WORST Sermon Illustration of All Time?

Travis Chappell
170 followers
Jun 15, 2025
Full episode: https://youtu.be/9bZWHbcz0D0
Travis Chappell talks to Andrew Cordle about the infamous "Polished Shaft" sermon preached by Jack Schaap at First Baptist Church of Hammond for their Youth Conference.
Follow Travis on:
– IG 👉🏻 instagram.com/travischappell
– FB 👉🏻 facebook.com/traviscchappell
– Twitter 👉🏻 twitter.com/traviscchappell
– Pinterest 👉🏻 pinterest.com/travischappellpod
Subscribe to Travis Makes Friends on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and don’t forget to leave a 5-star rating!
So, were you in the auditorium for the Polishing the Shaft sermon?
Uh, the famous one that's on YouTube right now?
Yeah.
Because, you know, he preached that sermon like 50 times.
The one that got famous.
Yeah.
Of course it hurts. Of course it's fine. Of course it's pain. Of course it's...
Ah, ah, ah, ah, ah, ah, ah, ah.
Gosh, just shut up. I can handle it. I know what I'm doing. I know what I'm doing.
Oh, God, that hurts. Oh, oh, God, I'm so tired. Oh, God, I didn't want to lose her.
Oh, God, I didn't want to have that pain. Oh, God, no, no.
But, no, the one that was there, that's like the YouTube famous one, I was not there for.
I was already gone because that was like 2000, I don't know, like eight or nine or something.
I've seen it. No, I was not there for that one.
But I have seen, I've been in the service when he is for that exact sermon.
And here's what's crazy, man, which a lot of people don't know this, but normally, this is so wild.
When he originally first started preaching that sermon, right?
I was in high school when it actually first came out.
That sermon first came out, right?
So this would have been like 1999.
Yeah.
When it, around the time frame that sermon first came out.
He preached that sermon at my high school on like when he was, he wasn't the pastor yet.
Sure.
Okay, and the way that he used it in all the years he did it until that one, you know how he used to do it?
No.
The way that he used to do it made a lot, a lot of sense.
But that one is like, you're watching it and you're like, I don't, I don't even understand what's happening right now.
The way that he used to do it was he would actually get a stick, like an old stick from a tree and a knife.
And then he would kind of like carve the knife.
Okay.
And he'd make an arrow out of the knife.
And he put a point on the tip of it.
And there'd be like a bump in the stick or whatever.
And then he would like sit there and like trim that off.
And he would use the knife, a big Bowie knife.
Yeah.
And he would trim like and make an arrow.
Okay.
That was the one, and which makes a lot more sense because he would try to say like, you know,
God has to test you to see if you'll, you know, whatever.
Yeah.
And that one makes more sense and is not this sexual innuendo.
But then the one on YouTube, which I wasn't there for, I never saw that one.
It looks like a Saturday Night Live skit.
It's my favorite.
Like there's no way it's real.
I've ever seen in my life.
There's no way this is real.
Like I, if you ever watch it, I watched the men on the platform, their faces.
Yeah.
None of them, none of them, none of them break.
That could easily be Will Ferrell.
Like, yeah.
You know, like literally doing a sketch.
It's, it's so mind-blowingly like this is, this is not real.
Facial expressions, hand gestures, what he was using, noise, like all of it.
There's no way.
I don't know.
I do.
That was, that was, it's wild.
It's how many, the good laugh, bro.
Because you know, the background of it's like, how'd you go from like carving a stick to an arrow?
Well, what's funny is I never saw that until after everything came out.
Again, let's give you a little bit of background about Jack Scott.
He was the lead pastor of the Hammond Baptist church until his firing last July.
Prosecutors say that he took advantage of a troubled 16-year-old girl who was a parishioner at the Fundamentalist Mega Church in Northwest Indiana and had come to him for counseling.
Because I was on tour for West Coast.
Okay.
During the summer where everything came out.
And then I saw that clip afterward.
And it was one of those just like, yeah, I think there were some signs, guys.
Yeah, definitely.
I was gone by.
There might have been a thing or two that would have tipped us off.
I was, I had been gone for like five years when all of it actually finally like broke, whatever it was.
And I remember getting the news of it thinking there's no freaking way.
But then as you go back, what was crazy was, so my, the assistant that turned him in.
Okay.
Who actually found the iPad, let's say.
And actually turned him in.
Works for me.
Oh, really?
To this day, yeah.
Wow.
He's like an IT tech wizard.
That's what he does.
And to this day, he works for me.
And so I actually have like all kinds of like pretty in-depth information.
And then matter of fact, his, because I ended up moving back up there to that area.
It already happened.
He was already sentenced.
He was already in jail.
So this was several years later, maybe three years or two years, something later.
I ended up moving back up there to do a bunch of real estate deals with a buddy and was there for like two years.
Well, while I was there, there was that massive transition going on in the church, right?
Yep.
And there was, there was a lot of really good workers, like straight up like worker bees.
Yeah.
And there, and two of them were on his staff that I, three of them, sorry, three of, three of his personal staff I hired.
Oh, really?
And one of them to this day still works for me.
Yeah.
And the one that works for me lives in Florida now.
But he was the one who actually turned him in and he still works for me to this day in like IT.
So I don't do ******* anything with that, with iPads or on that dude.
Like ****, I don't post anything.
It's all like, you know, Apple is always like, do you want to sync this?
I'm like, **** no.
I don't want to sync any ----.
It's all analog with him.
I write him letters.
So yeah, but all, all three really good people.
And I have a lot of behind the scenes information because they stayed through the whole time.
Yeah.
During the transition.
Yeah.
It's so wild now.
It's such a crazy time in life though, for sure.
Yeah.
I mean, and you know, he's not gotten much better since then.
No, I would say it's probably got worse.
Yeah.
From a standpoint of his guiding, it's what I would call, it's very inbred.
Oh yeah.
Totally.
It is the biggest issue.
And the people are just getting weirder and weirder and less in touch with reality as time goes on.
At that moment when all that went down, a positive that could have taken place from there.
I mean, a lot of that was obviously negative, but a positive could have taken place was,
it could have been a giant shift in that whole, say, religion, if you will.
Yeah.
And they could have said, hey, from, from, from that, let's, let's take this as all past
and look for the new direction of who we, our identity, our brand should be.
Yeah.
And they didn't.
They doubled down on their brand, which is already a dying ******* brand.
It's like you're, you're Blockbuster and you double down on that ----.
Yeah.
Even though Netflix just came out with like, not only like, it was like, uh, this is a
great analogy.
It's like they were Blockbuster.
Netflix already came out and was crushing you.
Uh, and then Netflix then starts, that's when they had Netflix had like the, the melon DVDs
though.
Yeah.
Imagine Netflix.
You still stay at Blockbuster stores.
Then Netflix goes online TV, which is what we all watch now.
Okay.
That's where it was, how far of a gap it was.
And then your brand at Blockbuster and then you being the leader of Blockbuster, like,
you know what?
Fuck it.
Let's just double down.
And what we currently have of more stores.
We need to double our late fees.
Yeah.
It's like, we did, we need to charge more if they don't be Ryan, the VHS is for us.
Like that was the concept of like, from a business perspective of looking at it, it
was like, dude, that was like a moment you could have shifted.
Yeah.
And they did, they doubled down on it.
And to me it's gotten worse.
I mean, I don't have anything to do with it anymore.
I'm, I'm, I'm kind of probably a unique one where like, I don't, um,
I don't hate them.
I'm not, I don't know if I'd even say I'm against them.
I just, I just don't care.
It's like, I am agnostic to any of that stuff.
There's like, there's good people and bad people everywhere in business and churches.
Like you obviously hope to see fewer of them in churches, but that's just not the case.
It just, you know, there's always going to be a percentage of people that suck and there's
going to be a percentage of people that are good people.
