Check Out James Conole's amazing channel: @RootFP
Our collaboration on James's channel: • How Will Your Spending Change Throughout R...
0:00 Intro 0:37 Meet James Conole, CFP® 1:02 What Does “Ideal Retirement” Really Mean? 2:44 The Trap of Chasing a Number 5:02 The 3-Step Retirement Planning Framework 7:52 Why Social Security & Pensions Matter More Than You Think 10:56 What a $1M Portfolio Really Means 12:45 Why Most People Don’t Prepare Accurately for Retirement 15:13 How Much Do You Actually Need? 17:01 The Heart of Retirement Planning 18:28 Don’t Let Tax Optimization Ruin Your Life 19:56 Why Conservative Savers Struggle to Enjoy Retirement 21:00 Avoiding Regret: What Really Matters in Retirement 21:49 Final Thoughts: Where Real Planning Happens
This video breaks down the only 3-step retirement plan you’ll ever need to retire comfortably. It goes beyond the numbers to explore how to create a fulfilling retirement lifestyle—emotionally and financially. You'll learn how to define your ideal retirement, calculate how much income you'll need, and identify key sources like Social Security, pensions, and investment withdrawals. If you're planning for retirement or wondering if $1 million is enough, this is the guide for you.
Hey guys, what's up? I'm Erin, and welcome back to the channel.
One of the pinnacle topics of this channel is retirement.
How to prepare for it, what to do when you get there, and pretty much everything in between.
With the help of my friend James Canole,
we dive into the topic of what it looks like to retire comfortably,
not just from a financial standpoint, but also from an emotional standpoint,
making sure that you get to accomplish all of your life goals,
because at the end of the day, that's what your money is there for,
to build the life that makes you feel happy, successful, and comfortable.
So with that, let's dive in.
Hey guys, today I am joined by James Canole of Root Financial Planning.
He has an amazing YouTube channel.
I'm going to put all the links for it down below.
So today we kind of want to talk about what it might take to retire comfortably.
Thanks for joining us, James.
Thanks for having me, Erin.
We chatted on my channel a couple weeks ago,
and I'm excited to be on yours and continue the conversation.
Yeah, thanks for being here.
So you work in-depth with clients on retirement,
and what an ideal retirement looks like,
which I'm sure looks different for everybody.
How do you approach it?
So that word ideal that you just said is where I would start.
I think a lot of, there's this sense, I don't know if you remember,
this was probably 20 years ago when I was a kid.
I remember seeing some commercial, and it was like this guy walking his dog,
and what's my number?
And I think it was probably some big insurance company.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
A million dollars, $500,000, and you get this.
All the different clients had a different number above them, right?
Exactly, exactly.
So everyone's walking their dogs or walking down the street,
and it was almost like this sense of there's a formula to get to your number,
which in some ways might be true,
but I think that that word you mentioned of ideal
is obviously very different for every person.
And the way we think about planning is almost like a good financial plan
is where you have your vision board on the one hand.
What do you actually want your life to look like?
If you can create the perfect retirement, the perfect life,
start with that.
And then the numbers on the other hand of how do we enable that vision?
So start by not even thinking about the numbers,
but what do you actually want to do?
What is the perfect day, week, month, year look like?
Where are you traveling?
What are the activities you're doing?
Who are you spending time with?
Some of these things cost money.
Some of these things don't,
but I think it's just that what you want life to look like,
conversation or just even ideation of what is it we're trying to create.
And then from there,
I like to at least start with the basic three-step process
that doesn't cover every last thing,
but it's just this three-step process to give you a basic idea of
what do you need to enable that?
What actually is your number?
To kind of go back to that commercial
that would unlock your ability to live this ideal life that you just referenced.
I feel like some of us in the financial community,
myself, I am totally guilty of it.
Sometimes we get more focused on the number itself
rather than the things we want to do,
where we want to travel,
how we want to spend it,
what activities we want to do,
when do we want to see family?
I think that's what the money's for,
but sometimes we get so caught up in chasing a single number
that we kind of forget what the number does.
Yes.
And here's the risk with that is,
say your number's a million dollars,
just to use a round number.
What you're going to begin to subconsciously start believing
is that once you hit that million dollars in your portfolio,
you've arrived.
And all of a sudden,
that confidence that you're looking for,
that peace of mind that you're looking for,
that just total sense of I'm here,
it's a bit delusional because you get there and you say,
oh, I don't feel any different.
Yep.
Maybe I chose the wrong number.
Maybe it's not a million dollars.
Maybe it's two million dollars.
And so you keep working,
you keep grinding,
you keep saving,
you hit two million.
And again, you're a little let down
because like, ah, that feeling that I thought I would have,
nothing actually feels different,
just the numbers have changed.
And in fact, some ways,
the feeling you get less confident,
you get more anxious
because the responsibility of all that
or the downside of one mistake,
it starts feeling like a bigger burden to manage.
And so if anything,
it's very easy to get caught in this trap of,
we'll call it goalpost planning,
of you're constantly moving the goalpost,
thinking that that's the magical thing.
Whereas if you view your portfolio
as the thing that you're pursuing,
you're missing the point.
The portfolio or your income or your assets,
those are the things that can enable you
to actually accomplish
what you're actually pursuing,
which is, Erin, to your point,
those relationships, those trips,
those experiences,
the things that actually matter.
And that's not to say the numbers don't matter
because without the numbers,
without the portfolio,
those things can't happen.
But we have to understand the proper context of
what should we be prioritizing
versus what becomes a distraction at best
and even a vain pursuit at worst
of you're completely missing the point
of what you're trying to do.
And sometimes even the way you described it,
it just always reminds me,
the journey to building it up
is so much easier
because I feel like you're going after that goal.
You're like, okay, I'm hitting this number,
whether it's a million, two million, whatever.
But once you hit it,
then all these other questions
that you didn't anticipate come up.
Like, how am I going to spend this down?
How do I actually start to withdraw?
Like, what does that look like?
And I know we touched on that
in the video that we did together,
where we talked about
like what spending looks like in retirement.
But you mentioned at the start
that there's kind of a three-part framework
when it talks about building up this portfolio.
How do you approach it
with that three-part framework?
Yeah.
I think that you,
so you start with the sense
of the portfolio doesn't exist,
as we mentioned,
just to be this number.
This portfolio exists in most cases
to create some level of income
that will grant you financial independence.
I mean, you can create the income
you need from that portfolio
to replace your paycheck
to do what you want to do.
And so the three steps I like to go through
is number one,
start with what are your expenses
actually going to be?
So if I'm preparing for retirement
and I'm, it really doesn't matter what age,
I'm in my 40s, I'm in my 50s, I'm in my 60s,
start with that ideal life.
What do I actually want to do?
Dream a little bit
and then work backwards
and saying, what's that going to cost?
Like I said, some of these things
that you want to do cost money.
If you want to take these trips to Europe,
if you want to take these cruises,
if you want to join whatever country club,
those are things that might cost
quite a bit of money.
On the other hand,
if you're like, I just want to be outside,
I just want to go hiking.
I just want to spend time
with my grandchildren.
I just want to spend time volunteering
down at a local shelter.
Those aren't things
that actually cost any money.
So it's this sense of
what actually matters to you
and then working backwards to quantify
what would it actually take for me
to be able to do each of these things
that I want to do.
So let's just use a basic round number.
Assume that you go through that
and you say, I need $10,000 per month.
I'm just using that
because that's simple math.
That's step one,
is define the amount you need coming in
in order to support
that vision that you have
for your retirement.
Step number two,
it isn't to say, OK,
how much portfolio do I need to have
to create $10,000 per month?
It's to say, well,
what non-portfolio income sources
will I have coming in that will help me?
Those get forgotten a lot.
They do.
And, you know, a lot of people will say,
and they'll say this verbatim.
I view Social Security as a cherry on top
or I view and say, that's great,
but keep in mind Social Security,
it's not designed to be
the entirety of your paycheck,
but it can be quite significant.
Oh, yeah.
Especially for high income earners.
I mean, you can get Social Security check
that can be three, four, even $5,000
if you have the month's payout.
Exactly.
And if it's a married couple in retirement,
you can double that potentially.
Both are.
So you can have a very healthy
amount of income.
And even if it's not
an incredibly high amount,
whatever it is,
whatever is coming in
from Social Security,
that's significantly lessening
the pressure on your other assets,
your portfolio,
to have to create all the income.
You stole the words right out of my mouth.
I was going to say,
it takes the pressure off investments.
Exactly.
Which there's some, there's a handful,
there's several benefits to that.
But I think that that's the thing
that people need to start with is,
OK, $10,000 is the number,
in our hypothetical example here.
Let's assume I have a couple thousand dollars
coming in from Social Security.
Maybe a spouse has a couple thousand dollars
coming in from Social Security.
Let's also assume that I have a pension
of $2,000 per month.
Obviously not everyone has a pension,
but I'm just using this as an example of
what income sources do you have?
It doesn't matter how you're invested.
It doesn't even matter how much you have
in your investment account.
Those are some income floors.
Those are some stable sources of income
that will be with you
for the rest of your life.
Well, in this case,
I would add those three things up.
$2,000 for me, $2,000 for a spouse,
$2,000, $6,000 is coming in.
That's a lot of money.
What that means is that $10,000
that I need to create,
going back again to maintain that lifestyle,
that ideal lifestyle,
60% of that is already taken care of.
Now I know there's taxes
and other stuff there,
so we have to,
there's some nuance to this,
but $6,000.
So what step three now is,
is step three is saying,
okay, well, what's the difference
between how much I want to spend
and how much I have coming in
in non-portfolio income sources?
In this example,
that's $4,000 per month,
$48,000 per year.
I'm just going to round that to $50,000.
I need $50,000 per year
to be able to supplement my pension
and our social security benefits
to get to the $10,000,
which then allows me to do
all those things
that I actually want to do.
And that $50,000 per year,
that's the final thing
that you can look at to say,
okay, what withdrawal rate is needed?
Or what does that represent
of the bigger pie of your portfolio?
And this is where you back into your number.
And there's all different kinds
of ways of looking at this.
Some people say you can spend 4%
of your portfolio per year
and have that last for 30 years.
Others will say higher,
mid fives and above.
Depends on a lot of things.
But let's just use a nice, simple number.
Let's say 5%.
No way a guarantee.
This is just saying,
use this as an example.
If $50,000 needs to represent 5%
to the bigger portfolio,
you can take 50,000,
divide it by 5%,
and that gives me a million dollars.
Not it doesn't give me a million dollars,
but it tells me you would need a million dollars
to be able to make this happen.
And so there's nuances
and we can discuss those.
And I think what might be helpful
to discuss, Erin,
is this isn't the only way of doing this.
There's other ways of creating this income
and we can discuss other options.
But you very simply said,
how do you attach your actual portfolio
to something that
it's actually designed to accomplish?
You started with your ideal,
your vision,
your here's what success looks like.
And as you've worked through that,
you've come up with a,
what is my goal?
Not to just become an ever increasing goalpost.
I keep pushing back.
But once I get there,
I know that I can now support
and fund these things that I want to do.
And I think you make a really great point here
that we need to highlight.
With a million dollar portfolio,
based on the scenario you gave,
if there's social security and if a pension,
you're getting an income of $120,000.
I think so many people default
to only considering investments.
And they're like,
oh, if you retire on just a million dollars,
you follow say the 4% rule
instead of a 5% rate of withdrawal,
they're automatically like,
oh, you're only living on $40,000 a year.
You're just going to be scraping by
in the vast majority parts of the country.
So I just think you need to consider
all income sources
because just look at the example you gave.
We're at a six figure income,
which could be a great income,
especially if you're living in a paid off home,
two income sources,
paid off cars,
kids are out of the house,
they're grown,
they're self-sufficient.
That could be a great standard of living.
You're not scrimping by
with a million dollar portfolio,
which a lot of people to these days,
just say a million dollars
just doesn't go that far.
Yeah.
And you could be right or you could be wrong,
depending upon the context
and what you're talking about.
And this is why starting with that idea,
what does your retirement look like?
Not what is the commercial talk about?
Not what is your neighbor doing?
Not what is your brother-in-law saying?
But what do you actually want to do?
And I find, Erin,
that's actually the hardest part for most people.
It's easy to pay attention to the numbers.
It's easy to say,
here's how much I'm putting in my 401k.
It's easy to,
sometimes we lose ourselves in the numbers
and we forget to actually think about,
what do I want to do?
What does my retirement need to look like
for me to look back one day and say,
I really got the most out of life
because I pursued the things I wanted to do.
Because this is what you do every single day.
You see people entering into retirement,
saving for their retirement,
then spending down in retirement.
How many people do you think prepare
for an accurate retirement?
Because my belief is that the vast majority of people
kind of look at what their spending is today.
And there's a lot of life changes
once you go into retirement.
Yeah.
It's very difficult.
Most people do not.
And for a few reasons.
One is, to your point,
if you're preparing for life today,
do you have a mortgage today?
And maybe that mortgage is paid off when you're retired.
And that doesn't mean you need to take a pay cut.
You're just going to naturally spend less
because you're no longer paying the bank
to repay your mortgage.
Do you have maybe children you're supporting today
with tuition costs, with life costs, whatever.
Maybe that goes away at a certain point.
I think some people, they look at their gross income today
and they say, man, I'm earning $200,000 today.
I'm earning $300,000 today.
Whatever it is, that's a lot of money to replace.
Well, keep in mind a good portion
that you're probably saving to a 401k
or you're saving for retirement.
You no longer need to save for retirement
when you're in retirement.
So you can take that out.
I want to pause you there actually.
Just because I have so many people in my audience
and I know these are going to be the same people
in your audience.
How many people continue to save
once they hit retirement?
Well, I think they think they need to.
There's almost this, I encourage them not to.
Yes.
Not just for sinking funds, like vacations
where you're pulling money out on a monthly basis
and preparing for that trip you're going to take.
But there's this mindset that's hard.
I've done this for 40 years.
How do I stop?
Correct.
And that's a difficult thing.
And I think when you can start to show
that you're just moving money from one bucket to it,
you're pulling from one to pay the other,
your net worth isn't actually changing.
Your progress isn't actually changing.
It's just limiting what you can actually spend
if you think through,
I got to keep saving a certain portion of this.
I like to think of that from the standpoint
of you shouldn't, or you don't need to keep saving
if you don't want to.
Even taxes, like taxes on social security.
Much more tax efficient.
A dollar that you earn there compared to a dollar in wages.
There's money coming from a brokerage account,
a Roth IRA, tax advantages to some of that.
All of those are way more efficient than earned income.
The earned income is the least tax efficient
income source we can have.
Exactly.
Payroll taxes, 7.65%.
So a lot of these things go away to where
even if you're earning a very healthy income today,
you don't need to maintain that same level of income
in retirement to maintain the same lifestyle you have
when you start backing out taxes.
Not all taxes, of course, but a chunk of them.
When you start backing out mortgage payments,
when you start backing out family support potentially,
when you start backing out other things
that are expenses along the way
that aren't going to be there when you're retired.
So where do you think most people fall
when it comes to their comfortable retirement?
I know that's not a word we can apply to everyone broadly,
but when we compare it to their pre-retirement income levels
and once they eventually step away from the workforce,
what kind of range do you think people should target?
And I know it's a range.
It's not going to be one number for everyone.
It's a range.
It's generally going to be...
I know there's statistics that say
maybe it's 60 to 70% of what you're currently spending.
But I think that what we try to encourage clients to do is
that vision board concept.
It can sound woo-woo.
It's almost like you have a chance to dream again.
You get the rest of your life to make retirement
the absolute best season of your life.
You no longer have to be working the 40, 50 hour.
Now, if you love work, keep doing it.
But most people, by the time they get to this point,
many people are ready to do something different.
So start with that.
Don't limit what could be based upon
what life already has been.
Think through, this has nothing to do with finances.
Think through what do you actually want to do?
And that could change things wildly.
Do you want to support scholarships
or give to charities that you care about?
Do you just want to spend time with your kids and grandkids?
Do you want to get really good at pickleball?
Do you want to prioritize your health
because you haven't done so in the last 30 plus years?
Do you want to move to a different part of the country
because you're no longer tied down
because your work is no longer a big part of your life?
So there's all these things that I think are actually,
like I said, more challenging
for a lot of people than the financial side.
That's where the range could be.
The standard 60 to 70% of pre-retirement income.
If you're just going to maintain what you're doing
or it could be dramatically different
if you're going to take a completely different path
in retirement than before.
I think that that, what you just touched on,
is kind of the heart of financial planning
but we don't get to talk about it really.
We don't get to talk about the money is really only there
to build the life you want.
It's meant to be used to build the life you want
but our content, our conversations with people,
it always has to focus on the number
because that's the question people have.
But really, the more important question is
what do you want to do with it?
Yeah, I'm going to give an example of,
this isn't necessarily exactly like what we're talking about
but tax planning is a big piece of what we'll do,
of how do you save money on taxes
throughout your retirement?
And that can be a wonderful thing
but it can also be a trap.
And it's a trap because let's assume,
Erin, we're going to do some Roth conversions for you
when you retire and in order for those to be most effective,
we're trying to keep your taxable income
as low as possible for the first several years of retirement
so we can shift money from your traditional IRAs
to your Roth IRAs while still staying under key tax thresholds
that we don't want to exceed.
You can take that to the extreme of,
oh, okay, well, I'm not going to take that trip
with my family this year
because I want to keep my taxable income low
and I'm not going to spend as much as I could have
because I'm trying to keep income super low.
And on paper, it's, wow, you're saving hundreds of thousands
of dollars in taxes over the course of your retirement
and it seems like success
when you're looking at a Monte Carlo number
or when you're looking at a,
here's what your portfolio is going to do.
And that's where you have to define what is success.
Is success that?
I don't think so.
Like make sure you're using the right yardstick.
Use the right yardstick.
Otherwise, you're going to get to the end of your life
with lots of money and lots of tax savings
but none of the experiences
or none of the things along the way
that actually made it worth living.
So how do you find that right balance?
Start with what you want life to look like
and then the financial side should do nothing
but compliment that and support that,
not in any way take away from it or detract from it.
I love that.
I kind of, it inspires me to maybe say,
maybe there's a goal planning session
that's not money related that goes into say each year
or maybe you just say,
these are my non-negotiables for this year
of a trip I want to take
or a gift that I want to give to somebody
and then just make sure to work those
into your financial plan
rather than just focusing on the dollars and cents.
Yeah, exactly.
And the last thing I'll say on this is
there tends to be an inverse correlation
of the people that have saved and invested
and prepared the most
tend to have the most difficult time doing this sometimes.
And what I'll always say is you are where you are
because you are who you are
and that's not just going to magically change.
So the person then, no, please.
I was going to add that I feel like people
who have experienced very severe economic situations
like in my generation,
we started in the workforce in 2008
that was a big economic downturn
and so many people don't trust the stock market
because of that.
I feel like if you go through these situations
where you experience a huge monetary loss
or you experience a huge job loss,
you're more conservative for the rest of your life,
including retirement.
I think that's a great example.
Do you know anyone from the Great Depression era?
Yeah.
My grandma is that.
The extreme levels of frugality
and some of this, by the way, is necessary.
This level of frugality is necessary
when there's a scarcity.
At the time, you have to ask yourself,
is this mindset, is this way of living still serving me
or have I moved past that point
of it's no longer necessity
and it's actually holding me back?
But you're right.
We are all shaped by our experiences,
our upbringing, typically the bad experiences
more so than the good experiences.
Maybe more of an impression.
It is more of an impression.
In many cases, that led to healthy behavior
when that behavior was necessary
and we have to constantly reassess and say,
is that behavior still helping me
or could I start to think differently about this?
I always look at things from the standpoint
of how do we avoid, to the greatest extent possible,
regrets at the end of our life?
So many of those regrets would be driven
by this scarcity mindset of saying no to things
because of the financial costs
or because of the perceived risk.
If we could take a step back,
we might realize that's not at all risk.
In fact, the biggest risk is not doing some of these things.
I know we started off with a very technical,
financial conversation,
but everything always goes back to
what does a life well lived look like?
Absolutely.
I think accomplishing it from an emotional standpoint
is the harder part of it.
The money's easy from the sense of
it has a concrete answer.
You know, there's a number,
but the emotional component is something
that's a little harder to target
and harder to sometimes allow happen.
Yeah, yeah.
Fully agreed.
Awesome.
Well, thank you for being here.
I've loved this and it was a pleasure.
Yeah.
Thanks for having me, Erin.
And I think this is the intersection of money
and I don't want to say emotion,
but money and life.
At that intersection is where the good,
real financial planning happens.
100% agree.
And I think it gets a little too overlooked.
So I'm glad we were able to talk about it today.
Likewise.
Thanks, Erin.
I'm going to put a link for everything
for James down below.
If you guys like this one,
give it a like,
share it with a friend.
And thanks for watching.
We'll see you in the next one.