"It's Pretty Sad!" Andy Mitten CLAIMS Rashford Leaving Man United Is The RIGHT Move!

Marcus Rashford
2 followers
7 Video Views·Jun 12, 2025
Charlie Baker and Barry Glendenning are joined by Andy Mitten to discuss Marcus Rashford's imminent move to Aston Villa.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Marcus Rashford, if he does leave for Aston Villa, will he go with fans' good thoughts
ringing in his ears or will it be just a fail to deliver?
It's pretty sad for me that it's come to this because on his day he's a player who touches
sort of world-class levels and probably been the brightest youth prospect since the one who's
touched closely to sort of the Ronaldo and the Rooney levels and at times you thought
he could go on to be a truly world-class player and Barcelona were interested in recently because
they saw what he did to them in 2023 as he wrote the game so I spoke to the manager
about that pretty recently and Marcus Rashford got that huge contract because there was a belief that
he deserved that huge contract because he was one of the best paid players in the world and
fortunately his career has been marked with too many periods where he's not been productive enough
and he hasn't come close to feeling like he's giving value for money. There's lots of mitigation
here, lots. Someone said to me recently if his career had started at the same time as one of
the class of 92 lads under Alex Ferguson it would look very different and I think that is a fair
point. He's been asked to play different styles of football and under different managers and it's
a confidence thing as well. I think it's the right thing for him to move on. I think he's made
mistakes as well. He's human. I think it's such a goldfish but I think for modern football
is at that level it's such a goldfish bowl now even more so than it was for Fergie's era
that I think that amount of pressure constantly online, wherever you go, on TV, all those things
I think that can't be underestimated. And also living in the city where you grew up
that only adds to the pressure. Manchester sits at the heart of a conurbation of 2.8 million
it's the second biggest in the UK but it's like a village socially and that just adds pressure.
I think fans are harder on their own but I think fans have been very patient and supportive of
Marcus Rashford but that patience is all but exhausted and brings me back to my opening word
it's sad that it has come to this. I've long wanted him to be a success at Manchester United.
I hope that he goes on loan and is a success and comes back and is a success but I realise
the chances of that, the probability that, given how loans tend to work out, are pretty minimal
and you'd like to think good luck to your lad but I'm hesitant, I'm shaking my head
because I feel so conflicted about the whole thing and it didn't start this season that badly
but he's a manager who is going to do things his way and he's absolutely adamant he's doing
things his way and in his opinion Marcus Rashford was not right to be being picked in his matchday squads.
I'm going to put a slightly contrarian opinion out there which you're welcome to rub it
but is Rashford actually that good because if you look at his numbers he's a one in three, one goal
in every three games striker, 138 in 426 games in all competitions, he doesn't provide that many
assists and for the money he's on, is he bringing anywhere near enough to the party?
Well he's not but I'm not sure Lionel Messi could be standing out in the Manchester United side,
Marcus Rashford has played him, if he would have had Rooney and Tevez and Ronaldo about him
I'm sure Marcus Rashford would have been more productive, he would have played more matches.
I do think there's a huge talent there and I've seen him score winners in Manchester derbies,
I've seen him drag the ball down at Granada away in a Europa League game and put the ball in the
net in such an exquisite style where you think with respect to say Danny Welbeck, Marcus is
a level above that and Danny Welbeck's got many many virtues and has had a very successful career
so not for nothing was Marcus put on that huge huge contract and the fans backed him, they sang
his name, he could have gone to Manchester City when he was a kid but his numbers are poor, you're
right Barry, this season and in too many of his seasons his numbers are poor so it's partly on
the team but it's also partly on him. I remember speaking to him in Perth 2022 at the end of a very
productive pre-season and he made the point that this is my first proper pre-season, I'm like what
you've never had one? No, he'd been injured, he'd been in international football, I just see a
negative cycle where confidence goes down, he gets ostracised, he gets frustrated, the fans turn on him,
fans can change the tune very quickly, the best example I give on that is probably a year ago
today, Man United at Wolves away, I stood outside the away end, I couldn't find a single Manchester
United fan who wanted Marcus Rashford to stay at the club because this was a few days after
going to Belfast which is a misdemeanor but it's not on the scale of some Manchester United greats
of the past and you know things are judged differently, society's changed as well and
the game started and Marcus Rashford scored and those very same fans were singing his name
so tunes can change very quickly and have done but the overall picture has been a bleaker one
which has led to Manchester United letting him go, I know he fancied Barcelona, I'm not
sure where he would have got in that team with Lewandowski, Lamine Yamal, Rafinha in his
three positions, Villa, I've liked Emery, I thought the British media were very unfair on Unai Emery,
I've been down to Villarreal and spent time with Unai Emery, I think he's a really, really impressive
coach and he's very successful at what he does so maybe that might be good for Marcus Rashford,
maybe a change of scene, being out of Manchester could all be good for him.
Yeah, finally Andy, it's Man United Crystal Palace today going for four wins in a row so
maybe the Amerim effect is taking hold, what do you expect from today?
Truthfully I'm nervous because Manchester United seem to be worse against teams at Old Trafford
and against teams who are not at the top so we've had these really good results at
City away, Liverpool away, Arsenal away in the cup but it's different at Old Trafford,
the record at Old Trafford this season is absolutely appalling so I'm nervous,
I'll be watching it thinking you know okay we've got to 10 minutes and Palace haven't scored yet
and this is the reality so I hope it changes at some point, I think it will change, I've been
impressed by Emery, I was at all the games in the last few weeks, I got back yesterday from
Bucharest and FCS being up Premier League quality but it was a pretty controlled and
routine win for Manchester United and we don't see them anymore, we used to see them against
Crystal Palace at Old Trafford, Palace have now got a much better record against Manchester United
than United have against Palace. Andy thanks for joining us, appreciate it. Thanks Andy.
Thank you. There we are, Andy Witton there, author of United We Stand with a Man United
Crystal Palace preview, did you learn everything you wanted to learn? Did you know more at the end
of the interview than you knew at the beginning of it Barry? Because that's the point. Yes,
I think Andy Witton is one of the most interesting people I've ever spoken to in football and I love
doing chats with him. Well there we are, we just had a chat with one of the most interesting people
in football that Barry's ever met and that is the warm-up on Talk Sport with Travis Perkins.
On AM, on DAV, via the Talk Sport app and on your smart speaker. Talk Sport.
