Ranking Member Jamie Raskin delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Jun 25, 2025
Hearing: Fiscal Accountability and Oversight of the Federal Courts
Thank you kindly, Chairman Issa. I appreciate that and welcome Judge St. Eve and Judge Scudder.
The hearing is on fiscal responsibility in the courts, which makes matters pretty simple for me.
We should make sure we give the federal courts all the resources that you need to carry out your
constitutional duties without having to fear for the safety of your judges or their families,
court personnel, and members of the public who are in federal courthouses. We should thus set
a legislative record today about the needs of the judicial branch. We should not attempt to see if
Congress can use our power of the purse to coerce judges into ruling this way or that way on a
particular case. That's an attack on judicial independence, the power of the courts to say
what the law is, as the court put it in Marbury v. Madison in 1803. Funding is essential to the
independence of the courts. Hamilton began Federalist 79 by acknowledging this relationship.
Quote, next to permanency in office, nothing can contribute more to the independence of the judges
than a fixed provision for their support, he said. In the general course of human nature,
a power over a man's subsistence amounts to a power over his will. Alas, power over the judicial
will is exactly what President Trump has sought since he took office. Judges who decide in his
favor are brilliant, faithful judges, and those who decide against him are communist, radical left
judges, even if they were appointed by a fellow Republican president. In March, Trump called for
the impeachment of a federal judge who ruled against his administration on a fundamental
constitutional question, a judge who had been nominated to bench first by President George W.
Bush. Quote, this judge, like many of the crooked judges I'm forced to appear before, should be
impeached, Trump posted on social media. Meanwhile, his allies in Congress have repeatedly fought to
change the way that the courts work just to benefit him personally and his administration,
such as when they tried to make all state cases against him and his associates removable to
federal court and to prevent judges from being able to issue injunctions that apply beyond the
specific parties to a case. And last month, this committee passed a provision stripping the power
of judicial contempt in certain cases that would allow Trump to ignore adverse federal court
decisions, even though eight in ten Americans think the president should have to obey the orders of
the courts. And that is indeed the whole premise of judicial review as articulated in Marbury versus
Madison in 1803. But the MAGA siege on the judicial branch has not just been limited to anti-judicial
legislation. Every major resource the courts need to act as an independent branch of government
is less achievable because of Trump's program. Trump's ad hominem rhetoric against individual
judges has helped fuel an increase in threats to judicial security. His lieutenants at DOJ have
sharply limited the buildings available to the judiciary, even as our courthouses are falling
apart. American cybersecurity, including our court IT systems, is weaker under Trump after he neutered
the sub-agency within the Homeland Security Department responsible for keeping us secure
from online attack. And Republican leadership took a bipartisan deal to get the judiciary more
federal judges and then twisted it to their own ends. And I'm exempting here my friend Mr. Issa
from that description. Some of our colleagues have suggested the only way the judiciary will get the
funding it needs is if judges change how they rule on decisions important to Trump. Punchbowl News
recently reported about the controversy over threats to judges. When asked about increased
funding for judicial security in light of the skyrocketing threats to federal judges, my friend
Chairman Jordan told a reporter, I don't know that there's going to be a lot of people excited about
giving them an increase. Another colleague reportedly suggested the judiciary quote
should stop screwing everything up if they want more security funding. Checks and balances only
work under the Constitution when the three branches of our government respect each other's
essential independence of action and decision. To withhold the means of guaranteeing the safety
of a judge or their family is to compromise that independence. A judge who receives deliveries at
her home reminding her that the people threatening her online know where she and her children live
may be less able to think clearly and rule objectively on the merits of a case if they fear
that their family's in danger. And that's not an academic point but an urgently practical one.
Threats to federal judges skyrocketed over the last six months as President Trump escalated his
personal threats and rhetoric against federal judges and courts. According to the U.S. Marshal
Service, 197 judges were threatened from early March to late May this year, more than double
the number of judges that had been threatened in the prior five months. Judicial security should
not and has never should not be and has never been a partisan issue. When Justice Kavanaugh was
targeted in 2022, Chairman Jordan rightly said, we don't want any violence here but let's not have a
double standard. And I agree with that. We must oppose all violence and all threats of violence
against the federal judiciary from whatever quarter they arise. We must give judicial branch
institutions all the security funding they need, wholly without regard to which judges are being
protected, in which cases they may be handling. Political control over judges is a hallmark
of monarchical and authoritarian regimes. Indeed, King George's attacks on judicial independence
were part of the bill of particulars set forth in complaint against him by Thomas Jefferson
in the Declaration of Independence. Quote, he has made judges dependent on his will alone for
the tenure of their offices and the amount in the payment of their salaries. Jefferson wrote,
it would be a dangerous breach of our constitutional values to withhold critical
security funding for the judiciary in an effort to change the way judges decide their cases.
I'm certain that we cannot and we will not do that today. I look forward to hearing
from our witnesses and I yield back to you, Mr. Chairman, the remainder of my time.
