Why The Millennium Tower is Still Sinking

Modern Arch
65 followers
37 Video Views·Jun 27, 2025
This is the Millennium Tower, a 58-story skyscraper in San Francisco that, at first glance, looks
like any other luxury high-rise.
But beneath the surface, it's hiding a massive problem.
Since its completion in 2009, the building has sunk more than 16 inches into the ground
and tilted 14 inches to one side, earning its nickname the Leaning Tower of San Francisco.
Many thought the issue was resolved after a $100 million effort to fix it.
But despite those repairs, the tower is still sinking, and the situation may be far from over.
Back in 2002, the Millennium Tower was proposed by Millennium Partners,
a New York real estate firm.
It would be the first high-rise to be built in downtown San Francisco in 20 years,
and there was definitely a large demand for buildings like it at the time.
The project was approved shortly after, and construction went underway in 2005.
It was designed as a high-end residential skyscraper in downtown San Francisco,
and would include 163 condominiums, 108 rentals, and a 136-unit extended-stay hotel.
It became the tallest residential building in San Francisco when completed in 2009,
and early on, it was thought to become a success.
The building was widely praised for its design and features,
and it even won nine different awards from various architectural and engineering organizations,
such as Structural Engineering Project of the Year.
Somewhat ironic, but I guess they couldn't have known it back then.
The last unit sold in 2013 brought the total sales value up to $750 million,
and marked a profit as the building cost $600 million to develop.
So all in all, things were looking good for the tower,
but it wouldn't last long until the disaster struck.
In 2015, authorities were informed that the Millennium Tower was sinking and tilting.
Well, the building has actually been sinking for a long time before it was announced.
In fact, it had actually sunk 15 whole inches before it was even completed in 2009.
But that wasn't the problem.
Let me explain.
You see, it's actually completely normal for buildings to sink a little
as the ground compresses underneath them.
It's called the settlement process,
and is especially true for tall and heavy skyscrapers like the Millennium Tower.
So the engineers were obviously much aware of this fact and took it into account.
However, what the developers didn't anticipate was the rate and extent of the sinking.
Instead of slowing down, like in most cases,
the sinking continued at an unexpectedly fast pace.
What happened with the Millennium Tower was also that one side sank faster than the other,
which led it to tilt to the side as well.
But what actually caused the sinking and tilting?
When we look at a skyscraper, we admire its impressive height and the design,
but the true engineering challenges often happen below the ground rather than above.
As heavy as skyscrapers are, they need a foundation strong enough to support them.
Most skyscrapers in not just San Francisco, but the world,
have their foundations anchored into the bedrock,
the solid area of rock that supports the soil above it.
This is generally the best method for ensuring a stable foundation.
However, in case of the Millennium Tower,
this method was particularly challenging since the bedrock lies as deep as 200 feet beneath it.
In contrast, in areas with many skyscrapers such as Midtown Manhattan,
bedrock is typically found at a much higher depth of 20 to 30 feet below the surface.
Now, this doesn't mean that it's not possible to anchor the building to the bedrock,
but it does become a much more difficult task from an engineering perspective,
and it costs a whole lot more.
Therefore, the developers for the Millennium Tower
chose to opt for a cheaper and more time-efficient approach.
They did this by using friction piles.
These piles were 60 to 90 feet long,
and were installed into the clay and sand layers beneath the site,
designed to transfer the weight of the building into the surrounding soil through friction.
Atop the piles sat a 10-foot-thick concrete slab,
which distributed the building's weight across the foundation.
Beneath the ground in and around the San Francisco area
lies a layer of what is called Old Bay Clay.
It's a soft and water-saturated clay.
Before the Millennium Tower was built,
engineers calculated that it would settle 4 to 6 inches over the span of its lifetime.
Now, you can't really blame the engineers for assuming that they wouldn't encounter
any issues with the clay,
since many other high-rises in San Francisco are also built with a similar foundation,
and haven't encountered any sinking issues.
But unfortunately, the Millennium Tower experienced a far greater settlement than expected.
The soil was simply overloaded from the weight of the 730-million-pound tower,
causing it to sink.
In 2016, the public was alerted of the problem.
The building had sunk 16 inches and had a 6-inch tilt.
As a result, condo owners faced plummeting property values,
with homeowners reportedly losing an average of $320,000 in property value per unit.
Some units even lost millions in resale value.
As you could have guessed, this led to multiple lawsuits from condo owners
who sued the developers for failing to disclose the extent of the sinking before selling units.
Even the city of San Francisco sued them for the same reason,
arguing that Millennium Partners had misinterpreted the structural integrity of the tower.
In response to the lawsuit,
the developers blamed the problem on the Transbay Joint Powers Authority,
claiming that the excavation on the nearby Transbay Transit Center
was responsible for destabilizing the soil under the building.
However, considering the sinking problems had started
before the Transbay Transit Center had even begun construction,
this wasn't the best excuse.
TJPA naturally denied the accusations
and laid the fault in the Millennium Tower's foundation design instead.
While the lawsuits and finger-pointing continued,
a team of engineers was commissioned by the city
to take a look at the skyscraper and evaluate its structural integrity.
Their verdict?
The building wasn't in immediate danger of collapse,
but it was still sinking and tilting.
Well, not sure that really gave the condo owners a sigh of relief.
After all, technically safe isn't exactly what you want to hear
when your multi-million dollar apartment is slowly leaning like the Tower of Pisa.
But it did at least give the developers some time to come up with a solution.
In 2018, the developers proposed a plan to stabilize the building.
The core idea was to install 52 new foundation piles all the way down to bedrock,
connecting them to the inadequate foundation piles that were responsible for the sinking.
Basically, what they should have done in the beginning.
The fix would have a price tag of $100 million and start in 2020.
But not even a year into the stabilization attempt,
studies showed that the effort had caused the building to tilt and sink
even further rather than stabilizing.
The failed attempt led to work on the building being paused in August 2021,
and it took a whole year for a new plan to take shape.
The revised plan reduced the number of piles to 18,
which would all be installed on the building's north and west sides where it was tilting.
By June 2023, work was finally completed and monitoring data confirmed that the fix
had successfully prevented the building from further sinking.
However, that's not the end of the story.
You see, the building still leaned 28 inches at the top.
And although the main goal of the fix was to simply prevent any further sinking,
some improvement in the tilt was also expected.
But the rate of the tilt improvement was progressing much slower than estimated.
In early 2024, data revealed that the tilt has only reversed by about an inch,
which is just a quarter of the amount originally predicted by the model.
And that's not it.
In 2024, it came out that the building may now be sinking in the center instead of the corner.
Monitoring data indicated that the tower is now
settling at the center at an overall rate of about a tenth of an inch a year.
A tenth of an inch is not that much, but it's not heading in the right direction,
states Harry Poulos, an internationally recognized expert on tall building foundations.
And that would be a bit of a concern in the longer term.
So it's safe to say that the Millennium Tower still has a long way to go before it's fully fixed.
This can also be seen in condo sales, with a penthouse unit selling for
$5 million less than its original asking price earlier this year.
But what do you think?
Will the Millennium Tower ever be fully stabilized?
Or will it remain on a tilt, like the new iconic Pisa Tower of San Francisco?
Comment down below.
Thanks for sticking with us till the end, and we hope to see you in the next episode.
