'That was painful': Van Jones reacts to Biden's debate performance
Jun 7, 2025
CNN political commentator Van Jones weighs in on President Joe Biden's performance during CNN's presidential debate.
Watch the full replay of the CNN Presidential Debate here
The president and former presidents making their way off the CNN debate stage. Looks like
Jill Biden, the first lady, has come out. Former President Trump walking off the stage.
The first debate of the 2024 campaign and the earliest presidential debate ever now
in the books and in front of the voters. Tonight, along with Aaron Burnett, the first word on what
those voters might make of it from our political professionals, from our CNN flash poll and swing
state focus group. We'll be talking to surrogates, including Vice President Harris, getting fact
checks from our Daniel Dale, and new reporting from inside both campaigns. With me here,
CNN political commentator Scott Jennings, Kate Bedingfield, David Urban, Van Jones,
Alyssa Farrar-Griffin, and Newsnight anchor Abby Phillip and David Axelrod,
and CNN chief national correspondent John King. John, let me start with you. Your thoughts.
Anderson, this was a game-changing debate in the sense that right now as we speak,
there is a deep, a wide, and a very aggressive panic in the Democratic Party. It started minutes
into the debate and it continues right now. It involves party strategists. It involves elected
officials. It involves fundraisers. And they're having conversations about the president's
performance, which they think was dismal, which they think will hurt other people down the party
in the ticket. And they're having conversations about what they should do about it. Some of those
conversations include, should we go to the White House and ask the president to step aside?
Others are, other of the conversations are about, should prominent Democrats go public
with that call? Because they feel this debate was so terrible. They do say, in moments in the
debate later, the president got better and got his footing. But then at the end, even his closing
statement was a little halting. The contrast between the two candidates. Let me be clear,
none of them, and a lot of Republicans, don't think Donald Trump had a great night. Donald
Trump broke the fact-check machine more than I can count tonight. That will be on the record as
we go forward. He refused to answer some very specific and direct questions about his conduct,
about January 6th and what all. So that will be dealt with out there. And sometimes there's a
parallel universe between the political elites and the American people. Be nice to see what the
voters say. But I can tell you, it started minutes in. It started with the first couple of answers,
and it has continued throughout the night from a, oh my God, oh my God, oh my God,
to what do we do about this? And it involves very senior people in the Democratic Party,
including elected officials, saying we have a problem.
And just to co-sign what John is saying, I mean, the panic that I am hearing from Democrats is not
like anything that I have heard in this campaign so far. And a lot of it has to do with, first of
all, there was a deep frustration about Trump's lies. I mean, he lied a lot tonight. But the
problem for Biden was that Trump was able to take sometimes incredible falsehoods and turn them into
some kind of argument, whereas Biden's answers were in a lot of cases not coherent, deeply
problematic, that he was not able to take pretty straightforward answers and answer them to the
American public, and then also at some points bringing things up that teed up Trump attacks.
So there is a real concern here tonight that there's been some real damage done that cannot
be undone. Biden solidified the perception among voters, but especially among his base.
They were hoping that tonight would be a game changer. They are now seeing a president who is
in the White House who they do not necessarily believe can do this for another four years.
David Axelrod?
Look, I can't argue with either of them about how Democratic leaders are reacting to this poll.
We said at the beginning that each person had a fundamental goal, and for Biden that goal was to
appear energetic, engaged, and look like someone who is capable of serving for another four years
for president. That was job number one. I actually think he scored a bunch of points. I think if you
just judge this on sort of policy stuff, he did score a bunch of points on issues like abortion,
for example, on some of the economic issues. But there is a feeling, I think there was a
sense of shock, actually, at how he came out at the beginning of this debate, how his voice sounded.
He seemed a little disoriented. He did get stronger as the debate went on, but by that time,
I think the panic had set in. I think you're going to hear discussions that I don't know
will lead to anything, but there are going to be discussions about whether he should
continue. I think part of it is Donald Trump did not meet his mission either. He could not
resist the temptation to be nasty, to prevaricate about a whole bunch of things, about his own
record, about Biden's record, and to seem petty and small at times. So what you saw was a
candidate who's deeply vulnerable and a president who may not be able to take advantage of it.
Listen, if anybody in America thinks that that was even close to being an okay debate by Joe Biden,
I'm living in a parallel universe. That was an unmitigated disaster for President Biden
from the second he walked out to the closing statement. The biggest issue for Democrats
is abortion, and he couldn't give an answer. He couldn't even give a coherent answer on the
biggest issue for Democrats tonight. I've heard from leading Democrats across the United States,
elected governors, congressmen, of course, texting me and saying, I'm worried I'm going to lose if
Joe Biden's at the top of the ticket. Bob Casey, I promise you tonight in the state of Pennsylvania,
is thrown up in his mouth because he knows that if he's got to stand next to Joe Biden,
he's going down in Pennsylvania. If he's on the ticket, I don't know how it's going to work.
Yeah, look, it was a really disappointing debate performance from Joe Biden. I don't think there's
any way, any other way to slice it. His biggest issue that he had to prove to the American people
was that he had the energy, he had the stamina, and he didn't do that. And so I think that is
of concern. And I think for a lot of Democrats, that's very disappointing. I will say Donald
Trump also had some really rough moments in this debate. And talking to the Biden campaign,
they say, you know, their dials started really moving away from Trump as he was increasing his
personal attacks on Biden. So I think there was a lot about his kind of character and the kind of
personal nastiness that he was putting on display, you know, that doesn't help him with the swing
voters that he needs. You know, and I also think you saw him continue to get sort of more and more
animated across the course of the debate and, you know, give some really problematic answers
about January 6, some really problematic answers about Putin. So, you know, Donald Trump did not
get off scot-free tonight by any stretch. But look, there is no two ways about it. That was not
a good debate for Joe Biden. Ben? That was painful. I love Joe Biden. I work for Joe Biden.
He didn't do well at all. He did not do well at all. And he looked, you know, I'll give you the
analysis, you know, kind of have the old man versus the con man. I can walk you through how I'm
supposed to see it and say it, but I just want to speak from my heart. I love that guy. That's a good
man. He loves his country. He's doing the best that he can. But he had a test to meet tonight
to restore confidence of the country and of the base. And he failed to do that. And I think there's
a lot of people who are going to want to see him consider taking a different course now. We're
still far from our convention. And there is time for this party to figure out a different way
forward if he will allow us to do that. But that was not what we needed from Joe Biden. And it's
personally painful for a lot of people. It's not just panic. It's pain for what we saw tonight.
And if I may just add to that, I think Joe Biden lost in the first three minutes. I think a lot
of voters probably tuned out and millions of people are having conversations with their families,
with their friends of if the president is up to the task and if he should step aside.
And I'm someone who believes the former president is a threat to democracy. I think he is a threat
to the America as we know it. He wants to fundamentally change our institutions.
He has laid out what his plan is. I am not confident that that is the man to take him on.
You cannot tell me democracy is on the line and then give that performance tonight.
If based on that, in 18 weeks, Donald Trump will be the president-elect.
The people doing focus groups tonight, and we'll see if our style group with Laura Coates
confirms this, Biden actually scores pretty well on the issues when he's talking about the
substance. And Trump's numbers went down both because he was ducking questions, he was lying
about some things, and he was refusing to answer. And some of it was the tone. They don't like him.
So when you see that, when you see sort of the statistics, you're going to look at like,
oh, that's a mixed bag. But to Vance's point about the president's performance,
that's what caused the panic. So the question is, and my question actually is,
what happens? Because it's a great political strength of Joe Biden,
is his resilience and his stubbornness. It's also sometimes a blind spot because he is so
stubborn. It's going to be very hard to someone, and I don't know who it is, who could go to Joe
Biden and say, you need to do this, number one. And the question is, again, I'm just telling you,
to Abby's point, I've been doing this for 30-something years, going on 40 years, and I
have never, ever had what happened on this thing tonight happen in the middle of the debate.
It started early and it continued. And to Vance's point, Van made a very important point.
These are people who love Joe Biden, who credit Joe Biden for kicking Donald Trump out of the
White House. They're Democrats. The Democratic Party is a very diverse party. It fights about
a lot of things. It has generational issues. It has regional issues and everything else.
The thing that unites the Democratic Party is trying to keep Donald Trump from getting
back into the White House. They love Joe Biden for kicking him out. They don't want him back.
They came into this debate nervous that Biden was in a weak position. They leave this debate
panicked. John, if you love the guy, how could you put him out there? If you love him,
if you love Joe Biden, if that was my father, you don't put a guy in that situation.
It's a great point. These guys know this better. These guys know this better because they talked
to them. There's this legacy in the Democratic Party. You don't challenge the incumbent because
when it's happened in the past, they haven't beaten the incumbent, and then the incumbent
has lost the general election. It was actually Donald Trump that helped make Joe Biden the
nominee because there was a feeling that if there were a primary, that that would weaken,
that Biden would probably win, but it would weaken him in a general election. There were people who
could have run and didn't run because the history of that is bad. The point is now he is the nominee
of the Democratic Party. This isn't the 60s. Voters choose the nominee. He is the nominee.
Only he can decide whether he's going to continue. As you point out, and as Kate knows very well,
this is a guy with a lot of pride and who believes in himself and the idea that he's
going to say, you know what, I had a bad debate. I think I'm going to walk away from this.

