You're Overpaying - And Dallas Builders Know It

Hawaii Property Market
5 followers
1 Video View·Jun 27, 2025
STOP RIGHT NOW. Before you write another check, tour another model home, or fall for another “limited-time builder discount,” you must watch this.
Something strange is happening with new construction prices in Dallas. Homes are getting “slashed” by tens of thousands… or so it seems. But when you look closer, the deal might not be what it looks like.
Looking to move to Dallas? Check out our website for everything you need to know!
💻 https://www.homeinDallasTexas.com
Are you overpaying for new construction in Dallas?
Well, you probably are at risk for doing just that,
and builders know it.
At the core of this question,
and why this is such a huge issue in Texas, is this fact.
Texas is a non-disclosure state.
Now, what do I mean by that?
Well, writer Seth Williams with REtipster explains,
some of the most important data we need
are the comparable sale prices
for the properties we're evaluating.
And he continues, but there's a problem.
This sold price data is not available
to the general public in some states.
Now, Seth's article focuses on investors
buying homes to sell or rent,
but you as a home buyer need to have the perspective
that your home is an investment.
I mean, true, you're not buying to rent it out, right?
You're gonna live there,
but you have to look at it as a way to build future wealth,
which brings us back to our original question, right?
How can you know if you're overpaying?
Well, let's talk about comparable sales.
REtipster helps us out again when it explains,
comparable sales are used as measuring tools
to help to determine the fair market value of a property.
And that's what we're after, right?
Like, we wanna know the fair market value
so you don't overpay.
Now, individual sellers and realtors,
they use sold homes to figure out a fair asking price,
like what a home should be listed for, right?
But here's the thing, builders don't follow those rules.
Builders wildly move their sales data
by raising the prices, slashing the prices,
and sometimes confusing things even further
with complicated incentives.
Now, you have plenty of states
where that just isn't gonna fly, but in Texas, it does.
Williams gives us some good insight into why that is.
He explains how levels of disclosure
fall into three camps in the US.
Green represents full disclosure states
where the sales prices of properties
are openly reported and accessible to everyone.
He continues, red denotes non-disclosure states
where no reliable public sources are available
to obtain sales prices for all properties.
Orange indicates states that fall in between
with limited disclosure.
In these states, making an educated guess
about property values is possible
based on the partial information disclosed to the public.
There aren't that many non-disclosure states.
I mean, they are definitely in the minority,
but wouldn't you know, Texas is one of them.
Now, if you're relocating to Dallas
from states like California, Washington, or New York,
this may be completely foreign to you.
Like, you're used to being able
to look up the public records
and see exactly what homes have sold for.
Well, that's not the case in Texas.
You are not going to be able to do that.
Homelite explains if you live in a non-disclosure state,
it means that sales prices in a real estate transaction
are not disclosed or recorded as public record.
It continues, if you want to know
the sales price of a home,
you'd have to ask the seller directly
or work with a real estate professional
who has access to the Multiple Listing Service, MLS.
Otherwise, you're in the dark.
Now, individual home sellers don't tend to think
about capitalizing on this.
And they also don't have the ability
to influence an entire neighborhood, okay?
They're just one seller.
The tendency is they're gonna look to a realtor
for a suggested list price
and then list their home accordingly.
New construction communities aren't like that.
The builders have entire communities
of like 20, 30, even 40 inventory homes
where they can move prices around to confuse you
as to what fair market value really is.
As a result, new construction pricing has a lot of movement.
They raise and lower prices every few days.
Now, if you speak with a sales consultant,
you're likely going to be told they're having a huge sale
and they've just slashed their prices.
But then on the flip side, all right,
you might hear, you know, my manager just told me
we're raising prices on Monday.
And maybe they are, all right?
The thing you have to remember
is neither of those events actually tells you
what the home should be listed for in the first place.
If they tell you they've just slashed prices,
your natural assumption will be that the home was priced
fairly to begin with and is now being sold at a discount.
If you hear prices are going up next week,
your tendency is to think
that the home is priced correctly now
and it's about to become more expensive.
Well, please hear me when I say,
neither of these things actually tell you
what a suggested list price should be.
You are truly in the dark on this.
So price reductions and price hikes
will get you caught overpaying.
If you're not careful,
rate incentives can get you caught overpaying too.
All right, what so often happens here
is the buyer gets focused too heavily
on their monthly payment, not the price of the home.
Interest rates are extremely powerful
when it comes to your monthly payment
and many builders will pay to have that interest rate
reduced and this isn't cheap either.
John Burns, a real estate research and consulting firm
estimates that permanently reducing a buyer's rate
by 1.5% on an FHA loan would cost between $19,700
and $34,200 for an entry-level home
depending on the home price.
Now, I am a huge fan of builders
paying down your interest rate,
but your risk here is in overpaying.
The builder wants to recover his costs
so he will often ridiculously overprice the home.
Now, we had this happen recently
with an Ashton Woods home our buyer was considering.
I mean, the offer was an amazing 2-1 buy-down
plus fixed rate forward commitment.
The interest rate for the first year was 3%,
the second year was 4% and all remaining years
were a fixed rate of 5%.
That is a fabulous incentive, all right?
But here's the thing, when we did the market analysis,
the home was overpriced by $50,000.
There wasn't a single sale in the entire community
that even remotely supported
what they were asking for in that home.
So the offer sounds amazing
and it's not that it just sounds amazing, okay?
It is amazing, but if you as a buyer
are only focused on your monthly payment,
you might jump at it if you don't have
that market analysis.
Now, in this situation,
Ashton Woods wasn't doing anything wrong, okay?
They're not doing anything wrong here.
They can price the home however they want to.
They were advertising an unbeatable rate incentive
where they would have recovered the entire cost
of that buy-down and a little leftover besides
if a buyer focused on the monthly payment only.
Now, hopefully I haven't sent you
into a nebulous no-man's land of feeling,
how will I ever know what a home should really be listed for
because you can know.
The data is there.
As an unlicensed professional,
you just don't have access to it
because again, Texas.
As REtipster explains, an appraiser or realtor
has to step in with the data
and ask where's the property located?
What is the square footage of the building,
both finished and unfinished?
What is the total acreage of the lot?
How many bedrooms and bathrooms are there?
What year was the home or structure built?
Have there been any recent upgrades or renovations?
Are there any special features?
This is just the starting point of a market analysis.
A solidly prepared analysis can take several hours
to prepare, especially when the ideal conditions aren't met.
Tipster explains, in a perfect world,
a comparable property would be 100% identical
to the subject property in every conceivable way.
However, in the real world,
no two properties are exactly alike
due to a number of factors.
I wanna show you a few examples
of what the constant price movement
looks like in new construction.
When I look on the MLS, I see arrows,
lots and lots of arrows.
Like take arbors at Legacy Hills in Salina, for example.
Four have just raised their prices
and three have just dropped them.
Or how about Walden Pond in Forney?
You have nine homes with price reductions
and seven with price increases.
So there's that constant price movement.
I mean, if the builder was just all about
offering a big sale, would he really be raising prices
on half his listing?
No, it's just more about constantly changing the prices.
Overpaying for a home is a huge problem
because let's say you buy a home for $520,000,
but the true market value was only $471,000.
If you need to sell within the next few years,
whether due to a job change, a family situation,
or just a shift in priorities,
you're going to be in trouble.
You will owe a higher amount.
And that means you either lose money out of pocket
or you're stuck in a house that you're upside down on.
It's draining you financially, but you can't sell it.
And it doesn't stop there, right?
If interest rates drop to like 5% and you wanna refinance,
you can't because your home doesn't appraise high enough
to cover the closing costs.
So now you're stuck with a 7% interest rate
and you can't refinance, okay?
You can't refinance, you can't sell.
So suddenly what felt like a dream home, right?
Becomes a burden that traps you, okay?
And this happens all the time.
In fact, let's walk through a real life illustration.
In this market snapshot,
three homes recently closed at around $170 per square foot,
clearly lining up market value.
But then one buyer came in and paid $186 per square foot.
So significantly above the norm.
Now focus on homes number one and four, okay?
They're identical in floor plan and size.
I reviewed the listing photos.
They're literally the same house
and they closed just one week apart.
Buyer A paid $323,000.
Buyer B for the same home paid $348,150.
So that is a 25,150 difference for no difference in value.
I mean, buyer A purchased at market price.
Buyer B, okay, they're already in the red.
Here's another case in Forney.
Two buyers each paid exactly $163 per square foot
for homes that were absolutely comparable.
Same features, same level of upgrades, right?
So this represents a solid benchmark
for what a suggested list price should look like.
Then along comes a third buyer
who paid $179 per square foot for a very similar home.
Now I reviewed all three comparables across the board.
Why would this buyer have paid so much more?
Well, here's what happened.
That home was originally listed at $604,900.
After a major price drop, it was reduced to $549,900.
And that's when the buyer entered the picture.
So with a realtor representing them,
the buyer ended up negotiating a final price of $520,000.
So sounds like a win, right?
So from their perspective,
they snagged a home already marked down
and then got it reduced even further.
The agent may very well have even celebrated the deal
as like a big negotiating success.
But let's look at the current reality.
If that same home were listed today,
the recommended price would be around $471,000,
which means the buyer overpaid by $48,115.
So on paper, the negotiation looked strong.
But in the real world, that buyer is now sitting upside down.
Now, I do want to point this out.
On a market analysis,
it is healthy to see a general trending up of values.
For example, you might see home sales
within a range of 150 to $160 per square foot.
Okay, that's perfectly normal.
That's a good thing.
At where you know a buyer has been taken,
though, is like we saw earlier.
You'll see several comparable sales at $163 a square foot,
and then one suddenly sold at $179 a square foot.
When that happens, the builder has scored a win here,
but the home buyer has overpaid,
and they're not gonna be able to sell.
Now, I want to give you a buying blueprint on this.
When you walk into a model home office
and a sales consultant greets you
and tells you what their homes are priced for,
realize that what they tell you is not an indicator
of what the home should actually be listed for.
Approach it from a standpoint of,
hey, that's helpful information, thank you for providing it,
but constantly be aware that it is the comparable sales,
the market analysis, the data that's gonna anchor you
on what a home should be listed for.
And I know this may sound cynical, all right,
but having been in this business for almost two decades,
I can tell you whatever price they quote
is probably not gonna line up with the market analysis.
I always tell my buyers,
when you walk into a model home, keep a poker face.
If the home is a 10 out of 10, don't say a word about that.
All right, decide if you like the home,
gather information from the sales consultant,
but don't at any time begin negotiating.
If there's a home there that would work for you,
jot that down.
But again, you want to keep things at an arm's length,
and the reason is that you don't know
what the list price on the home should be
because you don't have the data yet.
So what's your next step?
Getting that data, getting those numbers,
and make no mistake,
the market analysis does more than tell you
what the list price on the home should be.
It also tells you a 10 about our seller builder.
You can know if they've been coming down on price.
You can know if they are paying
towards the buyer's closing costs and how much on average.
You can know how exposed they are in terms of inventory.
All right, only after we know all that
do we begin engaging with the sales consultant
and negotiating.
By then, you have a tactical advantage
because you know a whole lot more about them
than they know about you.
You also know what price range the home should be listed for.
So market analysis first,
then discuss price and negotiations.
The sales consultant should not dictate
where negotiations start.
You as the empowered buyer first ascertain
what a suggested list price should be
and then negotiate from there.
Okay, so now let's talk about the gatekeepers.
All right, we know that Texas is a non-disclosure state
and you'll need to rely on licensed professionals
such as realtors or appraisers to gain comparable sales.
In Dallas, you will have realtors
who provide zero services whatsoever
but who will rebate part of their commission back to you.
Experienced buyers from disclosure states
may see this as a great opportunity.
They feel like with the data they're used to seeing,
they have a firm enough grip on value
that they can handle it on their own.
But what they don't realize, again, is in Texas,
you are blind to closed sales.
You are not going to be able to access the data.
So you go into the home purchase thinking,
how cool is it to get $10,000 back
from a no-service realtor
but then you overpay for the house?
I mean, sometimes by $100,000 or more.
A buyer like that can't sell.
If rates drop to 5%, they can't refinance.
In that situation, you as a buyer have to decide
if that temporary rebate is a win for your long-term future.
When you come from a full disclosure state
and especially where home prices are much higher,
whew, you've got a lot of risk here
if you're confident in your ability
to determine value on your own.
So you have your no-service realtor, all right?
But then you have realtors
who may have the best personalities on YouTube
and they'll provide some services
like meeting you at the property,
but they don't understand the importance
of the market analysis.
You also have realtors who just don't know how to do them.
What it boils down to is you absolutely must,
must interview a realtor before you decide to hire them.
Look for things like experience
and how much this person relies on data and reports.
I mean, have an extensive conversation
about the comparative market analysis.
Ask a lot of questions.
Now, hopefully it goes without saying,
okay, this is exactly what we do.
So if we sound like the right fit for the job,
the best way to reach us
is through our Let's Find Home questionnaire
that you can find in the description section.
You know, inventory's up, builders are motivated,
and pricing is tricky.
Now, we've covered the tricky pricing here,
but if you wanna know more about inventory and the market,
I suggest checking out this video.
In the meantime, this is Wendy Pinnell,
and I will see you in the next video.
