PLEASE FOR ANY COPYRIGHTS ISSUE CONTACT US FIRST ON : [email protected]. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Truth is stranger than fiction, or so the old adage goes. It certainly rings true in the tragic-yet-curious tale of a road crash in Indiana which killed five people all affiliated to Taylor University. It is a tragedy that still provokes strong emotions years later among all those connected to the devastating events. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thanks for watching our videos and don't forget to subscribe :) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our Website : http://www.creepy-world.com Facebook : https://www.facebook.com/cw.creepyworld Twitter : https://twitter.com/CreepyWorld_ Contact Us : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- AnimalsWorld : goo.gl/ocdBXq HappyWorld : goo.gl/yUyJfq -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #HappyWorld
this girl miraculously survived a crash
family members began to suspect she
wasn't who she seemed
[Music]
truth is stranger than fiction
or so the old adage goes it certainly
rings true in the tragic yet curious
tale of a road crash in Indiana which
killed five people all affiliated to
Taylor University it's a tragedy that
still provokes strong emotions years
later among all those connected to the
devastating events five students and for
university staff were all traveling home
in a school minivan on the evening of
April 26 2006 the group of nine had been
returning from Fort Wayne Indiana which
is about 55 miles north of upland the
town where Taylor University situated
the University at a campus in Fort Wayne
at the time D Taylor van was traveling
south along Interstate 69 as the clock
ticked past 8:00 p.m. the group found
themselves just a couple miles shy of
the exit for Marion meaning they weren't
far from home now however it was at that
moment that tragedy struck for reasons
that only became apparent after the
event a truck had crossed the central
reservation and was heading straight for
the taylor university van there was
nothing the minivan driver could do to
avoid the collision the result was fatal
for five of the nine passengers on board
among the dead was listed a member of
the Taylor University staff Monica fell
ver the crash also resulted in the
reported deaths of four young students
Brad Larson laurel herb betsy smith &
Whitney Soraka as well as three further
members of staff one student named Laura
Van Ryn had survived the impact yet she
suffered sickening injuries the scene
that emergency responders came across
that fateful night was heartbreaking
it was also chaotic with passengers and
contents of the van spread out across
the road while the survivors were given
life-saving care the response team also
tried desperately to identify the
victims of the crash Van Ryn of
Caledonia Michigan had suffered
life-threatening head injuries which
were quickly bandaged by emergency
workers her identity card was located
and kept with her the University senior
who was
two years old at the time was then taken
to hospital immediately she was in an
unconscious state the deceased were
removed from the scene and as the usual
practice family members were informed
identification cards and eyewitness
statements had been taken at the scene
so in-person identification was not in
fact required Whitney surak's family
declined to formally identify their
daughter most probably too distraught to
face the prospect of looking at her
injuries firsthand witness ROC was 18
years old and a native of Gaylord
Michigan she was a freshman at Taylor
her parents were devastated at the news
of their daughter had been killed in the
crash they began the heartbreaking task
of planning their daughter's funeral
days later an estimated 1,400 people
attended that funeral with Ciroc sister
providing the eulogy meanwhile van Ren's
family were summoned to her hospital bed
the young woman had suffered terrible
injuries that had left her in a state
akin to a coma she was unable to
communicate with those around her in
addition her face was bandaged and badly
swollen it was difficult even for her
closest loved ones to recognize her
understandably the crash sent shockwaves
through the Taylor community as
president of the university much
responsibility fell on the shoulders of
Eugene had occur to lead his staff and
students through the traumatic aftermath
Henniker özil offered support to the
families of the deceased and injured
Hammacher went to the hospital to visit
van Rijn who was still unresponsive he
offered comfort to the girl's parents
Don and Susie her head was fully
bandaged and she of course was still
unconscious have occurr recalled to the
TV news station Fox 59 back in 2016 I
asked Don if I could hold Laura's hand
and pray for her the university
president added what all those connected
to the events were continually asking
themselves and each other was why what
did the semi-trailer truck been doing on
the wrong side of the road crash
investigators interviewed the driver of
the vehicle and soon ascertained that
Robert F Spencer of Canton Michigan had
fallen asleep at the wheel that was the
reason his truck had veered onto the
wrong side of i-69 Spencer it also
provided false details in the lead-up to
the crash
eat actually been driving for nine hours
longer than permitted under federal law
without taking a significant break
doctoring his time logs to disguise that
fact he was subsequently charged with
five counts of reckless homicide the
victims families were further devastated
by this news one second of him falling
asleep and will suffer for the rest of
our lives
said the daughters of Taylor University
staff member Monika Felder in a joint
statement Spencer showed remorse for his
actions I know I'll have to deal with
this the rest of my life the truck
driver said at his sentencing
Spencer was eventually sentenced to four
years in prison for his role in the
accident he actually spent two of those
four years behind bars
yet years later Jeff Larson whose
brother Brad was killed in the crash
said he'd found forgiveness for Spencer
over the last several years my heart's
been drawn to respond with forgiveness
Larson told Fox 59 in 2016 while the
families were able to discover the
reason for the crash it didn't change
the fact that their loved ones are gone
and the surviving students still at a
significant fight on her hands to
recover from these sickening injuries
that she'd sustained in the crash
fortunately as time passed the young
woman began to slowly improve lisa van
Rijn Laura's sister had decided to keep
a blog of her sister's recovery the blog
was intended to update friends family
and other Taylor University students of
Van Ryn treatment and progress it was
also the place where well-wishers could
offer their prayers for the stricken
University senior on May 29th Lissa
offered an update while certain things
seemed to be coming back to her she
still has times where she'll say things
that don't make any sense wrote Van Ryn
sister slowly but surely the student was
regaining consciousness and the ability
to communicate which was of course
wonderful news for her family the
recovering crash victim was also
beginning to be able to whisper but some
of the things she said continued to make
no sense to her carers and her own
family five weeks after she was admitted
to hospital with these serious injuries
she'd sustained the road crash an
unbelievable discovery was made
what hospital staff have been calling
van Rijn by her name she'd been
responding in a barely audible whisper
with another then one day as part of her
recovery
van Rijn was asked to write her name but
she didn't write Laura she wrote Whitney
instead the young woman in the hospital
bed was not Laura van Rijn at all
it was Whitney Ciroc the chil women
looked remarkably similar from the color
and length of their hair to their
complexion and height but this was five
weeks later how would no one known that
this was the all a case of mistaken
identity and the body laid to rest all
those weeks earlier at the memorial
service had not been Ciroc at all but
Laura Van Ryn the wrong ID'd that
affixed to the body of Laura van ryn at
the crash scene according to Fox 59
that's why authorities have believed all
along that the body was that of Whitney
Ciroc and as for the woman in the
hospital her had injuries have been so
severe that the mistake was not realized
for five long weeks Karly Ciroc
Whitney's sister took over the blog post
originally started by Lisa Van Ryn to
offer her family side of events I did
not believe my sister was in the
hospital I thought for sure this was a
mistake when I walked into the hospital
room I was shocked and overcome with joy
wrote Karly it was an incredible moment
for the family yet it was a situation
also heavily tinged with sadness for the
van wrens soon after we saw Whitney our
family met with the van rinse and our
joy for ourselves was pushed aside by
the pain we felt for them it's hard
because our joy is their pain Carley
Soraka added van RINs mother Susie
summed up her feelings well it was hard
but we knew where our daughter was and
we knew that Newell and Colleen needed
to know where their daughter was van
RINs mother told TV news show today it
was still a tragedy
despite the joy felt by the Sox on top
of losing their daughter some reactions
to the event we're also distressing for
the van Rennes in particular there was
the off repeated question how did you
not realize it wasn't your daughter in
the hospital that
yeah a psychiatrist has stated that it's
conceivable under the circumstances how
such events could play out the family
members they're being told by the
authorities that it is in fact their
daughter
Richard McNally a psychiatry professor
at Harvard University told the New York
Times newspaper in 2006 the person in
the hospital is rather badly banged up
and bruised and they might conceivably
accept that verdict from the authorities
added professor McNally others have
asked how it's possible that the body of
what turned out to be Laura Van Ryn was
never positively identified yet this
practice isn't uncommon as dr. Tim palm
Bach a forensic scientist told the New
York Times sure in hindsight we can say
that an autopsy should have been done
but usually if it's clear that the
deceased wasn't the driver an autopsy
isn't done he continued unsurprisingly
the story received widespread media
attention events were covered in a
special episode of Dateline NBC while
they also featured on both the Oprah
Winfrey Show and today the Roselyn works
of fiction based on the subject matter
including episodes of both CSI New York
and house m.d.
as terrible as the tragedy was with the
pain for the two families only
heightened by the misidentification of
the body lessons have been learned back
in 2006 state coroner's in Indiana used
a system known as presumptive evidence
to identify bodies according to Toni
Cirillo who's the training director at
the coroner's training board in the
state this step was then followed up for
scientific findings that meant that the
evidence needed to identify the body at
the time of the crash consisted with a
regular form of ID such as a driver's
license the wrong ID had been associated
with Van Ryn at the crash site and then
surak's family declined to view the body
of what they thought was their daughter
further steps to confirm identity such
as DNA testing for example were only
performed at the coroner's discretion in
this case the coroner involved decided
against this course of action and of
course Ciroc was so badly injured that
van wrens family couldn't discern that
the person lying in the hospital bed was
not their daughter it was a terribly
unfortunate series of events that led to
the case of mistaken identity as a
result this
system of coroner's discretion has been
abolished in Indiana family
identification and/or scientific
evidence is now required for all
suspicious or unnatural deaths the two
girls home state of Michigan has enacted
similar changes it may be of little
comfort to the family of Van Ryn but at
least another Indiana or Michigan family
need never go through the same emotional
turmoil as they did in the aftermath of
the terrible crash on i-64 in Canada in
2018 the identity of two junior hockey
players was confused after a crash it
took 48 hours for the error to be
recognized and an apology was released
by the Saskatchewan office of the Chief
Coroner first Ciroc in particular the
mix-up has led to some surreal moments
she spoke about the event and its legacy
at the 10-year memorial service for the
crash victims at Taylor University a lot
of people wonder what people will say
about you at your funeral
I know Ciroc told the gathered audience
Ciroc also recalled some of the lighter
things that people had said etre funeral
such as her sister adding in the eulogy
that she didn't shower enough another
eulogize er added house rock wasn't very
good at sports yet one of the darker
moments Rock has felt as a result of the
crash and subsequent mix-up is something
called survivor's guilt poignant Lee the
crash survivor also spoke about the
family of Laura van Rijn Lee Van RINs
they love me like I was their daughter
because they believed that I was their
daughter Ciroc reported and even after I
wrote Whitney and their world changed
and they knew that I wasn't their
daughter they still treated me like I
was their family she added
unsurprisingly a bond is formed between
the Sox and the van RINs I love the van
Rijn family they're so great Ciroc was
reported as telling today
in fact the Soraka and van Rijn families
even collaborated on a book mistaken
identity two families one survivor
unwavering hope published by Howard
books and released in 2008
Ciroc is grass with a chance at life she
was afforded upon surviving the crash
she's now a married mother of three and
in a strange quirk in 2010 she was
married in the very same church where
her funeral had been held just four
years before it was another surreal
twist for the young woman and her family
it was such an unbelievable moment for
us because we were at the moment in our
life when we thought this would never be
a possibility newell Ciroc Whitney's
father told website the Huffington Post
in 2012 in the face of such tragedy in
loss it's important to celebrate any
happiness that survives