🔰Bob Iger's Disney is Worse Than You Think
We've got a great responsibility to the world of Star Wars fans out there and to recruit a whole new generation.
There's a picture on my desk of my shaking hands with Steve Jobs.
Look, the term woke is thrown around rather liberally, no pun intended in that regard.
We're happy with what we've been doing so far and certainly thrilled with this next installment.
I think a lot of people don't even understand really what it means.
That moment enabled me to say to Steve...
Infusing messaging as a sort of a number one priority in our films and TV shows is not what we're up to.
I got this crazy idea. We want to buy Pixar.
I'm Bob Iger and this is my MasterClass.
Bob Iger is not a creative. He's not a storyteller. He's not an innovator.
He is, in the purest sense of the word, a brand manager with a wallet.
And he's somehow been elevated to the level of cultural architect.
They say he saved Disney. But dig just a bit beneath the headlines and you'll find the real story.
He walked into a room full of legacy, bought the legacy of other men, other studios, other visions,
and passed off their sweat and art as Disney magic.
The real trick was doing it with a calm voice and a million dollar jawline.
But the man could read the ingredients off a cereal box and business reporters would call it a MasterClass in leadership.
It's all there, black and white, clear as crystal.
Quality needs attention to deliver quality. It doesn't happen by accident.
And quantity, in our case, diluted quality. And Marvel suffered greatly from it.
In the early 2000s, Disney wasn't quite the juggernaut it is today.
The animation division was reeling from a string of flops.
Treasure Planet, Home on the Range, Chicken Little.
Even the parks weren't doing so well. Pixar, not Disney, had become the face of quality animation.
So when Iger took over in 2005, he made a move that was both smart and unoriginal.
He bought the better company.
7.4 billion dollars later, Pixar became Disney property.
Obviously the press swooned. Analysts called it visionary.
But underneath the boardroom gloss, the strategy was alarmingly simple.
If you can't beat them, buy them. And then start milking.
Pixar had given us WALL-E, a near-silent love story about a trash compactor with a soul.
It was a risk that paid off.
After Disney swallowed it up, those risks dried up.
What followed was a graveyard of sequels.
Cars 2, Cars 3, Toy Story 4, Finding Dory.
All made with the same cautious precision of a committee trying not to offend shareholders.
Ask yourself this. When was the last time a Pixar film surprised you?
Not entertained you? Not distracted your kid for 97 minutes?
I mean, really surprised you?
Pixar used to do that. Under Iger, it became safe.
And safe is just another word for dead in the creative world.
Now if this were a one-time thing, maybe we could chalk it up to the natural entropy of success.
But Iger didn't stop with Pixar.
The company that introduced the world to Mickey Mouse, Cinderella, and Snow White
is adding thousands of new characters to its roster of heroes.
In 2009, he acquired Marvel for $4 billion.
Now Marvel under Disney was initially allowed to run like an independent lab,
thanks largely to Kevin Feige, who, unlike most corporate producers,
actually seemed to understand why people cared about the material.
And the result was a decade-long saga that crescendoed with Avengers Endgame,
a film so universally satisfying that it bought Marvel years of goodwill.
On paper, the MCU is the crown jewel of Iger's legacy.
Billions at the box office, an interconnected web of stories so vast
it turned casual moviegoers into lore-obsessed Reddit archaeologists.
But this was because Feige was allowed to build something
before the suits figured out what he was doing.
He built Marvel like an architect lays a foundation,
one film at a time, deliberately, with payoff in mind.
Then came Disney+, and Marvel went from a cinematic universe to a content farm,
a streaming treadmill that had to keep moving,
whether it had anything to say or not.
Disney Plus needed content.
The theme parks needed synergy.
The merch pipelines needed characters.
So the throttle jammed forward.
In 2021 alone, Marvel released four films and five TV shows,
and not one of them had a fraction of the narrative coherence
that defined the early years.
And then came the Flood.
She-Hulk tried to parody itself, but forgot to be funny.
Thing, Bruce, I'm great at controlling my anger.
I do it all the time.
Secret Invasion promised political intrigue and delivered.
Talking.
Eternals was three hours of, wait, what?
And through it all,
Iger's fingerprints were unmistakable.
More.
Faster.
Safer.
Because in his playbook,
the solution to a wobbling franchise isn't rethinking the approach,
it's doubling the dosage.
Feige himself started looking like a man
who lost his steering wheel somewhere between WandaVision's finale
and whatever it was that happened in Quantumania.
But if Pixar was the canary in the coal mine,
Star Wars is the crater left behind.
I bypassed the compressor.
In 2012, George Lucas handed over a mythos,
and he did it under the naive belief that Disney would respect it.
Instead, they launched a sequel trilogy without a blueprint,
without a plan, without even a narrative spine.
The Force Awakens recycled old glory.
The Last Jedi tried to burn it all down.
And The Rise of Skywalker, I don't even know what that was.
A hostage note written in crayon?
You know what Disney did
when they realized they'd hollowed out the soul of Star Wars?
They slapped Baby Yoda on a lunchbox and called it a strategy.
The Mandalorian was their apology.
Andor was their Hail Mary.
And everything else—
theme parks, Funko Pops,
a dozen greenlit shows they may or may not cancel—
is just a smokescreen.
They broke it.
They know they broke it.
But they think if they keep selling the pieces individually,
no one will notice the holes missing.
But this is what happens when every corner of culture
is run by MBAs who think art is interchangeable with content.
And Iger is their poster child,
the corporate messiah who stands for absolutely nothing
but understands branding everything.
He's the man who thinks acquiring meaning is the same as creating it.
And this, the Iger doctrine, has metastasized.
You see it everywhere—
in tech, in publishing, in education.
Spotify wants to data-mine your emotions,
not help you discover music.
Even college campuses now run like amusement parks with housing plans.
The product is secondary.
The IP is king.
Iger didn't invent this mentality,
but he's arguably its most charismatic salesman.
He represents the executive class
that confuses acquisition with authorship.
Synergy with substance.
His trick is always the same.
Identify what people love, buy it, stretch it thin,
and sell it back to them until it stops working.
You bumped into the ceiling which now has to be washed
and sterilized so you get nothing!
I don't want to apologize for making sequels.
Some of them have done extraordinarily well.
And they've been good films too.
There's a certain irony in watching Bob Iger
heralded as a titan of modern business.
Not because he's failed. He hasn't.
Not in the way Wall Street measures failure.
No, the irony is that his success
is the kind that hollows things out.
Iger's Disney is kind of profitable, sure,
but it's a creative corpse kept twitching
by quarterly earnings and corporate press releases.
You don't need imagination when you have market share.
And maybe that was the best place to start.
Not with the movies, not with the parks,
but with the playbook.
Because Iger's legacy is built on mergers,
definitely not stories,
Marvel, Lucasfilm, Fox.
One by one,
Disney acquired the crown jewels of modern pop culture.
To the investor class, this looked like empire building.
But to anyone who's ever made something from scratch,
it looked like a man collecting tools
he didn't know how to use.
You don't become an architect by buying blueprints.
You become one by building.
When he started the live-action remake era,
the media applauded.
Of course they would.
Iger's crowning achievement as a creative executive
was realizing he didn't need to greenlight new stories
if he could just repackage old ones.
For over a decade now,
Disney's film strategy has been built on the quiet belief
that it's safer to exhume old hits
than to risk making anything new.
And they've somehow convinced the public
that this is an artistic choice
rather than a corporate reflex.
Alice in Wonderland was made for a very specific reason.
Tim Burton plus Johnny Depp plus existing IP equals money.
They saw dark and gritty Batman money
and they wanted in.
It worked.
The film made a billion dollars,
which apparently was enough to greenlight
an entire genre of films
defined by absolutely nothing except
remember this?
We shot it again, but this time in HD.
And audiences did show up
because the brand still had goodwill.
But that's the thing about trust.
It can be spent, but only once.
And Disney spent it recklessly.
Beauty and the Beast,
Aladdin,
The Lion King
each release a little shinier,
a little emptier.
It's not that these remakes
were offensive in their execution.
It's that they were absolutely
unnecessary in their existence.
They weren't made because someone had something to say.
They were made because someone had something to sell.
And that's the distinction that matters,
especially when you're dealing with the stories
that built the house in the first place.
For The Lion King remake,
Disney poured hundreds of millions
into making it photorealistic.
Every hair follicle,
every blade of grass
was rendered with obsessive technical precision.
But in the process,
they drained the film of anything resembling life.
But of course, it made 1.6 billion dollars.
Because that's the scam.
Because these movies are purely designed
to remind you.
You remember that scene, don't you?
That line, that song?
Nostalgia as emotional fast food?
You're not meant to feel something new, no.
You're meant to recall something you felt once
and assume it's the same thing.
It left no cultural footprint.
No one quotes it.
No one rewatches it.
A ghost of the original,
wearing its skin,
but missing its soul.
Because every remake doesn't just fail
to live up to the original.
It quietly rewrites it in the public memory
and replaces iconography with imitation.
And they've gotten bolder,
or maybe just more shameless.
The Little Mermaid didn't even bother
to bring anything new to the table.
Mulan stripped out every ounce of charm,
humor, and melody,
and replaced it with what?
Snow White was probably the worst movie of all time
for very obvious reasons.
But the erosion doesn't stop with the remakes.
It leaks into every corner of the company.
I used to think about the theme parks
as monuments to creative ambition,
but are now shrines to intellectual property.
Galaxy's Edge, for example,
cosplays as Star Wars,
but it's really what an executive thinks
Star Wars feels like.
And somehow, these parks still retain more character
than Disney's film output.
Strange World, Lightyear, Wish.
These went from just being forgettable
to being aggressively forgettable.
You watch them and feel like you're being marketed to
in real time.
Because you are.
The message is never far from the surface,
and the story is always playing second fiddle
to the subtext.
That mindset is probably most visible on Disney+.
The platform was pitched as the company's future,
a launchpad for the next generation of storytelling.
What it became was a content graveyard,
a streaming treadmill churning out IP exploitation
disguised as prestige television.
Shows like Obi-Wan Kenobi, Ahsoka, The Acolyte,
and The Book of Boba Fett
were created to fill slots on a calendar.
But what makes this decline all the more frustrating
is that it wasn't really inevitable.
Disney ran out of courage, not stories.
But the reason so many Disney projects feel soulless
isn't because the artists are untalented,
many probably are,
but it's because the decision makers are afraid.
Afraid of offending the modern progressive dogma,
of taking a swing and missing,
of letting a story breathe
without corporate notes strangling the air out of it.
The problem is,
when a company becomes synonymous with the message,
it stops being a storyteller and starts being a sermon.
And stories, real stories, don't work like that.
They don't teach by dictation.
They teach by resonance,
by empathy,
by risk.
Walt Disney understood that.
But the people running the company today
will call themselves storytellers
when, again, they're really just brand managers.
You lose!
Good day, sir!
It's been a year since I came back
fixing a lot of problems that the company has had
and dealing with a lot of challenges,
some that were brought on by decisions that were made
by my predecessor.
Bob Iger announced his return as CEO of Disney overnight.
Iger retired from the company less than a year ago.
Bob Iger returned to Disney in 2022
like a man walking back into a fire he started,
holding a gas can in one hand
and a press release in the other.
The headlines hailed him as a savior,
the prodigal CEO returning to restore order
after the Bob Chaypek era.
But there was no order to restore,
only the consequences of Iger's own long-term strategy
finally catching up.
You can't really understand Chaypek's failure
without first understanding Iger's success,
or at least what was sold as success.
The relentless focus on streaming came from Iger's
pivot to Disney+,
the golden goose that laid content sludge.
The bloated Marvel lineup was greenlit under Iger.
The obsession with legacy IP, reboots, remakes, sequels
was all part of the architecture Iger built.
Chaypek's real mistake was standing at the podium
when the machine started coughing smoke.
And when Iger returned,
he simply polished the hood and revved the same engine.
One of his first moves was to announce more Star Wars,
led by Rey,
a character whose narrative arc was so poorly received
they practically had to invent a new trilogy
just to justify her presence again.
Add to that another round of Avengers films,
because apparently Phase 47 will fix everything,
and then the live-action remake of Moana, Snow White,
The Little Mermaid, Mufasa, and more.
But of course, it's not just about bad creative decisions.
Those happen.
What we're seeing is a deep-rooted creative paralysis,
an addiction to safety,
a complete pathological aversion to risk.
There's a reason people keep comparing Iger to Michael Eisner.
Eisner was Disney's CEO from 1984 to 2005.
He helped pull the company out of its post-Walt slump
and actually ushered in the Disney Renaissance
with films like The Lion King and Aladdin.
But over time, his reign soured.
His fall came when he shifted from fostering creativity
to exploiting it.
Direct-to-video sequels, fast-food partnerships,
slapdash projects designed to fill market segments.
Iger learned from Eisner's mistakes,
but not in the way you'd hope.
All that changed was the budget and the platform.
The exploitation stayed.
Same manipulation, just better lighting.
Eisner tried to wring dollars out of content he helped create.
Iger never created anything.
He just acquired.
And for a while, it worked.
But there's a shelf life to consumption without creation.
Sooner or later, the inventory dries up
and the factory needs to produce something new.
But it didn't.
And now we're watching the consequences.
In 2019, Disney owned the box office.
In 2023, they couldn't even make Indiana Jones profitable,
a franchise that should have been bulletproof.
The Marvels collapsed because people figured out
they're being served reheat after reheat,
masked as innovation.
But Disney doesn't know how to create anymore
because creation requires belief.
Belief in art over marketing, in story over synergy,
in the gut instinct of a storyteller
instead of the comfort of data analytics.
Iger doesn't believe in those things.
His faith is in consolidation.
He's a businessman who mistook content acquisition for vision,
and now that the properties are depleted,
there's nothing left but the echo of old successes?
And look, maybe that would fly if Disney had a cultural monopoly.
For a while, it almost did.
But audiences are leaving.
It's not like there's no appetite for new things.
Oppenheimer turned a three-hour historical biopic
into an IMAX event.
The audience isn't bored with movies.
They're bored with you.
And still, Disney clings to its old strategies
like an addict justifying one more hit,
pumping theaters full of their films,
pushing out smaller competitors,
dominating screens not because they've earned it
but because they can.
And that's the cruel irony.
For all the talk of inclusivity and diversity
in storytelling at Disney,
the actual business model is pure cultural imperialism.
Crowd everyone else out, saturate the market,
flood the zone with familiar faces,
monopoly masquerading as magic.
And Iger is the guy selling tickets to a show
that stopped being interesting a decade ago,
hoping you won't notice the sets collapsing behind him.

