The discussion explores the historical and cultural significance of the family, emphasizing its role as a religious and social unit rooted in ancestor worship. In ancient societies, families were the primary social structure, with altars and sacred fires symbolizing unity and faith. In China, traditional family values, tied to clan rituals and Confucian principles, were dismantled by Communist policies, notably land reforms and the one-child policy, which eradicated clan halls and family religion. This destruction, aimed at consolidating centralized power, left modern Chinese families as mere demographic units, contributing to declining marriage and birth rates. The narrative contrasts ancient self-governing family structures with modern authoritarian control, arguing that reviving family sanctity is key to resisting centralized power and building a better future.
0:00 Intro 0:07 Unraveling a Paradox 1:29 Beyond the One-Child Policy 2:19 The Family’s Historical Roots 3:25 The Sacred Essence of Family 4:29 Ancestral Fires in East and West 5:39 The Covenant of the Taimiao 6:26 Family as the Sole Society 8:01 From Family to City-State 9:23 The Clash of Faith and Power 10:40 The Destruction of Clans 11:56 The Gentry’s Golden Age 13:16 The Communist Upheaval 14:08 Born into Ruins 14:50 Misguided Blame 15:38 A Call to Rebuild
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Shuang. Welcome to Digging into China, where we explore China in depth to review unique
perspectives. Today, we are exploring a topic. Why does the Communist Party seek to dismantle the
family? Some of you might find this surprising, given that the Chinese Communist Party currently
promotes family values, encouraging young people to marry, build a household, and have more children.
So why would I claim the Party aims to destroy the family? It's true that China's youth today
face declining marriage and birth rates, prompting the government to urge young people to have
children. However, if we trace the issue back to its roots, the reluctance of young Chinese to marry
or have children stems directly from policies the Chinese Communist Party has enforced over decades.
If traditional Chinese family structures still existed, young people would not be so
averse to having children, and China's population would not be steadily shrinking. In the past,
one of the most criticized policies was the one-child policy, which limited families to
a single child. This drastically reduced family sizes, transforming Chinese households into what's
known as the three-person families. Such policies have been widely condemned as inhumane. Yet, I
believe there are even graver issues beyond merely restricting births. Since 1949, decades of
political campaigns have ravaged the traditional Chinese culture, obliterating the ethics and
concepts of the traditional family. These have been utterly eradicated. Today's families bear
little resemblance to the traditional family model. Now, a family is merely a demographic or economic
unit with some practical significance. In contrast, traditional families held profound
importance in matters of faith and religion. Today, we'll examine the true meaning of family
through the lens of traditional beliefs and religion. This discussion, of course, extends
beyond China. Let's begin by exploring the historical origins of the family. From a modern
perspective, a family is the most fundamental demographic unit, the bedrock of society's
continuity and reproduction. Most crucially, this unit holds immense practical value as a vital
resource. The family serves as a reservoir of human resources, consumer resources, and production
resources, a nation's resource bank. When a country's marriage rates decline and birth rates
fall, the government grows concerned. The loss of family resources signals a decline in societal
productivity, consumption capacity, and human resources, pushing society toward a crisis of
depletion. Typically, we view families through a material or societal benefit lens. This perspective
is highly mechanical and rigid, failing to capture the true essence of a family. Today, we'll delve
into what a family truly represents. A family's true significance transcends its role as a material
resource unit. It is a unit of religious faith and the foundation of social organization,
a critical distinction. According to British historian Larry Sidentope, the prehistorical
times, before the rise of ancient Greek city-states, the family was the primary, if not
sole, form of human social organization. It was the cornerstone of society, embodying its most
fundamental beliefs. The basic unit of social belief was the family religion, a universal trait
of early human civilizations. And what gods did this religion worship? The family's ancestors.
In ancient times, every household had an altar with a hearth at its center. The father served
as a priest, imparting the family religion's teachings. Family members gathered around the
hearth to pray, perform rituals, and cultivate a shared faith and purpose, uniting as a cohesive
whole. In Sidentope's book, Inventing the Individual Origins of Western Liberalism,
he describes the Greek and Roman households as having an altar with burning coals or charcoal.
Maintaining this fire day and night was the sacred duty of the household's head.
If the fire extinguishes, the family faced misfortune. Only when the entire family perished
would the altar's fire go out. Ancient Chinese family concepts mirrored those in the West.
Ancestral worship formed the bedrock of social order. For ordinary families, ancestral rituals
were vital for maintaining clan unity and ethical values. For the emperor, the head of the national
family, the Imperial Ancestral Temple, or Tai Miao, served as the state's ancestral altar.
Only founding emperors and their successors could be enshrined in the Tai Miao to receive
offerings. Upon establishing a dynasty, the first task was to build the Tai Miao,
install ancestral tablets, and establish regular grand ceremonies. The emperor's worship at the
Tai Miao went beyond personal filial piety. It linked the state's legitimacy and the mandate
of heaven to ancestral blessings. Per Confucian rituals, if Tai Miao ceremonies ceased,
the imperial clan was considered extinct, losing its right to rule. Thus, before major state affairs,
the emperor had to report to the Tai Miao. This was both a political and religious act,
affirming a sacred covenant between the dynasty, its ancestors, and the heavens.
As long as the Tai Miao fire burned, the dynasty stood firm, like the altar fire in ancient Greek
homes. If China's Tai Miao was abandoned, public trust would falter, and the nation's fate would
waver. In ancient terms, a family's demise was synonymous with its hot fire's extinction.
How should we understand the family altar? This requires some imagination, as ancient societies
differed vastly from today's. Back then, there were no government, nations, churches, or commercial
entities. The family was the sole social structure and the only source of identity and faith.
Everything a person was stemmed from the family, rooted in ancestor worship. This made the family
paramount. Ancient people formed tight-knit social circles around the families. Family members were
us, while outsiders were others, sometimes even adversaries. In ancient times, the highest moral
duty was to uphold the family, its faith, and its gods, the ancestors. Even property was viewed
this way. An individual's fleeting life made them a mere transient in the world, so property truly
belonged to the family or clan. The family's priest also managed its wealth, acting as the clan's
steward. Despite thousands of years of historical evolution, this reverence for family persists in
people's hearts. This explains why even today, people hold a special attachment to family, rooted
in ancient family beliefs. Thus, family bonds are less about blood ties and more about a religious
sentiment. As populations grew and people lived in denser communities, ancient family structures
began to evolve. Sidney Taub argues that larger human collectives emerged with historical progress.
Necessitating beliefs that transcended family religion. He writes that if the family, grounded
in religious faith, is the only enduring human unit, larger groups required specific conditions
to form. Before city-states, new family collectives had to emerge. Each societal expansion demanded a
new form of worship, recognizing a divinity greater than individual family gods. With the rise of
cities and city-states, people worshiped both family gods and, collectively, the gods of the
city-state. A city-state was essentially a grand altar. It's a sacred fire at the center. Citizens
guarded this altar and different city-states revealed different patron gods, explaining the
diverse deities in ancient Greek city-states. Public gods protected family gods to keep the
family altar's fire burning and protect the clans from outsiders. People first had to defend the
city-state. This was a root of ancient Greek democracy. While this describes Europe and the
West, Chinese people should find it familiar. China has long revealed ancestor worship.
Traditionally, Chinese society emphasized the family and the clan, defined by ancestral tablets,
the family's gods. Worshipping ancestors through rituals fostered a family-based faith, a cornerstone
of Chinese tradition. Modern Chinese have largely forgotten the spiritual value of ancestor worship,
viewing it as a mere remembrance of the deceased. But it's far deeper. It holds a religious core
that extends to social governance and politics. Traditional family religion centered on the clan's
sacred fire, united members into a cohesive community, resisting external forces while
fostering internal unity, economy, and politics. Evidently, a totalitarian regime like the Communist
Party is fundamentally incompatible with traditional family religion. To centralize
absolute power and establish an authoritarian state, it had to eradicate the grassroots family
religion. This is the core reason the Party seeks to dismantle the family. Across the world, despite
varying modern customs, early human history reveals striking similarities, particularly in
family gods and beliefs. Whether in pre-city-state Europe or ancient China, a family's essence was an
altar, with the elder or father as a priest passing down the clan's faith. In this context,
the family was a grassroots self-defense and self-governing entity. If families and clans
dominated society, people could achieve self-governance, needing no state, government, or
external institutions. Family religion and society enabled autonomy. The family was a political
entity. Historians like David Foray, a professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong,
have studied this extensively. In his book, Emperor and Ancestors, State and Lineage in South China,
Foray argues that traditional Chinese clans played pivotal roles in politics and economics.
In southern China, large clans united through kingship and held religious ceremonies in
ancestral halls, fostering tight-knit communities. Foray, citing prior research,
notes that clans functioned as corporate entities holding companies and trust funds.
Ancestral halls mirrored ancient family altars, serving similar roles. With the hall as a sacred
space and ancestral tablets as the clan's sacred fire, clans controlled grassroots politics,
commerce, and public works. Foray writes that by the 18th century, clans flourished widely.
No longer just elite constructed ties to officials, clans saw the gentry class
take over intermediary roles between local society and government. The gentry controlled
local affairs through organizations rooted in religious activities, contracts, investments,
and civil administration. Clans organized around the shared ancestors formed alliances integrated
into the local order. In the Ming and Qing dynasties, Chinese local politics balanced
the clan power and central authority. The government delegated to clans, which incorporated
loyalty and patriotism into their ceremonies, achieving political harmony. Grassroots society
could largely self-govern and family and state religion co-existed. But with the revolutionary
and communist eras, everything changed. The communist party, a terrorist and a fascist
entity, had to dismantle traditional structures to govern effectively, unable to control grassroots
society otherwise. In the decades after the party's rise, relentless campaigns destroyed
traditional customs and culture, particularly targeting clans. Land reforms executed or
imprisoned the landlords and the gentry, dismantling clan halls. Movements like people's
communes and production teams eradicated clans' social functions. Originally, clans managed the
land, trade, and production at the grassroots. Without destroying these halls, people would
have followed ancestral priests, not the party. To establish the leader worship, party loyalty,
and allegiance to a fascist state, the party had to obliterate the clan halls, family religion,
and the family itself. This destruction was largely completed by the 1960s and 1970s.
Today, Chinese people are born not into families but into their ruins. A home is no longer an
altar or a place to guard a sacred fire. The father or elder is no longer a priest but merely
an old leek awaiting exploitation. Today's Chinese family is just a unit for raising leeks, with two
old leeks nurturing a young one, ready for harvest. Many criticize the one-child policy's
inhumanity, but this misses the point. Without first destroying clan halls and family religion,
people would never have followed the party's birth policies, family faith not outside the
decided family size. Without dismantling clans and families, the one-child policy would have been
unenforceable. This one-child policy and today's pro-birth policies work only because the spirit
and soul of Chinese families have been eradicated. Chinese homes lack altars, sacred fires, or
priests. They are mere pixtures or cattle sheds. When the family altar's fire goes out,
it signals ruin. Family members become leeks, mere meat on a chopping block. Today's program
invites you to reconsider familiar historical issues from a new angle. Many define themselves
by opposition against authoritarianism or totalitarianism, but the real question isn't
what you oppose, it's what you will build afterward. Restoring family religion and the
sanctity of family life is the true path to a better future.
Centralized power and family religion are inherently at odds. One's gain is the other's loss.
If family religion weakens, centralized power grows, and vice versa. If people treat their
family as a religion with true faith, centralized authority will naturally win. If Chinese people
fail to grasp this, neglect the sanctity of family, and do not light and guard the family's
sacred fire, their fate will remain that of leeks. Thank you so much for watching. If you find this
video helpful, please like it, drop a comment below, and hit the subscribe button right here.
It'd really help YouTube suggest my video to others. I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.