Are Bike Skills Needed In Triathlon? | Tri To Disagree

sport and travel
205 followers
#sport #travel #running #marathon #cycling#training #race #triathlon #swim #bike #run #adventure #inspire
Welcome back to another edition of Try to Disagree, where we try to disagree about
something controversial in triathlon. Oh, yes. Today's controversial statement is
bike skills are not needed in triathlon. Well, yes. I think there is a growing trend
that you can do all your training indoors on a turbo where you can't fall off and that'll suffice
to get you ready for a triathlon, but is that true? Look, I get it because it's time-efficient
and there are benefits to indoor training in terms of getting powerful, doing very efficient
bike workouts, but I think we're probably on the same side here in terms of we both
enjoy riding a bike. We like to be fairly skillful while riding a bike and probably
see benefits to that. However, we are going to have to take sides, I'm afraid, James.
We are going to have to take sides. You see, we've seen more and more, I suppose,
pros out there who have foregone any bike skills training whatsoever, done all their training
outdoors, got really, really strong and still had a fair amount of success. Which way are you going,
Mark? I was hoping you'd choose. I'll go with you don't need bike skills.
Controversial. Okay. Yes, I'll go with you definitely do need to work on your bike skills.
Now, the thing is we've seen athletes, like I said, who haven't worked on their bike skills.
They've worked on Zwift and they've got really strong and they've done really well. I'm talking
about someone like Andy Potts or Lionel Sanders who have spent all their time indoors and then
biked really well in triathlons. Therefore, the answer would be, yes, you don't need to,
as Mark's going to argue. However, they've also picked and choose their races based on the
bike courses and they've chosen ones that only suit them. That's not really the most versatile
thing, is it? You want to be versatile, you can do anyone.
Well, you say that. I'd say, unfortunately, for the sport, a lot of the courses are going down
that route of being relatively flat straight. There's another debate entirely.
There's another debate entirely, which we could discuss another day and I'll agree it's maybe not
a great route. It does mean that actually it does lend itself to those athletes who maybe don't have
as many skills. Look, I don't want to point a finger but Lionel Sanders often comes up as an
example in this because he is renowned for doing pretty much a majority of his training indoors.
He's a fantastic athlete, but it is evident when he's out on the road, he maybe hasn't got as
great skills as someone like Jan Frodeno. Performance-wise, he's incredible and very
impressive. It's clearly worked and for many others like an Andy Potts and many others.
I mean, it's the whole, what's that Pirelli advert? Power without control is nothing.
Like if Lionel's got all the power in the world, if he then had the control to use it,
he'd go through even the few corners they have on these boring courses that are coming up more and
even better than he does and he would lose less time. Also, he'd be safer because he's able to
deal with any crisis that might happen, any rabbits running across the road or whatever
it might be better if you've worked on your bike skills. Yes, but maybe he wouldn't have as much
power because he'd wasted time training outdoors and it hadn't been quite as specific or as
efficient in terms of the training hours that you spent working on that. Lucy Charles-Barkley,
another great example, just won the Ironman World Championships. She said she did one ride
outside during 2023. Okay, but look at two examples. You've got Lionel Sanders and Lucy
Charles-Barkley. Lionel Sanders who chose not to go to Nice last year when the Ironman World
Champs were there because of the bike course. Lucy Charles-Barkley has also already announced
that this year she's going to focus on the T100 and not go to the Ironman World Champs in Nice.
They are literally passing up opportunities to win Ironman World Championships
because they are choosing to spend more of their time training on Zwift. Then they're going to the
courses that are easy, which as you say, there are more and more of, but you're not actually
working on your skills. There are a lot of reasons why you want to work on skills.
You've got me there to a degree. However, we're talking about pro athletes here who
are dictated by the calendar and needing to go to these certain events. The audience we're talking
to right now can choose a majority of the events that they go to, bar the Ironman World Championships
obviously, but a majority of them go, well, I want to do that course and I have limited hours of
training per week. I need to be efficient with that. I'm going to try and be as best an athlete
I possibly can be with those hours I have available. The best way to do that, maximize that
time, get on the indoor trainer, get powerful, get fast, turn up to these courses that suit me
and rip them apart. I can see the point. Absolutely. However, those same athletes
don't share their course with 19 other pros and safe draft distances. They share them with
3,000 other athletes who are all over the place. Let's be honest. Bike handling skills
might be significantly more critical. It may literally save your life and it'll probably
make you faster. If you are able to whip and whiz around all the other athletes comfortably,
confidently, you'll be able to go a little bit faster, you'll be able to worry a little bit less,
be less anxious, and you will actually be faster despite the fact that you maybe spent a little bit
less time on Zwift at your FTP during the training. I've got to be honest, I'm struggling
to fight you here on this one because also, for me, that is part of the enjoyment of cycling.
I like to have those skills to be able to handle the bike well. At the end of the day,
if I'm riding my bike that often, it seems a shame not to have the handling and the skills
to throw it around and have fun on the climbs and descents. In this debate around triathlon,
the indoor training is serving its purpose. They're getting strong and the results are
showing for that. The thing is, in a triathlon, when you're on a TT bike that is designed for
going fast in a straight line, you are faster if you've got a lot of power. However, triathlons
don't happen in a straight line. All the more reason to be confident and comfortable with your
handling so that you can go down in those aero bars as fast as possible, but still be confident
you get around the corners, still be confident that you can sit up, still be confident you can
deal with whatever objects might come at you or speed bumps or other competitors. That you
can only really practice when you're out in the real world and you do actual bike handling skills.
Now, a lot of people will turn around and go, but I can't do it because it's not safe. The roads
around me aren't safe, et cetera, et cetera. I can't work on my skills for my family and for
everything else I'm going to spend all my time on Zwift. I understand that. However, bike handling
skills don't only happen by doing all your training outside. You can do specific bike handling skill
sessions. Go to a safe bike course, go to a safe loop, go to a safe, even a parking lot that's got
no cars in it occasionally and do actual bike handling skills where you get better and better
at your bike handling. It may sound like it's time wasted, but half an hour spent in a parking lot,
learning to lean your bike this way, lean your bike that way, pick up something, whatever it
might be, make a really sharp corner, make a really sharp turn. It's going to pay dividends,
not just for one race, but for years and years and years of bike enjoyment. There's just no reason
not to work on your bike skills. As I said, this was always going to be a tough argument and tough
debate. I hear you. I agree. I guess this is where it comes down to is the limited time that
these athletes have available and it's trying to see the benefit and trade-off. All right,
if you go out for a long ride, there will be a significant portion of that long, steady ride
that you're probably freewheeling and all sorts. Actually, you can condense that in an indoor
training session and get the same benefit from three-quarters of the length, maybe even less in
some instances, depending on where you're riding. I guess that's what it comes down to for a lot of
these people with limited time, they've got family and all sorts going on, or just, as you've said,
road safety, the conditions, traffic, that to factor in. I personally would agree with you,
a little bit of time spent on bike skills, you'll see a huge, huge benefit from in the long run.
I think as you get your bike handling skills better and better, you get more and more confident
and you can actually, your world of cycling opens up a little bit more. You can go out on a mountain
bike, you go out on a gravel bike, and those handling skills will translate into your triathlon
bike. It doesn't actually, not having those bike skills or lurking on those bike skills doesn't
mean that now you must go outside more often, quite the opposite. It means you now want to go
outside more often, you want to spend more time on your bike. Their versatility and doing all the
different things actually makes you a better cyclist, not just a better cyclist skills-wise,
but actually a stronger cyclist. You can go ride up really steep hills because you're confident
in your bike and down really steep hills because you're confident in your bike. There's just no
benefit to not working on your bike skills. I think, yes, I mean, I've won this debate.
I knew I was going to because Mark, we threw Mark under the bus.
Genuinely, although I'm with you, it's an interesting debate. I was going to say,
it would be a really interesting thing to experiment with, with two different athletes,
but we already have that with the likes of Lucy Joss-Barkley, Lionel Saint-Germain,
literally our case studies. They've done incredibly well, but as you say, on specific courses.
Personally, I would say that their enjoyment or experience of cycling has probably been limited
as a result of doing that, in my opinion. They may disagree with you on that. However,
we'd be interested to hear your opinion. Leave a comment down below. Let us know
what your thoughts are. Is time spent working on bike skills
a waste of time and you should be better off holding your FTP on Zwift? Or do you think that
bike skills are possibly the most important thing you can work on as far as your bike goes
because everyone's safer and everyone's happier and you'll be a happier cyclist?
Let us know. Also, leave other questions for Coaches' Corner, hashtag GTN Coaches' Corner,
anything training related below this video or any of our other ones because next week,
we'll be answering your questions on GTN Coaches' Corner. Thanks for watching.
Cheers.
