Ranking Member Jamie Raskin delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Jun 25, 2025
Hearing: Restoring Integrity and Security to the Visa Process
Mr. Chairman, thank you very kindly. Um,
and thank you to all the witnesses for
being with us today. There there is more
to immigration than border enforcement,
as the ranking member of the
subcommittee just said, and it's a good
thing that our friends are waking up to
that. President Trump and Steven
Miller's ambition to deport 12 million
people from the country has been a
terrible failure on its own terms. But
even in its failure, it has turned our
society upside down. It has terrorized
both citizens and non-citizens,
destabilized and divided our
communities, wrecked small businesses
who've lost their workers, and trashed
our constitution for everybody. It's
gotten so bad that Donald Trump even
seems to have recognized that his
policies don't fit reality. Two weeks
ago, he gave the game away by
acknowledging that hundreds of thousands
of undocumented aliens working on the
farms and in the fields are quote good
longtime workers. and that he'd been
lobbied both by his agriculture
secretary and by large agricultural
interests to stop the ICE raids on farms
as they are spreading panic in keeping a
majority of the workforce from showing
up at work. So he decided he would stop
enforcing the mass drag net ice raids
there and invoke the same logic for the
restaurant sector also heavily dependent
on undocumented people. Of course, it
would apply equally then to the
construction se sector, landscaping and
gardening, nursing, you name it. The
vast majority of immigrants, even those
here illegally, are not rapists and
criminals, but hardworking people
essential to our economy just looking to
make a better life for themselves. Think
of the dreamers. So, it's good for us to
be having the first immigration hearing
in memory, not on enforcement tactics at
the border or in our communities, but
instead about visas. Alas, the
president's record on visas is riddled
with the same bursts of extremism and
dogmatism and fanaticism that have made
his enforcement measures so unpopular.
He and his administration have tortured
our laws and trampled our constitution
to kick out permanent resident green
card holders and students and target
universities who voice opinions that he
disapproves of. As part of its effort to
undertake a hostile takeover of
America's colleges and universities, the
administration interrupted interviews
for student and exchange visitor visas.
The result, about 15% of foreign doctors
slated to begin their work at American
teaching hospitals around the country
were unable to get their visas in time
to start the medical year next month.
All at a time when we have a serious
doctor shortage in the country that
threatens access to care and the
monstrous reconciliation bill threatens
to slash Medicaid funding on which rural
hospitals rely. The administration has
also recently implemented its xenophobic
travel ban to unilaterally ban entrance
to the country for all nationals of 19
different countries with minor
exceptions. Categorically denying visas
to nationals of these countries does not
make us safer or freer or more
prosperous. It cements us in the eyes of
the world as a vindictive, isolationist,
and increasingly undependable and
authoritarian country. The travel ban
will likely have significant economic
consequences by restricting travel and
migration from the targeted nations. In
2022, at least 298,000 non-citizens from
countries affected by the new travel ban
arrived in the US. Most of them came to
the US temporarily, spending money as
tourists or as students, fueling our
economy. The following year, households
with nationals from the targeted
countries collectively earned $3.2 2
billion in income, paid 715 million in
federal, state, and local taxes, and
held $2.5 billion in spending power.
Donald Trump also paused the refugee
program, claiming the entry of these
thoroughly vetted and revetted
individuals would be detrimental to the
United States. But then he allowed white
Africaners to apply via a Google form
and to undergo an expedited process to
come to the US as refugees. And it
should shock no one to learn that after
they arrived, report reporters were able
to dig up numerous anti-semitic posts
from uh the refugees. Uh one of them had
never been subjected apparently to the
new anti-semitism screen being used for
other visa candidates. The title of this
hearing is restoring integrity and
security to the visa process. How does
any of this restore integrity or
security? These random pauses, arbitrary
bans, ad hoc detentions do nothing to
improve security or integrity in our
process. President Trump has turned our
visa system into a terrain of caprice
and selective punishment he can wield
against his chosen political enemies and
use to demonize and scapegoat
immigrants, including visa recipients.
This war on immigrants is designed to
distract us from the fact that they're
trying to cut 14 million Americans off
of Medicaid, destroying small businesses
with chaotic and unlawful tariff
policies, gutting federal agencies and
programs charged with protecting
Americans against scams and frauds and
using the pardon power to transfer more
than a billion dollars from the victims
of crime to the perpetrators of crime.
Sometimes the president's had his lucid
moments on immigration. During his first
term, while saying he wanted to build
build a big beautiful wall, he said the
wall would have a big very beautiful
door signifying his support for legal
immigration. Um, in brief lucid moments
like these, I try to find hope that we
can work together across the aisle to
focus on a secure border, the removal of
immigrants convicted of serious crimes
and public safety threats, a pathway to
citizenship for the law-abiding
taxpaying undocumented immigrants who
Trump recently called very good longtime
workers, and a modernized immigration
system that will make it easier to come
here lawfully while protecting American
workers. We've come very close to doing
this in the past. We can do it again.
Tom Payne, who arrived in the country in
1774,
uh, fell in love with America when he
got here. He said, "This land will
become an asylum to humanity. Not an
insane asylum, mind you, but a place of
refuge for people seeking freedom from
religious and political and economic
persecution and discrimination from all
over the world. So, uh, let's live up to
the original vision of the founders.
This is a nation made up of immigrants
and the descendants of people who were
enslaved and of the original Native
Americans. But this is a land of
immigration, a land of immigrants, and a
land of laws. We can make it all fit
together, and I hope we can work
together on a bipartisan basis to make
that happen. Yield back, Mr. German.
