China's Most Charming City Broke?! PLA Reorganizes, Atmosphere Of Fear Pervades

China Truths
61 followers
"Shanghai Reportedly Borrowing 10 Billion from 8 Temples; Officials Rush to ‘Debunk’
China's Economic Slump: Young People Start ‘Revenge Saving’
Male Entrepreneur Opens ‘Private Police Station,’ Profits Over a Million in Six Months
Beijing Insider: The PLA Reorganizes, Fear Atmosphere Pervades
Microsoft Plans to Close All Physical Authorized Stores in China
Americans Warned to Stop Shopping via Chinese App Temu
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
Shanghai reportedly borrowing 10 billion from 8 temples, officials rush to debunk.
China's economic slump, young people start revenge saving.
Male entrepreneur opens private police station, profits over a million in 6 months.
Beijing insider, the PLA reorganizes, fear atmosphere pervades.
Microsoft plans to close all physical authorized stores in China.
Americans warn to stop shopping via Chinese app TEMU.
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
Shanghai reportedly borrowing 10 billion from 8 temples, officials rush to debunk.
On July 2, a screenshot purportedly from NetEase News circulated on social media.
The article's headline in the image reads,
The severity of local financial constraints may far exceed your imagination.
We are truly out of money.
The article mentioned in the screenshot states that,
According to an anonymous official from the Shanghai Municipal Finance Bureau,
Shanghai borrowed 10 billion yuan, about 1.37 billion U.S. dollars,
in incense money from temples within the Shanghai jurisdiction, including Jing'an Temple,
Longhua Temple, Jade Buddha Temple, Donglin Temple, Baohua Temple, Bian Temple, Panlong
Nunnery, and Hongfu Temple, as short-term turnover debt to balance the financial statement for the
Jing'an Temple contributing the most at 4.8 billion yuan, approximately 660 million U.S. dollars.
In response to the above news, Shanghai authorities urgently debunked the rumor,
stating that the information was false.
Director Pu of the Budget Department of the Shanghai Municipal Finance Bureau claimed
that Shanghai's fiscal operation in the first half of this year was generally healthy.
Notably, on the evening of July 2, NetEase also issued a debunking statement,
stating that NetEase had no information related to Shanghai's finances as depicted in the
circulated images. However, an internet search revealed that NetEase had published an article
with the same headline on May 29, 2024, but the article had been deleted upon visiting the webpage.
The reporter,
using the headline
We Are Truly Out Of Money, found an article with the same title on a Mainland China discussion
forum. The article mentions that data released by the Ministry of Finance shows a year-on-year
decline in national land sale revenues in the first quarter of 2024. The article states that
from the published data, it is not difficult to see that since 2021, land finance revenue
has been decreasing year by year, with significant declines each year.
So, what impacts will the sharp decline in land finance revenue bring?
According to the article, firstly, it will affect the financial situation of local governments,
including areas such as education and public transportation. Secondly, it will affect
official credibility. Now that local finances are short of money, it means that payments for
these construction projects may be delayed, which could negatively impact official credibility,
with the loss of trust being the biggest issue. Thirdly, it may affect overall economic stability,
including rising train ticket prices, and increases in water, electricity,
and natural gas prices. Currently, it is impossible to know the true financial data of Shanghai
and whether the finance department has borrowed 10 billion yuan from local temples to balance
the financial statement. However, there are many online reports about Shanghai being out of money,
including local CCP is out of money. Shanghai State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration
Commission, SASAC, asks party members for donations. China's most charming Shanghai
also out of money? Emergency halt to 624 billion yuan, about 85.8 billion USD,
Investment Landmark Project, Shanghai is out of money. Chinese people lament, small shops closed,
plazas deserted, from small businesses to large enterprises are suffering,
or Shanghai citizens fined for walking violations, government out of money.
It is worth mentioning that a similar meeting memo leaked from Kunming City,
Yunnan Province in May last year. This document, titled Kunming City Investment Expert Meeting
Memo, mentions at the beginning that Kunming City will have 20 billion yuan,
about 2.75 billion USD, of debt due in the next six months, the city investment company cannot pay,
the city finances are insufficient, and the province has stated it will not provide significant
assistance. Several chairpersons of the city investment companies have already headed to
Shanghai to ask for money. The memo says that seeking help from Shanghai is not an asset
exchange because Kunming has no assets left to give, this time it is directly asking for money,
because Yunnan is a designated support target of Shanghai, and in the past,
central government subsidies to Yunnan have been transferred from Shanghai,
amounting to several hundred billion each year. The memo specifically mentions that last year's
transfer payment from Shanghai to Yunnan has not been given, mainly due to the impact of the
In fact, after the US-China trade war began in 2019, the Chinese authorities repeatedly issued
notices requiring all levels of government to tighten their belts and prepare for tough days
ahead, calling this a long-term policy. Subsequently, the three-year epidemic lockdown
policy implemented by the Chinese authorities caused a huge impact on the Chinese economy,
with the Shanghai municipal government strictly implementing Beijing's enforced
zero-COVID policy in 2022, consuming a large amount of resources. The crackdown on real
estate developers by the Chinese authorities also caused a nationwide real estate crisis,
which further hit the land finance revenue that local governments rely on for survival.
China's Economic Slump, Young People Start Revenge Saving
Since the end of the pandemic, China's economy has struggled to recover.
The real estate market has collapsed, youth unemployment has skyrocketed,
consumer confidence remains low. During this time, young Chinese people,
unlike their peers in other countries who engaged in impulsive spending, also called
revenge spending, have turned to frenzied saving, leading to a trend of revenge saving across China.
In the past two years, many savings-related hashtags have sprung up on Chinese social media,
such as saving battle, saving check-ins, and accumulating gold beans.
On Chinese social media, a 26-year-old girl with the username LittleHomeBody
detailed how she managed to keep her monthly living expenses under 300 yuan
— about US$41.26 — sharing numerous videos showing how she reduced her daily
food expenses to below 10 yuan — about US$1.38. Meanwhile, others are seeking
saving partners on social media, companions with shared interests who engage in activities together.
This emerging social culture in China has led to online savings circles,
where members support each other in sticking to their goals. Their frugal measures include
dining at community canteens, which offer relatively cheap prices. Furthermore,
reverse consumption and the frugal economy also signal that Chinese youth are tightening their
purse strings. The former refers to consciously cutting expenses, while the latter refers to
actively seeking discounts and deals when shopping. Additionally, a trend of special
forces tourism has also emerged, meaning traveling in a way that challenges the limits like special
forces, visiting as many attractions as possible in the shortest time for the least money.
Commenting on this development, Sean Rain, managing director of China Market Research Group,
told CNBC, Chinese youth have a revenge-saving mentality. He believes that the confidence of
Chinese youth has vanished and that it will take years or even a longer period of prosperity for
them to feel secure enough to engage in revenge spending again. According to a recent report by
the People's Bank of China, the total amount of household RMB deposits grew by 11.8% year-on-year
in the first quarter of 2024. At the same time, the tightening labor market has exacerbated the
difficulties faced by young people. Xiao Miao, an assistant professor at NYU Shanghai,
also stated that people refusing to spend money is a real phenomenon. She added,
for some young people, it's because they can't find jobs, or they find it harder to increase
their income. Therefore, they have no choice but to cut back on spending. Since the pandemic,
the employment rate for fresh graduates in mainland China has been declining.
According to a 2024 College Graduates Employment Survey report released by Xiaopin last month,
only 48% of fresh graduates received informal job offers, a 2.4 percentage point decrease from
the same period last year. Meanwhile, the proportion of fresh graduates opting for
slow employment and freelancing increased from last year's 18.9% and 13.2% to 19.1%
and 13.7% this year, respectively. The Chinese Communist Party often avoids using the term
unemployment, instead using terms like slow employment, light employment, flexible employment,
and self-employment economy to obscure the reality. According to the survey, 90% of graduates are not
fixated on finding a good job, but are more inclined to find any job. The proportion of
graduates signing contracts in third-tier cities and below has also increased, accounting for a
quarter of the total. Male entrepreneur opens private police station, profits over a million
in six months. According to a recently exposed online video, a man named Zhang Chang'an Xian,
Shaanxi Province, initially wanted to start a business and thought a police station would be
a good project. The market was large, with six or seven police stations near the train station alone,
and people came to report cases continuously every day. Moreover, the local police were
inefficient in handling cases, making the idea of opening a police station seem like a good choice.
As a result, Zhang rented three or four storefronts near the train station and established
the Jian'an Town Police Station. Its business scope includes theft, missing persons, consumer
disputes, etc., almost identical to that of the police. Zhang appointed himself as the director
and appointed a woman surnamed Zhao as the captain of the plainclothes brigade of the
Zhang Xian branch. Ms. Zhao was responsible for recruiting fresh graduates, offering a
salary of 2,800 yuan, about 385 U.S. dollars and 20 cents, including food and accommodation,
and even providing civil servant benefits. Many young people were attracted and paid 30,000 to
50,000 yuan, approximately 4,127 dollars to 6,900 U.S. dollars, as network entry fees,
deposits, and equipment fees. After a few days of training, they went on duty.
The Jian'an Town Police Station handles cases differently from the official police.
Upon receiving a report, they not only respond quickly but also solve the problem on the spot
without making records or investigating, acting directly with speed and efficiency.
This police station not only never delays paying employee wages but also has a performance bonus
system, where each suspect caught earns a commission of 50 yuan, about 6 U.S. dollars
and 88 cents. As a result, the police officers at the Jian'an Town Police Station often work
overtime to earn more bonuses, arriving at the scene faster than the official police and quickly
solving cases. In less than half a year, the plainclothes brigade of the front station sub-bureau
of the Jian'an Town Police Station has solved over a hundred cases, easily earning millions
in profits. Their efficiency caused the front station sub-bureaus of Jian'an Train Station to
barely dispatch police in six months, resulting in a sharp performance decline. However, they
received dozens of complaints because the Jian'an Town Police Station, though efficient, handled
cases hastily and sometimes attacked innocent people. The victims, not knowing the attackers'
police numbers, could only report to the nearest police station. As the business grew larger,
Zhang Changhe planned to open another police station in Huainan. If not for an accidental
incident, Zhang Changhe's chain might have already opened. One day, two police officers handling a
case didn't know how to proceed and couldn't contact their chief, so they ran to the real
police station to report the case. The Royal Police discovered that the visitors were their
counterparts and were very enthusiastic at first. Unexpectedly, these two people stammered and
couldn't clearly state their chief's police number, and their police station's name was
not listed in the CCP's records, which aroused the real police's suspicion. Later, the police
followed the lead from the two reporting women and found their chief, Ms. Zhao, and subsequently
caught Zhang Changhe. According to the video content, this incident happened in 2014 but
has recently resurfaced online. Some netizens on Platform X commented,
This fact once again proves that even scammers do a better job than the CCP,
and the government's functionality is collapsing. Some political commentators believe that this
incident reflects that Chinese society under the CCP's rule is already very chaotic.
Lai Jianping, former Beijing lawyer and chairman of the Democracy Movement in Canada,
told the Epoch Times that, since ancient times, maintaining public order and enforcing laws has
always been a non-transferable public power of the government. No society can allow private
entities to undertake the functions of maintaining public order and protecting public interests,
otherwise, the government would lose its reason for existence. However, CCP police are often
described as one with the bandits, their most prominent traits being inaction and misconduct.
Therefore, in the minds of Chinese people, the image of the CCP police is not positive and
lacks credibility and trust. He asserted that such private police stations cannot exist for long
and will certainly be suppressed and banned because they are stealing the government's
power and function, which the CCP will never tolerate. Beijing Insider, The PLA Reorganizes,
Fear Atmosphere Pervades. According to the Sound of Hope, former Chinese media person
Zhao Longjian revealed on July 1 that the scope of the Chinese Communist Party's military purge
is astonishing, as CCP leader Xi Jinping forces political factions to take sides in preparation
for his next re-election. Last week, the CCP announced the handling of two former defense
ministers, Li Shangfu and Wei Fenghe, marking a stage summary of the military purge that has
lasted for a year. Zhao Longjian told The Vision Times that what the outside world has learned is
just the tip of the iceberg. A close friend in Beijing told Zhao Longjian that Xi Jinping's
purge involves the military commission, the military, defense, aviation, aerospace, state-owned
enterprises, and the military-industrial complex, with many high-level officials arrested or
disappeared. The current examination extends to the bureau level, and this purge action is expected
to end before October 1. This Beijing friend said that this purge of the military and defense
enterprises is rare since 1949, mainly targeting the factions of Li Shangfu and Wei Fenghe.
This is a re-establishment of political alignment. Xi Jinping aims to strike at the intertwined
factions and other princelings who are not fully submissive. Xi is deeply reshuffling in preparation
for his next re-election. Zhao Longjian mentioned that multiple aerospace accidents in China,
including the crash of a Tianbing technology rocket in the mountains of Hunan,
are the side effects of Xi's arrest of rocket force commander Li Yuchao and the purge of the
defense and military-industrial system. He said that the CCP's aerospace department,
satellite launch base, aerospace technology, and the rocket force are intertwined,
with personnel overlaps and exchanges. The already lagging aerospace industry has shown
a clear decline due to political statements and realignment, with widespread fear and
lack of focus on work. On June 27, there were reports of an explosion at a military ammunition
depot in Guizhou, with several similar incidents occurring this year. Zhao Longjian said that it
was to destroy evidence, a terrifying atmosphere pervades, no high-ranking official in the military
is clean, anyone could be purged under the guise of anti-corruption. Xi Jinping's purges have led
to significant resistance and negative sentiments in the military and defense enterprises.
This is the root cause of the 7-8 reported explosions in military depots over the past
6 months. Fearing bad luck in these military purges, they acted first by blowing up these
military depots to destroy evidence of past corruption. As for former foreign minister
Qin Gang, Zhao Longjian revealed shocking news, my friend in Beijing finally told me that Qin Gang
has long been dead, with not even a trace remaining. Li Shangfu is still alive but under
house arrest with some health issues. Xi Jinping will keep Li Shangfu as a tool to manage others.
Li Shangfu alive is more useful to Xi than dead.
Microsoft plans to close all physical authorized stores in China.
Recently, news on the Chinese internet revealed that Microsoft will close all offline authorized
stores in China, keeping only its official online store, JD flagship store, and after-sales service
points. According to Jianmian News, a Microsoft spokesperson stated that the company is continuously
evaluating its retail strategy to meet changing customer needs and has decided to integrate its
channels in the Chinese market. After closing various authorized stores, customers in mainland
China can still purchase Microsoft products and receive services through retail partners
and Microsoft's official website, Microsoft.com. Microsoft's official website shows that the
company currently has 51 stores in mainland China, mostly Xbox and Experience stores,
with only 7 authorized sales stores remaining. A report from China Business News noted that
some Microsoft authorized specialty stores in Beijing and Liaoning have closed in the past
half-month, while others are still operating normally. The Microsoft authorized specialty
store at Beijing Shidan Joy City is still open, with sales staff confirming they have received
the closure notice and are making preparations. Meanwhile, customer service staff at the Microsoft
China official flagship store on the Taobao platform reported that they have not received
any closure notices. The offline stores of Microsoft in mainland China mainly sell products
such as Microsoft's Surface series of laptops and Xbox gaming consoles. Chinese media analysis
indicates that Chinese consumers' recognition of the Surface has always been declining,
and this integration of channels by Microsoft is part of a strategic adjustment of Surface
sales globally. Americans Warned to Stop Shopping via Chinese App TEMU
On July 2, Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin warned Americans to be cautious of using the TEMU
marketplace app. Griffin told Fox Business, a week after filing a lawsuit against TEMU,
that the threat from China is not new, and it is real. TEMU is not an online marketplace like
Amazon or Walmart. It's a data theft business that sells goods as a means to an end.
He emphasized that while it's normal for marketplaces like Amazon and Walmart to collect
consumer data, TEMU uses malware and spyware to infiltrate devices and collect data. Not just
traditional consumer data, but using malware, spyware to have complete access to your information.
And, taking it one step further, their code is written in such a way to evade detection.
Griffin noted that TEMU is operated by Shanghai-based parent company Pinduoduo Inc.,
which includes former Chinese Communist officials in its ranks.
The lawsuit filed against TEMU's parent company seeks a jury trial, a permanent block on TEMU's
data collection activities, and a $10,000 fine for each violation of the Arkansas Deceptive
Practices Act. The suit cites research from Grizzly Research, which analyzes publicly
traded firms, alleging that TEMU can purposely gain unrestricted access to a user's phone
operating system, including a user's camera, specific location, contacts, text messages,
documents, and other applications. Grizzly Research suspects that TEMU is already,
or intends to, illegally sell stolen data from Western customers to sustain a business model
otherwise doomed for failure. They estimate TEMU loses $30 per order due to high ad spending and
shipping costs from China. One is left wondering how this business could ever be profitable.
TEMU is a notoriously bad actor in its industry. We see rampant user manipulation,
chain-letter-like affinity scams to drive signups, and overall, the most aggressive
and questionable techniques to manipulate large numbers of people to install the app.
In a statement to The Epoch Times on Tuesday evening, TEMU responded by stating that the
Arkansas lawsuit is based on misinformation, denying the allegations, and promising a vigorous
defense. They believe scrutiny will ultimately benefit their development. According to the
analytics website Backlinko, TEMU was the most downloaded shopping app around the world in 2023,
with more than 330 million downloads, about 1.8 times more than the Amazon shopping app.
On July 1, the Texas Public Policy Foundation issued a similar warning about the app,
saying that it can access almost anything on your phone, which means that Chinese Communist
Party officials could theoretically install applications and spyware files on an individual's
smart device to use for complete surveillance of all user activity on a phone. The foundation
warned that this would allow China to monitor keystrokes and logs to have direct insight
into login credentials for other social media, emails, and bank accounts. TEMU officials didn't
Don't forget to leave a comment in the section below to share your opinions on today's topic
with us. Make sure to like and subscribe to see more interesting topics from China Truths.
