Beyond Copying: Can China Break the Innovation Barrier?
This discussion explores why China struggles with innovation, attributing it to its planned economy, which conflicts with the unpredictable nature of innovation. Using evolutionary economics, it highlights how replication, variation, and selection—key to innovation—are stifled by rigid planning. Businesses, as innovation incubators, are undermined by an authoritarian environment that disrupts entrepreneurial roles, creating structural holes. Societally, China’s bureaucratic structure, rooted in an imperial legacy, produces knowledge focused on maintaining order, not fostering technical progress. This contrasts with freer, feudal-era thought. The text critiques the Lamarckian assumption that innovation can be orchestrated, emphasizing that true innovation requires uncertainty and free will, supported by chaos theory. To innovate, a society must de-bureaucratize, protect entrepreneurs through legal frameworks, and embrace uncertainty, as greatness cannot be planned.
0:00 Intro 0:28 The Imitation Paradox 2:00 Misunderstanding Innovation 4:09 The Flawed Logic of Planning 4:29 Evolution and the Roots of Innovation 10:38 Businesses as Innovation Incubators 13:35 The Entrepreneurial Void 14:37 A Society Without Innovative Knowledge 17:22 The Path Forward or the Road to Crisis
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Shong. Welcome to Digging
into China, where we explore China in
depth to review unique
perspectives. Let's discuss a
fundamental topic. Why does China
struggle with innovation? It's widely
recognized that China is not a hub of
innovation. Instead, it's often viewed
as a nation of imitation excelled in
copying, replicating, and duplicating.
This is a wellworn observation,
something most people are familiar with.
Yet few have deeply explored why China
has become a country of imitation rather
than innovation. There is a profound
reason behind this and examining it
today carries real significance. As
China decouples from the United States
and to some extent from the developed
world, the consequences for its economy
and its people's livelihoods could be
severe with impacts that are difficult
to fully predict. We'll approach this
topic from three perspectives. First,
we'll examine the concept of innovation
itself. What does it truly mean? To
address this, I'll introduce some basic
principles from evolutionary economics.
Second, we'll consider the role of
entrepreneurs and businesses. Businesses
are critical venues for innovation
serving as incubators for new ideas.
They too are part of the economic
evolution process. So, we'll apply
evolutionary economics concepts to
analyze this. Third, we'll look at a
society. A given society produces
specific knowledge structures and the
types and the knowledge generated in
Chinese society doesn't align with
innovation. Ultimately, innovation is
tied to the nature of societal
knowledge. Through these three lenses,
I'll explain why China lacks innovation
and unpacked underlying
causes. Let's begin with the first
question. What is innovation? How do
Chinese people interpret this concept?
To illustrate, let's consider some
recent news about innovation in China.
In February this year, an article in the
state-run economic daily reported that
in
2024, China's total research and
development spending surpassed 3.6
trillion yen, a
3.8% increase, ranking second globally.
This massive investment article claimed
will drive China towards becoming a
leading innovator. Another report citing
People's Daily via China's National
Intellectual Property Administration
stated that China's innovation capacity
ranks among the world's best placing
11th globally. This success, it is said,
stems directly from the Communist Party
and the state strong emphasis on
innovation, substantial financial
investment and meticulous planning. The
article argued that without such
support, China would have made no
progress in
innovation. I don't need to cite more
examples. The Chinese government
consistently frames innovation in this
way. It begins with unified national
planning followed by significant
societal funding and culminates in
steadily rising innovation rankings.
This is China's innovation narrative.
Many in China criticize the government,
expressing frustration, but their
reasoning often mirrors the official
line. These critics might argue that
China lacks innovation because
governmental data is unreliable, that
the reported investments in innovation
are inflated, and that much of the
funding is siphoned off by corrupt
officials. They attribute China's lack
of innovation to Communist Party
corruption. While this view is popular,
it's a simplistic argument that doesn't
withstand scrutiny.
So why does China struggle to innovate?
A key reason is its reliance on a
planned economy. The very concept of
planning in this system conflicts with
innovation. To put it plainly, planning
is the anti-thesis of innovation. This
issue isn't rooted in corruption. To
understand this fully, we must explore
some foundational ideas from
evolutionary biology and evolutionary
economics.
Economists have long noted similarities
between economic and biological systems.
In the late 19th and early 20th
centuries, economist Thorston Vein began
applying evolutionary theory to
economics. Later, scholars formalized
this approach as evolutionary economics.
By the 1970s, as our understanding of
evolution deepened, evolutionary
economics gained traction.
Let me outline the core concepts of
evolution simply. Evolution involves
three elements. Replication, variation,
and selection. These form the essence of
evolutionary theory. Life sustains
itself through self-replication. Relying
on herity to persist in economics.
Repetitive production labor serves as a
form of economic self-replication.
Production techniques and methods must
also replicate to endure. In these ways,
economic and biological systems are
strikingly similar. However, a crucial
aspect of evolution is variation or
mutation which aligns closely with what
we call innovation in economics.
Historically, there was a popular view
of biological variation proposed by
early French biologist Jean Baptist uh
Lamach. Lamar suggested that organism
intentionally adapt to their need. For
instance, giraffes with originally
shorter necks stretched to reach tree
fruits and over generations their necks
grew longer. This used and disused
theory posited that the traits used more
become more developed while unused
traits are trophy and these changes pass
to the next
generation. Later scientific experiments
show that this isn't entirely accurate.
Many traits aren't inherited this way
and many variations lack a clear
intentional cause. China's planned
economy mindset echoes leakism. It
assumes that evolution and variation can
be directed by subjective goals and
intentions that economic innovation can
be predicted and orchestrated. But since
Lamar's theory is flawed or at least
incomplete, this planned economy
approach is also
misguided. What's the correct
perspective? Let's return to the three
principles. Herity, variation, and
selection. Variation akin to innovation
is a novel creation or invention. It
depends on selection. In other words,
innovation requires an environment of
genuine selection. Selection isn't about
imposing a predetermined plan as plans
cannot yield truly new outcomes.
Renowned evolutionary economist Joffrey
Hodes in his book evolution and
institutions describes innovation as
follows. Meaningful human creativity
involves creating new structures and
dimensions not merely adjusting existing
parameters. Human behavior should embody
an element of uncertainty and uncaused
cause. This view holds that human choice
and creativity are inherently
unpredictable, allowing for free
action. This perspective challenges the
neocclassic idea of programming human
behavior with a fixed preferences which
leaves no room for true choice. Genuine
innovation transcends simple cause and
effect logic. It depends on the
environment that permits free choice,
fostering the potential for innovation
to emerge. Innovation must be nurtured
and awaited, not forced through
planning. Yet, once innovation takes
hold and a new order forms, it appears
determined at a macro level, fitting
into a cause and effect framework. Thus,
the world is both determined and
uncertain, consistent with modern chaos
theory. Hoderson further notes that the
complexity in the chaos theories reveal
that even a deterministic world appears
random and unpredictable. This doesn't
affirm determinism. Rather, it suggests
that even under deterministic
assumptions, free will remains viable.
Order and chaos are intertwined. Order
arises from chaos and freedom is the
source of order. China's planned economy
however stifles this freedom. Its
business environment and the social
structure are rigidly authoritarian with
the government dictating all. There is
no space for free will or spontaneous
order. The Chinese government fears
uncertainty and it seeks to eliminate
it. But innovations thrives on
uncertainty. Without it, true innovation
cannot
occur. I've outlined why China struggles
with innovation and what innovation
entails. In essence, the government's
drive to control and plan everything
through a planned economy makes
innovation
impossible. Innovation and planning
predefined expectations are
fundamentally at odds. By definition,
innovation is something new that exceeds
expectations. If it falls within a
plan's scope, it's not truly new. Next,
I'll explore two additional
perspectives. First, how does China
business environment and the role of
entrepreneurs impact innovation? Second,
how do China's unique social structure
and knowledge types hinder innovation?
Let's examine these in detail. In the
previous section, we discussed
innovation and evolutionary economics
conceptually. But these ideas must be
grounded in reality. All innovation
requires a tangible vehicle and that
vehicle is the fundamental economic
unit. The
businesses exist to lend the certainty
to the uncertainty of innovation through
specific organizational forms. They
serve as incubators for innovation.
Economist Ronald Kohl's argued that
business emerge due to transaction
costs. If international man if the
internal management costs are lower than
market transaction costs, a business
forms as this structure is more
efficient and cost effective. One of the
business's key functions is integration,
a unique institutional role. Businesses
unite talented individuals with
production capabilities, creativity,
technical expertise and management
skills alongside various resources. In
doing so, they enhanced the efficiency
of innovation within the business. The
entrepreneurs role is paramount. Many in
China undervalue entrepreneurs likely
due to the absence of a western
entrepreneurial tradition. Yet
entrepreneurs are indispensable. They
may not be the most technically
proficient or in inventive but they
possesses a unique ability to
orchestrate diverse talents effectively
and this skill is known as knowledge of
opportunities without certainty.
Economist Israel Kushner in competition
and
entrepreneurship explains that a true
entrepreneurial spirit stems from
alertness to information. Not its
complete mastery. Practically the
knowledge of a business employees isn't
owned by them but by the entrepreneur
who hires them. Entrepreneurs know whom
to recruit and where to find individuals
with profit generating knowledge. Their
primary role lies in strategic vision
and integration, transforming disparate
knowledge and skills into a cohesive
system. In modern social network theory,
entrepreneurs are critical nodes in the
economic network. At a macro level, the
economy is a decentralized complex
structure akin to the neural network of
the human brain. But at a micro level,
it's not entirely decentralized. It
features a centralized starshaped
structure with the entrepreneur at the
center connecting all branches. Without
this node, a structural hole emerges,
disrupting the organization and causing
the business to collapse. This node is
vital. The communist system excels at
dismantling these nodes, creating
structural holes. In the 1950s, China's
public private partnerships forcibly
removed entrepreneurs from businesses,
generating massive gaps. Business neared
the collapse. The communist government
responded by installing officials to
manage them, attempting to fill these
holes with
bureaucrats. But bureaucrats lack the
knowledge and abilities of
entrepreneurs.
They cannot integrate economic resources
or inspire creativity in subordinates.
The structural hole widens and no amount
of patching helps. To prevent total
collapse, the government resorted to
planned and administrative system.
Transforming businesses into
governmentlike entities. These state-run
enterprises are rigid, lacking the free
will to choose and thus cannot
innovate. Now let's turn to the third
perspective. Specific types of
knowledge. Innovation isn't a haphazard.
It's a distinct type of knowledge not
produced by every society.
Sociologically specific social
structures correlate with the specific
knowledge types. China's unique social
structure shapes its knowledge
accordingly. Chinese sociologist Faoong
in his accessible book imperial power
and a gentry power observes that in
ancient China before the Joel dynasty
society resembled a feudal system the
central government had a limited
authority and the local governance
relied on
heredity hereditary nobles. This
fostered the free thought and the will.
The hundred schools of thoughts in the
pre-CQing era owed much to this
classical feudal structure. After
theQing dynasty, China abandoned the
feudalism for an imperial system. With
power concentrated in a single emperor,
unable to manage a vast nation alone,
the emperor used the imperial
examination system to select
bureaucrats, transforming China into a
bureaucratic society. Bureaucrats
deferred from feudal nobles in
mindset. As the emperor's subordinates,
bureaucrats focused on anticipating his
desires, catering to his preferences,
and seeking favor. They had no incentive
to innovate. As innovation entails
uncertainty, which could displease the
emperor and risk severe consequences.
To protect themselves, they pursued
safe, predictable knowledge such as the
fixed moral and ethical framework of
Confucianism. This bureaucratic society
couldn't generate the technical
knowledge leaving production
stagnant. Fay Shaoong notes that
traditional society's knowledge class
lacked technical expertise but held
authority. They focused on literally
arts detached from technology. As the
economic elite, their interest lay not
in advancing production but in
preserving privileges, maintaining
norms, and upholding the status quo. Fay
Shaoong's analysis shows that the
emperor centric imperial system produced
the knowledge that reinforced the
established order fostering a vast
corrupt bureaucratic structure incapable
of innovation.
China's authoritarian social structure
preludes the knowledge needed for
innovation. In summary, the Chinese view
of innovation rests on a flawed Lakan
perspective fundamentally mistaken.
Second, China's businesses and
entrepreneurs face a hostile environment
where entrepreneurs can vanish and the
businesses are perpetually unstable,
stifling innovation. Third, China's
social and cultural environment doesn't
cultivate innovation friendly knowledge.
Without such knowledge, true innovation
cannot
emerge. In short, Chinese society is
structurally incapable of innovation.
Claiming otherwise reflects a
misunderstanding of China. This raises a
pressing question. If China lacks
innovation and is decoupling from the
United States, won't the consequences be
dire? Technology depreciates over time.
Without internal innovation, China's
existing technology will become
obsolete, potentially collapsing the
economic system. This could lead not
only to economic turmoil, but also to a
profound humanitarian crisis. How can a
society sustain innovation? The answer
lies in reversing the conditions I've
described. First, it must dismantle
bureaucracy. A bureaucratic society
cannot innovate. The system must be
removed. Second, society must protect
entrepreneurs and businesses through the
rule of law and clear regulations to
foster innovation. Third, it must
establish rules to safeguard free will
and the emergence of uncertainty as
innovation depends on it. These three
elements are
essential. As the adage goes, greatness
cannot be
planned. Thank you so much for watching.
If you find this video helpful, please
like it, drop a comment below, and hit
the subscribe button right here. It
really helps YouTube suggest my video to
others. I'll be back with more content
soon. Until then, be well.