The Impossibility of Perpetual Motion Machines

Basic Applied Science
14 followers
1 Video View·Jun 3, 2025
A perpetual motion machine is a hypothetical device that would operate forever without the need for additional energy. However, this violates the laws of thermodynamics, especially the law of conservation of energy. Friction and heat loss make absolute efficiency impossible in practice.
Thanks to CuriosityStream for supporting PBS Digital Studios.
Bad ideas come and go in physics, but there's one bit of nonsense
that is perhaps more persistent than all of the others.
The perpetual motion machine.
No working perpetual motion machine has ever been experimentally verified.
All break the laws of thermodynamics.
In fact, we classify them based on which law of thermodynamics they break.
We have perpetual motion machines of the first kind.
They violate energy conservation.
They pump more energy out than they need to keep running.
This includes most of the historical devices.
Then there are machines of the second kind.
They're a bit more subtle in their wrongness
because they break the second law of thermodynamics,
extracting energy by reversing entropy.
Many modern free energy devices fall into that category.
Now, the best modern designs are by you.
They are answers to our recent challenge question,
which we'll get to in the end.
But first, let's take a look at examples of what other people came up with.
This will be a fun little journey through some pretty terrible science.
Designing your own perpetual motion machine
became quite the craze from the Middle Ages through the Renaissance.
The first well-documented design was from the 12th century.
Bhaskara's wheel, named after the Indian mathematician,
it was embedded with these tubes of mercury
that would flow back and forth as the wheel turned.
Other types of over-balanced wheels
followed through the Renaissance and worked on the same principle.
Basically, that the shift in the center of gravity of the spokes on one side
should drive the wheel around.
There were also designs that employed the magical-seeming lodestones, magnets.
For example, this ramp in which a ball is pulled to the top of a ramp by a magnet
before falling through a hole and rolling to the bottom again.
Then there were the self-pumping water wheels or the self-blowing windmills.
None of these machines actually worked.
In every case, you can find a subtle bit of physics that the designers overlooked.
The over-balanced wheel pushes masses outwards on one side,
but at the same time increases the separation between those masses
so that the moment of inertia is unchanged.
A magnet strong enough to pull a ball up an incline
would also prevent it from falling through that hole.
Losses due to friction mean that water or wind driving a mill
could never produce enough energy to fully complete the cycle.
Close, but no perpetually burning cigar.
Now, to be fair to the people working during the Middle Ages and the Renaissance,
the law of conservation of energy hadn't been discovered yet.
Thus the proliferation of first-type machines that could generate more energy than they used.
But absolute proof of their non-viability
by the discovery of the first law of thermodynamics in the 18th century did not end the craze.
Inventors just graduated to instead breaking the second law of thermodynamics.
To review, the second law states that entropy can never decrease over time.
Or in other words, energy will tend to spread itself out as evenly as possible,
to a state of maximum entropy.
All machines work by riding this flow of energy as it redistributes itself.
Machines of the second kind claim to be able to tap reservoirs of energy
that are already evenly spread, effectively reversing the growth of entropy.
Now, before we get to second law violating modern perpetual motion machines,
let's take a look at some actually interesting ideas that illustrate the limit of the second law.
First up, the Brownian ratchet.
It goes like this.
A paddle wheel immersed in a gas is connected to a cog with a latch
that only lets it turn in one direction.
Individual gas particles are moving around with random, or Brownian, motion.
When one hits the wheel in one direction, the cog turns,
but in the other direction, the rotation is blocked.
That sounds plausible, and it actually works,
but only if the chamber containing the cog is at a lower temperature.
If it's at the same temperature,
then the cog is as likely to be pushed back when the latch raises.
Richard Feynman himself demonstrated this mathematically.
This is actually a specific example of a Maxwell's daemon device,
an entropy-reversing thought experiment that we've discussed before.
With no energy or temperature gradient, no energy can be extracted.
In fact, there's an absolute limit on the amount of energy that can be extracted
based on the difference in temperature.
That limit is defined by the most important,
perhaps the only important, perpetual motion system ever conceived.
The Carnot cycle.
In the early 19th century, Sadi Carnot described the most efficient possible engine.
It's a sequence of expansion and contraction of gas in a piston chamber
that will provide the maximum possible energy
as heat flows between reservoirs of different temperature.
Critically, the Carnot cycle is reversible.
Drive the piston in reverse with exactly the same amount of energy,
and it'll transfer energy from cold to hot.
In principle, a Carnot cycle could extract energy from a temperature gradient
and then pump it back in again, making it a candidate perpetual motion machine.
But even in this most ideal case, the ratio of energy in to energy out is exactly unity.
No extra energy is extracted.
The Carnot cycle is, in principle, a perpetual motion process,
but it doesn't break any laws of thermodynamics, so it's not the first or second kind.
In fact, it's the third kind.
These are perpetual motion machines that do not attempt to generate energy.
They just keep themselves running forever.
Sounds okay, right?
After all, Newton tells us that an object in motion tends to remain in motion
unless acted upon by an outside force.
So remove all outside forces, remove all friction,
all energy losses of any kind, and surely any machine can tick on forever.
Indeed, there are ideal systems that, from pure classical principles,
should run forever, like a perfect Carnot engine,
or a frictionless wheel with or without magnets or mercury tubes,
or a planet orbiting a star.
Just eliminate any leakage of energy.
But that's not just an engineering challenge.
It's fundamentally impossible.
Actually, quantum mechanics forbids this.
Due to the intrinsic randomness of all particles,
as expressed by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle,
everything moves.
Internal parts always vibrate, guaranteeing some friction and internal heat.
Even if that heat is recaptured, the outer walls of even the most carefully isolated system
must radiate, slowly leaking energy.
And then of course there's the gravitational radiation
that will slowly sap the perpetual motion of celestial systems.
The best-case scenario for a perpetual motion machine of the third kind
is a very, very slow wind-down to stillness.
Now that we've reviewed the three types of possible wrongness in perpetual motion machines,
let's look at some of the modern proposals.
Most look like the ancient predecessors,
often lots of wheels with lots of magnets somehow powering their own motion
and producing extra energy besides.
These are often referred to as overunity devices.
The ratio of energy out to energy in is greater than one.
And that name was actually coined by patent officers,
which in the US and the UK refused to review devices claiming overunity energy production.
And understandably, it eliminates 50% of their crank submissions.
Now the purveyors of overunity devices
typically do not claim to have created perpetual motion devices of the first kind.
They have various explanations for how they don't violate conservation of energy.
However, most end up shifting their device to the second kind of perpetual motion.
They violate the second law of thermodynamics
One popular source of free energy is the zero point energy of the quantum vacuum,
and it's the most fun to debunk.
I'm going to have to refer you to our entire playlist on the quantum vacuum for the physics,
but the important point is that any energy of the vacuum is exactly the same everywhere.
It has no energy gradient, so it isn't accessible as an energy source.
Now, it may be possible to create an energy gradient, for example, with the Casimir effect,
in which parallel plates are pulled together by lowering the zero point energy in between them.
But doing so repeatedly in an engine cycle takes at least as much energy as it produces.
The best you have is a perpetual motion machine of the third kind.
Most modern perpetual motion builders aren't so technical.
In fact, the worst of them wouldn't have physics or engineering chops
to build a decent overbalance wheel.
They rely more on pseudo-physics speak.
Zero point mag-grav plasma torus vibrations sounds fancy,
but are typically less good at generating free energy
than they are at directing you to the donate button
or selling you a telluric-filled wellness crystal.
Okay, enough with the nonsense.
Let's get to the challenge question,
in which I ask you to come up with a perpetual motion machine
based on the funky notion of negative mass.
According to some interpretations, negative mass should be attracted to positive mass,
but positive mass should be repelled by negative mass.
The result is that a positive and negative mass should accelerate indefinitely,
potentially powering an infinite energy device.
But how to build one?
Let's see what you came up with.
Many of you hit upon the most obvious and the most efficient approach,
attaching positive and negative mass apples to a dynamo
so that they chase each other in circles, driving a generator.
Here are some of the better designs.
Nice adaption of the Biscara wheel from Creepy Magician.
Alex Taylor has an exceptionally cool dynamo device
in which the masses are contained in a magnetic field.
He also does the full relativistic calculation for power.
Nice one, Alex.
We have a rare non-dynamo device from Adrian Romeo,
who uses cogs with negative and positive mass teeth.
This post-it will be framed in the Smithsonian
after the Romeo engine solves humanity's energy crisis.
And the prize for most outlandish goes to Epsilon Centauri,
whose machine requires an entire bubble universe
with closed Pac-Man borders, trapping the ever-accelerating apples.
If you saw your name and device just now, that means you're a winner.
You get your pick from the Spacetime store.
Shoot us an email at pbspacetime at gmail.com and we'll get your goodies to you.
And feel free to check out the store even if you didn't win,
or if you think you should have won, or if you didn't get around to submitting,
but are pretty sure you would have won if you did.
We all deserve merch.
Link in the description.
I'm also going to post some of the best solutions to this challenge on Instagram.
Check them out at Matt of Earth.
And I leave you with wise words from someone
who designed quite a few perpetual motion machines himself, Leonardo da Vinci.
Oh ye seekers after perpetual motion, how many vain chimeras have you pursued?
Go and take your place with the alchemists.
Da Vinci was way ahead of his time in some ways.
He knew perpetual motion was bunk even before the laws of thermodynamics came along.
But vain chimeras had only da Vinci known
that his own perpetual motion machines could escort him such sweet swag from spacetime.
Thank you to CuriosityStream for supporting PBS Digital Studios.
CuriosityStream is a subscription streaming service that offers documentaries and non-fiction
titles from a variety of filmmakers, including CuriosityStream originals.
For example, you can check out Destination Pluto,
which follows the timeline of the New Horizons mission from its inception
to the date of its close encounter with everyone's favorite Kuiper belt dwarf planet.
You can learn more at curiositystream.com slash spacetime.
Hey guys, quick announcement.
If you're in New York this week, I'm doing a fun science thing
this Thursday, March 7th at 9pm at Caviar.
It's called Astronaut Training, and it should be hilarious.
Well, my co-host should be hilarious.
I'm going to try to not look silly.
I'm not hopeful on that.
Link in the description.
OK, and on to comments from our last episode,
The Secrets of the Cosmic Microwave Background,
in which we deciphered the cryptic patterns embedded in the oldest light in the universe.
Francois Lacombe asks how astronomers distinguish
the very small temperature differences in the CMB from the rest of the microwave noise.
Well, this is a great question because isolating the CMB is a huge challenge.
The contaminating microwaves mostly come from our galaxy.
There's a lot from the dust in between the stars,
and also from individual electrons either bumping into other charged particles
or circling in magnetic fields.
Fortunately, we can model that stuff pretty well.
We know where the sources of this emission are from observations at other frequencies,
and can do pretty well modeling and subtracting them.
All that galactic emission doesn't look anything like the CMB in the way it fluctuates,
so it's pretty clear when we've subtracted it properly and have only the CMB left.
Abe Dillon asks whether the moment of recombination should depend on the local density.
Well, the answer is absolutely.
People tend to talk about recombination
as having happened instantaneously and at the same time everywhere.
That's not the case.
Recombination happened when the universe became cool enough
for nuclei to capture electrons to form the first atoms.
More dense regions were a little hotter, so recombination started later in those.
And in general the entire universe didn't make the transition instantaneously.
It took several tens of thousands of years,
which is a lot considering the universe was less than 400,000 years old then.
It took long enough that the patterns in the baryon acoustic oscillations,
frozen into both the CMB and into galaxy rings,
were blurred out quite a bit because the universe took a moment to become fully transparent.
Julio Tobosa-Garcia points out that the method used to model the CMB fluctuations,
multipole expansion, sounds like Fourier analysis.
Well, good insight Julio.
In fact it's pretty much exactly that, but for the surface of a sphere.
So Fourier analysis represents fluctuations in one dimension with a series of sine curves.
On a spherical surface you instead use spherical harmonics.
John Rodriguez wished he'd have known that the physics skill tree
is required to unlock the wizard class.
Also, if wizarding schools existed – and they don't, okay, that's just silly – then
they're probably more like Breakbills in The Magicians by Lev Grossman and less like Hogwarts.
So basically like your most obnoxiously elite Ivy League grad program.
You need 5 letters of reference from Nobel laureates, be in the top 0% on your GREs,
and yeah, first authorship in a paper in theoretical physics
from that high school science fair project.
you
