'Lodovico Capponi' (c. 1550–1555) by Agnolo Bronzino

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
4 Video Views·Jun 13, 2025
Curator Aimee Ng explores the life of Lodovico Capponi, the subject of a 16th-century portrait at the Frick by Agnolo Bronzino. A page at the Medici court, Lodovico had the misfortune of falling in love with a Florentine noblewoman whom Duke Cosimo I intended to marry to one of his cousins. Join Aimee with an Aperol Spritz as she discusses one of her favorite works in the museum and examines what some of the details—from his black-and-white outfit to the partially obscured cameo in his right hand—may tell us about the young man and his life.
Hello, I'm Amy Ng, Curator at The Frick Collection in New York, and welcome to another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
Before I start the episode, we've been so thrilled with how many visitors and virtual visitors and viewers we've had from around the world.
And we wanted to invite all of you to attend The Frick's very first virtual gala, which will be taking place on October 19th.
And for more information on that, please click on the link that's in the pinned comment below.
In addition to a very full roster of wonderful presentations and entertainment,
I will be giving a special tour of the second floor of The Frick Mansion at 1 East 70th Street,
which will be transformed into public galleries during the building's renovation project.
So please do click the link in the pinned comment if you want to hear a little bit more about that.
This episode is about an Italian Renaissance painting, Bronzino's Lodovico Caponi.
And because of that, I decided to pair this work of art with a very Italian cocktail, which is an Aperol Spritz.
Bronzino, of course, and this painting is very Florentine.
Aperol has its origins in the north, in the Veneto.
But I think it is a drink that is enjoyed all, not just through Italy, but the world over to some degree.
Aperol Spritz, that name has two components.
The Aperol part being the orange flavored liqueur that was invented in 1919 in Padua in the Veneto by the Barbieri brothers.
The Spritz part is, Spritz, many of you will have heard of this word.
It's actually from the German Spritzen, to splash or to spray.
And the story goes that after the Napoleonic Wars, the Veneto region of northern Italy was occupied by Austro-Hungarian soldiers
who found the taste and the strength of wines from this region to be unusual and not entirely palatable as is.
So they would Spritzen, there would be a splash or a spray of water to sort of temper the wine.
Hence you get the Spritz or Spritzer.
An Aperol Spritz is a three to one recipe.
Three parts Prosecco, dry Prosecco, two parts Aperol, and one splash of soda water.
You can garnish that with an orange or a lemon slice.
Cheers.
That just one taste can almost transport one to a piazza in Florence during aperitivo hour.
Almost, but not quite.
I have the pleasure of talking to you about this painting, Lodovico Caponi by Bronzino.
And Xavier and I, you know, all through these programs, we talk so much about our favorite this and our favorite that
and so many things are high up on our list of favorites.
This one really is one of my most favorite, if not favorite works at the Frick Collection.
And years and well before I started to work at the Frick as a curator,
this is a painting that I would come to visit.
Every time I came to the museum, I would make sure to stop by and say hello to this one.
I know I'm not the only one.
There was, in 2004, a writer, David Masello, who published in the New York Times
a beautiful and very moving piece titled My Friend Lodovico,
which really was about this friendship that he had formed with this painting.
It's a painting that he would visit when he would go to the Upper East Side and would pop into the Frick.
After a bad breakup, he would come see Lodovico.
In the days after September 11th, he came to see Lodovico.
So this is a painting that's at the heart of many people who are close to the Frick.
Though he might be a friend to many people, he's not a particularly friendly face.
It's a very cold, sort of closed, somewhat impassive face on this young man.
And this is a hallmark of the painter Bronzino,
who is very well known as a portraitist with this kind of sitter,
this sort of porcelain-closed face.
Bronzino was born in 1503 in Florence, lived his life in Florence, died in Florence.
He was born Agnolo di Cosimo, and we're not sure exactly how and why he came to be known as Bronzino,
even Agnolo di Bronzino.
There's some speculation that it had something to do with his complexion,
perhaps that he was somewhat darker in complexion than his Italian contemporaries.
Bronzino, the bronze one, if you're tanned in Italian, you are abbronzato.
Again, we don't know the origins of the name.
You can't really talk about Bronzino and his career in Florence
without talking about the Medici family.
Bronzino was appointed court painter to Cosimo I,
who was second duke of Florence and who was appointed grand duke of Tuscany in 1569.
The best known of Bronzino's portraits probably is the wife of Cosimo I,
who is Eleonora da Toledo.
This is her with her son Giovanni,
who unfortunately died not too long after the painting of this portrait of malaria.
This is one of Bronzino's most famous and also most copied, most reproduced works of art.
It has everything that one wants in a Bronzino,
the fabulous outfit, the elongated limbs, those fingers that are impossibly long,
the porcelain, flawless faces.
And when you look closely at any Bronzino, but in particular this one of Eleonora,
you get a sense of his commitment to meticulous detail
and particularly in articles of clothing of high luxury,
like this amazing brocaded dress.
And when you think that the court tailor to the Medici court
had about the equivalent salary as the court painter Bronzino,
you get a sense of how important it was not only to dress Eleonora this way,
but also for the artist who could convey her as well in this way,
immortalized as he did her in paint.
But if the elegance and sophistication and refinement of Bronzino
is the most characteristic of his art,
there's another side to Bronzino too, which is somewhat more carnal.
Subversive, maybe a little bit more base.
This is his portrait of Nanno Morgante,
who was the court jester to the Medici court.
And this was a portrait that Bronzino submitted as his contribution to a debate,
an artistic debate happening in the middle of the 16th century,
which had a long life actually in the Renaissance and after the Peragone,
which art was the most important, the most superior.
Painting or sculpture.
Well, Bronzino submitted this as part of his contribution to this debate,
his portrait of Nanno Morgante from the front,
and it's a double-sided portrait, also Morgante from the back.
And again, so this sort of subversive other side to Bronzino.
And these extremes, this duality of the highly elegant and sophisticated
and the somewhat more base also exists in Bronzino's production in poetry.
He was a very accomplished poet and his poetry could reach the highs
of Petrarchan verses, Petrarchan style,
down to something a little bit more subversive and base.
For example, a poem of his entitled Il Piatto, The Debate,
which is really a sort of allegorical but highly descriptive poem
about a journey through a giant's body,
the whole body of this individual.
The Frick portrait is a later portrait by Bronzino.
It has everything that one wants in a late portrait by Bronzino,
the extreme refinement, those impossibly long fingers, the porcelain face,
but it has no shortage of wit, as we will see, as many of you know.
Ludovico Caponi here is shown as a young man.
He's probably in his late teens, early twenties.
This is stylistically dated to the 1550s, early 1550s.
Ludovico Caponi was a page at the Medici court.
And some of you may find the name Ludovico Caponi familiar,
especially those of you who are familiar with the city of Florence
and its Renaissance works,
because Ludovico's father, also called Ludovico Caponi,
was the patron of the Caponi Chapel in Santa Felicità,
in which Pontormo painted his great altarpiece of the deposition
or the entombment, whichever one you want to call it.
Bronzino probably had a hand in the decoration of this chapel,
most probably in the roundels above.
And this may have been where he met the Caponi family
for whom he would paint later,
the Pontormo painting, of course, in situ,
and painted in the late 1520s.
The wit of this painting is sort of startling at first
when you meet this picture.
Yes, there's this amazingly authoritative young man
set against this bright green backdrop,
but it's not a backdrop that's pretending to be
a domestic space in the home.
This is a backdrop that seems right out of an artist's studio.
Its artifice, its dramatic draping being right there,
declaring itself to some degree as a constructed portrait.
It sort of takes on a life of its own back there
with its ripples and its waves.
This young man, barely out of his teens probably,
but looking out so strongly with such great authority.
And when I say impassive,
there's really nothing that's going to get by this young man.
Those cold, grey-blue eyes, that slightly raised eyebrow,
the left eye just a little bit wall-eyed.
Not anything, no humour, nothing,
just the stoicism of somebody who's very serious
about who he is.
And yet that ruddy, that wonderful red hair
that's tussled in every which direction
and which points to his youth.
His clothing, the white sleeves
and the obviously very fitted satin and velvet doublet,
these two colours, the black and the white,
scholars have associated with the Caponi coat of arms,
which is a coat of arms that is exactly black and white.
It's nowhere near as sumptuous
as the costume of Eleonora d'Atoledo, of course.
But when you look very closely,
the very simple, from a distance,
very simple white sleeves are slashed
in the tiniest little strokes, purposefully, of course,
in order to reveal the sumptuous material below,
another layer of silk weave of some sort, very expensive.
Every thread, every fray articulated carefully by Bronzino,
just as he did the gold brocade of Eleonora's dress.
And down to the cuff, the meticulous needlepoint
and needlework of the embroidery and black of that cuff,
Bronzino also articulates in his very fine brushstrokes.
In the years of teaching and giving gallery talks
and discussing this painting with our museum visitors,
particularly our younger visitors,
a certain question has come up again and again,
and that is about the placement of Ludovico's sword.
You're right, when you look closely, many of you will know,
he does not carry a sword.
And the article of clothing,
the accessory that some of these visitors
are mistaking for a sword,
is an example of that fascinating chapter
in the history of European men's fashion,
called the codpiece.
This is neither the time nor the place
to go into the history of the codpiece, of course,
but it had its origins as a very simple flap of fabric
that covered this part of the man's body
between the two pant legs,
which eventually, of course, it grew to take on a life of its own.
And as it became more exaggerated, more flamboyant,
stuffed, larger, more protruding,
it came more and more, of course,
to represent masculine virility, strength,
exactly what a sword hilt hanging from the side of a man
would signal to those who could see him,
somebody who was very strong, again, masculine virility.
And you can see also the other accessory
low down in the composition,
right down at the bottom edge,
held in his left hand is a pair of brown gloves.
You can see just the fingers behind his hand in the shadows.
Now, gloves, of course, from the Renaissance
onward for men and for women
through many countries in Europe,
all the way through to the 19th century and beyond,
are a symbol, of course, of fashion, of luxury,
of wealth, of practicality to some degree.
In this portrait, the fact that he's got them off
and he's holding them invites a little bit of informality.
He has taken them off.
He has exposed something of his flesh.
I wouldn't say it's deeply intimate,
but it's a little bit more informal
that he has removed the gloves
and he's in our presence with exposed flesh.
On the other side of that exposure, of course, though,
is a deliberate obscuring.
In his right hand,
with those impulsively long and elegant fingers,
he holds an object that he is at the same time
kind of hiding from our view.
It is a round object, kind of like a cameo,
and I'm showing you on the right
just an example of the kind of object that this could be.
The object on the right is a middle-of-the-16th-century
Italian cameo carved from shell,
so the various layers of the shell would reveal white,
and then you go a little bit further down
and a dark background.
That's probably what we're seeing
painted in the Bronzino portrait,
although we don't see much more of its details.
It is encased in some kind of frame
like the one that you see on the lower right here.
This is, again, a middle-of-the-16th-century Italian.
It's actually a wax model.
It's white wax on a black background encased in a frame.
The sitter is Ferrante Loffredo.
This is in the Schur collection,
which is affiliated, of course,
with the Frick collection in some ways.
What Bronzino has painted in is probably a female bust,
so a portrait of a woman.
We cannot see her face.
We can just see the top of her head and the dress
and a few letters,
and the letters that are visible are S-O-R-T-E,
an Italian fate or fortune.
Some scholars have suggested
that this is just half of the word that we're seeing,
that the legend on this cameo or medal
goes all the way around,
that maybe it's consorte, so consort or wife.
We just don't know.
When we think about Bronzino being also a poet,
it gives a little bit of richness to the possibilities.
He's playing, this is a visual game,
also with words.
What exactly he's playing with, it's not so clear,
but there's certainly a game going on here
with whoever his viewer was meant to be.
Some scholars have associated this game
of you don't know your fortune,
or he's concealing his fortune, his future,
his wife, his love,
with the true drama
of Lodovico Caponi's life and biography.
We know a lot about his biography
because there is an extensive biography
written about him during his lifetime.
He fell in love with a woman,
a Florentine noblewoman called Maddalena Vittori,
and it was not meant to be
because the duke, Cosimo I,
did not approve of this match
because he wanted Maddalena to marry a cousin of his.
So Cosimo I really stood between
Lodovico and Maddalena getting together,
but they held this relationship in secret for some time,
and he even rented a palazzo nearby
to the one she lived in
so that he could see her as she walked on the streets
because they weren't allowed to get together.
It's very romantic.
Eventually, it's the duchess, Eleonora da Toledo,
that fabulous woman painted by Bronzino with her son,
she intervenes and finally convinces Cosimo I, the duke,
to allow these two young people to get married.
Cosimo relents and he consents to the marriage
only if they would get married right away,
within three days, which is what happens.
They go on to have eight,
some sources say six children,
and he, Lodovico, lives a very long life.
He dies at the age of 80 in 1614.
It should be said that the dating of this painting
to somewhere between 1550 to 1555,
when Lodovico is in his late teens, early twenties,
this is a dating based on stylistic evaluation.
There is no primary source,
there's no inscription that gives us the date
or even identifies the sitter.
So this is something that is based on comparison
with other works of art by Bronzino at that time.
And so some may wonder,
how do we know that the sitter is Lodovico Caponi?
Well, the identification was made in the 1950s
by an Italian scholar called Luisa Beccarucci.
And she, Beccarucci, discovered something
that was the key to her identification
in Palazzo Caponi in Florence.
There are actually two Palazzo Caponi,
Palazzi Caponi in Florence.
This is a view of the Arno,
the very thick bridge in the middle,
of course, is the Ponte Vecchio.
And on either side,
the one on the right is the Palazzo Caponi
and on the left is the Palazzo Caponi.
On the right is Palazzo Caponi alle Rovinate.
This has been the ancestral home
of the Caponi family for a very long time
and still to this day is a private residence
and has many beautiful works of art.
On the left is Palazzo Caponi Vittori.
So this was originally of Maddalena Vittori's family.
When they got married,
it became part of the estate of Lodovico Caponi.
It's in the one on the left,
Palazzo Caponi Vittori,
here on Lungarno Ricciardini,
that the object of interest
is connected to the Frick picture.
This is now a fabulous luxury hotel.
In the Salone, or the Grand Salon,
there is an extensive decoration in fresco
made in 1585
by the Italian painter Bernardino Pochetti.
And this is a room and decoration
that celebrates moments in the history
of the Caponi family.
For example, in this lunette painting,
it is commemorating a moment in 1431
when Neriti Gino Caponi has a great military victory.
Below this lunette,
I hope some of you can see a small portrait,
and I'll show you a detail of that here.
This is the portrait that appears below that lunette,
and it is unmistakably based on the Frick portrait.
Of course, the portrait in Palazzo Caponi
is wearing something different.
He's wearing a gorget,
a part of armor that protects the neck.
But even down to the tussle of hair,
that sort of slightly uncontrolled curls
of this young man's hair
are clearly taken from the Frick.
There is an inscription on the ceiling
that attributes the commission
of that whole decoration of the room in the Salone
in Palazzo Caponi to Lodovico Caponi.
So that is how this identification has been made.
Lower down the wall,
there is a portrait of presumably Maddalena Vettori.
It seems, unfortunately,
Pochetti did not have a great bronzino portrait of her
to model his portrait from.
And on an end wall,
I hope you can see just beneath the two lunette paintings,
are two portraits of very young women,
presumably two of the children of Lodovico and Maddalena.
There are, however,
a number of empty medallions in this decoration.
There are six empty medallions
where presumably children of Lodovico and Maddalena
would have appeared.
It's unclear why in 1585,
when Lodovico Caponi is in his fifties,
he is choosing, or with the artist,
choosing to represent himself
in this room of history of his family
based on a portrait made 30 years ago of him
as a late teen, early twenties,
as a very young man.
This painting, the Frick painting,
must have meant a lot to him.
It must have been a very important part of his life
for it to still stand as the source
to represent himself 30 years later
in a room that encapsulates his place in a family history.
So I hope those of you who were not so familiar
with this portrait before
got to know Lodovico a little bit better.
For the rest of us, there are mysteries that will remain.
What exactly is he holding in his hand
and what is he trying to convey with it?
When exactly and for what was this portrait made?
And what special place did it have
in the life and in the identity
of Lodovico Caponi that it would serve this purpose
as a source 30 years later
for his identity as a 50-something-year-old man
in this room in Palazzo Caponi?
Well, like any good friend,
no matter how well you know them,
there's always more to discover.
And with that, I will take a sip of my Aperol spritz
and try, try to have it sort of transport me
to my favorite bar in Florence
in the company of good friends
overlooking the Arno on a warm autumn afternoon.
Thank you so much for tuning in.
We'll see you again next week.
