4 "What If" Moments in History

Events In History
298 followers
2 Video Views·Jun 11, 2025
Use my code "SIDEPROJECTS" to get $5 off your delicious, high-protein Magic Spoon cereal by clicking this link: https://magicspoon.com/sideprojects Thanks to Magic Spoon for the sponsorship.
What if?
This question has enthralled and plagued humanity for as long as we've been capable of puzzling
over more complex ideas.
The human brain is constantly backtracking through its history, searching for alternatives,
better options, things we should have said, things we shouldn't have done.
Our collective history is much more coherent and set in place.
We know that we once painted now-extinct animals on cave walls, and the ancient civilization
blossomed around the Mediterranean.
We know that the 20th century brought bloodshed on a never-before-schemed scale.
History is set.
But that doesn't stop us from going back and examining specific points that can be
described as global sliding doors moments.
When a slight change, one way or the other, could have led to a profound effect on the
path we took and the world we live in today.
The Second World War was filled with what-if moments.
But two stand out above all others.
One in the East and one in the West.
These two events completely changed the course of the long-running war.
But had one or both gone the other way, our world today might have been completely changed.
The Battle of Stalingrad was fought between August 1942 and February 1943, providing the
first significant Nazi war loss.
The annihilation of Hitler's Sixth Army amid the wreckage of Stalingrad led to the
eventual collapse of the entire line that had pushed into the Soviet Union.
As we know, this capitulation led to a hasty retreat of the remaining German forces, followed
by the re-energized Red Army who chased them all the way back to Berlin.
Yet this was a battle that very much hung in the balance.
Had the Nazis broken through, overcome brave Soviet resistance, and taken the city symbolically
named after Joseph Stalin, it would have been an enormous boost for the Nazis and a crushing
defeat for the Soviets.
One could assume that efforts to take Leningrad and Moscow would have been redoubled and,
had they both fallen, it would have been a disastrous thing for the Soviet cause.
With the Soviets defeated in the East, albeit with a shaky defensive line around Moscow,
the Allies would have had a tough decision to make.
As we know, on the morning of the 6th of June, 1944, a vast armada appeared out of the morning
haze off the coast of Normandy.
D-Day has gone down as one of history's most pivotal moments, which fundamentally
changed the course of World War II and, with it, the path that led us to where we are today.
And yet, how different things could have been?
What if the legendary German commander Erwin Rommel, who was in charge of defending the
coast, had not taken the ill-fated decision to return to Germany for his wife's birthday
at precisely the wrong moment?
Look, whether the Allies would have even launched D-Day had the Soviets already been
knocked out is debatable.
With only one major front still active, Hitler would have significantly bolstered Western
defences along the Atlantic wall, considerably raising the risk of failure, which was already
pretty high.
Now, let's say they did go ahead.
But Operation Fortitude, the grand deception plan that kept Hitler guessing where precisely
the invasion would come, wasn't nearly as effective.
Instead of the loosely strung defensive line that met the Allies on the beaches of Normandy,
they were greeted by the fearsome Panzer Divisions, kept in reserve for far too long.
The result was a harrowing bloodbath that saw Allied soldiers again limping out of Northern
France with their tails between their legs.
What would come next is difficult to say.
Remember those Saturday mornings as a kid?
Cartoons and a bowl of your favourite cereal?
Or maybe several bowls if your name is Simon?
Well, guess what?
The magic is back.
And it's called Magic Spoon.
Magic Spoon brings back the childlike nostalgia.
I've finished my mouthful.
Of Saturday morning cartoons with flavours that fuel your inner child and your adult
taste buds.
Plus 13-14 grams of high quality protein and just 4-5 grams of net carbs per serving.
Making Magic Spoon perfect for those of us who are leading a keto or carb conscious lifestyle,
which I am as of this year.
My doctor was like, you've been on a bit of weight.
And I was like, really?
And he's like, just try to eat a little bit healthier.
So I'm like, okay, doc.
Sorry.
And the best part?
Zero sugar.
That's right, Magic Spoon is sweetened without any cane sugar, corn syrup or sugar alcohols.
Say goodbye to boring cereals.
Magic Spoon's variety pack comes in four exciting flavours, fruity, frosted, cocoa
and my personal favourite, oh I've got a box of that right here, peanut butter.
This is the absolute jam.
You should absolutely, I mean if you like peanuts and peanut butter, add this to your
order.
And they've also got new interesting flavours all the time.
This is what I'm having right now.
That's what I was just eating.
Honey Graham.
There's also this one, Honey Nut, which reminds me of, I was a huge fan of Honey Nut cereals
when I was a kid.
And then this one, Toasted Marshmallow.
I took this home to my kids.
And they're like, Dad, I want cereal today.
And I'm like, you can't have cereal every day.
And they're like, Dad, I want the cereal!
And I'm like, okay.
At least it's good for you.
Magic Spoon is gluten-free, grain-free, soy-free and naturally flavoured, making it a wholesome
choice for everybody.
It's fuelling, it's wholesome, it's made with no artificial ingredients and has the taste
that you'll love, with more protein and less sugar.
Grab your variety pack today and use the code SIDEPROJECTS for $5 off your order at magicspoon.com
slash sideprojects.
That's magicspoon.com slash sideprojects.
There's a link below.
Thanks to Magicspoon for sponsoring and now back to today's video.
Would the Allies have sued for peace at this stage?
Would the manic Adolf Hitler have simply marched his soldiers to the end of the Earth until
they were finally defeated?
Would the Americans have backtracked out of Europe, choosing to focus on Japan instead?
Would the Allies have won World War 2 because of two battles?
Had they gone the other way, everything could have been very, very different.
Now so far, we've talked only about what-if moments relating to events we definitely know
happened and what might have occurred after.
However, for this next scenario, we're actually going to look at what might have come before
a possible event.
What if there was a great flood that consumed the Earth, and what might have existed before
it?
Our knowledge of human history begins to get pretty vague between 5,000-10,000 years ago.
Thanks to archaeological research, we have a rough idea, but concrete conclusions are
hard to come by.
We don't know how relatively simple societies were suddenly able to construct the Great
Pyramid of Giza over 4,500 years ago, or exactly how they built Gobekli Tepe over 10,000 years
ago.
One alternative theory of world history that is getting a makeover in recent years is that
of a great flood that once consumed the Earth.
Long a conspiracy theory favourite, stories of such a deluge can be found in ancient scripts
worldwide, from the Bible's tale of Noah to the story of Manu and Mata in the Hindi
texts.
Almost every society has some kind of great flood myth.
But science has been much harder to quantify here.
Many experts now agree that a massive deluge did occur at some point between 7,000 and
12,000 years ago, but whether it consumed the entire planet is still fiercely debated.
Recent theories and evidence point to the Black Sea as one of the most likely locations
for such a flood, while studies of ancient civilizations highlight that several new groups
with new customs appeared in different areas around the world, namely Egypt, the Himalayas,
and Central Europe.
Some argue that these were Black Sea farmers displaced by a massive flood, while others
push the alternate history to the extreme and claim that there was an advanced civilization
that predated the Egyptians by thousands of years.
And let's just say, from the get-go, that practically zero archaeological evidence has
been found about an advanced civilization that would have predated the Great Flood.
Yet humans just can't get enough of this story.
The tale of the lost city of Atlantis was penned by Plato in 359 BC and continues to
enthrall us to this day.
Is it possible that there was a sophisticated civilization capable of building a mighty
city thousands of years before the Great Pyramids of Giza?
And if so, was there more than one?
One theory about the Great Flood myth is that it could have been linked to a comet that
hit Earth between 3,000 and 2,800 BC.
And it created the Burkle Crater, located at the bottom of the Indian Ocean, sending
mega-tsunamis around the world that may not have consumed the planet but would have caused
widespread damage.
This theory is contentious, but it at least gives us an event that could have inspired
tales worldwide.
Others suggest flood events could have been linked with mega-volcanic eruptions and the
dramatic climate change that might have come with it.
We know that the 1883 Krakatoa eruption caused weather changes that lasted decades, some
argue even longer, and in the grand scheme of volcanoes, Krakatoa was still relatively
minor.
Could a supervolcano eruption thousands of years ago have produced climatic changes that
could have appeared like global flooding to an early civilization?
Other theories, and we're getting pretty far out now, suggest that humans may not have
even been the first to industrialize society on Earth.
Again, there's no evidence to support this, but considering humans have inhabited the
Earth for only around 0.007% of the planet's history, it's not necessarily a totally outrageous
idea.
Or maybe it is.
We'll leave that to you.
Back to reality, sort of.
In October 1969, the world held its breath.
With the US and the Soviet Union facing each other down over Cuba, millions worldwide watched
in horrified fascination as the Earth seemingly tiptoed towards its first full-scale nuclear
war.
Thankfully, it didn't happen.
But what if it did?
If you're looking for sliding-door moments during the Cuban Missile Crisis, you're almost
spoiled for choice.
What if Kennedy had authorized strikes on Cuba?
Especially, as we now know, that tactical nuclear weapons were already on Cuba and primed
to attack any US invasion.
Or what if the Foxtrot-class Soviet submarine B-59 in the waters near the island had launched
its nuclear weapons after coming under a perceived attack from a US helicopter?
Once that first nuclear weapon had been launched, it would be difficult to see things ending
quickly and without widespread obliteration.
There have long been scenarios that carefully played out what might come next.
But it certainly would not have been pretty.
If a tactical nuclear weapon had been deployed against US ground troops or ships in the vicinity,
the retaliation would have been fierce.
Most likely, much of the Soviet Union would have been destroyed, while major cities on
both US coasts would have been immediately targeted and replaced with gaping nuclear
wastelands.
As for Europe, that would have probably depended on whether Britain and France launched their
nuclear weapons to defend NATO.
If they did, you would expect immediate retaliation, meaning only patches of Britain, mainly in
the North, would have remained.
France would be devastated, with much of the area around the country horribly affected.
So what would be left?
After the waves of initial strikes, and once both the Soviet Union and the US and its NATO
allies exchanged apocalyptic blows, we could expect an eerie calm as the dust settled.
Large parts of the world, including South America, Africa, parts of Asia and Oceania,
would have been unaffected by the initial attacks.
But how severe the contamination fallout would be would determine what came next.
Theoretically, a global nuclear war wouldn't necessarily mean the end for humanity.
Pockets of the world could continue, but without the vast interconnected trade web, you would
expect societies to fall back several centuries at least.
Forget the Internet, forget manufacturing, forget fossil fuel extraction.
We would revert to a much more basic existence.
And that's the best case scenario.
The worst alternate history of this situation is that poisonous nuclear gases slowly envelop
the planet, killing every human in their wake.
In 1957, Neville Shute released a book titled On the Beach, in which such an event played
out and where the residents of Melbourne and Australia were forced to wait for the inevitable
doom that was slowly drifting south from the war-torn nuclear wasteland of the Northern
Hemisphere.
From one event that almost everybody has heard of, to one that might be new to you.
In the early years of the new millennium, when Europe moved from BC into AD, the Roman
Empire was a roaring beast, dismantling all that came before it.
The entire Mediterranean coastline was now under Roman control, with borders stretching
north in Britain, south to modern Sudan, and east into what is today Armenia.
It was by far the largest empire the world had ever seen, and many in the glittering
city of Rome were licking their lips at the thought of yet more expansion.
While the Roman Empire wouldn't reach its official peak in terms of landmass for another
hundred years, something happened in Northern Germany in 9 AD that sent shockwaves through
the empire, and which many historians argue completely altered the direction of history.
Germania was always a thorn in the side of the Roman Empire, and what went on to become
modern Germany was never fully conquered by the Latin warlords from the south.
But they did come close.
The region had been effectively split into two for many years, with the Rhine River as
the natural border.
Everything west was firmly under Roman control, but to the east, an expansive area lay outside
its sphere of influence and remained under the control of various chieftains.
In the winter of 5 AD, Roman Emperor Augustus ordered his troops north, crossing the Rhine
with the intention of bringing the rest of Germania to heel.
After four years of skirmishes, little significant gains had been made, and with several legions
leaving to deal with an insurrection in the Balkans region, Roman numbers were limited
in Germania.
In September 9 AD, Roman General Publius Quincilius Varus ordered the three legions under his
command to march west to deal with a revolt after a Germanic prince who was also a Roman
citizen tipped him off, a tragic decision based entirely on bogus info.
As the legions entered Teutoburg Forest, located southeast of the modern city of Bielfeld,
they were forced to march along a single muddy track that stretched the 20,000 men or so
over several miles.
The famed fighting style of the legionaries had now been completely negated, and when
Germanic warriors rose out of the undergrowth around them, they were just sitting ducks.
The Battle of Teutoburg Forest, also known as the Varian Disaster after its ill-fated
Roman commander, lasted for four days, with the Germanic tribesmen slowly grinding down
the legionaries by withdrawing and then attacking at weak points along the route.
It resulted in the complete destruction of three legions, with Varus committing suicide
rather than risk capture.
This was the first time anything like this had happened to the Roman Empire since Hannibal
came within a whisker of taking Rome two centuries earlier.
These were not well-trained warriors, as had been the case during the Second Punic War,
but men who the Romans considered little more than barbarians.
The effect in Rome was seismic, bringing the Empire's rapid expansion under Augustus
to a shuddering halt.
While Roman soldiers crossed the Rhine again several years later, this had more to do with
revenge than a genuine attempt to take control of the region.
So what's the alternate narrative here?
Things could have been very different if Varus had never taken the bait and waited for the
returning legions before moving.
Had there been a uniform drive across Germania, the Romans would likely have prevailed.
This means the Empire would have been much more secure, with all of Germania now under
Roman control.
Remember that it was the tribes from Germania that poured south and sacked Rome in 410 AD.
Would this have happened if the region had been completely subjugated four centuries
earlier?
If it didn't, then would the Roman Empire have fallen in quite the same way?
Maybe the Empire would have continued for several more centuries?
Another fascinating way to look at this is what would have happened to modern Germany?
With the Romans in complete control, the region would probably speak a completely different
language, perhaps a Latin-Germanic hybrid.
And had Gaul, now France, and Germania remained under a single, unified banner, would the
simmering tensions between the two countries ever have appeared in the same way?
The story of what happened in the Teutoburg Forest played an enormous part in German nationalism
centuries later.
It became a symbolic tale that mirrored the struggles of German states under Napoleon's
occupation.
If it had never happened, perhaps history would have moved into the 20th century with
a very different Central European consensus.
Perhaps World War I would have never occurred.
Which means World War II would never happen because Germany was not crippled under the
Treaty of Versailles.
Suddenly, a battle that occurred over four days in a forest in Northern Germany, nearly
2,000 years ago, begins to look like one of the most critical events in all of world history.
