“This Is An Arrogant Government” | Keir Starmer In Trouble As Labour Rebellion Grows

UK Prime Ministers
23 followers
Ministers are discussing the prospect of further concessions to win over a growing list of Labour MPs poised to rebel against planned welfare reforms ahead of a crunch vote next week.
Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner said talks between backbenchers and Government were “ongoing” on Wednesday night as Downing Street seeks to head off what would be Sir Keir Starmer’s first Commons defeat.
Tory MP Mark Francois joins Talk’s Mike Graham to discuss this fruther.
#politics #government #keirstarmer
We must start really with this vote on Tuesday, Keir Starmer facing a rebellion at home, which
is possibly going to be, in effect, a sort of vote of confidence in not only him but
in the government, isn't it?
Well, he's absolutely boxed himself into a corner.
It looks like the Labour whips have massively overplayed it.
I think, in a nutshell, the problem Starmer's got is if he, A, pulls this bill at the last
minute, or B, loses it, or C, waters it down so much as to make it effectively meaningless,
he's no longer really the Prime Minister.
He's just some bloke who lives in Downing Street.
Because if you look at his majority on paper, it's massive.
If he can't actually produce that majority in the eye lobby of the House of Commons when
he needs it, he's not really running the country.
No.
He's not even running his party, is he?
Well, a lot of this is a completely self-inflicted wound.
This is an arrogant government, and I think they've kind of, as I say, and I was a senior
whip for a few years, I know a bit about that, they've kind of over-whipped their backbenchers.
They've gone in with the knuckle-dusters far too early, and they've had a massive pushback,
and now they're between a rock and a hard place.
Because when they did go in with the knuckle-dusters, as you say, there was only about 80 rebels,
and now there's over 100.
And so it seems as though that didn't work.
They're now going to try the soft-soap tactic, that Keir Starmer's going to come back and
try and talk them into some kind of standing down on the rebellion.
But either way, this government has been in not quite a year, next week it will be a year,
we'll be all, I won't say celebrating, commemorating some of the things that they've done.
And we were looking at what they have done, and there hasn't really been anything good.
And I don't say this as a kind of totally anti-Labour person, I'd quite like the government
to be quite a good government in this country, no matter who's doing it, but they can't seem
to make anything work.
No.
And there's no plan, there's no strategy, there's no moral compass by which they're
aiming.
It's all soundbites and slogans.
And I think the public have realised that, I think Parliament's realised that, I think
a lot of Labour-backed benches have realised that, and that's why his authority is sort
of seeping under the door.
One of the reasons for this, there are numerous Mike, is because it's a government utterly
obsessed with human rights.
The Prime Minister is a human rights lawyer, Lord Hermer, the Attorney-General, now famously
a sort of religious zealot, if I can, about human rights.
And because of that, they take bizarre decisions, like being prepared to pay £30bn of British
taxpayers' money to Mauritius, to rent back a bunch of islands that belonged to us in
the first place, and also pursuing Northern Ireland veterans through the courts, whilst
at the same time being prepared to make it easier for Gerry Adams to sue the government
and thus the British taxpayer.
Because their minds are obsessed with human rights, they end up tied up in these ridiculous
knots which look daft to the voting public, but seem to make sense to them.
So it's a government completely hidebound by its obsession with the Human Rights Act
and the ECHR, making one mistake after another, and even their own backbenchers can see it.
Hence the mood.
Right, and of course, we'll come back to the SAS story in a second, but that includes as
well their obsession with human rights of refugees, stroke migrants, whether they're
legal, illegal, you know, they keep talking about deporting people.
They haven't deported anyone since last year.
They haven't deported anyone since many people decided to go back voluntarily.
We learned this week from The Sun that people are getting off boats in this country and
within hours they're working as delivery drivers for food companies because it's that easy
for them to do it.
It's absolutely extraordinary.
Well of course, and the public see this on their television screens and they get very
angry.
Now, before you say to me, why didn't you do something about it, we did have a plan.
It was called the Rwanda Plan.
Some people liked it, some people didn't, but it's one more plan than Labour have got.
They tried to recreate something with Albania, and you had that farcical press conference
with that six foot seven Albanian, where the PM basically says, you know, we've got this
deal.
And then live on camera, the Albanian president says, well actually no, we don't mate.
I mean, it was like something out of the thick of it.
So there's no plan.
They haven't smashed the gangs.
The gangs remain resolutely unsmashed.
In the home counties, they're trying to cover our constituencies in concrete, a number of
places in my...
But one called Dollyman's Farm, I feel passionately against.
They've got no compass, there's no plan, as I say, and the public can palpably see it.
He's in real trouble.
I've been a Member of Parliament for 24 years.
He's in real trouble.
Yeah, I said this from the moment he got in actually, but certainly from last autumn,
there was something that was going to happen to him, whether it was some kind of independent
sort of story, whether it was going to be a piece of policy that went wrong, or some
act that went on inside the party, I just knew that he wasn't going to last.
And it's all unravelling the wheels, coming up faster than ever.
And Ange just waits.
Oh, she's very much helping him on his way, isn't she?
She's not doing anything at all to come to his aid.
But, you know, you're right to say before I ask you about what you should have done,
I know that the Labour government blocked every single thing the Tories tried to do.
And you talk about human rights, and they used their human rights lawyers.
You know, where are all the human rights lawyers now when Starmer keeps talking about deporting
people?
They've all disappeared.
You know, you wouldn't have been able to move for them if it was the Tories trying to do it.
And so that's what happened.
Well, actually, the human rights lawyers, a lot of them, are working for the people
who are trying not to be deported.
You know, there's a lot of money to be made doing that.
No, sure.
But what I'm saying is that they were very vocal about what the Tories were trying to
do, and how cruel it was, and how against the law it was, and how it was, in fact, putting
Britain on a par with terrible, terrible ghastly countries like Russia and Belarus, and all
of that.
They've all gone very quiet, haven't they?
Yeah.
I mean, you know, this slogan that they're going to smash the gangs, well, the gangs
remain resolutely unsmashed, as people can see on their televisions every night.
So what do they do?
They have gimmicks.
They have summits.
They rename units.
They create, you know, channel commanders, and all these sorts of things.
I mean, the guy who was their channel commander, who was a respected three-star general, you
know, resigned within a few weeks of getting the job, because he could see that it...
Well, why he did it is ultimately down to him, but some people think he could see it
was impossible to do within the parameters, the legal constraints that were provided.
So the public see this on their televisions, and they get angrier and angrier.
Yvette Cooper, bless her, literally hasn't got a clue what she's doing from one day to
the next, and that's why he's in real trouble.
I'm not saying, you know, he'll be gone by the end of next week.
I'm not making that point, but you can tell when a Prime Minister is losing authority
in their own party.
You can smell it in the tea room in Parliament, and he's got that whiff about him now.
No question.
Which brings us to what you mentioned earlier, SAS veterans hounded with the threat of prosecution.
This is also, I think, the reason why Keir Starmer's lost his authority is because he's
being seen very much as a hypocrite, because he puts out all these statements all the time
about how he's standing up for our armed services, how he's standing up for the security of Britain,
and every single time you see a statement, you go, well, actually, that's not true, because
if you were standing up for the armed forces of this country, why are you going after members
of the armed forces for something that they did dozens of years ago?
Well, look, Mike, this is something I've campaigned on personally for years.
I once raised it at Prime Minister's Questions with Theresa May about six years ago.
I remember, yeah.
The case of a guy who was a Chelsea pensioner, St David Griffin, I think, from memory, who
was being pursued, even though he was in the Royal Hospital at Chelsea, for goodness sake.
So look, here's, if I may, here's the Daini Mayholt campaign, good for them.
This gets legally a bit fiddly, but let me see if I can absolutely boil it down.
When we were in government, we brought in a thing called the Northern Ireland Troubled
Legacy Act to provide protection to armed forces personnel from this endless cycle of
investigation and reinvestigation, often at the behest of Sinn Féin.
Labour said in their manifesto they wanted to repeal that, but it took four years of
campaigning to get the last act, so it would take a long while to replace it.
So what they're doing is they've got what's called a remedial order, which is a procedure
based from, wait for it, the Human Rights Act 1998, and they're using this remedial
order, which is a sort of parliamentary surgical knife, to take out bits of the Legacy Act.
And the two key effects of that, if you're still with me, are one, it would remove a
lot of the protections for our veterans.
So this whole conveyor belt of inquests and further inquiries would restart.
And two, and here's the equally awful bit, it would make it easier for Gerry Adams and
his cronies to sue the British government, and ultimately therefore the taxpayer.
What self-respecting Labour MP, and there are decent Labour MPs in the Labour Party,
what Labour MP, by the way we're debating this in Parliament this afternoon, what self-respecting
Labour MP would want to walk through the lobbies and vote for what I've just told you the government
want to do, the vote will be in the autumn, and then go back to their constituency?
They're not going to get bought a pint down the Royal British Legion, are they?
No, they really aren't, and that is the problem.
Starmer, funnily enough, is just about to speak at the, I think it's the British Chambers
of Commerce Global Annual Conference.
We might dip into it at some point.
No, I understand.
And by the way, most Labour MPs don't even know that's what they're going to be asked
to vote for.
No, of course.
But they will after today.
But the point is that he's going to be talking about building up our defences, he's going
to be talking about recruitment, he's going to be talking about making Britain stronger,
but yet, how on earth can he then do that with a straight face while pursuing these
men who have served their country, put their lives on the line, been in terribly risky
situations, facing death, shooting people to kill them when they had to because that
was their job, and they were asked to do it by the Prime Minister of the day?
How can they be being chased?
Well, they're now partly being pursued under an Act which came in after most of these incidents
took place.
The Human Rights Act didn't come into British law until 1998.
Most of the conflicts and the troubles, most of these incidents, often between the SAS
and the IRA, but obviously there are others, happened decades before that law came in,
right?
So this is awful, and in terms of recruitment and retention, what sane person would join
the Army today if you know you've got a government that doesn't have your back, that even if
you do the right thing and you kill a terrorist who's trying to kill you and your comrades,
years later some bunch of human rights lawyers, aided and abetted by a Labour government,
are going to come after you for doing it.
Who in their right mind would join the Army?
So it's not just an argument about the history of the troubles, it's also a very hard-nosed
argument about recruitment and retention in the British Army, and the Army on paper is
meant to be 73,000 trained troops, it's under 71,000 and it's going down, and if you carry
on with this, what will happen is fewer people will join and more people will leave.
So this is really dangerous.
So when the Prime Minister, you know, puts his hand on his heart and he talks about his
commitment to the Armed Forces, well okay, I'm not calling him a liar on national TV,
but why is he doing this then?
How does that stack up with all these peons of praise for the Armed Forces?
It really doesn't, it's ridiculous.
We had a former SAS commander in here who spoke very well to us, he was in charge of
the SAS after 9-11 in Afghanistan, and he came in and he's just about to be,
or he has become the chairman of We Serve, which is an organisation that we very much support.
And you know that, can I just mention the petition very quickly?
Sure.
Okay, there's a parliamentary petition for people who want to protect Northern
Ireland veterans from prosecution.
It's got over 140,000 signatures, because it's over 100,000.
We've got a debate on the 14th of July for three hours in Westminster about this,
so thank you to all of your viewers that signed it.
But the more people that carry on signing it, it's technically open till November,
the more signatures on that petition, the more moral weight we will have in that debate
in three weeks' time.
So I would very much urge any of your viewers and listeners to go onto the parliamentary website,
it takes seconds to do, and sign that petition.
If you want to do something positive as a British citizen to defend our veterans,
who defended us, please go online now and sign the petition.
Absolutely, we will do that.
Ed Butler was the guy that we had here just the other day, he was a magnificent guy,
and he said, and he spoke out very well, because not a lot of people do,
because of all sorts of reasons.
But he said, you know, the government should not be doing this,
they should not be pursuing people, and they have a duty of care,
quite frankly, to the people who put their lives on the line.
My colleague Sir David Davis, as everyone knows, served in the SAS years ago.
He's been very instrumental in this campaign, along with myself and a few others.
But it's the veterans, ultimately, who are making the case, but we absolutely agree with them.
And, you know, David Davis has made this point,
that often the soldiers you're talking about had to take split-second life or death decisions,
you know, in the dark.
It's very easy to sit in an air-conditioned courtroom 50 years or more later,
and second-guess what that soldier did or didn't do,
but you weren't that soldier, and you weren't there.
Yeah, I know.
And as I say, if we carry on, they call it lawfare.
Yeah.
If we carry on with lawfare like this, the army will shrink and shrink,
and that is not in our interests, that does not promote our national security,
it doesn't make us a strong partner of NATO, it doesn't help us support Ukraine.
