50 Smart Digital Door Locks – My Top 3 Favorites?
Hey, what's up? Alex here. Back in December 2020, I did a video talking about my top 5
home products that are worth buying. Fun fact, that is the last video I shot using my mobile
phone. Till this date, the list is pretty much the same for me. Smart doorbells, purified water
dispenser, smart laundry rack, robot vacuum and smart digital door locks. In my last 2 videos,
I covered robot vacuum and smart doorbell products with some purchase recommendation.
Finally, it's time we look at smart digital door locks in this video,
specifically on mortise locks which are commonly used for our main door.
So the plan is, I'm gonna check out as many locks as possible then share with you guys my top 3
favourites. To do that, I'm heading out to every major lock retailer storefront to have a look at
what are the locks that they are selling. Of course, I've already done some homework online
to see what are the brands and models there are. For some of the companies that doesn't have a
storefront, I've managed to get them to send me a demo test unit mounted on a stand.
Okay, so let's go and check out the smart door locks we have in Singapore now.
Just to let you guys know that this video is not sponsored by any of the lock brands
and also not by any of the shops that I'm visiting. They have no idea that I'm going
down today. I'll try to take some video clips in every shops that I visit,
but if you don't see any footage, means they don't allow me to film anything inside.
When you visit these shops, you are immediately overwhelmed with so many brands and different
models to choose from. There are locks from US, Europe, China, quite a number of them from Korea,
and even local brands as well. So how am I going to choose from all these?
To me, the most important reason for getting a digital door lock is for convenience. No need
to carry any keys out and no need to spend a minute or so to unlock the door. All you need
is actually fingerprint unlock, at most a pin code for backup. Able to unlock with cards,
RFID tags and etc are just extras to me, they are not the main selling points. I mean,
what's the point of having so many ways to unlock when ultimately, you are just going
to go with fingerprint? The idea is actually very similar to unlocking your mobile phone.
Facial recognition is also starting to pick up for digital locks, but right now, I feel that the
tech is not matured enough. It can also be a battery disaster if there is high human traffic,
but I can see that it can be very useful for elderly having problems with their fingerprints.
I will personally go for those design that allows you to unlock using your fingerprint
and open the door at the same time in one step. This is the most convenient. So the fingerprint
sensor should be placed on the handle so that when you hold the handle, your finger will naturally
fall on the sensor. With that, this eliminates about 50% of the locks, including all from
Samsung. Samsung is also selling away their smart lock line of products, so it's better to look
elsewhere at the moment. Next, at 2022, I am looking at smart locks and not simply digital
locks from a decade ago. This means that the lock must have some form of connection protocol
which you can set configuration and manage via an app with event tracking, notification and so on.
So either Bluetooth, WiFi, ZigBee or Z-Wave with WiFi being my least preferred because of power
consumption and security reasons. Again with this requirement, this eliminates about another 25%
of the locks out there. For Bluetooth locks, if you want remote access to the lock, you will
typically need a bridge or hub which is an additional cost but it's optional. For ZigBee
or Z-Wave ones, they will connect to their existing smart home hubs. If you don't have a
smart home hub, then unlikely you will get this just for a lock. So for the remaining 25% of the
locks, I will consider the design which is subjective to personal preference, other security
features like having child lock. Build quality is hard to access just by touching it, you kind
of need to dismantle the whole thing so that is tough. And lastly, yes, I will consider the price
as well. If it is costing more than 1k SGD, then it better have something awesome to justify the
price tag. Initially, I thought this is going to be very tough looking at over 16 brands and
roughly 50 models to come up with my favourite top 3. In the end, it turns out to be pretty
straightforward. So coming at number 3 is from a local Singapore brand, Igloo Home. They have
expanded their business to the global market which is pretty impressive. This is their push-pull
model, retails at 769 SGD including installation. This is covered mostly in matte black with a
glossy border around it. You can see that the design is quite unique, not your typical push-pull
lock design. So fingerprint sensor on the handle, this is what I like. And it is with this design,
it is not in an awkward position if you want to use your thumb or index fingerprint to unlock
depending on your preference. So if you like to use your thumb, you will hold on to the handle
this way, unlock with your thumb, then push the door. If you like to use index finger,
you hold on to the handle this way instead, unlock with your index finger, then push the door.
The whole unlocking process time which includes the fingerprint verification response time,
plus the time for the bulb to retract, is close to 5 seconds. Decent, not the fastest but good
enough. But the relock time is fast which you have the option to set this on their app. Some
of the locks take like 3 to 5 seconds, which I don't like because you sort of have to pause
and wait to make sure it is locked before walking away. Then of course you have your standard RFID
card and pin options. For the keypad, you have to touch to activate it. Once light up,
then you can key in your pin. For feel safe mechanism, this is the part where you connect
a 9V battery to jumpstart it in the case where there is no battery. Then right underneath,
you can remove this part to access the keyhole. Okay now going to the inside,
you have your standard battery housing at the top. You can put a maximum of 4 AA batteries.
Then instead of the fingerprint sensor, you have a button here, press to unlock.
But you can actually just pull the handle directly to unlock. Behind is a child lock feature,
which can also be a feature for anti-peephole theft. So that's all on the exterior hardware,
now going to the software. This is a Bluetooth lock, no option for Wi-Fi bridge. That means
you have to be in Bluetooth range if you want to open or lock with your app. I like how they
designed their app, very clean and easy to use. Left navigation will see account settings,
properties management if you have more than one property and to choose which lock to manage.
Once in the lock, you have quick navigation below, settings will see battery life and
give you an estimate when to replace them. Then you have the relock timer which I just covered,
number of attempts to lockout to prevent people from trying multiple pins to try to guess the
pin code, volume settings and so on. You have locks with timestamps to check what time your
kids came back or go out. Then access is where igloo home really stands out. You have the
flexibility to create different types of pins for different use cases. You can remotely create
one-time pin for the lock even when the lock doesn't have any internet access. They patent
their algo pin technology which is like a form of 2FA authentication where you have a personal
token sitting on their cloud server. So this will generate the pin and store them in a very
secure manner. Igloo home also have locks for your HDB metal gates as well. So I will always
recommend to get the same brand that has the feature to automatically unlock the other once
one of them has already been unlocked. That means for example once you unlock the gate, you can
straight away open the main door. So igloo home has this capability. Although personally, I really
see no point in having double locks. And of course if you want to support local brands, you can definitely
check them out. Coming in at my second place is the Aqara A100. Aqara is a very well-known
smart home company. I have used many of their products and actually covered them quite a lot
of times in my videos. Their products are very high quality and at very affordable price. This A100
is a very recent new product launch from them. You can purchase it from HomeSmart at $678 SGD,
inclusive of installation and 2 years warranty. If you don't need the installation services,
they are okay to sell just the lock itself at $479 SGD. HomeSmart is a local Singapore company
that distributes Aqara products and all the setup installation services. Some of you are asking me
for a lock that supports Apple HomeKit. So yes, Aqara products all support HomeKit, including
this smart lock. Not just HomeKit, Google Home is supported as well. I am so excited to share all
the smart features but let's look at the lock itself first. All of their locks go with the
lever handle design, no push-pull. For me, I don't really have a strong preference to either one.
Unlike the N100 which is kinda round in shape, the A100 went with a more common squarish
corner design which I definitely prefer more. The whole lock is in black, I mean really black.
Besides the keypad area which is using glass, the rest of the lock has a very nice touch and feel
to it, something like a textured powder-coated surface. So again, most importantly, the thumb
print sensor must be on the handle so that you unlock and open the door in one single motion.
This lock falls under the super quick unlocking process time, we are looking at something around
2 to 3 seconds, very impressive. This is not a fully automatic lock whereby the 3 bolts here
don't pop out and retract in by itself. Okay, let me demonstrate. So when you close the door,
the relock time is immediate. But you can see and hear that the 3 bolts are not popping out.
Why is that so? Because you will need to push the handle up. Same thing, when you unlock the door,
you won't see the bolts automatically retract in, you will have to push the handle down. But since
this is a lever handle design, you will still have an additional step to push the handle down
before you can open the door. So actually, this is alright. The 3 bolts are like an additional
security. The door is already locked so you can actually don't use them, it's up to you.
For fail-safe, here is your keyhole and right underneath there is a USB-C port.
Now let's look at the inside. Battery housing at the top which you can put 8 AA batteries.
Over here below is a knob for you to lock from the inside. You can see the 4th bolt pops out.
So when you do that, normal users will not be able to unlock from outside,
only administrator user permission can enter. So for example,
if your kids didn't come home on time, you can use this to lock them outside the house.
Okay, so other unlocking options. You have your standard pin code and NFC cards. Besides these,
you can also unlock with Apple home keys. That means once you add a home key to your Apple wallet,
you can then unlock with your iPhone or Apple Watch. I can see this being quite useful especially
for the Apple Watch because these are things that you carry with you anyway and it's 100%
accuracy rate, unlike fingerprint which is never 100%. Next is using Google Home to unlock. So
this lock has both Bluetooth and ZigBee. First, you will configure it on your phone with the
Acara app using Bluetooth. After that, you can bind an Acara 3.0 hub like the M2 hub to the lock.
Once you do that, you then have the ability to do remote unlock. Once you have added Acara
to Google Home, you will then be able to see the lock device there. I will demo triggering
and unlock using the Google voice assistant. Google, unlock smart door lock. Can I have your
pin? 112233. Alright, requesting to unlock the smart door lock. Or you can also go to your Nest
Hub or using Google Home from your mobile phone and unlock from there. The same should apply to
Apple HomeKit and using Siri. Inside the Acara app, it has all your standard smart features like
user management, event locks, and able to set one-time pin or a periodic pin. So overall,
I think if you're an Apple HomeKit user or Google Home user, you like to set some interesting
automations with the lock, I think for sure you will love this lock a lot. Alright, time to
announce my number 1 favourite smart door lock, and that is the Lock-in SV30 Pro. Lock-in is a
very popular brand in China that is only selling door locks. For Xiaomi locks like the one I have
installed in this house, it's actually an OEM from Lock-in. That is also why there are many
similarities between these two. You can buy this from Interlock, selling at 799 SGD including
installation and 1-year warranty. Interlock is a local company that resells various brands of
digital door locks. If you're a Mi Home user, you'll be very interested in this lock. But even without
a smart home, this is a very good lock by itself. Okay, now let's take a look at the exterior hardware
first. You can see that this is a push-pull design. The front has a lot of it covered with glass in
black. The rest of the body is in silver. The material used is very solid and well-built. And
after checking out so many locks, I realized that many of them has this rubber or plastic strip
around the lock. If you have one, you can go and take a look at yours now. But for this S30 Pro,
there isn't, which makes it look super sleek and also a red dot winner for 2020. Once again,
fingerprint sensor on the handle. They even make these parts land at an angle, perfect and
comfortable position. Similar to the Aqara A100, the unlocking process time for this is super quick
at around 2 seconds. But because this is a fully automatic push-pull model, you can straight away
push open the door once it's unlocked, reducing that by one step. Okay, so what do I mean by fully
automatic? It means that the bolt will pops out and retract by itself this way. That also means
that the handles at both sides are always at a fixed position. There isn't any catch inside unlike
some of the other push-pull locks including my Xiaomi. So that's the meaning of fully automatic.
As you can see, relock time is immediate, no waiting, no pause at all. So what else do we have
in the front? The keypad which has numbers printed on it with a battery icon here which I suppose
will light up if battery is low. There is also a key here which is to trigger home automation
once you leave the house like switching off your lights. The Aqara A100 has this as well. Right
below the keypad is a doorbell. Basically, you have a doorbell function but I don't think in
for a doorbell. Same logic as putting your doorbell at the peephole, not to mention that this is so
small. Then you have NMC unlock, the keyhole you can find it over here for failsafe, then underneath
there is a USB-C port for emergency power. Looking at the inside, for the battery, you have a maximum
of 8 AA batteries. You have a few security features here. There are sensors at the back of the handle
to detect human touch. So to unlock, you have to hold on the handle and press the unlock button
here. This is an anti-peephole tap feature. This button over here is to enable locking from the
inside. Similarly, only admin access can unlock from outside once it's enabled. When you enable
child lock on the app, the unlock button will be disabled. You will have to turn this knob to
unlock instead. Now going to the app, this is a Bluetooth lock and connects to Mi Home, supports
both the Singapore and China mainland region. Within the app, the features are pretty similar
to the Aqara and my Xiaomi lock whereby you have your access management, events tracking,
alarm notifications and automations. It can be connected to your Xiaomi V3 gateway that supports
Bluetooth mesh. With this, you are able to remotely manage your lock. But take note that it doesn't
support remote unlock for security reasons. But you still can generate and send one-time pin or
periodic pins without the hub, just the lock itself. I'm actually quite torn between the Aqara A100
or Lock-in SV30 for my number one because this can really go either way. The Aqara is cheaper
and comes with better smart home integrations, but the SV30 is better in many ways if you focus
just on the lock itself, which I think ultimately that's more important when you access a lock.
For you, it might come down to whether you prefer a lever or push-pull design.
Couple of honorable mentions include the Aiyu YDM7220 Biosecure, something very different and
makes sense during this COVID period. The Philips 9200 is also quite good with lots of features,
I just find these too expensive. But I will also recommend to play safe and not get those locks
that are super cheap or from very small startups. Some of you might ask whether you should buy the
locks from local suppliers or get it from somewhere else. The benefit of getting from
local is they will help you to install and you will have warranty and after-sales support.
My take is if the house have kids or elderly staying together, then having that support is good.
At least you don't need to worry so much when things happen. If you are staying alone or just
with your other half and you just want to buy it at the cheapest price, then that's okay as well.
If that's the case, if you need help to install, I put my handyman contact number in the description
below. So I hope this video is helpful for you in choosing your smart door lock. For those that's
watching that already have one, I'm interested to know which model you are using and what's
the reason you choose that. Do share with me in the comments. That's it from me for this video,
see you all next time. Bye!

