The Art and Drama of Michelangelo's Last Decades | Curators' Tour British Museum Exhibition

Ancient Art Channel
12 followers
In 1534, Michelangelo left Florence for Rome, never to see his native city again. He was 59, which many contemporaries regarded as old, but for Michelangelo this move marked the beginning of a dramatic new chapter which would fundamentally shape his experiences as an artist and as a man. Join British Museum curators Grant Lewis and Sarah Vowles as they take you on a tour of our exhibition Michelangelo: the last decades #GJWculture #Antiques #Art #ArtExplained
Hello, I'm Sarah Vowles and I'm Grant Lewis and we're here to give you a tour of Michelangelo
the last decades. We'll be taking you through section by section looking at one or two objects
in each section which help us tell our story. There are five sections in the show which are
broadly chronological but which also focus on particular themes and periods but there
are also some overriding themes in the show that we'd like to bring out now.
And one of those is friendship. We often think of Michelangelo as being quite a solitary worker,
the person who famously sacked all of his assistants when painting the Sistine Chapel ceiling.
And yet throughout the show we see him developing many very very close friendships with like-minded
individuals like Tommaso de Cavalieri, a Roman nobleman, or Vittoria Colonna with whom he had
a very very strong spiritual affinity. But we also see a lot of collaborations
of an artistic nature with colleagues including with the man here, Daniela de Volterra,
with whom Michelangelo often works but increasingly becomes a friend and who's there
at Michelangelo's death. And with these artistic friendships often come a lot of collaborations
and collaboration is another theme of the show. We see Michelangelo often delegating ideas to
other artists because he's not able to fulfill the demand or he wants other artists to work up
his ideas. But I think the most overriding theme of the show is faith. Michelangelo's faith
underpinned everything that he did and the drawings and letters and sonnets that we include in the show
demonstrate him exploring that spirituality in lots of different ways and not just through the
monumental frescoes for the Pope. There is a lot of Catholic imagery in this show but I think
that Michelangelo's late period speaks to all of us of all faiths or none because his experiences
of aging are so universal. He copes with failing physical health, he worries about the future of
his family and he worries about whether he has lived a good life and what happens next.
And I think these are emotions that we can all relate to as we get older.
We pick up the story in 1534 when Michelangelo was in his late 50s and we meet him when he's
frankly at a bit of a low ebb. He's just emerging from one of the most difficult periods of his life.
This difficult period begins with the disastrous sack of Rome in 1527 by imperial troops who
absolutely ransacked the city and left the Pope who was a long-standing companion of Michelangelo's
imprisoned in the Castel Sant'Angelo. The Pope appealed to Michelangelo for help and yet rather
than coming to the Pope's aid, Michelangelo actually supported the rebels. He was at heart
a Florentine Republican and he starts accepting new work for the new regime but within a year or two
it was clear that the Republic was not going to last. The Pope and the imperial armies had come
to an agreement and pretty soon their armies were marching on Florence and so rather than
embellishing the new city, Michelangelo finds himself building fortifications as Florence
enters a very nasty siege and despite valiant efforts and really quite impressive performance
from Michelangelo's fortifications, the city fell. He therefore finds himself in an incredibly
difficult situation once the Pope and once the Medici return. Entering his late 50s he really
feels a need to shore up his position and how does he do that? He does it by working, really working
for anyone who has any sort of say in the new Medici rule in Florence. This leaves him incredibly
tired. By 1531, so a few years before we actually start the show, one or two assistants are getting
slightly worried that Michelangelo might actually die and yet despite all this busyness, despite all
of this effort, he carves out time to make a series of gifts for friends. There's this extraordinary
burst of gift giving and more than anyone else he wanted to give gifts to a young man he met
called Tommaso de Cavalieri, a young Roman nobleman who Michelangelo meets in Rome in 1532 and really
leaves a quite remarkable impression on Michelangelo who very quickly makes a series of incredibly
lavish gifts for Tommaso, mostly incredibly finely worked drawings in black chalk of which we have
one here. A beautiful drawing of Titius having his liver devoured by an eagle or in the myth
truly a vulture for having attempted to rape Latona, the mother of the goddess Artemis.
Now why this subject? It's a very interesting subject to give to someone. This has been a
subject of huge debate. Indeed the nature of Michelangelo's relationship has been a subject
of huge debate. There are some people who see a drawing like this as an expression of
Michelangelo's wild passion for Tommaso for whom he clearly feels very fondly. Personally I think
it's more of a warning. I think this is Michelangelo loving Tommaso so much, being so concerned for his
welfare that he's sending him an admonition against love. It's almost as like he wants to
keep this youth wrapped up in cotton wool, free from all of the sins of the world. Now why do I
think this? Well I think two reasons. One very important reason is the technique.
This is absolutely minute and it's finished. It's got a jewel-like quality and what that does is
encourage you to look incredibly closely and look for a very, very long time. When Tommaso actually
gets the drawing he says, I will look at it for two hours every single day and I think looking
at a subject like this, Tommaso would get this admonition advice quite clearly by looking at
Titus's supple skin about to be ripped open by this vulture. The second reason I'm inclined to
think this is more of a platonic gift, so to speak, is the back where Michelangelo traces,
in an extraordinary act of mental plasticity, traces Titus's form through the sheet of the
paper and develops it as an idea for a risen Christ. A risen Christ that feeds into a series
of drawings Michelangelo is making at the same time. We're not quite sure why but it's part of a
moment where the subject of Christ's resurrection is really fascinating him and it's some of these
drawings that in turn influence his depiction of Christ in the Last Judgment, which within a year
or two of meeting Tommaso becomes really the sole preoccupation in his artistic life.
Michelangelo lived at a time of seismic religious change as the Reformation spread in northern
Europe. The period that we cover in the next section, the 1540s, looks at the time when the
Catholic Church began to formalise its response to Protestantism, which resulted in the hardening of
boundaries and new definitions of heresy. But at the beginning of the decade there is this moment
of optimism where everything seems possible and people believe that it might be possible to bridge
that gap, that gulf, between Catholic and Protestant. In the late 1530s Michelangelo
meets Vittoria Colonna. She's from one of Rome's oldest and noblest families and she is renowned
as a religious poet. She's a member of a group called the Spirituali, or the Spirituals,
who coalesce in Rome around the figure of Cardinal Reginald Pole. They're an elite intellectual
circle and they believe that the Church does need to be reformed but from within and they are also
particularly interested in the crucifixion as a symbol of Christ's sacrifice and his redemption
of humankind through his blood. Vittoria sends Michelangelo a present, probably at Christmas in
1540, of a book of her religious poetry which she's had written out by a scribe and bound
especially for him. It's an extraordinary present. He's astonished with it and in return he makes
poems for her but the most significant output of their friendship are the artistic designs that he
makes for Vittoria which draw on their shared spiritual interests. One of those designs is this
Christ on the cross which shows us a remarkably powerful vision of a Christ who is not dead or
dying but living and robust and strong. Michelangelo does allude to his torment in the twist of his
torso which looks back to the antique sculpture of the Laocon but the overriding impression
chimes in with the spirituale idea of the crucifixion as a moment of victory over sin and
death. Now this might look like a highly finished drawing but it's still a working drawing because
you have these angels here on either side who've been added over the sky. Now we know exactly what
Vittoria thought of this composition because we have the letter that she wrote after she'd seen
it for the first time and that's displayed next to the drawing in the exhibition. She says
unique master Michelangelo, my most singular friend, I've seen the crucifixion and she says
it has crucified all other pictures in my memory. She says I've looked at it with a magnifying glass
and a mirror and a light and I've never seen anything so exquisite and this gives us a real
sense of how Vittoria actually looked at the designs that Michelangelo sent her. They were
not just artistic objects but also stimulants for meditation and contemplation. The imagery
that Michelangelo designed for Vittoria appealed not only to moderate reformers but also to more
mainstream Catholics and the compositions became enormously popular and it's through this that we
meet for the first time a figure who's going to crop up a few times throughout the exhibition,
Marcello Venusti, who is a painter from northern Italy who becomes Michelangelo's favoured
collaborator in the 1540s and 1550s. Venusti was the one who would take Michelangelo's designs
and turn them into paintings for a variety of patrons. Now it's important to remember
that for patrons in the Renaissance having a painting by Venusti was fine because they wanted
Michelangelo's genius, his idea, his ingenio and it didn't matter so much that Venusti was the one
who had actually painted the pictures. Michelangelo's friendship with Vittoria gave him models of
poetic and affective spirituality that would remain with him for the rest of his life and give
him a firm foundation and this foundation of confidence in God and Christ and the crucifixion
would become ever more important to him throughout the late 1540s because his life was about to enter
one of its busiest and most demanding phases. And the reason for this uptick was in a word
architecture. We don't often think of Michelangelo's architecture as much as say his painting
or his sculpture and yet for most of the period covered by this exhibition architecture was the
main draw on his time. This was a bit of a surprise for Michelangelo who didn't really see himself
as an architect and who despite knowing many of the great architects in his youth in Florence
actually comes to architecture quite late in his life. He was in his 40s when he really
takes it up seriously and yet in 1547, in the same year that Vittoria Colonna died,
his architectural career really does expand quite suddenly. He gets really the most important
architectural project there was, the rebuilding of St Peter's Basilica, the project that really
occupied him more than any other for the rest of his life. But there are also others and other
really important commissions as well including the far from insignificant matter of building
the Pope's Palace, a project that has been going on since the 1510s. The study we have here is a
study for a suite of windows he designs at the top of the courtyard. It is a study of a simple
pedimented opening but this was really the architectural form I think more than any other
look cited Michelangelo. Why? Because he was able to play around with it, he was able to
change proportions, he was able to introduce details, change the shape of pediments in such a
way that each time he could create a new form. As this courtyard was taking shape, Michelangelo
was developing ideas for other parts of the palace including a really exciting idea for the
garden. But the Pope died, plans changed and Michelangelo was increasingly occupied with other
projects. He was just very very busy and we really see this if we look at the back of this drawing
because it's filled with lots of little thumbnails that at first glance maybe don't look interesting
but revealed the variety of projects Michelangelo was involved in. Now there's been quite a lot of
disagreement as to what these sketches refer to but for myself I'm pretty clear. We have here at
the top left a study for the drum of the dome of Saint Peter's Basilica, the dome that was going
to tower over Rome. We have an idea for a staircase in the Laurentian Library dating from the late
1550s, a project Michelangelo has been working on for over 20 years now. We have a ground plan for a
Florentine church in Rome, a new Florentine church, San Giovanni dei Fiorentini, which Michelangelo
is working on in 1559. So we can see that this sheet is constantly around Michelangelo, he's
constantly picking it up, juggling so many different ideas for different projects. But alongside
juggling we also see, and I think this is really interesting, the cross-pollination of ideas,
motifs he develops for one project then being reused for another. And this isn't just between
architectural forms, it's also with his painting and sculpture. If you look at the bottom of the
sheets you can see there's a study of an arm, which probably relates to a pieta, and which
help these juxtapositions, help Michelangelo to infuse his architecture with that human quality
that pervades his sculptures. And the proof of the pudding of this to-ing and fro-ing, this back and
forth of ideas between projects, can be seen on the front of the drawing, because in the early 1560s,
so well after a decade after he'd actually made the first drawing on the sheets, and later even
then all of those studies we've been looking at on the back, he returns to the front and he
reworks the drawing he'd made for the Palazzo Farnese. He adds a lot of chalk lines over the
earlier drawing, and what he's doing is repurposing the drawing for yet another architectural project,
a very very important one, and this was the Conservator's Palace on the Capitoline Hill,
the heart of secular Rome, complementing of course St Peter's, where he's redesigning the heart of
sacred Rome. Now this was expediency, Michelangelo was probably 87 when he made this
new amendment to his drawings, it might indeed be one of the last dateable drawings we have by his
hand, but in this expediency is also an artistic decision, continual exploration of the pediment,
the theme he loved so much, and take it in new directions. Michelangelo was working in the
Pauline Chapel for most of the 1540s, but it was a difficult time for him personally as well,
he was severely ill twice in the mid-1540s, and towards the end of the decade, to add insult to
injury, he started to suffer again from the stone, which we think was probably a bladder stone.
He writes letters like this one here, where he complains about being unable to urinate and the
pain that it causes him, and he grumbles about the doctors, and the cure for this was also an insult
to him, because he was required to drink medicinal water from the springs near Viterbo, which meant
that he wasn't able to drink his favourite Trebbiano wine. About a year after this treatment started,
he grumbles in a letter, and he says I'm living a life to which I'm not accustomed. At this date,
Michelangelo is also very worried about his family, he is the patriarch of the Buonarroti family,
because his father had died shortly before Michelangelo came back to Rome, and the only
male in the next generation is Michelangelo's nephew and ward, Leonardo Buonarroti. Michelangelo
spends about five years trying to convince Leonardo to get married, round about this time, so that the
family line will continue, and we have numerous letters across this time suggesting prospects he
might consider, introducing him to matchmakers, and other approaches. Essentially, Michelangelo
is channelling Mrs Bennet from Pride and Prejudice. Now, over this time, the letters gradually become
more and more hectoring and impatient, and a particularly wonderful example is this letter
here from the British Library, which is a real gem, because it shows us Michelangelo in all his
irratability. He's writing to Leonardo, giving him advice on what he should look for in a wife,
and he says don't worry so much about the dowry, that's not important. He says people are more
important than possessions. A nice disposition, frankly, is what you need to look for, and then he
goes on and he says as for beauty, since you aren't the best looking young man in Florence yourself,
I wouldn't worry about it too much. Ouch! Now, this story does have a happy ending though, because
Leonardo ends up marrying Cassandra Ridolfi from a distinguished Florentine family, and so the future
of the Buonarroti is secured for another generation. But the point to get across is that at
this period, Michelangelo is preoccupied with his family, with his work, and people are still
demanding commissions from him, and so what he does is he develops his collaboration with Marcello
Venusti into a more formal partnership. We have a couple of case studies here that show how this
works. One of these here shows an enunciation which was commissioned by Cardinal Cesi in the
mid-1540s. As you can see, Michelangelo starts by making preparatory drawings which focus on the
figures in the composition. He develops these to the point where a more finished modello drawing
is produced, which Venusti then uses as the basis for his painting. Michelangelo is really only
interested in the figures, and so Venusti is the one who adds in a background of his own invention
and chooses the jewel-like colour palette, and this is why these drawings shouldn't be seen just
as works by a follower or copies. They really are the product of a collaboration between the two
artists. Now thinking about Michelangelo working in tandem with other artists brings us to what is
for us one of the most exciting works in the exhibition. So here we are at the Epiphaneia,
which is the most memorable instance of collaboration in the show, not only because
of the extraordinary size of the painting but because we have this, the preparatory cartoon,
the only surviving complete cartoon we have from Michelangelo's hand. Now when I say cartoon I
don't mean anything loony tunes, I mean a one-to-one blueprint essentially that was made
immediately before beginning the work. It really was your final port of reference before embarking
on a painting or embarking on a tapestry or something like that, and one would often transfer
the image straight from the cartoon to the surface you were going to work on. Michelangelo must have
made hundreds of these. We know he gave examples from the Sistine Chapel to friends as a gift,
and yet large cumbersome things like this, they get knocked around, they suffer water damage,
they get rolled up and they don't tend to survive, so it gives a really quite remarkable insight
into a stage of Michelangelo's working method that we're not terribly familiar with. Now cartoons
should be quite clear, you should be able to look at them and know exactly what you're going to do
on the basis of them, and yet Michelangelo's one isn't terribly clear. There are lots of vague
suggestions, you get changes of mind as well, and all of this is really quite a net metaphor
because the Epiphany is a project about which we know very little indeed. First, we're not
really sure what's actually going on. We have figures we recognise, we have the Virgin Mary,
we have Christ, St John the Baptist, a figure that we presume is Joseph, and yet there are so many
questions. Why is the Virgin seemingly pushing Joseph away? Who is this rather important figure
who fills the left half? It has been suggested it's St Julian, but we really don't know,
and then who on earth are all of these extra figures that we have attending the Virgin Mary
in the background? And who, point two, would actually want such an iconographically complex,
iconographically odd picture for what must have been an altarpiece? A picture this size
could only have been an altarpiece in a church. And mystery three is the artist involved because
whereas earlier we looked at collaborations with well-established artists, Marcello Venussi,
Daniela Volterra, in this instance Michelangelo turned to a bit of an unknown, a man called
Ascanio Condivi, who made the painting that we have here based on the cartoon. And this really
is the night that two become one, because for the first time in 500 years we've actually reunited
painting and cartoon together. We spoke earlier about Michelangelo's letters.
There's almost 500 of them that survive today, and here we have two of the last. This one here
on the left is surprisingly short when you compare it to his other letters. It dates from two months
before his death, and he's writing to his long-suffering nephew, Leonardo, in Florence.
He starts off, normally, thanking him for a delivery of 12 cheeses. This happened quite a
lot. Leonardo would send produce or wine from the family estates. And then Michelangelo goes on to
say that he's sorry he hasn't replied to Leonardo's recent letters, but he says,
La mano non mi serve. My hand no longer serves me. And the thing about Michelangelo is that his
handwriting is always beautiful right up until the end. He's 88 here, and even the start of the letter
is beautifully written. But at this point, where he says that his hand is giving way,
the line starts to slip down and the letters begin to crumple, and you can see that there
are these ink blots at the end caused by uneven pressure on the pen. And just take a moment to
think what this means for Michelangelo. He's 88 years old, and for his entire career, he's relied
on his hands as the method of producing his amazing architecture, sculpture, fresco, drawings,
and now suddenly he's having to face up to this reality that his body is beginning to give way
before his mind. So he says here, don't worry, I'm going to keep writing. I'll get other people
to write the letters for me, and I'll still sign them. So fast forward two months. We're now on the
14th of February 1564, four days before Michelangelo dies. And Daniela da Volterra, his friend and
assistant, writes this letter on Michelangelo's behalf, again to Leonardo Buonarroti in Florence.
And Daniela says to Leonardo, I went to visit Michelangelo yesterday, and he's taken a bit of a
turn for the worse, and I said to him, did he want me to write to you and ask you to come to Rome? And
he told me three times, I beg you, I beg you, I beg you. And so Daniela says to Leonardo, I think you
should come as quickly as you can. I don't think there's much time. And Michelangelo, as he promised,
has signed the letter here at the bottom, and you can see what a difference two months has made.
The letters are scrunched up. It's barely legible. You can see how much trouble he's having holding
that pen. And indeed, as far as we know, it's the last time he ever did hold a pen. So this letter
goes off to Florence. Four days later, Michelangelo dies, and Leonardo doesn't make it in time.
Michelangelo dies without seeing him again. But Michelangelo does have his friends around him at
his deathbed. Daniela de Volterra, who wrote this letter, Tommaso de Cavalieri, and others. And most
importantly for Michelangelo, he receives all the sacraments that he'd wanted. So this is the point
where we say goodbye to Michelangelo the man. But as you leave the show, there are a few objects,
just to warn you that Michelangelo the myth is already well underway. We have a heroic bust
by Daniela de Volterra and his studio. And we also have a copy of the Sari's Lives,
which more than any other text has created this image of the divine Michelangelo that we all
still know today. Thank you so much for joining us. We really hope that we've whetted your appetite
to come in in person and enjoy the extraordinary works of art we've been showcasing, delve into
the stories behind them, and of course, explore the many works that we haven't had time to feature.
And a big thank you from me too. The exhibition is on here at the British Museum until the 28th
of July. But please keep an eye on our website and our YouTube channel
for further events and content. Hope you've enjoyed it.
