
motorists, um, injury and that sort of thing.
And I didn't know like what levels you recommend for that kind of stuff.
Well, the typical, um, live typically in, in the auto insurance world, the
cheapest part of the policy is the liability part of the policy.
So I always recommend carrying high liability, like 500, 300, or something
like that, because it's not the difference in that and going cheaper on that is very
and if you get into the hundreds of thousands of dollars of liability, it,
um, it's seldom as it seldom stops at 100, you know, or 200.
Um, so you want to get a, you want to get the 500, 300 or 500, two 50
hybrid structure with that particular company, something like that.
So in general, in the insurance world, liability is one of the best buys.
It's the least you pay for.
And, uh, it's a, it's a good spend as you get wealthier and you start to say you
have a net worth of more than a half million dollars or, and, or you have a
large income, you're probably even going to want to pick up a liability umbrella
policy to attach to the top of your homeowners and the top of your car.
Insurance.
You can buy an extra million dollars in liability for those two things.
And an umbrella policy for a couple of hundred bucks a year in most cases.
And so once again, that kind of makes my case that the, um, liability
insurance is just not that expensive.
And, uh, other than that, most of the standard coverages are fine on the other
stuff and what you're looking for is just an apples to apples comparison of
what you had so that you can see if you're really saving money and you typically
will be saving money when you use someone like a Zander that is
an independent insurance agent.
Hey, thanks for the call.
Appreciate you joining us guys.
We talk about this in the ads all the time, but it's good to just stop as a
teaching tool and let you understand there's two types of insurance agents out
there, there's captive agents and independent agents, captive agents work
for one company, like a state farm or a nationwide or something like that.
They can only sell that company.
They're captive.
They're owned by that company.
In that sense, uh, an independent insurance agent can sell many policies
for many different companies.
Now they can't sell for the captive companies, but what you'll find is the
independent insurance agent that shops among several different companies will
almost always beat your state farms and your nationwides and that kind of thing.
Uh, for one thing, there's no expensive football players on their commercials.
Uh, costs a lot of money to get an NFL quarterback on your commercial costs
a lot more money to get two of them on your commercial and just keep this in
mind, that's built into your premiums.
Okay.
And state farm is the largest insurance company in America on property and
casualty, but they are definitely not the best.
Uh, I personally had trouble with them getting to pay them client,
getting them to pay claims.
People hit my car with, and they had state farm insurance.
I always go, Oh crap, this is going to be a fight.
I'm going to have to fight these people to get my money out of them.
And, um, so that, that's what you run into.
Uh, and so, you know, you want to net and it's not big, does not mean better
and more expensive does not mean better.
And just cause you went to high school with the person doesn't mean it's better.
Okay.
You're looking for an independent insurance agent and they will shop
among see independent insurance agent works for you.
They get paid when they do a good job and you buy the other people
work for the insurance company.
And so that's why they call it a state farm agent or a nationwide
agent or an all state agent.
Those are captive companies.
And when you shop, you'll almost always get a better deal when you shop against
those and, um, and many times much better coverage even.
