Carnegie Hall's Opening Night in 1891

Opera House Stories
2 followers
3 Video Views·Jun 5, 2025
On May 5, 1891, Carnegie Hall opened its doors for the first time, Tchaikovsky ushering in a new standard for the presentation of live music and public events in New York City.
Now 120 years later—in the first of a new series—Carnegie Hall's Museum Director and Archivist Gino Francesconi provides a fascinating and entertaining insight into the Hall's first Opening Night, using some of the earliest and rarest artifacts from the Archives.
Hello, my name is Gino Francesconi. I am the director of the Archives and the Rose Museum
and we are celebrating our 120th anniversary here at Carnegie Hall.
And so I thought I'd like to take you back to opening night of 1891
and I'll show you some of the more rare treasures we have here.
Ground was broken in 1889. This is the silver trowel that Mrs. Carnegie used to lay the
cornerstone and it says, with this trowel Mrs. Andrew Carnegie laid the cornerstone of the new
music hall building southeast corner 57th Street and 7th Avenue, New York, May 13, 1890.
Andrew Carnegie stood right next to his wife Louise and proclaimed that this hall will
intertwine itself with the history of our country.
Now it's amazing because the corner of 57th Street and 7th Avenue, while it's Midtown today,
on May 13th of 1890, it was three and a half miles north of Midtown, the 14th Street area.
That was Midtown. It was the heart of the city. People weren't really sure
if this was going to be a success or not. It was an extraordinarily large building
in a quiet neighborhood. This is really one of our treasures. It's one of the few drawings we have
in the architect's hand. Now the interesting thing about the architect is that he had never
designed before a concert hall. William Burnett Tuthill was only 34 years old. Extraordinary
when you think the chance that Andrew Carnegie took with this young architect. The history of
acoustics was just beginning at this time, but Tuthill was an amazing cellist. The detailing
was extraordinarily simple. I like to say sometimes if you walked into the Home Depot of the day,
the details that are in the hall were the ones you would have found in the box three for a dollar.
In fact, if you look at some of these wreaths that are in the boxes, they're on every other
keyhole in Park Slope in Brooklyn. And yet the magic that the architect created by his simplicity
is stunning. So Tuesday, May 5, 1891 arrived. This is one of the more valuable items we have.
It's a program for the opening week festival. What they did was they invited the most famous
musician of the day, Tchaikovsky. Opening night was totally sold out. In fact, one article says
the ushers were getting as much as a dollar and a half to let people sneak in. Just a glimpse
of Tchaikovsky. Opening night audience, they saw the entire New York Oratorio Society on stage,
and the oration began. Damrosch conducted the Leonore Overture No. 3 of Beethoven,
and then Tchaikovsky was now going to come out and conduct the March Solonale.
The next day, the newspapers were filled with praise. Everyone from the beginning was
already saying this actually could become the center of New York's cultural scene.
To me, it's as an American story as any immigrant coming to this country and making it big.
Imagine, what are the chances of a poor location, an inexperienced architect,
coming up with one of the greatest concert halls in the world?
