Why Is Evicting Squatters So Hard in California? | Jonathan Madison

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
152 Video Views·Jun 5, 2025
In California, some property owners return to find strangers living in their homes, and police often can’t remove them. The law doesn’t always distinguish between a squatter and a tenant. Jonathan Madison, Lead Attorney at The Madison Firm, explains how this legal gray area is playing out across the state and what might shift next.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Is squatting a big problem for California?
A lot of people say this is overly exaggerated
by the media and it's not as bad.
Our guest today is Jonathan Madison,
who's a real estate attorney who has dealt firsthand
with squatting cases and he's seen a trend.
He's here to tell us what's going on
with squatting in California.
And if as a homeowner, if there are any ways
or any laws that can help you protect yourself.
I mean, it was just very evident
for everybody in the court to see
this guy is playing the system.
He took a buyout.
It's a shame because we're not only emboldening con artists,
but we're basically legalizing theft.
I'm Siyamak Karami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Jonathan, it's great to have you back.
Welcome back.
Thanks.
Thanks for having me back.
It's good to see you.
We want to talk to you about squatting
because squatting in California
and the rest of the country, it's happening.
How big is it?
You know, it's massive right now
and it's beyond the state of California.
It's nationwide.
They're having a squatting issue.
That's why you're hearing like people like DeSantis
and different big names in different states
that are actually taking action
to address the squatting issues in those states.
California, unfortunately we're behind
on the laws that actually address squatting.
We made some attempts, but it's far and wide.
It's beyond the inner cities.
It's beyond the urban areas.
It's everywhere.
We really want to understand how the laws work.
We have had guests on the show
and you told us about it too in the past,
but if somebody breaks into your property
and how does it work?
Like they can come in and take over?
Can you explain?
You know, I wish it weren't that simple,
but in California right now, it just about is, CMAC.
And in theory, one can come to your property,
say you have an investment property,
or say your property,
you haven't checked on it for a month or so,
you're not really gonna know if a squatter has come
or someone's broken into your property,
unless perhaps you've installed
some kind of a ring camera device.
But it is easy enough for a person in California today,
and they're protected by California law, by the way,
to come into someone's home that's not theirs,
somehow gain access to it, rekey it, break in somehow,
stay there for a period of time,
could be a matter of days or weeks,
and when the owner comes back to that property,
the squatter can tell the police when they come,
I live here, I have rights.
The part that's very difficult for a lot of people to digest
is the fact that the squatter doesn't have to prove
that they have a lease,
that they have an identification
consistent with their identity there in the home.
They don't have to show proof of people
who know them to live at that place.
All they have to do under California law today,
and these are the protections.
Whether you still call them protections
after this interview, these are the protections
that say if you somehow find yourself in a different home
or find a way into someone else's home,
and you're able to articulate to the police officer,
I'm here, I have rights, this is my place,
the police officer nine times out of 10
will look at you and say, well, I can't do anything,
and they'll look at the landlord
and they'll say, it's a civil issue.
And the squatter will be able to live there
until that landlord, property owner,
pays to get them out by legal action,
and that's pretty much how it goes.
Have you seen that happen?
I have, more often than I would like, I'll tell you that.
And even one time was too often.
But Stephanie Warren, who was another,
a former participant and guest of yours,
she was the first client that I had
that really encountered this issue.
This was about two years ago when it happened to her.
She had just recently purchased a property in Oakland,
and this was sort of an investment property.
She'd only had it on about three weeks or a month or so,
and she was planning to make renovations to it,
go in, and so when she went inside the property
after escrow closed, she noticed that it'd been broken into.
Some glass on the floor and some things happened.
And so she goes in, finds that there were squatters there,
somebody with a baseball bat saying,
get out of my house, get out of my property.
The irony, they said my property.
And so what does she do?
The same thing any other landlord
or property owner would do, she calls the police.
So the police show up.
Fortunately, she has ring camera footage
of them breaking into her property.
She thinks that'll be fine.
She calls me up on the other line and says,
stand by, you're my attorney, you don't need to say anything.
And I'm just as much in shock and awe as she is
when I hear the police officer say,
there's nothing we can do, it's a civil matter.
You have to get a court order from a judge
to get these people out.
And she asked me if that was the truth.
I said, well, I think the police should remove them,
but I don't know what to do in this situation
because California law appears to protect them.
And so that was the first time
I might encounter a client issue
that actually dealt with this issue.
If you have this situation, God forbid you have it,
what's the process of going through that?
And when you say the process,
just kind of how to get a squatter out,
kind of step by step.
So there's a couple of things any property owner
or landlord should know in California right now.
SB 602, Senate Bill, and Senate Bill 448.
Those are laws that have made it somewhat easier
to get a squatter out.
They basically say, okay,
if you post a 72 hour notice on your door,
you can ask the authorities,
serve a copy on the local sheriff,
but you can ask the authorities to remove the squatter.
Unfortunately, I haven't seen it work yet.
So with this caveat out there, it may not work,
but you should take action
in advance of any potential squatter coming.
You have an investment property,
a vacation home out there,
you're gonna be gone from your property for several weeks,
post the appropriate notice,
and hopefully you can do something about it.
So essentially you can go get a permit for a while.
Is it a year?
There's some-
Yes, it's been extended up to a year by way of SB 602.
And so you can do that and you can continue to renew it.
So you can, before, if you have a second home
or if you have a vacation home,
or if you're going on a long vacation,
you should go and apply for that?
Is that-
Well, actually it's something
you don't actually need to apply for, fortunately.
This is something, it's basically a notice
that you can post on your door, post on the property.
The only catch is you have to serve the notice
and it has to have the right language.
So not telling anyone to go out there on ChatGPT
and rely on it, right?
Make sure you get the help of a professional to do it
so it's effective.
But you would take that notice that's correctly drawn up.
You would take it to the sheriff.
You would let the sheriff's office know,
I'm gonna be out of town
or I'm worried about a potential outsider
coming into my home.
Please be on standby and alert.
And they lodge into their files
and they're supposed to await a phone call from you
if and when something happens.
So essentially you have to go to the sheriff's office
to file for that if you have a doubt
that somebody may break in.
Yes.
And it's kind of like minority report, right?
I mean, you don't really know until you know
that a squatter's gonna break into your property.
But unfortunately it's a measure that I would encourage
just about any California landowner or property owner
to take.
Just to be safe beforehand.
Just to be on the safe side.
Otherwise you'll be paying an attorney a lot of money
to get that squatter out,
which goes to your question about the process, CMAG.
If you don't have that measure in place
and perhaps if you do have it
and the authorities still don't act,
which is a possibility.
The law doesn't actually say the sheriff
or the police officers have to act.
It just says they may enforce, right?
So that's a caveat.
But the process is if you find yourself in a situation
where you have a squatter there,
you don't know some kind of stranger,
whoever it is in your property,
first thing you do,
I still say contact the local authorities.
Perhaps there's a chance that some officer
or sheriff out there might do the right thing.
They might feel they can do it in their jurisdiction.
I don't know anyone who doesn't in San Francisco,
Oakland, San Jose, San Mateo.
I mean, I could go down the list of places,
but that's the first step.
Call the local law enforcement.
Make sure you have a police report on file.
Then you would wanna retain counsel,
retain an attorney to file an action for eviction.
They'll post the appropriate notice on the door saying
they have to leave within a specified time.
They don't leave within that specified time.
You file the unlawful detainer action.
That's an eviction action for those who may not know.
And you get a court date.
Hope that the tenant or the squatter here,
you hope that they don't hire an attorney
that's paid for by your tax dollar as a landowner,
as a property owner.
You hope that they don't hire free legal assistance
because they can file all kinds of motions
to delay the process.
Even though they're squatters, is that?
Even though they're squatters.
In fact, CMAC, I think the irony in my profession right now
is most of the squatter cases I deal with,
they're able to retain free legal counsel
that's paid for by all of our tax dollars.
That's essentially put aside for tenants, right?
Because when sometimes some landlords
may be doing wrong things for the tenants
and this is to protect the tenants, right?
Exactly, exactly.
And you hit it on the nail there.
It's protecting tenants,
but it's not necessarily protecting squatters.
The problem with California law right now
is that the law doesn't distinguish
between a squatter and a tenant on its face.
And squatters have gotten roped into this classification
of being deemed a tenant.
And that's dangerous because it puts the law
in a situation where it's emboldening con artists
and people who are breaking into homes
and saying, you can do this and still be protected
if you do it the right way and you know the lingo.
Tell the police officers, tenant rights, civil rights,
and then all of a sudden you have free access
to utilize someone else's property.
And it's really a shame.
It's really, and this was born out of the COVID-19 crisis,
of course, the pandemic.
But it's a shame because we've really found ourselves now
in a place where we're not only emboldening con artists,
but we're basically legalizing theft.
If you like to know what's happening in California,
you definitely should read the Epoch Times newspaper.
There's a section in there that talks about California
and California news in a very non-partisan,
non-biased, factual, calm manner.
For example, one of the stories here is about gas prices.
Lawmakers are asking the regulators
what's going on with the gas prices in California.
This story has all the details of what happened.
We also have other stories in there.
One of the most fascinating ones
is how the wolves are attacking farmers
and ranchers, their cattle.
Now, the state has been responding to these attacks
by launching a map to help farmers and ranchers
know where the wolves are.
This is an amazing and fascinating story.
We've been following it at Epoch Times.
There's a lot more stories in here
that you should be checking out.
If you find these stories interesting,
make sure to check out the Epoch Times newspaper.
We'll leave you a link below.
We have a special offer for our followers, for our fans.
It's a dollar a week.
Make sure to check it out, and if you like it, subscribe.
Now let's go back to the interview.
So you were mentioning the process.
They could delay the process,
but what's usually the length of the process
and how much does it cost?
I will say it varies depending on what county you're in.
On average, I'd say the process could be anywhere
from four to eight months, you know,
depending on the jurisdiction you're in
and depending on how much motion practice,
how much fight you get from the other side.
And then in some cases, the squatter,
in fact, in a number of cases,
the squatter will get paid to leave by the landlord
on top of all the other legal fees.
You know, so you'll end up in a situation
where if you're the landowner, CMAC,
you've not only lost eight months potentially
of rent at your property,
you've let someone stay in your property,
you've paid for the utility bills,
you've paid for water, you've paid for garbage,
you've paid for heating,
because California law requires you to do all that,
by the way.
You'll get sued by the squatter if you don't.
But you've done all that, you've lost rent,
and then on top of that,
the squatter often gets paid like a buyout sum
that can range anywhere from 10 to 20,
I've seen up to $100,000 to leave someone's place, right?
And that's the kind of thing we're dealing with right now.
Have you dealt with cases like that
where your customers had to pay?
I have.
I have a client up in Red Bluff.
Perhaps you wanna interview him.
I won't disclose his name here,
but I have a client up in Red Bluff.
He has three properties up there,
and he paid a contractor
to kind of do some rehabilitation work,
some renovations on two of the other properties.
The contractor lives in one property.
And the contractor one day decided,
wow, well, why don't I just allow myself access
to the other two units and move my family,
my girlfriend, and all these other people
into those other units?
And so that's what he did.
So my client now is in a position
where he has to make a decision
to go through this heavy litigation process
or pay a pretty good sum to the contractor.
And I think he's gonna pay a sum to the contractor
because he understands he gets his property
back sooner that way,
but otherwise he's gonna also be paying me
to litigate this process.
And so at some point when you're a landowner,
you also gotta determine
how am I gonna put food on the table still?
How am I gonna pay for the mortgage, right?
He's thinking, well, I may do better
if I pay this guy to leave next month
so I can put some people back in those properties,
cover the mortgage.
I can't tell you the number of people,
landowners who have gone bankrupt
because of this phenomenon.
And you are in the thick of all this, right?
You're seeing a lot of cases, right?
Squarely in the thick of it.
I was, and it's common in practice,
CMAC for attorneys in the profession to talk, right?
I was talking with another property owner attorney.
He was telling me about a case that he had
down in Los Angeles.
It really almost brought me to tears.
He talked about how his client was a single mother,
worked two jobs, a lot of her life.
Her father passed away and she inherited a condo, right?
Nice condo down there.
And as she was in her grieving stage,
I mean, you can't do a whole lot
when you're in that grieving phase, right?
As she was grieving, she went,
I guess she checked both the units or one of the units,
found out that a squatter had moved in
and started just kind of living there,
living in the property.
And she obviously just didn't know what to do.
So she contacted an attorney,
eventually got back to the person that I talked to.
And even with him, I consider him a great attorney,
great at what he does.
It took him almost a year
to get that tenant out of that unit.
This is a single mother we're talking about.
She didn't have a whole lot of money.
The single mothers are some of the people,
the individuals we should be fighting hardest
to protect in this society.
They're the most vulnerable.
I read about a veteran up in Oakland,
like 15 minutes from where I am,
seeing back in San Francisco.
Read about a veteran who had returned
from like a long hospital stay.
You know, he was battling a pretty big health condition.
So he returned home,
find squatters that had found their way inside of his house.
He called the police,
thought that he would have some clout
by telling the police officers,
I'm a veteran of the country.
And the police officers told him,
what I told you earlier, it's a civil matter.
So we have this veteran that ended up
sleeping in his vehicle for months
while the squatters occupied his house
until he could afford some legal representation.
And it's these kinds of stories, CM Mac,
that for me just tell us,
what tells me how far from just of a society that we are.
You know, we talk about tenants' rights being civil rights.
So are property rights.
Everybody talks about tenants' rights.
What about property owner rights?
Those are civil rights as well.
And when you have laws that are supposed to
or intended to protect,
purported to protect the most vulnerable in our society,
tenants, people at the lower end
of the socioeconomic spectrum,
have someone tell me who's protecting the homeless veteran,
who's protecting the single mother,
those people who happen to own property
and that aren't rich and wealthy.
You mentioned that you cannot turn the power,
electricity, and all those things off.
You get sued.
How does that work?
There is a law in California that basically says
if someone is occupying your property,
you cannot turn off the electricity,
can't turn off the power and electric,
can't turn off the heat,
can't turn off the garbage, any of that.
And the idea behind that is what we call in-
It's like the tenant probably, right?
Exactly.
And look, CIMAC, if you had a law-abiding tenant,
if you had a tenant, right,
you have a lease agreement with the tenant,
of course they deserve working heat.
They deserve access to water, running water, hot water.
They deserve access to a habitable living condition.
And in the law, we call that the habitability,
warranty of habitability,
the implied warranty of habitability,
if you want to get technical about it.
But it's this idea that every tenant
or occupant of property has rights
to live in comfortable conditions, habitable conditions.
The problem here is that you and I should clearly,
and hopefully most of the viewers
should clearly be able to distinguish
someone who breaks into someone's home
and unlawfully stays there
from one who has a legal lease agreement,
enforceable lease agreement, to actually live there.
I pay rent there, I stay there.
Even if I don't pay rent there,
the landlord knows who I am
and I'm lawfully living here, right?
The law does not distinguish that right now.
The law says if you have an occupant in your home, period,
they are entitled to running water, heat, gas, and electric.
It doesn't matter how they got it.
Doesn't matter how they got it.
Law says they're entitled to all the utilities.
They're on Netflix and Hulu while you're at it.
That's a joke.
They're not entitled to Netflix or Hulu.
But it's a little sarcasm, but the point is,
how is a law, how is a justice system
gonna penalize landlords for not having their lights on
or their gas and electric, all these things,
for someone who's broken into their home?
And that's the problem that you probably read
about this story down in Los Angeles.
An elderly lady, a senior,
who had actually rented out an Airbnb to a tenant.
And I'm sorry, she actually didn't rent it out.
She had an Airbnb.
A squatter broke into the Airbnb, stayed,
and then the squatter ended up suing her
because she had turned off the lights, the gas, electric.
She was dealing with some hard times.
She didn't even know the guy was there.
And so he sued her.
Wow.
And so, and I think they ended up settling
after about eight to 11 months or so.
But when you end up in a situation,
if you're a property owner,
you either work your butt off to get the property,
you inherited the property.
Somehow you got access to that property.
You wanna shut off your lights,
you wanna turn off the utilities, it's lawful.
But because someone broke into your home and took possession
now you're required to make sure they have running water.
You're basically furnishing their lifestyle.
You're making sure that they have a place that's habitable.
You're making sure they have comfort.
Someone who stole your property, stole your possession.
And I just think that's fundamentally wrong.
Now, Jonathan, some people say
that this whole squatting issue is overblown in the media.
You know, there's too much talk about it.
You are seeing this on the ground.
Do you see more, there's not a lot of data about it, right?
You know, there's not, I'll say this,
there's not as much data on-
The numbers.
On the mainstream as there should be, you know.
I'll tell you this, as someone who's boots on the ground,
who's in the court system just about every day,
who works with real clients,
people in real time who have dealt with the issue,
I don't think it's overblown at all.
I don't think it's amplified enough.
Now, I'll tell you why.
I think if it were amplified enough,
we'd have some law in place enacted that said,
okay, well, we're gonna listen to common sense if,
and let's just make it very simple, CMAC, very simple.
If you can prove that you live there,
you can show a lease agreement,
you can show some identification,
maybe even know someone who could say,
yeah, I think he lives there.
Okay, well, then you're good.
You're fine.
If you can't do that,
and perhaps it's documented on some kind
of a ring camera device that you broke in
and it's that obvious, you don't get to stay.
You should be removed by a police or the sheriff.
I think if we had a law enacted
that were that simple, common sense, straightforward,
I don't think you'd hear about these situations.
And have you seen more?
When was the, you said the first time
you saw a couple of years ago,
what happened after the pandemic?
Was there another law that caused this or?
I would qualify that, right?
Because the pandemic, you had all these laws
that were born out of the pandemic, right?
You had the Tenant Protection Act is one of them,
but you had the eviction moratoriums, of course,
and you had these laws within the eviction moratoriums
that said, if you're living a property,
doesn't matter if you don't have a lease agreement,
doesn't matter if your lease agreement is slated
to end at a certain time, you're protected, you know?
And look, it was an emergency situation.
There was a lot going on.
We understand that was a tumultuous time
for our nation, the world.
But after the so-called eviction moratoriums expired,
we still have those laws in place, right?
That say, hey, if you're an occupant,
doesn't necessarily matter how you got there.
You have rights, right?
That's kind of how we got here.
And I think the solution is just kind of retweaking it
to make common sense again.
California Insider is partnering
with Californians with Energy and Science
to have a panel on energy issues in California,
from the regulatory side of things to innovation.
This panel is gonna be on June 13th in our studio.
Make sure to sign up.
We'll look forward to seeing you here in person.
So Jonathan, in your experience,
you have been seeing some of these individuals
that are doing the squatting, right?
You've had to deal with them in court.
What are they like?
You know, they range in personalities.
There are some commonalities that I've seen.
Again, not generalizing all squatters out there,
but from what I've seen in court,
there's a couple of different personalities I've seen.
I've seen someone who was squatting in property
who was asked questions by a judge.
Judge was trying to ascertain
whether they actually lived at the property or not.
And the individual who was squatting
in that particular property looks up at the judge
and says, very confidently
and very knowledgeable about the law.
Starts quoting the civil code, the evidence code,
and says, well, my rights are protected pursuant to.
And I said, wow, this person sounds more articulate
than their lawyer.
So I remember, you know, some of the lawyers
that I did professionally, we were just kind of talking.
How did that happen?
But it tells me that the tenants really are,
or that some of these squatters really are that savvy.
We're not just dealing with individuals who,
we're not just dealing with individuals
who may be hard on luck or need a place to stay,
but there are professionals out there,
know their rights under California law,
know how to quote them to a judge,
know how to utilize the protections they have
to stay in properties, and quote, unquote,
game the system, right?
You have those.
And there's an example out there,
the popular Malibu squatter, right?
And short story is, there's this individual
who was going to different places in Malibu
squatting in different properties.
Malibu, of all places, hence how they got the name.
But it points out a bigger problem.
And it was getting paid, right, that individual?
Was getting paid to leave
out of every one of these properties.
It's a real operation.
You break into the property,
or you find a way to get into the property,
even if you don't break in.
Some tenants were savvy enough to hire a locksmith
to change the locks, prove to the locksmith,
I don't know how you do that,
maybe you drop some fake lease or sham lease or something,
prove to the locksmith they had rights to the property,
locksmith changes the locks to let the people in.
So you have people that do this,
they'll stay on the property,
and they'll get a check to leave.
So it's a real operation.
And while I have yet to find,
and I'm not gonna be a conspiracy theorist out there,
but I have yet to find any legitimate organization
out there of squatters,
but I wouldn't be surprised if there are some kind of,
whether groups or underground organizations,
people that get together, whatever you wanna call them,
and literally plan out what properties
they're gonna squat in,
how much they're gonna get paid,
and have a real strategy.
Because the individual I just told you about
was very savvy, very intelligent.
So we're not just dealing with people
that are hard on luck.
Tell us about this court case,
can you tell us what happened?
I represented the landowner,
who had a squatter living there in his property.
Squatter had been there for a few weeks or so,
landlord filed the unlawful detainer action.
So we're in court on the squatters,
actually we're in court on my motion,
we made a motion in conjunction
with removing the squatter.
We're basically trying to show and establish to the court,
the squatter does not have rights to be there.
It's called a motion for summary judgment.
And so the judge turns to the squatter
to hear testimony directly from the squatter,
and says, can you tell us,
can you give us some kind of proof
that you actually have lived there?
Can you show us some kind of what we call
clear and convincing evidence
that you live at the property?
So the squatter proceeds to look into his backpack
right there on the stand.
He says, okay, well, let me,
he's looking for stuff,
he pulls out some pieces of mail,
he puts them on the table,
gives them to the clerk,
clerk runs them up to the judge.
As the judge is reviewing the documents,
because these are purported documents
that would show the squatter lives at the property,
the judge looks at the squatter and he says,
well, as I'm reviewing these,
can you tell me what evidence other than this
do you have that you live there?
Do you have a lease?
How do you know the property owner?
Do you know the property owner?
And the squatter says,
well, the law says I don't need to know the property owner.
And the judge looks at him and says, what?
And the squatter says,
yeah, well, under evidence code section,
under penal, basically starts quoting
all of these different laws, right?
And I mean, it's actually pretty impressive
from my standpoint to see someone in layman's terms,
not an attorney, having understood
and being able to articulate this in such a fashion.
And so, I'm sitting there and I can't object.
I mean, he's over there, the judge is listening to him.
And so I'm just appalled.
I'm listening to this guy really tell the judge
about what the law is,
as if the judge didn't know himself.
But the judge says, whoa, I know what the law says.
What I'm trying to understand is,
do you have any proof that you live there?
And the tenant said, well, or the squatter rather,
says, well, I gave you some pieces of mail.
The mail just said, it was like some medical bills
from a different place.
And then I think the squatter had some friend
to send him mail after the fact,
just to show that he had a residency.
Some games that they play.
Some letters from friends.
Yeah, some letters from friends.
Some postcards or something.
And so the judge ended up taking the matter under submission
but there was definitely an exchange there.
The judge was, first of all, very surprised
but also very frustrated.
And look, the courts in Alameda County are,
I'd still say they lean tenant-friendly
more often than not,
just because of the demographic,
the jurisdiction up there.
But there was clearly an exchange
and everybody in the courtroom could see it.
The judge was flustered.
The squatter was confident.
And I was confused.
But I think that illustration, a real illustration,
tells us we have a problem that needs to be fixed.
And I was encouraged that at least the judge
took issue with it.
The judge is not just saying,
oh, well, let's give it a pass.
The judges are actively scrutinizing these people
and the situations.
And personally, I think maybe the squatter
would have done better if he just said,
hey, I'm on hard times.
But you go the extra mile and say,
oh no, I know my rights.
He basically, to me, he was saying,
this is my business, this is what I do.
And so you're not gonna talk me out of this
when I know what my rights are.
And the fact that he said, yeah, I know what my rights are
and he started quoting his rights,
he's quoting the law which protects him
and he does have rights.
So for me, puts me in an adverse position
because I'm supposed to argue the law
but it's the contrary part of the law.
But if he's quoting the law that protects him,
I can't say it's not true.
So anyways, that was the dynamic.
Did the judge make a decision to change that
or it had to go?
We ultimately did not win our motion for summary judgment
because, again, of a loophole in the law.
And so we ended up getting him out.
We went to trial ultimately and he took a buyout
and he ultimately left.
But as far as that motion,
I mean, it was just very evident
for everybody in the court to see
this guy is playing the system,
he's winning and there's nothing even anyone
could do about it.
Because the judge is not gonna change the law.
All they can do is enforce it.
There is another concept,
it's called adverse possession of homes.
Adverse possession, yeah.
Have you seen cases with this?
And can you explain that for those people
that have property, they should know about this?
Yeah, yeah, no, it's a great question, CIMAC.
Adverse possession, this is the concept
they teach you in law school
and you have all these hypotheticals.
And it's funny, I remember having hypotheticals
and now I'm seeing more of them in real time.
Did you think they would be possible?
Yeah, now they're possible, it's wow.
So thank you to the California legislature.
But in a nutshell, adverse possession
requires about five elements.
I won't bore the people who are viewing
out of their minds, but in a nutshell,
adverse possession is, look,
you have to have continuous and open possession
of a property for about a five year period.
It has to be open and notorious,
that's what the law says.
You have to pay taxes, you have to,
you actually at least have to take actions
on the property, right?
You can't just be in hiding,
people can't know that you're,
people can't not know that you're around.
You can't just, you can't be in adverse possession
if you're hitting the whole time.
It has to be very clear that, look,
this is my place, I've taken steps to occupy it,
and then after a certain period of time,
I believe the law's still five years,
the law can deem you to actually have a stake
or an interest in that property.
The difference between adverse possession
and what I'll call squatter possession
is that squatters have come in
in different properties and they're basically saying,
well, yeah, this is my place, I'll kick my feet up,
and I'm not gonna pay the taxes,
I'm not gonna pay the rents,
I'm not gonna contribute,
and I'm just gonna stay here as long as I can.
And by the way, the law says,
I may even be able to get a buyout, you know?
I may even be able to get a paycheck at the end of this,
you know?
So, but that's the difference.
And there's no criminal consequences,
or do you, is it possible to go after people
like that criminally?
It is, it is.
And to be fair, it is possible.
The likelihood of success on the prosecution,
I don't know.
I'll tell you this, in my practice,
since the day that I had the first encounter
I told you about,
I haven't seen one tenant, excuse me,
one squatter prosecuted for squatting in the property,
that at all.
And I mean, I honestly don't know
that the district attorney's offices
in our state are taking those as a priority.
And look, there are worse crimes out there.
There are certainly more heinous crimes
than staying at someone else's property,
but doesn't mean the people breaking in
shouldn't be penalized for it, you know?
And so that's why I take issue with it.
Crime is gonna happen, right?
Whether it's people breaking into homes,
breaking into cars, stealing things.
You know, in California, as you know, CIMAC,
you have that $999.
$950, which is gone now.
Which is gone now, right, right.
But that was a thing for a while,
and it was like, okay, finally someone woke up.
But the point is, we know crime is gonna happen.
But without safeguards, without punishments of some kind,
there's just no enforcement,
and people are gonna continue to do it
because it's convenient.
Do you have any recommendation for our audience
that might be concerned about this?
Well, there's two things.
If you're a property owner out there,
or a landlord out there, I would tell you a few things.
Number one, make sure you have a notice,
the appropriate notice posted on your door.
So when you're not there, you should post a notice?
Absolutely.
If you're not there, it's a 72-hour notice.
Make sure you have the assistance of a professional
to prepare the notice for you.
And you put it on your door?
Is that how it works?
You put it on your door, actually all points of entry.
So if you have a back door,
put it on the back door as well, side door.
And make sure you serve that notice
on your local sheriff's department.
Make sure they understand you're gonna be gone
for a period of time,
so they have had it documented as well.
And so that's at least one thing you can actively do
to stop someone from coming in.
At least if they get in, you have a better chance
of calling law enforcement and dealing with it.
And I think that that's probably the largest viewership,
probably viewing this video.
If you're a law-abiding tenant,
keep doing what you're doing.
If you're a squatter, I hope the law changes.
That's what I'll say.
And what about the law?
What is needed to fix this?
For me, and it's funny,
I was just having this conversation with my law partner.
If it were up to me,
I would make it a very blanket approach.
And it would basically be an amendment
to the Tenant Protection Act.
I would have an amendment that said,
to the extent one is deemed a squatter,
we all know what a squatter is.
We don't have to get into the language of-
Someone broke in and took over here.
To the extent one is deemed a squatter,
cannot identify themselves upon request,
cannot produce a lease agreement.
And it is open and obvious that they are a squatter.
They have no rights to possess the property of another.
And they can be arrested
at the discretion of the local law enforcement.
And I think that language would be still very discretionary,
very soft, because there are people out there that say,
you broke into a home,
you should absolutely be prosecuted.
At least you leave some discretion
for local law enforcement to exercise the punishment
that they deem worthy, that meets the crime.
San Francisco is different from Los Angeles,
is different from Red Bluff and whatnot.
So that's pretty much the change that I would see.
It's very straightforward.
You have people in the legislature that are saying,
oh, if we amend eight sections and codify this
and get 300 letters from the departments,
you don't need all of that.
All you need is to make the adjustments
to the language in hand.
You need to change the Tenant Protection Act.
You need to change the laws locally
that make it easy and lawful
for one to come in and break into someone's property.
Make it a crime, you'll deter the crime,
and you'll protect the most vulnerable people out there,
which may surprise some of us CMAC
are actually property owners.
Are people in California, in Sacramento,
the legislature, the lawmakers,
are they paying attention to this?
They are paying attention to it,
and that's the good news.
The legislature is not only paying attention,
but they're pretty much forced to
by their constituents, right?
And I think that's why you've seen
the recent enactment of laws
like SB 602, SB 448,
a number of other laws out there,
and you're sort of seeing the shift
from a very sort of a tenant advocate-based
string of laws to now there's actually
an open ear for people who own property.
Another example is there's a law out there
that did not pass.
Sometimes I tell people at CMAC,
you often learn more from the laws
that don't pass than the laws that do,
and there's a law out there that would've created
essentially what's called an office of tenant advocacy
as a whole nother entire government arm
would cost millions of dollars and whatnot.
That failed.
And by the way, one of their purposes
would've been the protection of occupant rights,
which could've been squatters, of course.
The fact that that bill failed
and it did have more support than one would think
tells me there are some legislatures,
some legislators out there that are waking up,
hearing the cries and concerns of property owners,
landlords who are saying enough is enough,
and so now you have certain laws
that allow you to post the 72-hour notice.
And look, in being an optimist,
I do think things are gonna continue to shift
in the other direction,
not for the purpose of the landlord being right
or the property owner being right.
I always say it's not about who's right,
it's about what's right, right?
And I think at the end of the day,
if we continue on in this direction
where you have more laws that continue
to give landowners and property owners
a means by which to enforce their rights,
to pay their bills, pay the mortgage,
keep possession of their properties,
I think you'll end up in a situation
where you're able to penalize those who break in
and you're still able to protect those tenants
who do need help,
because there are a lot of tenants that need protection.
There are a lot of people
at the lower end of the socioeconomic spectrum,
vulnerable people, individuals,
classes of people that need protection.
So it's important to continue to protect
the most vulnerable, whether they be tenants,
whether they be property owners.
And I think over the next probably three to five years,
you're gonna see more laws that benefit property owners
rather than disenfranchise them.
Now, if the laws change,
is it possible to go after these people and prosecute them?
Absolutely, absolutely.
Because the individual I referenced earlier
wouldn't be able to say,
oh, well, pursuant to California evidence code,
the rebuttal from the judge will be,
well, there's also a law that says
you can't squat on somebody's property unlawfully.
You can't be there, right?
So again, I think the good news for property owners
out there and landlords,
yes, you're still in California.
Yes, you're still dealing with squatters today,
but the laws are changing day by day in your favor.
And you ask anybody out there,
even on the tenant side, landlord side,
attorneys out there,
they will tell you the wind is at the backs
of landlords and property owners
in terms of the movement, right?
From the law, the legislators,
and the advocates out there.
Because I think people are waking up.
They're waking up and saying,
common sense says this is not right.
So a short answer, long answer to a short question,
yes, it would make it far easier
if the laws were changed to get someone out.
Jonathan Madison, real estate attorney.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you, always great to be here, see you, Mac.
Let us know what you think of the laws
of squatting in California and nationally.
You can always email us at ciamacacaliforniansider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Ciamak Korami, this is California Insider,
and we'll see you next time.
