The Strange Origin Of Cave Temples - Hugh Newman Vs Praveen Mohan

ancient literature
168 followers
Hey guys, today we're going to look at an ancient...
Hey guys, today we're here at Mandika Patu here in ancient India.
So we have Hugh Newman who's a big celebrity. He's actually living in England and he's now
in India. He's the man behind Megalithomania. This is a YouTube channel. He does a lot of
conferences. He has appeared on BBC, he's on Ancient Aliens, on History Channel,
he's on Bosnian TV, he is on Skynet Australia, Gaia TV, amongst other things. He has written
many books, he has produced different documentaries. I'm lucky to have him and we're going to explore
Mandika Patu temple which is at least 1400 years in India. But there's something really unique
about the Mandika Patu site. Can you tell me what it is? It's completely different than most of the
temples built in ancient India. It's built with a negative construction technique. Now what does
it mean? What's a negative construction technique? So how would you build your house?
Or how would you build an office or a temple or whatever? So you start from the ground level and
you start adding materials to it. This is how we do it. This is what we think about when we talk
about constructing something. But here, it's not built by adding material to it. It's built by
removing materials to it. So this is really crazy. Most people don't understand
that this is really unique about this temple. Nothing is added to create this temple.
So this temple was created by removing materials. So it's like a negative construction technique.
Yeah, that's interesting, isn't it? Because it also makes it like a permanent temple.
Yes. It's never going to go anywhere. You can't take a stone away.
Yes, exactly. You can't destroy it. It's almost like this permanent,
megalithic, like immortal space. Yes. Okay, let's go up and take a closer look.
Wow. Hugh, let's remove our shoes here. Sure. So just because these are still Hindu temples
and we'll just try to be as respectful as we can. According to historians,
this is 1400 years old. Mandagapattu is a 1400 year old site, which makes it one of the oldest
monolithic temples in South India, if not the oldest in South India. Some historians argue
that we have Badami Caves, which is also built around the same time. They think Badami Caves was
built maybe a few decades before this. But this is at least the oldest monolithic temple made out
of one stone in this state. So officially, this is the oldest temple in this state around 1400
years old. But is there absolute proof of this? I mean, could it be much older? Were these
god-like figures added later? I mean, what do you think?
This is a good question. I always wonder about this. I always think the temples are
built much, much older back in time. I would even say 5,000 years old, 10,000 years old.
Sometimes I say, is it possible that these temples were built 12,000 years ago? Okay. But
that's why I say this is a unique temple. Okay. So we have this. Okay. So here you have an
inscription. Yeah. Okay. And we're going to try and see what this inscription says. Can you read
this here? Absolutely not. No chance. Yeah. So we're going to try to spray some water and see
if we can read the inscription. Okay. So here I have pure distilled water guys. This is distilled
water that I'm using. So this way we don't damage the inscriptions, you know. But as you can see,
it's not really clear. So I'm going to spray some water and see if that brings it out. Okay.
But you can see at least some parts of this coming out. So what the inscription says here,
this inscription is in Sanskrit here. It says,
So what does that mean, right? So what that means is that he says,
this temple was built without adding any wood or timber. No metal was added. No bricks were added.
Not even a binding material like lime mortar was added to this. So this temple was built
without adding anything by a person called Vichitra Chittan. Okay. And this is the name
of a king called Mahendra Varman who lived 1400 years ago. So, and this is a theory. And of course
you could argue that Vichitra Chittan was not the name of Mahendra Varman. So that's one point.
Okay. So we don't know like perfectly, we don't know for sure if this was built 1400 years ago,
because it doesn't say the name of the king directly. It doesn't say Mahendra Varman.
It says Vichitra Chittan, which means a weird architect, which means a strange architect.
That's what it actually means. Really? Yeah. It means a strange architect. Do you think they're
kind of hinting at some kind of like, like magician or some kind of elite? I would like to
think so. Because the other thing is, is that to me, these, this inscription looks like it could
easily have been added later. It's possible. It doesn't look like it's extremely high quality,
like much of this temple is. Well, that's a good point. And I don't know. I mean, that's just,
that's one of the things we find in Egypt, for instance, like if you go to the Serapeum at
Saqqara, there's inscriptions on these beautifully cut, polished, you know, stung granite sarcophagi,
but the inscriptions are clearly added later. They're much less quality. Okay. And it makes
me wonder about many of these temples, were they super ancient? And then, then the decoration and
the writing may have been added later. And I'm just purely speculating. I could be wrong. Right.
It's just the sort of feeling I get when you look at, you compare it to other places around the
world. Right. That's, that's an excellent theory. So Hugh's bringing up something really, really
interesting. He's saying that, is it possible that this inscription was added later? Because
he's saying that the quality of the pillars and everything looks really amazing. But look at the
inscription. It's definitely of low quality. Okay. That, that's an excellent point here.
Let's go inside, see what else we can find. Okay. Okay. So let's go to that central chamber
and tell me what you think. Yeah, this is very, very interesting. This is,
oh, so this almost feels like it's some kind of a meditation chamber to me. That's what I get
feeling. I sort of feel, sense that a couple of other sites, I mean, I don't know. I mean,
was there once a lingam here? Is that now gone? And why is there some kind of spillage there?
Is that because there was a lingam? You tell me, what do you think? Well, I don't know. I mean,
it just seems like that. There should be. There should have been a lingam here, right? Yeah. But
do you think it's gone? It appears that way. I mean, there's, it's almost like a space for it.
And I don't know, I mean, because it's so old, this place and, you know, we are speculating,
it could be really old. Okay. We just don't know, you know, we don't really know what was going on,
but I just get a sense of this. Obviously, this is the kind of holy of holies.
You know, this is a central chamber, probably dedicated to Lord Shiva. Yeah. Let's go and look
at that, that chamber. So this was probably a chamber dedicated to Lord Brahma. Okay. But
where is Lord Brahma? Yeah, true. Where are the statues? And it's like, so in a general sense,
you have Vishnu on one side, Shiva in the middle, and Brahma on this side. Is this a general thing
we find in most temples? Yeah. I mean, even in the earliest temples, would that be the case?
Yes. Okay. So do you know, I mean, do you know if any statues or anything or lingams were found
here? Or is this, is it always been a sort of sparse temple like this, with no ornamentation
as such? See, this is a very good question, right? No historian has addressed this question,
because the inscription that I read says this is a temple dedicated to Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva.
So it talks about three gods, right? Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. But where are the gods? The gods are
not there, right? The inscription also said something important. It said nothing was added to
it. Right. So there maybe was nothing else here then? So if it was added, that falsifies the
inscription. Gosh, okay. It gets very confusing after a while when you kind of try and compare
what the reality to what the inscriptions say. Right. If it was dedicated to Brahma, Vishnu and
Shiva, where are the statues? You see, let's go and take a look at the third chamber. Yeah.
So this is the third chamber, right? This is probably dedicated to Vishnu. Again,
what does the inscription say, right? It says that this temple is dedicated to three gods,
Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. But where are the gods? The gods are missing,
right? And you don't see a sign of destruction. If it was destroyed, it would look completely
different, right? You would see the broken stuff here. So where are the gods? The gods are missing.
So that goes against the inscription. If you argue that these statues were made of wood or metal
and they were just installed here, again, that goes against the inscription. Yeah. Because
the inscription says nothing was added to it. Yeah. You see, and now we're in a complete...
Nobody is addressing this, actually. No historian or archaeologist has addressed this. Because what
we find in the inscription is not matching up with what we see here. Is it possible that we're
looking at an invisible statue? I'd like to... Is it possible that they were thinking that Brahma,
Vishnu and Shiva were invisible gods at that time? Well, you know, that's one possibility.
Another possibility, you can definitely argue that maybe the inscription was added later.
Maybe there's something missing that we don't understand. There is one thing, but that being
pretty much the only inscription here, there's none in here. There's none on the walls. There's
none on any of the pillars or anything like this. Yes. There's none in the chambers. Right. So that,
to me, that kind of reminds me of a place like ancient Egypt and ancient Peru, where the older,
more megalithic sites don't have any inscriptions, like the Great Pyramid even. It's only later
temples from a much later era that they started putting all the hieroglyphs on. And so it just
feels a bit like that. This feels like one of the sort of pristine, super ancient temples.
Do you have an example of a site in Egypt where you think the inscription was added later?
Definitely. I mean, I think not dissimilar to this is the Assyrion at Abydos in southern Egypt,
where there's no inscriptions there originally. But later, Seti I started putting inscriptions
on top of the temple, on top of the surfaces. Oh, at Assyrion and Abydos, right? Yeah. And that's
the giant megalithic, almost subterranean temple, which has got 200 ton, 300 ton blocks.
There's one more detail that you're going to like. Okay. You see this? Yeah.
And you see that on the other side? Yeah. What is that? You see here?
Okay. Yeah. What is that? You see these square slots, two on this side and two on this side?
I have no idea. What would that be? A door? Exactly. A door. So would this have been a
stone door? That's the question, isn't it? Because if the inscription is true,
they cannot add anything from the outside, right? They cannot put a wooden or a metal door. So he
had to carve this. If the inscription is true, and if these slots were put there for the doors,
he had to carve a swinging door from the bedrock itself. Yes. Is that even possible
to create a monolithic door that's a part of the entire big stone? Is such a technology even
possible? Yeah, that'd be difficult, wouldn't it? It's beyond my imagination. But if that
inscription is true, that's the only way. Because he says, no, I'm not going to add anything to this.
Yeah, yeah, that's true. I mean, you've got all the kind of parts to kind of place something.
Right. So it just seems like it could well be, it could be something there. But would that be
sealed off? Or would it be, you know, open it from, would it be, would it be split down the
middle, open like this, like a cupboard? Yeah. That is fascinating, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah. See,
again, you can see the same slots on that side too. You can see, because they definitely put
doors. Yeah. There's no doubt, right? Yeah, there's something going on, isn't there?
For what purpose as well? I mean, why put a door to guard a chamber that's empty here? Yeah,
that's it. The chamber doesn't have anything. There must have been something in these. Right.
So that just defies the whole inscription completely. And I just, I'm just baffled by
this. With the spillage? That is just like, you know, if that, if this is a Shiva area,
right, then there would have been a lingam. Yeah. Like you say, an invisible lingam.
Right. This is my theory. Maybe is it possible that he thought that Shiva, Brahma and Vishnu
were originally invisible gods? I can, I can hear the echo as you speak. Yeah. Wow. You can go
inside and you can hum and you can get the reverberation if you want. Yeah. You can go
inside and you can do it. Check this out. Oh, it's a spider in there. You can feel that. Yeah.
Oh my God. It's just like engulfs you. It's like completely surrounds you. Yeah. So this could well,
these could well be designed for acoustic purposes then. There could be an element of that. Yes. So
it has this kind of almost like putting you into an altered state as you kind of chant and sing
or play drums or musical instruments here. See, this is what I'm saying. I'm saying that this
chamber is empty and it had doors. So imagine if you were like a master meditator, right? So you
would go in, you would shut the door, you would sit inside and imagine chanting the mantras.
Like imagine the reverberation that's going to be around you. Yeah, no, for sure. And I think
I think there's probably specific size, geometry, you know, acoustic kind of design
within this. See, even here, even here we can see the echo, but as you go inside,
the reverberation is just magical. You can see the vibration of every word you say.
So that's very, very interesting. Yeah. See, here's the big dilemma for us, right?
If that inscription is true, because the inscription says we have three gods, Brahma,
Vishnu and Shiva, where are the idols? If you say the idols were added externally
using metal or wood or something like that, again that falsifies the inscription. Now,
if the inscription is true that nothing was added to it, why do we see these slots for the door?
That means the only way that a door like this could be created is to make a megalithic
door made of stone as a part of this giant rock. This is beyond my imagination. Do you think,
have you ever seen one like this? One place that you've been to and written about, Coral Castle,
and this, this was in the 1950s, he did this, but he somehow managed to do that. But this feels like
it's number one, it's older, a lot older. And number two, they've gone. And quite possibly,
that could be the case. I mean, it could have been the same bit of stone, but they must have
been removable somehow. Yeah. Okay. So let's forget the doors. I'll show you the doorkeepers.
Look, you've got even, this is something you don't see much at temples or megaliths in England,
although you do get a few pagans and druids, but this is a living temple. People are doing
rituals here. Ceremonies, even marking this, what turmeric is it on? Turmeric, right. On this kind
of gold. Yeah. You can see them lighting oil lamps. They're putting turmeric on it. Yeah. Those
all temples in India are still living temples. Locals come here and they do specific rituals.
That's amazing. Yeah. It's just like a continuity all the way through since. Of course, this is the
last bastion of a pagan civilization. And we got 1 billion people
worshipping the gods from thousands and thousands of years. And that's why we want to protect it.
Yeah. Yeah, for sure. So to you, what does this mean? How can you explain this to someone like
me? This is the first time they've been to a temple like this. So these are the doorkeepers.
These are the guardian doorkeepers. These are called Dwarapalakas, which literally translates to
guardian doorkeepers. So you usually find them guarding the doors of the gods. Of course,
that's really interesting because the gods are not there. Right. So we didn't see the gods inside. So
what are these two figures actually guarding? Right. What are they like, like protecting?
We don't understand that. And then, what do you think? How tall do you think this figure is? How
tall are you? I think you're like six feet tall. Yeah, I'm six foot one. He's got bent over like
this. He's bent over and still you can see how tall he is. So we're talking eight to nine feet
tall. Right. I mean, there are giants in mythology here, aren't there? There are giant skeletons
that have been found. Yes. He is a Nephilim. He is a giant. So these gatekeepers, are they
kind of remembered as giants then? Is it one of the traditions? Yes. Okay. Yes. Amazing. And he's
not really human. You may have thought that he's human, but he's not really human because look
here. Look at the sides of the mouth. You can see the fangs. And you know, another interesting thing
about this is that he doesn't have any eyelids. Yeah. He doesn't have them like this. So his eyes
are popping out. Yeah. It's pretty weird. Yeah. Yeah. So these are our gods. A lot of people think
like Guadalupolegos are humans, but you can see the fangs coming out. Let's go on the other side
and let's see if that figure has fangs too. Okay. Okay. So this doorkeeper on this side,
he's not bent over, right? So you can see how tall he is. He's easily eight foot tall.
Yeah. He's about eight foot. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And again, look at the detail here.
He's not human. Yeah. There are fangs, aren't they? That is strange. Very happy though.
Yeah. Happy fellow. They've got different hats. Yes. I mean different styles of adornments and
everything else. See that Guadalupolego on that side did not have this projection. You see this
projection coming out of his head. He has something coming out and going. It looks different. I think
this is a snake. Do you think this is a snake? I think, yeah, you can see the face and you can
see the eyeball there. So I think this is, there's a snake coming out of his head and look at this
side here. Yeah. Right. He's leaning on that giant wooden club, right? Like a maze. And if
we go past him without asking for his permission, he's going to take it and he's going to like
smash us. Right. And you see this Cobra wrapped around the stuff. Whoa. And now you should
compare, because you're, you're, you're a giant for an Indian, right? You're like, you're more than
six feet tall. Yeah. You're definitely taller than me. So put your hand next to his hand and see how
it feels. Yeah. I mean, look at that. Yeah. See how. That's about right. But this one here is like,
what the hell? See that? Why is that one so big? Maybe it needs to be that big to hold this giant
club to hit the people. Yeah. You see, he was an actual giant. So his hand is so large.
You know, like you say, if he's guarding something, where is it? Right. What is he guarding? Do you
think it must've, this is all wrong, this inscription and it must've been taken. Do you
think there must've been things here? What's your opinion? If there was something taken, right?
That must've been added to it, right? Because we don't see any sign of destruction. Yeah. But
the inscription says nothing was added to it. The inscription clearly says
whatever was taken out, it was just cramming, right? So this is the mystery of Mandagapattu.
This is a real mystery, but there's one more mystery. Okay. That there's just one last
mystery of Mandagapattu. Yeah. That, I don't know if you caught it, are we at the ground level
of the temple or are we at the top or where are we, do you think? Well, that's what I noticed
when we came here. The fact is, is that the steps, they're clearly not original, are they? I mean,
so what, is this a thing then at these temples where they're just raised up like six or seven
feet and then suddenly there it is? I mean, why would they make it like that? You know,
unless you kind of levitate up and walk on in. But is there a reason for this? I mean,
what's your take on that? There is something really, really strange about Mandagapattu temple
and I saved the best for the last because this is a totally new rock cutting technology because
we're not at the ground level and we're not at the top of the rock either. Yeah. We're in the
middle level. Yeah. And there's no temple like this where builders started from the middle.
Right. So there are two types of rock cutting technology in monolithic temples. One is called
the cut out rock technology. For example, Kailasa temple in Ellora caves. So they start from the top
of the mountain and they start to remove the rocks out. They cut the rocks out and they create
the Kailasa temple. Right. There are temples where you start from the ground level and you go in and
you create temples. But this temple, we are not at the ground level and we are not at the top either.
So this is a totally new rock cutting technology. For some reason, they started in the middle
of the rock. Okay. So this is a new rock cutting technology and nobody has understood this until
now. So we're going to give it a name. We're going to call this Tamil rock cutting technology
because we are in Tamil Nadu, the state where we speak Tamil, because I can't think of a better
name. But we want to call this Tamil rock cutting technology because they started from the mid
section. We are at least seven to eight feet above the ground level and we're definitely not
on top of the rock. So they started from the mid section and if we go down, I'll show you what
they've done below. Okay, let's check it out. Let's put the shoes back on. Let's go down and see.
Right. Now, what do you think about these steps? Well, these look don't look like they're very
ancient. So were they just added later? Absolutely. Right. Because the whole idea of building a
monolithic temple is not to add anything to it. Right. So you can clearly see these are
individual stone slabs. Right. And you can see that this is all new. They've just put
concrete here. You can see this is new. Right. But now this is the ground level. Well, this
may not even be the ground level. I mean, it's probably lower. Yeah, probably lower. Exactly.
Right. So this is the mid level. And you can see this is like 50, 60 feet on top. Yeah. So how did
people climb up without these steps? I mean, that's my height. That's six foot at least maybe
six and a half feet. And it would have been much lower. You can see they're put. Look, if as we go
here, I mean, I mean, the only way you could get up is just go along this thing. But that's not.
Yeah. See, if you came to this temple, let's say a thousand years ago, how would you get in?
Yeah. There's nothing there. There's literally nothing. Right. It's just it's almost like it's
been designed just to be there. Right. To not go in. Just a view from almost like a distance. Right.
Why would they build a temple where nobody can even enter? It's very strange unless it was like
was it a practice run? Was it like a kind of levitation? Yeah. I mean, could they have been
like using this as to kind of practice their technology here? And they were kind of and they
kind of accidentally gave the game away that they could levitate or they were giants. Something like
this. Well, this is an interesting point. Like if they did levitation or were they actually like
real giants, they could just go up. I mean, you've got you've got these niche like niche like this
here. But is that natural? You've got a couple here, but you're not going to get your foot in
there. So what do you what do you think about this, for example? I don't know. I mean, this
could be a niche. I mean, it's got a little kind of I think that's probably partly natural,
but it doesn't look like it's kind of being hacked out. It's hard to tell. What about what
about this one? There's a lot of weathering here. And what about this one? Yeah, there are. Oh,
there are a few actually, aren't there? Yeah, you can see them. These are definitely tool marks.
Yeah. So that's something there. I mean, this is one. Whether there was something. This is one.
These are tool marks. They were cutting the rocks. They were creating another level at the ground
level. So you think this is like the beginning of the next level of construction? Yeah, they
kind of they have finished it and they started with the ground level. That's interesting. They
may have even gone below and then like gone deeper and deeper. We don't know how deep this
rock is. So these are the clues really, aren't they? But still, getting up there to even work on
it is difficult. Why would you do it, right? Why would you start from there, not at the top,
not at the bottom? Why would you start in the middle? And then you start at the bottom. And
why did you just abandon it? Why did you not finish it? Yeah, I mean, that's a big question
mark, isn't it? Yeah. On the top, you can see like this is about 50, 60 foot tall rock, right? Yeah.
Now at one corner, you can see that line. I don't know if you notice that line. Yeah,
yeah. You can sort of see what that is. A little bit of shaping. Yeah. You see that line?
Yeah, that's true. What is it? Is that natural? It's difficult to tell from here, but
does it remind you of anything? You can see another line here. Yeah, there's a couple up
there, aren't there? Actually, yeah. That is interesting because that could suggest they
were beginning something up there. These could suggest they were beginning something down here.
Yes. So, has this been recognized as an unfinished temple? Well, that's a standard
theory. Most of the historians and archaeologists think that most of the ancient temples built
around this time are all unfinished. Okay. But see, that line up there, you know what that is?
That's called a dripledge. Okay. That's a canopy. Like, you know how we build canopies on the
houses? So, when it rains, the rain will just fall like this. It won't go inside. Okay. So,
they're starting to do that. That means they would have built another level and then they
would have finished it like a tower. Oh. Up like this. You see the monuments in Mahabalipuram?
They wanted to finish it like that. Yes, I see. But I don't think they ever did. Yeah,
that's very interesting. Yeah. Yeah. So, that's a dripledge or the canopy. We're looking at like
a 1,400-year-old canopy, if not older, right? At least 1,400 years old. So, that's what we see.
You see a kind of a temple that's unreachable, hanging in midair and with all these strange
details. Yeah. I mean, to the untrained eye, there's really not much here. But when you start
looking at all the little details that you've been pointing out, you realize there's something
else going on here. What is your opinion? I would like to hear your opinion, right? Because you've
traveled around the world looking at all these megalithic structures. Have you seen anything
like this? Not exactly like this. But what I do find interesting is that it just reminds me of
places like the sort of unfinished temples in Peru, you know, and that's often granite.
It reminds me as well the way that everything's kind of placed. Even some of the temples in
Egypt as well. And even if you start looking at the Hypogeum caves of Sardinia,
Malta, Menorca even, you do get this thing. But often, it's not in granite. That's the difference.
So this is like 10 times harder to deal with. Because that's usually limestone or fairly soft
sandstone or something like this. But this is granite. So this is a different beast. But just
the fact that they're going straight into rock and not leaving anything else available, I think,
is unique. And I've seen elements of this throughout southern India at certain sites.
And they just had this mastery of working with granite. And some of it looks like it's even
polished when you go to certain sites. This looks a little bit more rough-hewn. But still,
it's an immense amount of work. So what do you think about this temple? Did you like it?
I did. I think it's very interesting. It's just the fact that the ancient people of India were
carving out of solid granite, I think, is just mind-blowing. I think we have to accept that as
a kind of wow factor. Because I think most people, if you look at pictures or look at videos, you
think it's limestone or some kind of soft rock. But this is granite. So yeah, I'm blown away by
this place. So on a scale of 1 to 10, how much would you give the Mandagapattu temple? I think
I would give it 11. 11? You think this is 11? I'll show you a temple that's a 100. Let's go. Okay.
