Why Are Some People Left-Handed?

The Explore Channel
18 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Evolution spent nearly 400 million years crafting these works of art, two of the most important
pieces of the human evolutionary puzzle. Yet 99% of us end up being good with one hand
and not the other, for common tasks like writing, high-fiving, and the all-important one-handed
texting.
Even life itself seems to have chosen sides. Our amino acids are said to be left-handed.
Our DNA turns in a right-handed helix.
Both of our hands seem fully capable, they're both connected to fully functional arms, so
we'd expect an even split when it comes to which hand we prefer. In the animal kingdom
where we find creatures with a preference for one paw, hoof, or wing, it's usually
50-50. Yet on average, only 1 out of 10 humans are southpaws.
I guess the real question is, why are so few people left-handed? Maybe it's because the
world is conspiring against them. Spiral notebooks, scissors, e-readers, video game
controllers, zippers, even can openers. If only somebody would open a chain of stores
that's specifically stocked with products for left-handers. That's a moneymaker.
Even language hates lefties. To be correct is to be right. And correct is also a word
that comes from right. Gods are full of righteousness. To be skillful is to have dexterity. Kings
are regal. Left itself comes from Old English meaning weak, and words for left give us
sinister, gauche, maladroit. Bad dancers have two left feet.
But language turns out to be an important part of the puzzle. Our brains are cross-wired,
meaning that the right hand is controlled by the left side, and vice versa. But that
doesn't mean our brains are symmetrical. In the 1860s, French scientist Paul Broca
discovered that a region of our brains used for speech processing usually only located
on one side. Language is a complex process, and the move to one hemisphere probably helps
the brain deal with it more efficiently. Today we know that in 99% of right-handers' brains,
Broca's area is located only in the left hemisphere. And in left-handers' brains,
it's also on the left. 70% of the time. Only 19% of lefties process speech in the
right hemisphere, and 20% of them use both. So, language and hands, not directly linked.
That's confusing.
Two similar theories have been proposed to explain this. They suggest that as early humans
evolved, a gene mutant popped up that threw a whole bunch of our brains' functions to
one side, and allowed them to specialize. If you have two copies of the so-called right-shift
mutation, language and hand dominance move to the left hemisphere. That shift is slightly
less if you carry one copy, and if you don't carry the right-shift mutation at all, language
and handedness could go to the right or the left, just by chance.
This means instead of there being a gene for left-handedness, it's really the lack of
a gene. A genetic influence makes sense, since parents seem to sometimes pass on handedness
to their kids. Two right-handed parents only have a 9% chance of having a left-handed child.
One parent being left-handed raises that to 19%, and two to 26%.
But research has found evidence of right-hand preference in captive chimps. And yes, I'm
talking about throwing poop. This would mean that a brain shift for coordination came first,
before we became the talking, throwing geniuses that we are today.
There's even another theory, which goes back to the video we did on how our bodies
tell right from left when it comes to our guts, that this whole brain-hand-sidedness
can be traced all the way back to our embryonic days. And in 2013, researchers reported that
some of the same genes that tell our spleens and stomachs which way is which are linked
to brain asymmetry.
I know you guys hate this, but the answer is, we still don't really know for sure
why more of us aren't left-handed. Sorry.
As you've seen though, we've got some great ideas that people are still researching,
but that's how science works.
Of course, if being right-handed and shifting our speech and coordination to one side was
such a great thing for evolution, why do lefties still exist?
One idea says that whether it's on the baseball mound or the tennis court, we right-handers
do worse when facing lefties. We're just not used to all your strange southpaw ways.
And if you happen to be holding a sword instead of a tennis racket, being a lefty might be
a great survival tool.
A simpler theory is just that nature enjoys variety.
Chris McManus believes that left-handers may have what he calls random cerebral variation,
their brains are just more shuffled up. This might lead to more unexpected connections,
more crosstalk between the right and left hemispheres, and maybe more creativity.
What's clear is that having a diverse set of brains have made humans a much more interesting
species.
We may not have all the answers yet, but these questions have taught us a lot of important
lessons about the brain along the way. And hey, at least we're not burning them at the
stake. Stay curious.
If you want to learn more about southpaw science, check out the book A Left-Hand Turn Around
the World by David Woolman. Link down in the description.
The current Ebola outbreak in West Africa is by far the worst in the short history of
this strange virus, and it's ignited a wave of alarm and generalized freak-out around
the world. But today we're going to give you a detailed, accurate explanation of this disease
to try and give this whole situation a nice, calm, comforting, scientific hug.
