Oh No, European Banks Are Doing Something REALLY Weird

Global Finance News
11 followers
Sweden becomes the latest major economy to slide back to recession, adding its name to a growing
global list of negative GDP. And that's before the tariff shock and payback too. No wonder European
banks are loading up on government bonds in a way we haven't seen since the pandemic and the lockdown.
But despite that, the ECB is sending letters to major European banks warning them to get control
In this kind of environment, small wonder for all of it. Where European banks are raising their
exposure to shadow lending, first of all, they don't seem to understand the risks of doing so,
believing those are actually minimal. But more importantly, in this global economic climate,
where one by one economies are contracting again, the chances for a major and maybe even permanent
setback are far higher. European banks think that they're playing it safe when they're playing with
macroeconomic fire that's heating up, unlike the economy. But that part, the banks can absolutely
see. That's why as places like Sweden go back into recession that they never really left,
the allure of safety and government bonds, which banks piled on to yet again here in April. For
short time, risky markets got this idea that trade wars broke everything. So trade delays and hopefully
some deals would just fix it all. But what we're seeing, even central bankers outside the Fed can
see this, this thing was broken long before we got to tariffs. And all these big global economies
are taking big hits in Q1, even before the main event. This is what markets have been saying to
expect for the last several years. And everything that keeps happening is closely aligned with us,
consistent with that idea. Rates are going down with the globally synchronized economy as one by
one, they all show up with negative GDP, even before we get to the tariffs and more importantly,
the payback. We've seen the list grow just in the last couple of weeks. We've got South Korea,
negative GDP, Bank of Korea talking about more rate cuts than they had predicted and forecast
just a little while ago, a couple weeks ago. Japan, another one in Asia. The Japanese are very likely
to experience a technical recession, which isn't a real thing, but two straight quarters of negative
GDP to start the first half of 2025. China, China just can't get going. In fact, they reported more
bad PMIs this past weekend for the month of May, which we went over in Yerudal University's daily
briefing. Plus, there's been some developments in China's real estate in Hong Kong, especially
where company, real estate developer New World announced Friday, a shocking development,
they're skipping interest payments on some debt, all the while they're trying to secure a massive
syndicated credit deal, which makes the mess even that much more consequential. That's something I
wrote about in Yerudal University's deep dive analysis on Friday, and it keeps going. Australia,
Australian retail sales actually declined in April, a month over month, even though they were
forecast to increase at a relatively decent rate, so big miss in retail sales. Capital investment
in Australia fell for the first quarter. Again, economists were expecting a gain there. Construction
spending was flat when it was supposed to be rising. And remember, the Reserve Bank of Australia
talked about doing a 50 basis point rate cut at its last meeting. Well, maybe they weren't taking
it seriously, but they at least announced that to the public because they see the weakness developing
in Australia, which is a bigger deal because downturns in Australia just don't happen. Well, maybe
this one actually is happening. How about North America? We've got Mexico and Canada. Mexico is
going to be in a deep recession, even though the central bank there said, we're not forecasting
recession. They're forecasting everything but using that term. Canada, Canada's in substantial
economic difficulties to begin with. Labor market negatives up there in the payroll reports. Even
U.S. GDP was negative in the first quarter, while many people are dismissing it as a one-off due to
imports. Imports actually crashed by a record amount in the month of April. What we saw that
was really concerning in U.S. GDP was that consumer spending was off, along with negative sentiment.
And then we get over to Europe. The German government said there's going to be no growth in
2025 after being subjected to no growth in 2023, and then again in 2024, forecasting recovery each
time, only to find out none is at hand. Of course, the markets there are predicting exactly that. The
economy is not picking up. It's not recovering. And interest rates, both market and official policy
rates are reflecting those developments. Plus, the German economy is seeing rising unemployment,
steadily rising unemployment that's getting increasingly dangerous. And it's spreading,
not limited to just Germany. We've got labor problems now in France that experienced two
straight quarters of declines in its jobs numbers. So we've got a global list that's getting longer,
not shorter. That's why central banks all over the world keep cutting interest rates. Many of
them say, well, we're done, we don't want to do any more, only to turn around and see
unexpected weakness force them to go back into it. Nobody wanted to be racing to the bottom.
Last year, they said, don't expect to be racing to the bottom. But here they are doing it anyway,
because economic conditions before we even get to tariffs and the payback are not strong and
resilient. They are exactly what the market has been saying, consistent with rates that go down,
go down a lot and then stay there a long period of time. Everything continues to move in that
direction rather than move away from it. Now, before we get back to the rest of today's video,
I want to tell you about today's video sponsor. We talk all the time on this channel about the
dangers the world is facing, trying to come to grips with the aftermath of the pandemic and the
lockdowns, the difficulties associated with the supply shock and price illusion, not to mention
still living in the shadow of the 2008 crisis. To put it mildly, there's a lot of systemic
uncertainty. Now, I've recommended gold as a store value hedge for years. In fact, it's the
ultimate error hedge. While gold prices are at an all time high, price appreciation isn't the
only way to profit. You can earn a yield on gold paid in gold without selling your metal. When the
price of gold increases, so does the cost to store it and insure it. Don't lose money owning gold,
earn a yield on it instead. And Monetary Metals allows you to earn up to 4% on your metal in their
gold leasing program. And you start earning that 4% yield immediately upon funding your account.
The yield you earn is paid in ounces of physical gold or silver, which you get in addition to any
price appreciation from gold and silver during the year. So join the thousands of investors earning
interest in physical gold and silver every month with Monetary Metals. There's a link in the
description of this video that has all the information that you need. We thank Monetary
Metals for their sponsorship. And now back to the rest of this video. In one of those central banks
that had been more aggressive in cutting rates due to past weakness, but also satisfied with
the amount of rate cuts that they had done, that's Sweden, the world's oldest central bank,
the Riksbank. The Riksbank said, we're going to rush to get ourselves down to 2.25%, which they
did because of economic weakness that developed in 2023 and to an extent in 2024. But then at
2.25%, they said that should be enough. That'll support the economy and the recovery. We don't
need to go any lower from here. Except more recent economic data, along with market developments,
show they're going to go lower from here, whether they want to right now or not.
Though there are more signs that even Swedish central bankers are realizing they need to do
this too. What the Swedes reported was a, quote unquote, surprise drop in GDP for the first
quarter of this year, again, before we even get to tariffs. After initial report of flat GDP in
the first quarter, it's since been revised down to minus 0.2% quarter over quarter against
expectations of a small positive, 0.1%. And even the fourth quarter GDP, which seemed to be
solid at 0.8%, that has since been revised down pretty substantially to just 0.5%.
So what GDP shows is that, like the Riksbank had said, Sweden was supposed to be coming out of the
2023 recession and the 2023 traditional recession with negative GDP, rising unemployment, and all
of that. So with rate cuts by the Swedish central bank in 2024, plus the general direction of the
economy, everybody was expecting and forecasting a recovery, a legitimate sustained recovery in
2024 heading into 2025. But instead, 2024, while there was positive GDP and some positive developments
in the economy, like we've seen in other places such as Japan, it was all a false recovery, another
false dawn. Because there was warning signs at the end of 2025, plus the artificial distortions
along the way. And then the first quarter, all the upheaval that we've seen in markets as well as
the global economy, Sweden succumbed with a negative number just like Japan. Also the United Kingdom too,
another one that's in the same boat. All of them had experienced recessions, traditional recessions,
the recognizable form of recession, back in 2023. And all three of those, the UK, Japan, and Sweden,
looked like they were getting out of it in 2024, only to see all three of them at the end of 2024
in the first part of 2025, stumble badly. It was only a false dawn in 2024, even before we get to
tariffs and the payback. And all of this has confounded mainstream economics, which thought
that first of all, coming out of the 2023 recession, there would be a recovery. But if there wasn't a
recovery, or if that was questionable, the rate cuts, especially the aggressive rate cuts by the
Swedish central bank, that would certainly make sure that the Swedish economy was moving into
a recovery mode. Instead, what matters is not rate cuts. Remember, they're always a reaction to
weakness, not a solution to them. What really matters, globally synchronized. And that's really
the point here for this entire video. But according to Bloomberg, an unexpected economic contraction,
yeah, an unexpected economic contraction in Sweden, boosted expectations that the Riksbank
will cut interest rates over the summer to support a rebound in output. Why was this not
expected? Markets were already signaling problems to begin with. Then again, the mainstream media,
because of economists, they ignore all of these markets signals in favor of central bank
pronouncements. But back to the article. The first contraction since the fourth quarter of 2023
suggests that an economic recovery in Sweden is faltering despite a series of cuts by the
Riksbank, just as a global economy is dented by intense uncertainty over the direction of U.S.
trade and security policy. Economists said the figure raises the chances of another easing move
in the next couple of months. And how many times do we have to see this in order for people to get
the point? Rate cuts are not easing. They don't support the economy. They are merely a reaction
to weakness. Like I said before, the aggressive rate cuts by the Swedish central bank last year
up until the early part of this year were a reaction to the 2023-2024 weakness, which they
thought, officials thought, had worked. They fell for the false don, saw GDP turn positive and
thought, hey, this rate cutting stuff does seem to work like the textbooks. Oh, crap, it didn't.
Now they're reacting to new weakness that shows up in 2025, weakness that had already showed up in
the first quarter, which means that rates end up going even lower yet again. And since the Riksbank
is already at 2.25%, it's very likely by the end of the year they're under 2% and probably even
thinking about whether or not they want to go down to 1% and maybe less there. None of this was
supposed to be happening. Last year, everybody said hire for longer. Markets said, no, not hire for
longer. Economic weakness is going to develop and get worse. And that central banks were going to
chase that economic weakness with their policy rates, which is exactly what we're seeing right
now. The thing is the economic weakness in Sweden is coming from exactly where we're supposed to
believe rate cuts are going to help the most. Back to the article. Economic activity was weak in the
first quarter and forward-looking signals subdued growth in the second quarter as well, according
to a senior economist with Svenska Handelsbanken AB, who also pointed that household consumption
was, quote, significantly weaker than the central bank's forecast. Hence, today's outcome supports
our view that the Riksbank will cut rates again in June and probably several times beyond.
We also need to note that without the artificial boost in exports due to the tariff distortions,
the artificial high, that was the only reason the GDP wasn't a lot worse in the first quarter than
just minus 0.2%. There won't be that artificial boost in the second quarter. Hence, as the
economist says, the central bank is going to be chasing even more weakness with even lower
interest rates, even lower policy rates, that the market said this was going to happen all along.
But it's not just Sweden. Just in its own neighborhood up there in Scandinavia.
In Finland, for example, GDP adjusted for seasonal swings stagnated in the first quarter from the
prior period when it grew a revised 0.2%, so already zero in Finland. And a flash estimate
had indicated expansion of 0.1%, which suggests that it's a little bit weaker in Finland than had
been anticipated as well. But Denmark, Denmark last week reported its first quarterly contraction
and output in more than two years. This one minus 0.5% quarter over quarter. And Norway,
while GDP was positive in the first quarter, it had contracted by a serious 1% in the fourth quarter
of last year. So this weakness across Scandinavia is widespread there too. Globally synchronized.
Given all that, no wonder what European banks are doing, loading up on safety and liquidity.
They continue to buy near record amounts of government bonds. According to the latest data
from the European Central Bank on the MFI balance sheets or Monetary Finance Institutions, what they
call banks over there, their aggregate balance sheets showed a 44.2 billion euro increase in
government bond holdings in April, which followed a 51.7 billion increase in March, a 49.4 billion
increase in February, and the big one, an 82.1 billion increase in January. Altogether, year to
date, just through the end of April, European banks have added an astounding nearly a quarter trillion
in government bond holdings. That's the second most in any four-month period behind only the
pandemic and the lockdowns and all the mess in the middle of 2020. Since last June, government
bond holdings among European banks has soared by 321 billion euros. At the same time, as I keep
pointing out with all these monthly updates, European banks do not want to lend to the real
economy any more than they have to. And while lending to households and non-financial corporations
or just general businesses, that has increased by 159 billion euros in the last, really going back
to last June when the ECB started cutting rates. While it sounds like maybe the ECB's rate-cutting
policies are successful, it's actually not. It's actually the opposite. That's even less than the
2010s, back when it was hardly a roaring success for banks, I mean the silent depression. So the
increase in bank lending to the real economy is basically just a rounding error at this point,
certainly not a response to lower rates. And remember, market rates have been going lower
since October of 2023. So lower interest rates are not helping lending in the European economy
because banks are increasingly risk-averse. And that also goes to the one area that they
are lending, and that's to these shadow banks, these investment funds that we keep talking about,
keep hearing about. Lending to non-MFI financials, which are these shadow banks or investment funds,
has increased by 74 billion euros since the middle of last year. But really, going back to January
2024, it is shot up by 161 billion euros. So you can see what European banks are doing here.
They're buying tons of safety and liquidity, no surprise there given the economic climate that
we're talking about. They're lending as little as possible to the real economy, mostly like
Chinese banks, just to their best, safest customers, while also extending loans to
shadow banks and investment funds. Thinking that those loans to shadow banks and investment funds
in particular are like lending to their best customers in the real economy, they're safe and
liquid because these are investment funds. But that might be a big mistake. In fact, that's
something that the European Central Bank, of all people, the European Central Bankers are saying,
we need to get a handle on the shadow bank lending because we don't believe banks have a handle on it
either. Neither the risk properties, nor what would happen, what might happen if conditions
really do become impaired and serious in European markets, really the global marketplace.
In fact, according to Bloomberg, the ECB has signaled that it's sending letters to executives
at certain banks, cautioning them on their practices in financing private funds or the
shadow banks, at least according to people familiar with the matter. In another indication
of the ECB's determination, it plans to conduct on-site investigations on the matter at several
major European banks. The regular staff recently visited Societe Generale in one of the first such
exercises, and Bloomberg reported at the time that the supervisor had asked top banks, including
major French and German lenders, France and Germany, that's where the economy is in biggest
trouble, for details of their exposure to private credit firms, as well as their lending to funds
operating in the space. And that review found that banks aren't able to properly identify the
detailed nature and levels of their full exposure to private credit funds. So you can see the problem
here. If banks are treating this as sort of a safe and liquid asset class to lend to, at the same
time you're buying government bonds, seeing the global economic climate turn in the wrong direction,
the ECB, even the ECB is saying maybe you're wrong about the safety, the perceived safety, the lower
perceived risks of lending to these shadow banks. Because what happens if the ECB is wrong about
their recovery call across the European economy, and even the wider European economy, including
those outside the eurozone like Sweden or the UK? If the economic downturn doesn't end, or it
accelerates to the downside, there are risks of all sorts of bad things in private credit, including
rising correlations that can more directly impact bank balance sheet operations. And those risks
have greatly increased with these quote unexpected GDP declines that are now showing up all over the
world, even before we get to tariffs and the payback. And we already had one liquidity shock
in April that showed how poorly the market-based junky credit had actually performed, and luckily
it only lasted about a week and didn't go on beyond that. So everyone assuming a soft landing, or at
least a stagnation, but what if the stagnation which has forgot how to grow recession, what if it
continues and continues to take its toll on everything to the point that something actually
does go wrong, especially when combined with a tariff shock and the payback from all of these
distortions. There's a pretty substantial risk which is likely why ECB is stepping up its efforts,
and you have to say to yourself, if the ECB can see this, how much of a real risk must this actually be?
So we have interest rates around the world, policy rates too, that are going down reflecting these
weaker economic circumstances. And Sweden is just the latest on a growing list that already includes
Finland and Denmark. You've got Germany and France, both of those with questionable economic
circumstances, as well as more and more data that shows the labor market getting into bigger and
bigger trouble. Japan, South Korea, China, Australia, Mexico, Canada, while nobody in America wants to
admit it, America too, especially with American consumers pulling back on their spending. So for
the European banks with a heavy emphasis on the Europeans and those near the Eurozone, no wonder
they're piling up government bonds. But at the same time, they're taking risks that they don't
fully appreciate, which is kind of what banks do with these shadow banks. They think they've got
the risk cover, or at least have them at arm's length, but even the central bankers can see
that's not necessarily the case, especially if the central bankers are wrong about the overall
economic direction. If the central bankers are this freaked out when they think the economy's
recovering, what would happen if the economy doesn't? The Fed is the odd one out. You've got negative GDP,
threats to the labor market, growing all throughout the rest of the world. Rates that go down, they go
down by a lot, and then they stay there. The further we go in this process, the further we go in the cycle,
the more that aligns with it. The more that gets consistent with it, not less. And it's not just
European banks that are lending to shadow banks. I talked about how American banks are lending to
offshore shadow banks in the video link below. As always, thank you very much for joining me.
Huge thank you Eurodollar University members and subscribers, and until next time, take care.
