How Did Our Most Famous Ancestor Really Die?

What Was The Life
13 followers
5 Video Views·Jun 13, 2025
Hi everybody, it's Hank on your friendly local Eon social media of some kind.
Do not forget our 2023 calendar featuring some of our favorite main characters of
paleontology from classic Eons episodes available at ComplexlyCalendars.com.
One day in eastern Africa, about three million years ago, a tree branch cracked and broke,
sending a small human ancestor plummeting to the ground. This wasn't any old tree,
but one that was nearly 14 meters high, almost as tall as a four-story building.
And the poor little hominin didn't survive this,
breaking most of the bones in her body upon impact.
And maybe you know this hominin, or at least you might have heard of her.
Scientists call her Lucy, and her species is Australopithecus afarensis.
And a paper published in 2016 argued that this
might have been how our famous fossil ancestor met her end, by falling out of a tall tree.
But in order to fall from a tree, Lucy would have had to spend time in trees, right?
And scientists are split on whether or not her species was still doing a lot of climbing.
So what actually happened to Lucy? Did she really take an ancient nose dive?
The answer is part of a decades-long debate over how exactly our ancestors
transitioned from life in the trees to life on the ground.
And it turns out that Lucy's fall might be a question that's as much about how
our ancestors lived as it is about how she died.
In 1974, when Lucy was first discovered in what's now Ethiopia,
it was immediately clear that she was a big deal.
From the arid soil, scientists recovered a lot of her fossils,
including fragments of her jaw, spine, ribs, pelvis, arms, and legs.
Her skeleton was about 40% complete, which meant that she contained tons of information.
In contrast, previous discoveries from Africa were often limited to skulls, jaws, and teeth.
Also, she was really old.
By dating the volcanic layers surrounding her fossils,
scientists found that Lucy had been deposited just after 3.18 million years ago.
This made her the oldest fossil human ancestor found at the time.
And this meant that she could answer questions about the evolution
of some of our most unique adaptations.
For example, in what order did our ancestors acquire each of the traits that make up our
unique suite of features today? Like, did we evolve a big brain first?
Or the ability to walk upright on two legs?
Probably the biggest thing that Lucy revealed is that bipedalism had already evolved by the
time her species appeared, a topic we covered in another Eons episode called When We First Walked.
The shape of her pelvis, as well as the inward angle of her femur, and some other features
suggested that she was already an obligate biped.
She had to get around on two legs, not four.
So the combination of Lucy's completeness, her old age, and the insight she provided
into our evolutionary history were the major factors that made her famous.
Of course, it didn't hurt that she had a catchy nickname.
Borrowed from the Beatles song, Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds, the name was given to her
the night of her discovery, when the team was celebrating and that song came on.
But since Lucy was uncovered in the 1970s, her story has only gotten more interesting.
Scientists have continued studying her for decades, and they've found more than 400
additional specimens belonging to her species, Australopithecus afarensis.
These come from across Ethiopia, Kenya, and Tanzania and date from 3.7 to 3 million years ago.
This makes Australopithecus afarensis one of the longest existing species of early human ancestors.
But even after decades of research, we still haven't learned all there is to know about Lucy.
In 2015, a group of scientists became interested in the amount of damage they could see on her
fossilized bones. Lucy appeared to have a lot of fractures. Based on the pattern,
they concluded that a fall from a tall tree had caused the breaks.
Their interpretation of the fractures was that Lucy had stretched her hands out in front of her
to try to stop her fall, breaking her hands, wrists, arms, shoulders, and jaw in the process.
Basically, she was a wreck. It was an astonishing idea,
one that allowed us to vividly imagine what might have been her final moments.
But while the idea that Lucy fell made headlines all over the world,
it was received a bit more skeptically across the scientific community,
because it fueled a debate that, like Lucy herself, had been around for decades.
Did life in the trees remain important to Australopithecus afarensis,
even after they found their footing on the ground?
Now, we know that before our lineage split off from the one that led to chimpanzees,
our shared ancestors were up in the trees. After that split, the members of our branch
of the family tree transitioned to life on the ground, potentially starting around
six or seven million years ago. But the move down to the African forest floor
didn't happen overnight. There were likely many different stages in the transition,
and because of where Lucy sits in the family tree, her species potentially is a key piece
of the puzzle. And since we can't go back in time and observe whether Lucy was hanging out in trees,
we have to go on the skeletal evidence. We already know from her lower body,
specifically her femur, that there's no question that Lucy and other members of her species
were adapted to be skilled walkers. But when we look at their upper bodies,
the picture starts to get interesting. A shoulder blade preserved from a juvenile of her species,
nicknamed Lucy's Baby, looked more like a tree climber than a permanent ground dweller.
And the slightly curved finger bones seen in her species are well adapted for grasping branches.
So Australopithecus afarensis had some adaptations from moving through the trees,
but did they actually use them? Some scientists think that these traits in Australopithecus are
just a useless evolutionary holdover. See, natural selection really only modifies what's
important at that time. Other stuff sometimes just gets left as is, sticking around long after
losing its evolutionary purpose. And this brings up an important distinction. Does the skeletal
evidence point to things that a hominin's body could physically do, or is it pointing to a thing
that hominins actually did? There might have been some advantages to being a good tree climber,
even after becoming a good walker. For example, some other ground-dwelling apes, like chimpanzees,
often build nests and tree canopies to sleep. This strategy would have worked well for hominins
like Lucy. She was small, only about a meter tall, and not particularly fast, a prime candidate
to be preyed upon by big cats and other fierce predators. But behaviors like nest building and
canopy sleeping don't really fossilize. And this is where Lucy's fall comes in. It offered a
potential new type of evidence that theoretically showed what Lucy actually did. By arguing that
she fell from a tree, the researchers were suggesting that she was essentially caught
in the act of being in trees. And while broken bones that might have been caused by falls have
been proposed for other hominins, there was one major problem in this particular case.
Their fracture patterns weren't unique to Lucy. When the 2016 study that put forward the fall
idea first appeared, researchers working at her discovery site, a place called Hadar,
quickly objected. They said that similar fractures were prevalent on the bones of other animals,
like elephants, giraffes, and rhinos, found throughout the site, not just on Lucy.
Lucy's discoverers pointed out that it was more likely that the damage was produced by
fossilization processes, resulting from millions of years in the ground. During that time,
their bones were probably exposed to water, crushing events, pressure from the sedimentary
layers above, erosion, and even plate tectonics. This type of damage better explains why these
fractures appeared across species at this single location. Because as one researcher pointed out,
rhinos weren't exactly falling out of four-story high trees. So while Lucy's fall was possible,
the scientists hypothesizing it didn't consider all the other explanations for these kinds of
fractures, which is a must in science. And the question of whether her species still spent time
in the trees, or how much time they spent there, is still open. So while the fall hypothesis kind
of lost its footing, what the study really shows is that Lucy's bones still have things to teach us.
And even after decades of research, we still love Lucy.
We're falling for this month's Eontologists!
Jaxi Weiss, Colton, Melanie Lamb Carnevale, Annie and Eric Higgins, John Davison Ng, and Jake Hart.
Become an Eonite at patreon.com slash eons and you can get fun perks like submitting a joke for us
to read. Like this one from Cassie W. Where did the female Dromysaurid live? I don't know, but Alaska.
It didn't make sense until I heard myself say it out loud. And then it just became so much worse.
And as always, thank you for joining me in the Adam Lowe Studio. Subscribe at youtube.com slash
eons for more fabulous fossils. This line just reminds me of Cher. And since we can't go back in
time and observe whether Lucy was hanging out in trees. If I could turn back time.
And since, and since we can't go, now it's in my head. Picturing Cher on the battleship. Yes.
