Bi Gan Loses His Heart 比干剖心 | Chinese History - The Shang Dynasty E22

Shang Dynasty Culture
18 followers
134 Video Views·May 26, 2025
In this episode of 'The Shang Dynasty', we talk about Bi Gan, one of the ‘Three Sages of Late Shang’.
Hello and welcome to the show. My name is Api Ngo. I'm that Chinese history guy.
Here we share the stories from the myths, legends and histories of the Chinese people,
from the first creator to the last imperial dynasty. More than 6,000 years of stories,
one video at a time. And if you like stuff like this, remember you can help the channel
by giving us a like, a sub, a comment or a share. Now in this episode of the Shang dynasty,
we'll talk about Bi Gan, one of the three sages of the late Shang dynasty. Now why is he acclaimed
by future generations as a premium example of fearless loyalty? And also what was the
price that he paid for holding on and living by his ideals and his beliefs?
Now the protagonist of today's story is a man named Bi Gan. He was the son of King Taiding,
the younger brother of King Diyi and he was the uncle to King Zhou, the tyrant of the Shang dynasty.
Now his name at birth was just Gan and he was later granted the fiefdom of the land of Bi,
which was in today's Qifu region in Shandong and therefore he was later referred to as Bi Gan.
Now Bi Gan, according to records and documents, was a very studious and diligent boy growing up
and by the age of 20, he was appointed to the position of Grand Tutor of the Shang dynasty
to assist his brother King Diyi in the day-to-day running and governing of the realm.
Now when Diyi was gravely ill and on his deathbed, it was said that Bi Gan prayed to the gods
to spare his brother's life in exchange for his own life. So we can tell that he places a very
great emphasis and importance on familiar ties and relationships with his family members.
Now when the king was troubled over who to name as heir to the throne, Bi Gan actually argued for
naming Di Xin, who was the younger son of King Diyi. He argued for Di Xin to take over the throne
over his older brothers because Di Xin not only displayed outstanding talents and strength since
he was a young age, he was also the only one with a legitimate claim, being born of a full queen
rather than being born of consorts or concubines. Now Bi Gan of course made these suggestions and
argued for Di Xin's position as heir because it, for one, officially it adhered to the succession
rule that was laid down by King Zhu Jia generations ago. But at the same time, Di Xin was actually
Bi Gan's favourite nephew and Bi Gan really believed with all his heart that Di Xin would
be the one, the talented and the strong young man that he was, that he believed that Di Xin would
be the one who would lead the Shang dynasty and the Shang kingdom out of the predicament that they
find themselves in at that time. So when Di Xin ascended to the throne after his father's death,
Bi Gan was appointed to the position of Grand Counsellor of the Shang kingdom.
Now his job, his duties as Grand Counsellor of the kingdom of the dynasty was to of course
offer advice and counsel to the king and at the same time assist in the day-to-day running and
the governing of the kingdom. Now Bi Gan's central policy direction was advocating for lower taxes
and much lighter conscriptions. He also pushed for agricultural developments and development of
metalworking, metallurgy and metal forging and to stockpile resources for the kingdom.
This was so he could increase the productivity of the land and to allow the people and the land
and the economy, most importantly, time and breathing room to recover from these generations
of expenses and troubles and chaos. So the rebuilding of the military was only possible
when the economy of the land was sufficiently recovered under Bi Gan's policies and his
supervision. Now things were going pretty well for a period of time, especially the
kingdom saw a form of revival, a form of recovery under his early cautious policies, but
good days don't last. After the multiple military campaigns that were successful and victorious
under the new king and they enjoyed this period of revival, Di Xin became more and more arrogant
and his actions became more and more cruel and oppressive. He started to believe his own hype,
he started to believe that he was a god amongst men, he started to believe that
all the successes the kingdom enjoyed were due to his own actions and his own merits.
Over time, Di Xin started to morph into the King Zhou or Zhou Wang of the Shang dynasty as we hear
so much of as we remember him today. And of course Bi Gan being the loving uncle and the
grand counsellor of the kingdom was disappointed in the changes that he saw in his king, in this
man that he believed would change the fate of the kingdom and the dynasty. However, he did not give
up on his nephew, on his favourite nephew. He never stopped offering counsel, he never stopped advising
the king against these harsh taxes and these heavy conscription exercises. And he repeatedly
tried to make the king see the cruelties in his actions and his policies. But by this time,
having drank his own kool-aid, King Zhou saw Bi Gan and his cautious policies more as annoyances and
hindrance to his own greatness. Now in an illustration of King Zhou's cruelty, it was said
that once when the king was having a drink with his queen Daji, the seductress, the fox spirit,
you know what have you. When they were having a drink, enjoying themselves, they saw an old man
and a young boy crossing a river. Now the young boy made his way through these icy cold waters
very quickly while the old man was still shivering while taking every tentative step through the
waters. And King Zhou just offhandedly commented that, oh the young boy can brave the cold of this
icy water better than the old man because young people have denser bones than older people.
Now Daji did not believe him, did not believe the king, so the king ordered the old man and
the young boy be captured and brought to them. And he had their feet cut off above their ankles
to show to the queen. See, take a look at this cross-section. See, yeah the young boy's bones
are denser than the old man's. Look, look at the difference. Yeah, just to prove a point, he had
their legs cut off and they most probably died even if they didn't, it wouldn't be long. So yeah,
and you know, having proven his point, but the queen Daji by this time was unwilling to admit
that the king was smarter than her. So what queen Daji did was that she claimed that she could tell
the gender of unborn babies just by observing their mothers. And this intrigued the king, of
course, and to test her claim, King Zhou ordered a hundred pregnant women be captured and brought
before them. So once they rounded up these hundred pregnant women, Daji then ordered these women
sit down. And when we say sit down, it's not like what we think of today. There were no chairs
back in those days. Chairs were not invented until I think the Han dynasty. So back then,
people sat down like how you see the Japanese sit today, you know, on their knees resting on their
foot. So yeah, so Daji ordered these hundred pregnant women sit down and then stand up again.
And then she told the king that those who raised their left leg first when standing up were carrying
boys, while those who were carrying girls would raise their right legs first when standing up.
And to prove her claims, yeah, I think you know where this is going. To prove her claims, the
order was given to cut these pregnant women open and take out the fetuses to check the gender of
the babies that they were carrying. Now hearing the terrifying screams and the agonizing wails
of these women being cut open alive, Pikan barged into the king's private party and seeing what was
going on around him, I mean he must have been horrified, you know. And he trembled in rage
and he pointed to the king and he acknowledged the king to his face. The furious Pikan by this time
also pointed to Daji, the queen of the land. Mind you, pointed to her at her nose and accused her
of being the root of all the rot that has been plaguing the Shang court at this time. And he
accused her of being the one that led the king astray. She was the one that caused the king to
become cruel and oppressive and, you know, turning him from being such a talented and sweet young boy
into this monster that everyone sees as today. And, you know, he demanded that the queen should
be executed together with her entire clan, you know, as a form of penance to the people.
Now remember, this was the king's uncle, blood uncle, related by blood. So, you know,
although King Zhou was like seizing, you know, fuming, he did not say anything and he just
kept quiet while Pikan went on and on. And seeing that the king, you know, kept his silence and did
not rebuke him or say anything, Pikan continued with his admonishment. Oh my king, a natural
disaster happened during King Shang Tang's time and the roads were all clogged with corpses.
And seeing the devastation, King Tang himself got off his carriage and wept as he held the corpses
in his arms, blaming himself for not being able to do more and to do better for his subjects.
He immediately ordered the opening of state granaries and treasuries to deliver aid to the
people. He ensured that all who were hungry got food and all who were cold had clothes. His
benevolent rule warned him the praise and the adulation of the entire realm. But today, my king,
you have gone against everything the founders of our great dynasty stood for. King Tang went through
countless hardships to found the kingdom and the dynasty. King Pankeng took great pains in
rebuilding the kingdom from nine generations of chaos. Now King Wuting toiled in the land together
with the peasants and the slaves, while King Chu Jia was so disciplined that he never drank more
than three small cups of wine in any sitting. Now my king, if you do not stop your cruelties,
if you do not stop your oppressions and return to the ways of our great ancestors, the kingdom
and the dynasty will indeed be at great risk. Now because Pikan was his own uncle, King Zhou
could not possibly blow up at him and castigate him openly. So King Zhou just nodded courteously,
politely. If he was capable of that, he nodded while listening to his uncle, while listening
to Pikan's demolishments. But inside his heart, he was silently fuming and seething with anger
that he could not do anything to his own uncle and the Grand Councilor of the state. So yeah,
there was this great anger boiling under the surface against his uncle by this time.
Now after this whole debacle and this whole incident, I mean nothing changed. The queen
was not executed. King Zhou did not change his ways. In fact, things got even worse. He became
even more cruel. He levied even harsher taxes and he ordered even heavier conscriptions. And so
Pikan went to his brother and his other nephew Wei Ziqi and he asked them to go speak to the
king about his behavior as well. And he was hoping that with so many family members advising him and
talking to him, hey don't be such a douche, be a better king. He thought that it would help and it
would change the king's mindset and behavior over time. Nope, not gonna happen. Not with this
fella. You know, for their efforts, Ji Zi had his head shaved and was thrown into the dungeon and
he only escaped death by pretending to be mad, by pretending to have gone crazy in the dungeons.
And Wei Ziqi, who was the king's own older brother, he escaped unscathed from a very heated
conversation. But after the conversation, Wei Ziqi realized that his brother was beyond hope. There
was no way of changing him and the kingdom is most probably doomed. So Wei Ziqi took all the
implements of the royal family and he left the capital, hoping. And I guess he had foresight,
so he took all these implements and left the capital, hoping to preserve at least the ability
for ancestral worship should the dynasty and the kingdom really fall. So yeah, I mean even when
close family members are imprisoned or have left the capital, we could only imagine what's going on
with the rest of the officials or the ministers of the court. So by this time, the majority of
these capable officials of the Shang court had either left the capital to find a better place
to live or they would have defected to the dukey of Zhou. And very soon, all 800 vassals of the
Shang kingdom, the Shang dynasty, all 800 vassals defected and the Zhou army arrived at this place
called Mengjin, which is in today's Mengjin county in Henan. The Zhou army arrived at Mengjin to rally
with the allies, with these 800 defected vassals to rally with the armies of all these allies
for the final push into the Shang capital at Zhaoge. Now, one would have thought that, you know, okay,
everyone has fled, everyone has left, the king, King Zhou, the tyrant is basically left to his own devices.
But, Pi Kan did not leave, he did not waver in his service to the court and he stayed behind to the
very, very bitter end. I guess Pi Kan could never give up on his king and his favourite nephew.
Now, in these final days of the dynasty, Pi Kan defiantly, you know, went to the king three days
in a row to point out in no uncertain terms the king's mistakes and his cruelties and his sins
and he begged the king to repent. And of course, with the whole world collapsing around him and
then you have this guy who keep harping on your mistakes and your sins and your crimes, of course
the king, being who he was and the kind of person he was, got extremely irritated by the incessant
counsel that his uncle was giving him at this time. And he questioned Pi Kan,
why, why are you so persistent and insistent, you know, when the whole world is burning up
around us, why are you still so persistent? And in response to the irate king's questioning of his
persistence, Pi Kan fearlessly told him in the face, now my king, it is disloyal for a servant
not to point out his master's mistake and it is cowardice to hold back counsel in fear of death.
If death is the price to pay for offering good counsel and good advice, then it is a worthy
price for loyalty. A king should have officials that can bravely point out his mistakes and
correct him. A man should have sons and friends that provide him with good counsel and advice.
And as a servant of the court, I must fulfill my duties and responsibilities to the kingdom.
Now we all know the tyrant Jie of the Xia dynasty lost his kingdom because of his
cruelties and his lack of virtues. Now my king, you are emulating his behavior and making his
mistakes. Aren't you worried about losing your kingdom and ending the Shang dynasty as well?
It is my most crucial duty and responsibility, especially now, especially today, to remind you,
oh king, of the consequences of your actions and what it might bring forth. So you know how
sometimes when you reach the peak of anger or any emotions, you suddenly just become calm and clear?
Yeah, that's exactly what happened with King Zhou at this time. You know, being so furious that he
just became calm. And with a very quiet voice, he said to Bi Gan, my dear uncle, I heard
that great sages throughout history have seven openings in their hearts. Now why don't we
take a look and see if you are really a sage at heart? With that command, King Zhou ordered
to have Bi Gan's heart open and had his heart dug out from his chest. And alas, alas, alas,
the most loyal servant of the late Shang dynasty met his gory ends at the hands of an unrepentant
tyrant. And even to his last second, to his last breath, Bi Gan showed no fear and he did not flinch
as he was brutally murdered just for speaking the truth. And you know, hoping that, you know, dying
for his ideal, dying for his belief, you know, hoping against all hope that his death would
finally be a wake-up call for his nephew. Now as we all know, that did not happen. It did not wake
the tyrant up. The kingdom was destroyed. The dynasty was ended. But although the death of Bi Gan,
his death would not change the course of history, his loyalty and his fearless counsel earned him
great admiration from future generations. And together with Ji Zi and Wei Zi Qi, they would
be together known as the three sages of the late Shang dynasty. Now of course, as we discussed with
stories about King Zhou, we know that this transition period between the Shang and the
Zhou dynasty, the records and the documents of this period is highly suspect to say the least,
with a lot of exaggerations and a lot of misinformation and propaganda of the time
mixed in with real events of what happened. So it's not that much different from the
records, the stories of Bi Gan. So according to some new artifacts that were found,
it is said that Bi Gan actually died more than a decade after King Zhou. So yeah, the story about
him having his heart cut out is suspicious at best, although we can't say that it did not happen.
These new discoveries cast a lot of doubt on this story, although it is a nice story,
I have to admit. And there are other stories that circulated about the death of Bi Gan,
if his heart was not cut out by the tyrant, how did he die? Some stories, some versions of the
story say that more than 10 years after his nephew's death and the fall of the dynasty,
Bi Gan being unwilling to be a subject of the new Zhou dynasty, committed suicide by
throwing himself into a river and he drowned. So yeah, we'll never know, we'll never know for
sure today. And another very interesting story about Bi Gan was that after he died,
and he went up to the celestial realms, he met the Jade Emperor, who yeah, we haven't
spoke about him in a while, right? Yeah, Jade Emperor, the great god king guy in the sky. So
Bi Gan passed away and he went up to the celestial realm and met the Jade Emperor,
and the Jade Emperor was really very impressed by his behavior and his activities, you know,
when he was alive, seeing that he was a compassionate man who was just and unbiased
in his dealings. And because a man who has no heart, his heart was dug out, a man who has no
heart could not be biased, and a man who has no heart will definitely be just. So the Jade Emperor
appointed Bi Gan as the god of fortune, which basically is still worshipped today by many,
many Chinese across the world. So if you go into a god of fortune temple, most probably the deity
that they are worshipping in their temple is Bi Gan. Yeah, so that's the trivia for you.
Well, I hope you enjoyed this story as much as I enjoyed telling it, and if you did,
the best way for you to support this channel and the best way to help keep the lights on around
would be to be a patron of the channel, and to do that, you can sign up on our Patreon page
available in the description box below. And if you are not ready to make such a big commitment,
it will really help the channel out if you could just like, sub, comment, and share.
And I guess that's it for today, and yeah, in the coming episodes, we'll be talking
about the other two great sages of the late Shang dynasty, so I will see you beautiful people
in the next episode.
