When the music is in the characters' heads

The Greatest Film Composers
66 followers
My debut novel, The Quiet, is now available to pre-order.
There are links in the description and there'll be more info at the end.
Oh thank you very much.
Director Charlotte Wells has probably had to answer more questions
about the ending of After Sun than any other part of the film.
In one interview for the National Post, she said,
I do not know what possessed me to do it but I pulled under pressure into the edit.
I dropped it on the timeline just to see how it would feel and it just kind of struck magic.
And then the challenge of the next nine months of editing was earning it
and earning the confidence to allow lyrics to be so obvious in the film.
And the lyrics are obvious.
As Sophie is dancing with her dad, both in the memory of that night in Turkey and in the dream
rave, Freddie Mercury and David Bowie sing about pressure that brings a building down,
about the terror of knowing what this world is about,
about how love dares you to care for the people on the edge of the night.
Here Sophie and Callum are on the edge of the night, dancing their last dance.
And there's no hiding from the lyrics either.
Stripped of everything apart from the vocals and now subtly underscored by Oliver Coates'
haunting music, Wells is begging for us to listen to the words.
She doesn't want us to miss them.
But this isn't the only time in the film where lyrics are so obviously paired with the story.
A few scenes earlier, after Sophie has given her mortifying performance of R.E.M.'s Losing My
After her dad has left her alone to crash on stage, Sophie is sitting by herself at the bar,
and in the background we hear Never Ever by All Saints.
The words aren't as clear as with Under Pressure, but they're still there.
A few questions that I need to know.
How could you ever hurt me so?
Never ever have I ever felt so low.
It's completely understandable why people would want to talk to Wells about these two scenes,
the karaoke and the last dance.
They're two pillars in the story.
Everything else seems to fall about them.
But for me, what's more interesting than the songs or the lyrics themselves is the presentation.
When Sophie sings Losing My Religion, everything is shown in excruciating detail.
The way she starts off smiling, looking towards her dad for help.
The notes she chooses to sing, some of them right, most of them wrong.
The way she stares at the screen, shuffles on her feet, folds her arms.
By stark contrast, the dance scene is vague and distorted,
cut into pieces by the rave sequence where we see adult Sophie dance with,
fight, embrace her father.
Both of these scenes are memories.
One Sophie remembers in clear-cut detail.
Your mind has an unparalleled ability to store every second of an embarrassing experience.
But the other she remembers only in abstract.
She knows her father danced.
She knows she was happy.
Maybe she knows what song was playing.
But maybe she doesn't.
And over the years, this memory has been slowly changed, mixed in with her grief and anger.
We're not just hearing under pressure.
We're hearing Sophie's version of a song that might have been playing that night,
passed through filter after filter, a flower reduced to the stem.
This is not the only piece of media to present music in a subjective way.
Returnal is a game which some of you might have come across.
It's a roguelike shooter released a few years back that follows the story of Selene,
an astronaut who crash lands on an alien planet and who has to fight for her survival.
Throughout the many runs you complete in the game, it's cripplingly hard.
I died many times.
You start to piece together fragments of her story.
She's following a beacon, the white shadow as she calls it.
She has or had a son and she keeps finding things from her life on the planet.
Her house.
Exactly as I left it.
Another astronaut.
A song that she knows too well.
Well, more accurately, part of a song.
A descending sequence of four notes which first appear as you enter act two of the story.
Just to warn you here, there will be major spoilers for Returnal.
After you've seemingly beaten the final boss of the game, Nemesis.
After you've left this hellscape of a planet and the never-ending cycle of death and rebirth
and then lived a whole life.
You're then thrown back to the beginning again.
It's an awful moment.
Your stomach sinks as you realise what's happening.
No, I can't be here.
I escaped.
And then as you begin to explore again, you see that the world is the same but different.
And it sounds different too.
This is the song I was always playing.
Four notes which descend from C to G, never changing their pitches,
appear in floaty electronics.
Sometimes distorted, sometimes focused and clean.
The music takes advantage of the PlayStation's 3D audio technology.
These notes are placed physically in the world,
encouraging you to go through one passageway and not another.
You're being led somewhere.
Eventually you reach a decaying spire,
like the remains of some ancient theatre or coliseum, and you ascend.
As you do, the music gets louder.
The descending notes fire out over and over again above the texture
as the organ's chant grows and morphs.
And where does it take you?
The fourth boss, Hyperion.
As you fight them, they play the organ,
like some supercharged version of the guitarist in Mad Max Fury Road,
and again we keep hearing the descending notes.
What we'll find as we continue Selene's story
is that these notes aren't created by Hyperion or some god controlling her fate.
They're made by Selene.
In her real life, Selene was in an accident.
She drove off a bridge into a river, her son Helios in the backseat.
The song Don't Fear the Reaper by Blue Oyster Cult playing on the radio,
with its repeated descending sequence of four notes.
What Selene is hearing on Atropos, her self-created purgatory,
is a memory of a song, the only fragment that remains, looping endlessly.
She is desperate to forget her trauma, but her subconscious won't let her.
She keeps leaving small reminders for her future self,
breadcrumbs leading her back to the river.
How happy is the blameless Vestal's lot.
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, like Returnal, is about the desire to disappear.
But unlike Returnal, Joel is making an active choice to forget,
undergoing a procedure to remove the memories of his girlfriend, Clem, from his mind.
My name is Joel Barish and I'm here to erase Clementine Krasinski.
We see their relationship played in reverse,
told through jumbled memories of their time together,
starting at the ending and ending at the beginning.
Similar to After Sun, music plays an important part in the construction,
or deconstruction in this case, of memories.
In the title sequence, which appears 17 minutes into the film,
we see Joel crying in his car,
listening to a version of The Corgis' Everybody's Got to Learn Sometime.
The song only really appears twice in the film,
once in Joel's car and then once right at the end.
But there's also a small fragment which is easy to miss.
About halfway through his procedure, we enter a memory that Joel doesn't want to lose.
As he begs to keep the memory alive,
we hear a garbled rendition of Everybody's Got to Learn Sometime.
Please let me keep this memory, just this one.
This was Clem and Joel's song.
That's why he was listening to it when they broke up.
That's why it's there at the end when they reunite.
That's why it's there at his happiest moment.
He's trying to hold on to this music,
hoping that the memory will latch on in some way,
or hitch a ride.
I'm just exactly who I want to be.
At the end of the film,
both Clem and Joel get access to recordings of their past selves,
talking about their relationship before the procedure.
They don't remember recording the tapes,
but equally, they don't refute that they made them.
As Celine wanders around the wastelands of Atropos,
she finds scout logs recorded in her own voice,
describing things she never remembers doing,
describing thoughts she never remembers having.
It takes her a while,
but eventually she accepts that it is,
was her,
that made those logs.
Well, at least one version of herself.
Returnal and Eternal Sunshine are about forgetting the past
and seeing what's left.
Aftersun is about trying to reconstruct it.
But all these stories are about a thing that doesn't exist anymore,
our past selves.
When a family member tells you about something you did
when you were young,
or when you look at an old photo of yourself,
or think about a time at school,
doesn't it feel like it was someone else who lived that life?
To me it does.
It doesn't feel like I experienced those things,
just a version of me.
I think we all leave a bit of ourselves in the past,
along with the things we loved,
the films we watched,
the books we read,
the people,
the music.
And so in the end,
all that might be left of a memory is a few notes of a melody,
or a fragment of a lyric.
That doesn't sound like much,
but it could be enough to bring you back to a past life,
to the time you fell in love,
or to the last time you danced with your dad.
Thank you so much for watching.
As you saw from the intro,
my debut novel,
The Quiet,
is now available to pre-order.
So this book follows the story of Hannah and her son Isaac,
and they live in a world where an enormous spherical field,
called the sound field,
has covered the earth.
This field produces a constant background hum,
and has also accelerated climate change,
leading to a massive refugee crisis
from the southern hemisphere to the north,
and meaning people need to sleep during the day
and work at night.
The Quiet will be released in the UK and the US in May 2025,
and you can now pre-order using the links in the description.
Take a look at my website as well,
for more information about the story.
Pre-ordering is really the best way to help out me as an author,
as it contributes to first week sales,
meaning I'm more likely to get on those elusive bestseller lists.
Thank you so much,
and I'll see you next time.
