The mixed-media samurai documentary MIYAMOTO MUSASHI - Anime Review

Movie Review
40 followers
24 Video ViewsยทJun 26, 2025
So welcome to our review of a little film called Miyamoto Musashi, which came out in 2009.
So this was a surprise. I checked this out because I was interested in Miyamoto Musashi.
Who is this guy?
This guy is a legendary samurai who lived through the transition into the Tokugawa shogunate.
The famous shogunate that is, if you think of the samurai era.
You know, you think of samurai and peasants and rice farming and all those classic things.
That's the Tokugawa era. From about 1600 to about the mid-1800s.
And he basically lived through that 1600 era transition.
Very, very, very successful samurai. He faced dozens and dozens of men in mortal combat and won.
And he wrote a book called The Book of the Five Rings.
Which is a book about bushido, the samurai code.
Which is a thing that's evolved over time.
And The Book of the Five Rings is considered one of the classic texts on that concept.
On what bushido might be.
And this is the interesting thing.
It's by Production IG.
Which is a well-respected anime studio.
Directed by this guy who's done a lot of interesting things.
He directed Video Girl Ai.
He directed California Crisis.
Otogi Zoushi.
Combustible Campus Guardress, which is awesome if you get a chance to see it.
He worked on the Ghost in the Shadow movie.
Patlabor 2.
Rose and Versailles.
Joe.
Oh my goodness, all sorts of great stuff.
This is a mixed-media documentary.
Mixed-media?
It's not...
It's a documentary?
It's a documentary.
There's live-action footage.
There's CGI.
There's traditional anime animation.
Oh, wow.
And it is basically trying to correct a lot of misinformation.
Or a lot of the assumptions about misoption in real life.
That have evolved over time.
It's kind of a weird thing.
It's kind of like us coming out with a documentary about George Washington.
You know, we're not going to spend a lot of time telling you all the events in Washington.
He didn't cut down that cherry tree like you think.
Exactly.
So, it is trying to provide kind of a scholarly context.
Where here's what people think.
And here's what people who have actually researched this have to say.
But in a very kid-friendly way.
It's all sub-type.
In Japanese.
So you can follow it if you're a kid.
So it's very easy that way.
About the first half covers Musashi's samurai code.
His view on how to live and behave.
And how that related to what he went through as a person.
And how his biography informed his beliefs.
So, for example, he was a foot soldier.
And he was always fighting around samurai on horses.
If you were on a horse, you were a piolet.
His style was the two-handed fighting style.
Two-handed?
Yeah.
Now, when you think of a samurai who is about to attack you, what is his stance?
Well, I would think he has his sword in both hands.
Exactly.
And Musashi says that's dumb.
Ugh.
And can you think of why that might be dumb?
Well, it ties up one of your hands.
It gives you a strong punch.
It does.
But...
Now, here's the thing.
Imagine I'm here with my sword in my hand.
Right?
And I'm just holding with one hand.
And you're going to strike me.
Oh, that leaves me open here.
Right.
Now, you have all that power, right, that you can use to deflect.
Right.
But how do you actually get that power?
If you're just standing like this and trying to do that, you can't get the power.
So what you do is you swing back, right?
At which point I kill you.
Ah.
Oh.
Yeah.
There's a flaw in the two-handed approach.
And one of Musashi's ideas was basically that the two-handed approach was the way.
That was just how you were targeting the whole sword.
That's why you do it.
And he said it's not logical.
It's not rational.
He reinvented their wheel.
He completely reinvented the wheel.
Wow.
And...
But also, more importantly, when you're on a horse, you can't do this.
No, you've got to hold the reins.
You've got to...
Exactly.
Yeah, you're out of control.
Totally.
So his style was very much inspired by him imagining being on a horse.
Ah.
And that's how he practiced, being two-handed.
And then when he fought people with that style, he realized, oh, this is effective.
Oh, wow.
It's made of all that.
So that's kind of the idea behind it, is that there's a lot of this understanding of Musashi's
life and how that evolved with youth.
And then the last half is about these sort of misconceptions about these popular views
of Musashi and historical record.
People see him as this kind of Zen master.
He's actually very practical.
So, for example, at one point, he fought somebody who had a sword with a bouken, like this.
A wooden sword.
Yeah.
Against a samurai sword.
With a metal against wood.
Right.
And he fought.
And he fought that way.
He survived.
After hammering a bunch of nails in the end.
That's smart.
Exactly.
And that was the idea.
You could even use a wooden sword against an opponent.
Yeah, but the point is, you find a way to make it effective.
You don't just use your Zen power with a wooden sword.
That could overcome all sorts of requirements of, you're not allowed to have a weapon.
Oh, well, I've got to stick with a nail.
It's not okay.
I'm using it for plowing this field, and now I've got to...
And that was one of his views, is that he very much promoted this idea of being very practical.
Of saying, figure out your opponent.
Figure out what you have to do.
And use whatever you have.
Whatever's at hand.
So, for example, he was facing a very stubborn man in the deep winter.
And the man said, I will wait for you in this one spot until you come and we'll fight.
And so Musashi went there ahead of time, got it out, and waited two days.
And so the guy came, had his little fire, sat with his retainers and waited.
Day later, he waited.
And Musashi showed up, managed to get the guy alone, fought him, and killed him because the guy was cold.
He basically said, you know, what I'm going to do, I know he's going to stand out there in the snow waiting for me.
He just waited until he was finished.
Right, you know, I'm a samurai, I'll tough it out.
Tough guy, I'm a tough guy.
Musashi shows up all nice and warm and limber, and okay, let's do this.
He used the guy's hubris against himself.
Yes.
Wow, that's pretty practical.
It's very practical.
So, back to the focus.
It's a real mixed bag because a lot of the film is basically this all-CGI classroom with a professor,
who's this sort of super-deformed old guy who's going around lecturing,
and then this girl assistant in a kimono who's going around in the background showing off and kind of demonstrating stuff about horses and so forth.
And a good chunk of the film is just that, of just him explaining things to you.
Then there's some live-action footage of these various locations Musashi was in.
So we know where the Battle of Ryozohara was, and we have footage of that in the field.
But the main thing for us is these Production IG-produced anime-footage sequences,
which show these moments in Musashi's life.
So you see that duality.
And these are very stylish.
There's obviously not a massive animation budget.
In other words, it's not 30 frames per second of animation.
But they put a lot of time and effort into making those footages feel remarkable and feel different.
And also very desaturated.
Because the CGI is kind of cartoony, and the live-action is live-action.
They specifically went with this very desaturated, grayish palette for that,
with things like red popping out of the blood and things like that.
Which makes it feel big and remarkable.
Especially for somebody living in this very brutal time.
It is this black-and-white sort of thing.
It's a very historical feel, having the color removed.
And I think it's also partly because a lot of the Musashi films are black-and-white films.
So it's kind of a callback to that.
It feels a little bit like a black-and-white film.
So, direction and cinematography.
The live-action shots are simple and clean.
It's like a documentary.
And when they're showing a shot of a field...
It's not a field, right?
Here's the field.
The CGI tends to hold on the CGI a little bit too long.
It's a little, I don't know, like a kid's show.
Where if you're showing somebody explaining something, you kind of hold on that for a long time.
So you can absorb it.
So it's not really dynamic, but it works fine.
The anime is much more arty, much more dramatically edited.
Two characters facing off, you'll hold on that.
And there's the break, and some action and movement, and lots of camera angles jumping back and forth through that.
So that's very well done.
And I would say, if you like the animation, the movie is worth watching.
You might be one of those people who starts watching movies and just fast-forwards to the animation.
And that's totally fine, and they are worth watching for that.
But having an interest in the history of it...
Yeah, definitely helps.
I did not know much about Musashi.
I knew he was looking to buy five rings.
I'd read that at one point in the past.
That's about all I knew.
And I found it very interesting how much material they could provide.
So you don't need to be a Musashi otaku to read that.
The narrator himself...
He can get into kind of lecturing old man mode.
Which is a little annoying after a while.
They kind of push that a little bit too much, where I wish there were more visuals.
I wish there was a bit more than just CGI character talking to you for a while.
Not too bad, just sometimes in a drag.
There are a few funny moments where he gets really worked up over a topic.
And really frustrating, because Musashi wasn't like that!
People really think that!
No, that's not really true.
But the voice does get a little grating over a while.
They are doing that kind of, you know,
old man explaining things to you voice.
Is this English, or is this Japanese?
All Japanese.
And I watched a fan sub.
I don't know if it's available any other way.
It came out eight years ago now.
So, I don't know.
Someday.
And other than that, there's not much else voice acting.
I don't think the female assistant talks at all.
There's a little bit of the historical characters talking back and forth.
But those are brief.
It's mostly the acting.
And those are fine.
There's not much to talk about there.
So, because it's basically a set of corrections to modern assumptions about Musashi,
it can feel unsatisfying.
Because it's not plotting out Musashi's life.
It's not plotting out Musashi's philosophy.
So, assuming that some of us already have those assumptions about him,
but we might not even know.
And I think they provide enough context for you to understand what they're talking about.
But there's not a through line,
in the sense of going through, you know,
when he was born, when he died, or whatever.
Or, you know, here's the beginning of the Book of Five,
reading through to the end.
It's a variety of things, kind of like a lecture.
It's very much like a lecture about the topic.
So, I found it fascinating.
And I think it's definitely something that you can appreciate without knowing that stuff.
Just be aware of that going in.
It's not for everybody.
But I think it's interesting.
It's one of those things where you will learn something.
And this was a studio IG for the whole trilogy?
Retro IG.
Now, as with everything, I know they did the anime.
I'm sure other people were involved.
Oh, that makes sense.
They subcontracted out or whatever.
But I believe this was a Retro IG, you know, directed project.
And they found other people to do it.
Fire him out to different...
Yeah, exactly.
The director was certainly a Retro IG person.
All that kind of good stuff.
So, as a history box, it would be worth seeing.
Definitely interesting.
And to that point, one of the nice things is it does give you that context
of things like the Battle of Sekigahara,
which is one of the things that helped form the shogunate.
It gives you elements about samurai, about Bushido, about things like that.
So, for example, one of the reasons...
We'll leave on this one.
Musashi was not really a helpful word among Japanese people until the 20th century.
He was just some samurai who wrote this book one day.
Until the first Russo-Japanese War.
The Japanese government, the military particularly,
had really turned their back on the use of swords in war.
Understandably.
Bring a sword to a gunfight.
Exactly.
And then there was this major battle where the Japanese were defending this fort
against a bunch of Russians.
The Russians all picked a bayonets and charged.
A sword!
Yeah.
A short sword!
Very short.
And the officers pretty much held their ground,
but the enlisted men ran.
They were freaked out by this.
They just could not handle that.
Can you imagine if it was a Russian?
Yeah, with a knife on the end of their gun.
Both a knife and a gun.
Done.
So, this was a major problem for the Japanese military
because they didn't have anything within their military,
or really their propaganda,
around this vital aspect of this quarter combat.
So basically, they went back and said,
okay, was there some Japanese hero,
well known for using blades,
who also had a philosophy of battle?
Ideally focused around this.
To give you an idea, at the time,
the only major book about Ushido was in English.
What?!
Because it just wasn't a thing they talked about.
It wasn't a...
They were modernizing!
They were part of the modern future!
That was the past!
We don't care about that!
Oh yeah, that's for the old people!
Exactly!
So, Ushido was driving some other things.
But the major book was written by a Japanese person
living in San Francisco.
So, they translated that real quick,
brought that over,
and then started popularizing Musashi.
And that's one of the reasons for this film.
It's saying that, you know,
then that became this idea.
Musashi was this, you know,
brilliant person.
You've got to triangulate a little bit
of the sources and history,
so it's not just the one source history book.
Okay, here's some references.
Yeah, Musashi was definitely used
as a political tool after his death.
As so many people are.
So, this helps provide more of that information.
Cool!
Did you find that useful?
You learned about Musashi!
Exactly!
What year was that?
2009.
That's when the movie came out.
The problem is,
there's a lot of research on Musashi movies.
Oh, there's a lot of them.
Lots of them.
This is the 2009 version.
In fact, they start by showing,
you know, all the books about Musashi,
and all the DVDs about Musashi,
and all this kind of stuff,
and then saying,
and they're all wrong.
You know, because a lot of them
are based on this weird historical thing.
So, yeah, look for the 2009 version of the movie
and you'll find it.
And yeah, I found both of them.
Ooh, I've got to see this.
Yeah, both of them.
