Why is Affordable Housing Costing More Than Market Value? | Tia Patterson

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
194 Video Views·Jun 18, 2025
In California, the cost of building affordable housing keeps climbing, with some units nearing $1 million to construct. At the same time, older developments are at risk of falling out of affordability as costs rise and protections expire, putting pressure on the system meant to support low-income residents. Tia Patterson, CEO of the California Community Reinvestment Corporation, lays out what’s driving these pressures and what it would take to build and preserve housing that meets the need.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
The cost of building affordable housing in California is sometimes over a million dollars
per unit. In most cases it's between 600 to 800 thousand dollars a unit. People are wondering
why it costs so much to build affordable housing in California. Our guest today is Tia Patterson
who's been in this space for multiple decades and she can tell us what are the key flaws when it
comes to building affordable housing and how to fix them. That's what I mean when I say and all
of the above approach. It's not just building because you're not going to build your way out
of this. You're not going to regulate your way out of this. You're not going to finance your
way out of this. You've got to do all of the and not just produce but preserve. I'm Tia McCoramy.
Welcome to California Insider. Tia, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you.
I'm happy to be here. You have tremendous amount of experience in affordable housing your whole
career. You've helped California in affordable housing. We want to talk to you about this because
there's a lot of issues and Californians are wondering what's going on with affordable
housing. Can you tell us what's challenging California right now? I think if you look at the
biggest issue facing affordable housing it is a lack of supply of housing that is affordable
at certain income levels. In addition, it's a lack of housing supply at all affordable levels whether
it is entry-level home ownership or housing for extremely low-income residents. And so it's a
supply issue that has been ongoing for a number of years where we have put ourselves in a hole
or a deficit because we're just not building enough housing. And then the reasons for that
vary but at the its core we're not building enough housing. There was a time where we could develop
a lot of affordable housing. Was it before the recession right in 2008? Was it there was
development agencies right? 2008 we had the housing crisis and we saw a lot of industry housing
builders leave the industry because of default or bankruptcy because there was so much going on
after that housing crisis. But even prior to 2008 you had the last time California actually
probably kept up with building the housing that it needed for its population was probably in the
80s. So you look every year they say we need 180,000 units built a year to get to the number
that we probably need between 180,000 and 200,000 units. We're building less than 100,000 units and
we have been doing that every year since the mid 80s that we have built less housing. So
it's been probably 40 years creating this deficit of overall supply of housing. When it comes to
affordable housing I think one of the biggest decreases in affordable housing came about
when we saw the elimination of redevelopment and that was in 2010-11 because there were
20% of the redevelopment funds were available for low-income housing. So there was a funding source
that probably ranged between 1 and 2 billion dollars a year just over a billion dollars
that was available for low-income housing. That funding source went away but also some of the
powers that a redevelopment agency went away. Elimination to the barriers, land use, some of
the other structural issues that you got with redevelopment. And so we have seen a reduction
in the financing available for affordable housing and the ability to actually build
affordable housing. We've seen a reduction in that. Now you mentioned the reduction and there was
a billion or two billion available and the state has its way of funding that. Can you explain to us
why that's not meeting what it used to do? Well the ability to know year after year that you have
certain amount of revenue that's coming in on a just on a regular basis. One of the things that
you need for development, residential development, is some degree of certainty and the ability to
meet certain time frames. We have in California since the elimination of redevelopment created
other alternative funding sources but those funding sources come by the way of housing
bond measures. So we have these boom and bust where we will go out and we'll issue debt to
be able to build housing and then when that money is gone then you go back out and issue debt again.
And so instead of having like an ongoing revenue stream that will be there so that people
can plan and have some certainty, we have these boom or busts kind of ups and downs of the financing
that's available for housing. One of the biggest tools that we use for affordable multi-family
rental housing is the low-income housing tax credit and that's been around since the late 80s.
1986 there was a tax reform and that came about as of that. So for 40 years we've had this tool
that provides tax credits, federal tax credits, to support the building of affordable housing.
But that's a certain defined amount of money and so when you have a gap you need another source
that comes in to help make sure that that housing stays affordable and that gap financing is what
redevelopment did. It came in as that gap financing so that developers knew each year how much would
be available and with alternative sources, ups or downs, it lessens that certainty that you would
have that the financing is going to be there. So financing is a big issue from what you're saying
and how does it work for a developer to get this tax credit so they will go apply?
Yes and it's very competitive, extremely competitive. You may have four to one, five to one
projects that are eligible that could get the tax credits but there are only a few, a number
of tax credits that are available. So there's competition that goes around and the competition
comes around four times a year. So we have this housing finance system that is based on limited
resources but then we make it more difficult especially when it's got state funding that's
coming in for that gap to make the whole project work. That state funding is also competitive.
So I've got to go compete for the state money and then I've got to go get local money and then I've
got to go now get my tax credits. So we've made all of these hurdles on the financing end that a
developer has to jump through to put their capital stack together for them to then go and be able to
get the tax credits and then start building. Sometimes it takes five to seven years just to
put all of that together between your site and getting site control and then building up all
of your capital stack. You can bring five to seven different capital stacks in. We've made it very
complicated to finance affordable housing not just in California but in the nation as general. We've
created a lot because everyone wants to say that they've leveraged. So if local government says I
put in fifty dollars and I helped create that many units they want you to go leverage it two to one.
They want someone else to bring in more money. Each time you bring in a different source of
financing you have the financing charges that go along with that. So layering money on top of each
money isn't really leveraging anything. It's just creating more costly cost of capital.
So a developer comes with an idea to build this kind of housing and then they have to secure the
land, right? The land can be bought or is it like it could be? It depends. Sometimes it's bought,
sometimes it can be surplus land, it can be church land, it can be free land that is donated
but most of the time the developer is acquiring that land. Now when the developer acquires that
land the amount that they've paid for that land helps them in their competition for the tax
credits. And so you have to show a certain amount of debt to be able to get the tax credits and to
get the competitive points on the tax credits. To put the application together to get a tax credit
deal it's probably close to a hundred thousand dollars just to put the application together.
So these are not ma and pa's going and getting tax credits. These are sophisticated developers
who are using the tax credit affordable housing finance system. So there isn't a program specifically
for affordable multi-family housing just you and I wanted to go be developers. It doesn't really
exist. You have to pretty much be well capitalized, sophisticated, experienced developer to be able
to even navigate those processes. Because it's complicated. Oh it's very complicated, overly
complicated. Is these kind of tax credits enough or they have to bring other types of funding? They
have to bring other types of funding and when you look at the history of tax credits here in the
state of California the amount of tax credits whether it is a nine percent credit which doesn't
require you to be pairing it with debt or a loan or a mortgage you can just have the tax credits
pay for the whole development. You don't have to get extra debt to go with that nine percent.
We also have the four percent tax credit which has to be paired with debt. So if you look at
total tax credits that are allocated in the state of California between both the nine percent side
and the four percent side California over the history of tax credit has never exceeded about
25,000 affordable housing units either created or preserved on an annual basis. So you're not
going to be able to ever meet your financing needs with just tax credits in the state of California.
And I think that's where we lose it sometimes because everybody wants to focus on the tax
credits because that is 99 percent of the housing affordable housing for rental in the state of
California you're going to use some kind of tax credit. But if the tax credits are limited you
have to be able to say how do I complement or supplement that tax credit system so that I'm
getting more financing that's available so that I'm getting more housing. $25,000, 25,000 units
of affordable housing on an annual basis is never going to meet the need. How many do we need?
I would say closer to probably a hundred thousand. If you wanted to say if you're saying we need
180,000 to 200,000 units every year and that includes market rate at least half of those
should be made affordable to folks between that are low extremely low income to moderate income
I would say at least half of those probably more. So what you're saying is we have limited amount
of money for this and we're giving it to this 25,000 units but it doesn't really make a dent.
Is there another way to use this funding? I would say we should focus on cost efficiency.
The average amount of a unit for a multi-family unit especially if it's permanent supportive
housing units is about $700,000 a unit. That is really really expensive. Now you build into that
that it's going to stay affordable for a long term but we don't put enough emphasis on cost
like are we incentivizing developers to reduce the cost of affordable housing. We put a lot of
other things on affordable housing. We want it to be more energy efficient than any other
development. We want it to have child care. We want it to have extra services. We want it to be
the cream of the crop and some of those what we view as public benefits they cost money and so at
some point policymakers are going to have to decide do I want all of these layers of public
benefit that cost a lot more which means I'm going to have fewer units or do I want to roll back some
of those extras that we're putting on to affordable housing so that we can reduce the cost. I have a
development now that is about 58 units of housing. It's a co-shared space. It's a beautiful development.
It would be wonderful. It would be the perfect model for permanent supportive multi-family
housing. The construction costs for that development was less than $300,000 a unit.
Why are we not building more of those types of developments with tax credits as opposed to
layering all the public benefit? Now I'm not saying the public benefit is bad.
What I'm saying is you have to have trade-offs and at some point is it worth having all of those
public benefits when you know you have a supply issue or do you want to just build more housing?
Safe, sanitary, decent housing. How do we get to that? And I think what we need to do is we need
to evaluate the tax credit system. We need to evaluate the scoring system and we need to figure
out a way to where we can increase that by looking at cost efficiencies. That's what we've been
wondering because we hear the numbers for some projects and it's like a million dollars a unit,
$700,000 a unit and it just it's hard to fathom. To get your head around that. Why it adds up to
that and these are big public projects. Right. So you think potential corruption or what's going on
but it seems there's a lot of programs. It's multiple things. It's time that it takes the
carrying costs, the financing costs for putting seven different financing sources. It's taking
three years to get through three different rounds of public funding. It's the extras that we put on
affordable housing. California's regular building standards are the highest in the nation. Our
energy efficiency standards are the highest in the nation. You can't hardly get any greener.
So but on affordable housing we wanted them to be even greener than just our regular housing and so
it's like let's think about this. Are we're saving what a teaspoon, a tablespoon of greenhouse gas
at $50,000 a door and I know that that is is satire that's probably but that's the trade-offs
that we need to be thinking about. New construction is already energy efficient. Do we need to add and
on to that because every extra that we add on to that is going to increase the cost. You mentioned
the cost. Is it clear to developers do developers have incentives to keep the cost down or there's
no incentive in this? I would say for housing that is financed with low income housing tax credits
there isn't a large enough incentive to keep costs down. In 2000 we did for the state tax credits
because in 2019 the governor did pass a state tax credit which is about 500 million that was
coming in annually to help support and increase the supply because we were under utilizing our
four percents like we weren't using all of it. It later became much more oversubscribed but at that
point in time it wasn't and that very first year of the state tax credits the tiebreaker or to get
the state tax credits you had to show cost efficiencies. That was later changed that scoring
system was changed and you saw people using more state tax credits and more state subsidy but that
initial year you did see a spike because cost efficiency was built into the program. Since then
we've rolled that back but I do believe we really need to really think about the cost of affordable
housing streamlining that process and making it a lot less complicated. What do you recommend you
have a lot of years of experience in this space how would you do it with the resources we have
how would we be able to create more of these units? I would start by a thorough evaluation of our tax
credits and I would start with a and we have a housing plan we have local governments who have
plans. Sometimes it's just talking to one another and the state in my opinion shouldn't be picking
individual projects. The state should serve more of if they're providing funding we are going to defer
that to local governments to do if local governments have all of their place pieces in place.
We sometimes as the state of California do it backwards in my opinion and that we want to dictate
the individual projects well what you should be saying is if your projects look like this
and meet these basic parameters here's your block funding local governments because local
governments are the ones that are approving the actual developments. So how do you incentivize
local governments to quickly approve housing so that you're not running against those roadblocks
you give local governments that political cover to approve the housing and you do more block grants.
I think this notion or this narrative that if it's competition that you get the best product
I don't know that that's necessarily true. I think those projects that meet certain parameters that
are ready to go and shovel ready should be able to go to a counter and say my project's ready to go
I meet all these first come first serve with the projects that look a certain way and they
get the financing. How do we create a system that is more shovel ready ready to go providing
developer certainty that decreases the time I think you would get more projects. And you mentioned
the local governments they would they have the main say in approving this right in terms of
on the ground can you explain that how the process works. So each land use decision whether it's
approving something whether it's a commercial development or a housing development local
government approves those projects on a discretionary basis. Those projects will come before
their planning commission and sometimes their city council. On those discretionary actions
they can say no and oftentimes feel pressure to say no because that's when newbies will show up
and say we don't want we don't want you to build that housing because property taxes or affordable
housing you get less property taxes a local government may be more inclined to approve
that car lot as opposed to that housing development. So we have created a set of policies
that incentivize local government not necessarily to approve housing development.
So how do you roll back those policies to incentivize local government to actually approve
housing. So your thought is that right now from what I'm gathering is if I have a project I'll
go to different agencies to get this tax credits and then then after I got the credits got the
financing then I go to my local government or I might have talked to them but then I go to my
local government for approval. Is that how it works? Yes in effect local government is hopefully
you're talking to local government all along the way but if you were able and I know the governor
has a proposal now and where they say that they want to align state resources so that they're not
developers aren't having to go to all of these different places but they also have to align the
programs because each of the programs may have a different set of rules so and each policymaker
bless their hearts they want special veterans housing they want homeless housing they want
transitional housing they want housing for and so then they create a program for each different
population what you need is affordable housing just blanket affordable housing and so to be able
to have money that could fit all of those needs one pot of money that can go to any of those needs
would be much more would be easier to administer than 15 to 20 different programs. I feel really
sorry for our department of housing and community development that staff there's been over 150 pieces
housing legislation in just the last five years that staff has grown from 400 full-time employees
to over 1,600 full-time employees in just the last five years and then they're trying to enforce
and put in place all of these new programs for housing that's a lot how do we slow down to speed
how do we slow down to be more efficient I think they're constantly drinking from a fire hose
because our policy makers want to create policies that they think are going to help
what you're doing is you have staff that are almost tripping over each other because they're
trying to keep up but what we need is one program that finances a variety of affordable housing
that then can be used for senior housing foster youth housing veterans housing but one pot of
money that fits the needs of that particular community as opposed to creating 40 different
programs that have each have a different set of rules. So essentially what you're recommending
from what I'm gathering is we need to go back to the basics of affordable housing first and just
doing that and using the systems and credits we have to just and lower the cost significantly
yes and then apply that to all these communities that need it. Yes think about it if you have
an affordable housing development each local government has to approve what's called a general
plan that tells you what they're going to build when and how over the course of the 10
5 to 10 years of that general plan every local government in the state of California has a
has a general plan as part of that general plan they have what's called a housing element where
you are provided a number that says these are your regional housing needs and this is the amount of
affordable housing or housing at all income levels we want you to build so if that local government
is building housing that's consistent with that general plan and consistent with your housing
element why is it not just approved by right why do I have to go get a yes or no I should just be
able to take it to the counter someone look at it say that it works it fits and we're going to
build it but we don't we've created so much complication in our system that's not what
happens because now if I take it and the local government has to make a discretionary action
now I've invoked what's called CEQA which is the California Environmental Quality Act
so CEQA in my opinion is not always used as a shield but as a sword and a lot of times you'll
see YIMBYs or not YIMBYs the NIMBYs using CEQA to just ban the affordable housing from being built
altogether and so think about when CEQA was came to bow it came about in the 70s when there were
no environmental rules or environmental regulation people were just dumping toxic
waste since the onslaught or since the beginning of CEQA we now have a whole regulatory framework
for air water that we didn't have before CEQA came about so CEQA is a disclosure law that's
supposed to disclose to you whether or not you there is an environmental impact on whatever it
is I'm building if you have regulations that are monitoring the air and preventing you from doing
bad things to the air or bad things to the water or to the ground why do I need CEQA for a
residential development that's consistent with everything that already exists so you'll hear
from developers all the time we want a CEQA exemption I would go even further why do you
need CEQA when you have environmental regulations in place that already protect the environment
CEQA came about at a time when you didn't have those environmental regulations so sometimes I
think we should stop and look at the circumstances and look at the history and understand how do we
get back to simpler basics do we need to be able to do all of these things should we give someone
the right to bring a lawsuit against something that already is within the regulatory framework
and is consistent with laws that we already have on the book why should they have the ability to
keep that development from being built now in terms of local governments getting involved your
thoughts is you should give the money to them or or have them have access to the money so then then
when they have the money then it's their project and they have to champion it with the community
yes I think there is a distrust that local government is not going to do the right thing
there's an absolute there's this tension the state and local governments and local government wants
local control and the state wants them to build all this housing the state is not building any
housing none local government is approving the housing developers the private sector is building
the housing so who are our essential partners and how do we actually come to the table to partner
with them as to make as opposed to making it more difficult for them so long as we look as
local government as our adversary at the state level and look at developers as an ad an adversary
as opposed to a strategic partner and coming together I think we talked earlier about civility
can we all come to the table and have a reasonable solution to how we're going to get this done
because you all need each other you need some of the resources from the state you need the approval
part you need the approval powers of local government and you need the private sector to
come in who's actually building these housing without any of those partners at the table
you're not going to be able to get it done and Tia how would you do it if you had a blank slate
it took us years to get into this mess there is no one-size-fits-all there are no civil bullets
but I do think we should take a step back and look at the whole system I think what we're doing is
we're doing a little piecemeal piecemeal piecemeal without look taking a step back and looking at it
holistically we need an all of the above approach where you are supporting everything from homeless
shelters to entry-level home ownership we've made it very difficult for developers to build
smaller single-family entry-level home ownership we don't incentivize it we've made it very
difficult we focused on homelessness and we focused on permanent supportive housing and
we focused a lot of attention on that segment of the population because we have a horrible homeless
crisis in the state of California but you're seeing a different kind of homelessness you're
seeing working families who are now living out of their cars but still going to work so that means
we're not supporting the entire system or the entire spectrum of affordable housing and so how
do we create a system that supports the entire spectrum of affordable housing from homelessness
to entry-level home ownership when they say all boats rides when the tides rise if you're just
focusing on one segment which is the most expensive housing there is then you're going to throw the
market off how do you actually support the market with your policies and your resources so that all
boats will rise when the tides rise so you mentioned working together in an ideal scenario
because these are affordable housing so the developer probably will not may not earn a lot
of money right or how would it work in an ideal scenario it's it's funny that you mentioned that
because i think there's this especially in the affordable housing space there's this belief that
developers are making a lot of money developers have or capped at a 2.5 million dollar developer
fee their their construction of the affordable housing could be 40 50 million dollars but
they're limited to a 2.5 million dollar developer fee that only that had been there that cap on
developer fee had been in existence for 25 years they just raised the cap like two years ago because
there's this false narrative or false belief that they're making a lot of money they are not
making a lot of money because and oftentimes what happens in affordable housing is that they'll call
do what's called deferring the developer fee and they'll use the deferred developer fee as part of
their sources and uses so that it comes in as capital as part of that capital stack so i'm
going to give up my money to help make pencil this deal and so and when you defer a developer
fee or you could use that as one of your sources you can leverage and get more tax credits so
oftentimes they'll defer that developer fee over a certain period of time to get more tax credits
and help pay for the deal so there's this real belief from policymakers that developers are
making a lot of money no that's not really true and what we see in california where it's trending
now not just in california but nationwide following covid the income that was coming
in on affordable housing has not met projections because we deferred rents people weren't paying
rents remember that people were not paying rents rents got suspended so income coming into these
properties were less but expenses were up and so we've put a lot of pressure on housing in that
we want to limit the amount of rents and a lot of times you can't raise the rents because you
have a regulatory agreement and because of the funding that you took you have you have to keep
the rents at a certain at a certain level and you can't raise those rents but the expenses
are rising faster than the income and so we're creating a gap and we're putting a lot of pressure
on affordable housing and i'm really worried about so we've been focusing on production
which rightly we should because that's the biggest issue but if you don't have a preservation
strategy what happens in year 15 when that tax credit investor is gone and no longer watching
the project what happens when that project is now upside down financially when the income is
less than the expenses and that project can no longer pay its mortgage i think we need to pay
attention to that and we as policy makers in the state of california have not looked comprehensively
at the system at some point you can be filling up a bucket full of water but if you have a hole in
the bucket and you're losing just as much you're never going to be able to make any headway because
you have to pay attention to those units that may be lost and that affordability that may be lost
while you're building affordable housing how can they be lost would they get foreclosed they get
foreclosed upon if you go into default and you're foreclosed upon that affordability is lost so
essentially you have the rental units that are paying you rent as a developer at a certain
amount but your costs have gone up yes and and now you can you're upside down yes so then you
you default and a new investor will come in and would it still be after year 15 the investor's
gone so that's my point my point is we may have a problem we may have a problem with those projects
that are now coming to year 15 that may be financially upside down so who will have to take
uh the state and the local government should be coming up with a preservation strategy
someone needs to be thinking about out of my portfolio i'm in irvine all of the affordable
housing in the city of irvine are that we may have put money into what does that portfolio look like
is it fiscally sound i the city of irvine came in and put six million dollars in that deal
is that deal penciling still in year 15 or is it financially getting ready to go belly up
no one in my opinion is really paying attention to those fiscal problems that are coming as a
result of covid rents people not paying rents and income not meeting the expenses the cost
two to three to four hundred percent over premiums that we weren't paying before and so those costs
are constantly rising but those incomes are limited who's paying attention to that now i
told you tax credits came about in the late 80s so those original tax credit deals went for 30 years
not for 55 years so those tax credit deals that are coming to year 30 when that regulatory
agreement expires does that housing going to go market rate or is it going to stay affordable
who's paying attention to that so there are preservation issues coming up because either
the loss of the regulatory agreement has expired or because those properties are now fiscally upside
down we should be paying attention to that so what can happen if these projects go belly up would they
get foreclosed and sold to new new investors and then the rents will go up essentially they could
go out of being affordable they could go out of going worst case scenario they will no longer be
affordable best case scenario you have local governments the lender and a new affordable
housing developer stepping in to preserve that but that requires people having a conversation
that requires you paying attention to knowing what your portfolio looks like the default rat
rate on a tax credit deal is historically low a tax credit multi-family residential development
is probably one of the safest asset classes there are but what we're seeing is a trend what we're
seeing are projects that would have never gone into default trending toward having expenses that
exceed the the income coming into that project that's a new phenomenon we haven't historically
seen that and because we're starting to see these trends i really think we whether it's local
government the state of california need to be working together on preservation strategies
because preservation is just as important as production you have to have both that's what
i mean when i say and all of the above approach it's not just building because you're not going
to build your way out of this you're not going to regulate your way out of this you're not going to
finance your way out of this you've got to do all of these and not just produce but preserve
Natia this phenomenon is it national too or is it mostly california i would say it's
we are probably at the forefront but it is a national issue and people are paying attention
now because they realize this has been a problem ongoing problem for decades but when you and i
have children that can't afford to buy a house in their own neighborhood that's when everybody
starts paying attention when it hits you personally when you see the homeless population exploding and
you're saying what is going on when you're driving down the street and you see these
you can actually visualize it then that's when you realize it's a problem but this is a problem
that's been in the making for 40 years where we have underbuilt and taken away resources
and frameworks that were put in place to be able to support a housing system they no longer
you have a problem because those frameworks those finances were taken away and we have not thought
to come back and reevaluate the whole system and think about how to uplift a system so that all
boats rise. Natia you have dedicated your whole career to this right why? Because i was a kid who
grew up in public housing owned by the housing authority in the central valley my mom was a
single mom she worked Sears and Roebuck and in the 70s when women weren't allowed to take a
mortgage out in their own name that's just recently this was my mother was able to take advantage of
changes in the law that allowed her as a single woman to purchase a home using a down payment
assistance program so i have seen where safe sanitary and stable housing has been able to
change lives and break generational cycles of poverty my sister and i both have advanced degrees
i own my own home my sister owns her own home because of that that support of having safe
sanitary and decent housing that is kind of what they say the american dream now whether it's
home ownership or just having a safe place to lay your head that's not under a bridge that you know
your kids will be able to come home and study that so these are the reasons why i'm passionate
about this because i have seen where housing affordable housing has been able to help change
my life so this is something i'm very passionate about because i've lived it and i've had those
lived experiences. By now you should know that we are part of the Epoch Times newspaper
having this paper associated with us we are able to get story ideas and a lot of sources
now this week's paper had one amazing story about what's happening with the Tijuana sewage crisis
we actually have been covering this crisis on the show now we are hearing that the switch is
actually going airborne and miles and miles away into the San Diego coast up to even La Jolla
there's also another story that's fascinating in the paper it's about equitable grading remember
California Insider we covered equitable grading from all perspectives from the parents to the
teachers the people that actually created equity grading program and superintendents of schools
who implemented it now San Francisco just rejected the equity grading method for the school district
and the paper has the story in it we have a special deal for you you can subscribe for a dollar a week
for a digital edition you can also get the print you will be surprised by the quality of journalism
that goes into this paper now let's go back to the interview
this phase is some challenges the state is facing especially with affordability what do you think of
the future of California housing should be so non-partisan like whether you're blue red or purple
it's whether you believe in the right or the left we all need a safe sanitary decent place to live
and so getting back to civility and having those conversations about what trade-offs are we willing
to give so that we can address this crisis if that means your neighbor is going to have a to
have the ability to build an adu or a duplex should you be able to say no to that because
you want to be a nimby we have to be able to all come together and be able to say let's move forward
let's come together let's not fight one another about the creation and preservation of housing
at all income levels sometimes you hear from the far right and sometimes you hear from the far left
from the far right you're hearing things like get rid of affirmatively furthering fair housing
I think we language matters because you don't want to get rid of affirmatively furthering fair
housing because the reason why we have a crisis in some neighborhoods is because you redlined
certain neighborhoods you've kept and excluded whole communities from being able to buy a house
you thwarted generational wealth because of certain government regulations so affirmatively
furthering fair housing is necessary to ensure that we're making our meeting our housing needs
and so that's a fight from the far right and then you can even get it from the far left where you
have some of the biggest nimbies are in some of our most liberal communities where they don't want
increased density because they don't want to block the sunshine from their tomato plants so we need
to stop listening to the far right we need to stop listening to the far left and we need to come
together with practical solutions is it really the need to pay a higher prevailing commercial wage
on a small apartment complex that's privately owned in the central valley why am I paying
San Francisco wages for a small apartment complex in the central valley is that really the trade-off
we want to make why am I requiring extra 10 energy efficiency on top of the highest energy
standards there already are in the nation is that really necessary so we have to be honest about
what's important to us in the state of California and have honest conversations about what are the
trade-offs what is needed and how are we really going to address this issue so you grew up in
affordable housing and you managed to become one of the leaders in the state in on this topic how
did you do that the first home we lived in was the family home and it it was my grandmother my mother
the two kids some of my uncles this beautiful home this was the home that my great-grandfather
had built that home burned down when I was five years old and so the family kind of split up
my mother who was a single mom we went and we had public housing and that public housing that we
lived in was in the middle of a neighborhood I didn't know I was poor I was a I was poor but
like in my mind I didn't know I was poor so we lived it was a fourplex in the middle of a
neighborhood we had teachers that lived in the neighborhood we had my mom who worked part-time
at Sears and Roebuck we had you know the dentist lived in the neighborhood because it was like
this affordable housing in the middle of a neighborhood so after school we would go to
Miss Latrell's house Miss Latrell was the captain of the police's mother so I like I grew up in a
community and a support system but it was affordable housing and so having affordable
housing and mixed income housing and weaving that into the fabric of the community I think
so important it is important to not redo the mistakes of our past we shouldn't be creating
ghettos we shouldn't be concentrating poverty and areas of concentrated poverty and sometimes
that's what happens because that's the cheapest land to buy is in those distressed neighborhoods
now I'm not saying don't build in distressed neighborhoods but ensure that you balance that
high resource areas low resource areas we need affordable housing and both it's not an either
and or it's an and and so incorporating that and I think is important and for me
seeing that as a kid and growing up where I saw you know housing that I lived with kids and didn't
know I was poor I didn't know I was poor until I got ready to apply for college and then I looked
at the little FAFSA and mom I was like oh this can't be right this is below the federal poverty
my mother was like yeah no that's right make a dollar out of 99 cents and so just having that
as a kid and growing up and and the stories and sitting with my sister it's like my there's a one
particular story I tell sometimes when I go and have conversations about affordable housing I don't
see affordable housing and the partners of affordable housing as like a pie I don't see it
like that because with a pie each person gets their slice when I was a kid growing up my mother had
these single friends they all had kids and once a month we would get together we would rotate
houses and we would get together and we would have it was called the potluck Fridays on Fridays we
would all have a potluck we would bring whatever was in the refrigerator my mother you know we'd
go through the refrigerator you have spaghetti with we chopped in with the tomato sauce or
leftover fried chicken or bread and we as kids thought that was like the best time in the world
like oh my goodness it's potluck Friday like we looked forward to potluck Friday
so after I became an adult my sister and I were sitting down talking to my mother and we were
like oh my god we love potluck Fridays and my mother started laughing and she said that wasn't
for fun that was because we were so poor we didn't have enough food for us to feed our own family but
if we brought everything together we would have enough to be able to make meals and to feed all
the kids so that was out of necessity that we did that that wasn't just social but then I was like
what if we looked at affordable housing like a potluck like everybody bring something to the
table have you ever been to a potluck like there's always food there's food left over
there's all kinds of food so if everybody brought a dish bring a two dishes but if everybody bought
something to the table then you're not fighting over the crumbs that are left over it's everybody
gets to get fed and so if we could envision it like that I think we would be better off
Tia Patterson president and CEO of California Community Reinvestment it was great to have you
on California Insider thank you it's good to be here let us know your thoughts on how we can solve
the affordability issues in California especially when it comes to housing you can always email us
or comment we read all of your emails and comments
I'm Siamak Korami this is California Insider and we will see you next time
