Can regenerative farming deliver? A new long term experiment at Rothamsted aims to find out...

Integrated Agriculture
4 followers
1 Video View·May 28, 2025
Regenerative farming is gaining traction for its potential to improve soils and reduce emissions. A new long-term experiment at Rothamsted – a site with a long history of agricultural research – is designed to assess how well the practice actually works, from crop yields to agro-ecosystem resilience
Comments are disabled for this video.
Farming has got a lot more complicated.
If we think about the concept of regenerative agriculture,
it's not about one single change,
one single innovation or intervention, if you like,
it's about changing the whole system.
So when we set up this experiment,
we thought about what are the things that we could change
that would impact the system most.
And the things that we've changed
are the types of crops that we grow.
So we look at three different rotations
which have increasing numbers of crops grown in them.
We compare two different ways
of preparing the soil or tillage.
So we compare an inversion tillage ploughed system
with a reduced or zero till system.
Then we add organic material to some of the plots
and that's as green compost.
And then finally, we apply principles
of what we call integrated pest management,
where we try and reduce pesticide use on some of the plots.
But we're combining all of those different ingredients
in different combinations to see how they affect outcomes
and affect the behaviour of the system.
Well, the squares on the chessboard, if you like,
represent those different combinations of treatments,
those different approaches to farming systems.
So immediately behind me here, we have a spring barley crop.
Then we have a winter oilseed rape next to that.
And then beyond the winter oilseed rape,
we have an interesting plot
where we have what we call a perennial legume lay.
So in that particular rotation, as well as annual crops,
we are also growing this two-year lay of perennial legumes.
And we're doing that to build soil health,
to build soil fertility and soil carbon.
So we have that.
And then beyond that, we have a mustard crop.
So we're measuring the worms.
We're measuring soil health.
That includes the biology, the microbiology of the soils,
the physical structure of the soils.
We're looking at pest, weed, and disease pressure.
So we're interested in understanding
how these systems regulate pest, weeds, and diseases,
which can then buy us some headroom
to reduce the amount of pesticides we use.
And then, of course, we're also measuring yield
and we're measuring grain quality as well.
My particular interest is in the carobid beetles.
These are predators of many crop pests
and weed seeds as well.
So we're particularly interested
in what drives where they are in fields
and how we can increase their abundance.
They can also react to pest outbreaks.
So literally sensing the pests in the field,
so they smell them with their antennas
and they move towards those pests.
So in the case of the violet ground beetle,
they actually track along slug trails
by smelling along the slug trail into the field,
finding those pests and dealing with those outbreaks.
I set up pitfall traps,
which is essentially a cup in the ground.
Beetle runs along, falls in, dies.
And we do have to kill them, unfortunately,
because they are so voracious predators
that they will just eat each other in the traps.
So although I love beetles,
I do have to kill a lot of them.
But we find out what drives their abundances in fields
so that I can figure out how to get more of them
in the long run, which is good news for everybody.
The interest in this has been overwhelming.
I have been so encouraged by the motivation
of farmers to get out there,
see what's happening in their fields.
We want to see what the different amounts of carbon
in each of the plots
with the different treatments apply to them.
So we do that by taking samples of each plot
and analysing the results,
and then using statistics to compare
how the different combinations of treatments
have impacted those results.
So carbon is important
because it's one of the fundamental
building blocks of the soil.
So you'll have soil texture
in the soil, sort of mineral components,
but then the organic matter
is going to be sort of the life of the soil.
So it's going to feed the animals in the soil,
it's produced by the plants to build these relationships,
as well as influencing the soil structure then
to provide a good water and air balance,
as well as habitat for the life forms.
Carbon works as sort of the currency
between plants and microbes,
with the plants providing it to the microbes as food,
and then the microbes provide
other resources to the plants.
You can view every farm if you like
as a unique experiment.
Every farmer is continually adapting their practice,
continually adapting their farm
to deal with the pressures
and the problems that they have.
So as well as collecting data
on these kinds of plots at Rothamsted,
we're working with commercial farmers
to monitor the effect of their practice
or their change in practice
to add data and add evidence
to these kinds of platforms.
When we talk to farmers,
what they want is evidence.
There's a lot of conversation
and there's a lot of chatter
about this works, that works.
Now we're never going to be able to say that definitively,
but what we are going to be able to say is
the balance of evidence.
If you do this, you will see these effects,
these beneficial effects.
