WHY 120FPS WON'T LAST. FRAME RATE COMPARISON. What should you shoot with?

Studio Solution
24 followers
#Education#filmmaker #teachnic filmmaker
Let's talk about something as controversial as politics, and that's frame rates. People choose
their frame rates like they choose their political parties, and they get very offended if you don't
like the same frame rate as them. Politics aside, let's look at some frame rates. Here's 23.98,
which just consider me talking about 24 and 25 for the rest of this video when I mention that.
Here's 29.97, and here is the same shot in 59.94.
Last year I made a video about frame rates, but I was specifically talking about slow motion,
and it actually became the most popular YouTube video I've ever made. But a lot of people got
pretty upset with it because I wasn't saying 120 frames was the best frame rate ever. But I was
talking about slow motion. This is where you take 120 frames and play it back at 23.98, so it's about
five times slower. Super slow motion. And this is not always the right choice when you're creating
films. And let me say this, there is no perfect frame rate. I would say there are better applications
for each frame rate. So first off, what is a base frame rate? To simplify it, it's the frame rate you
intend for your film to be viewed at. It's how many frame rates per second that you're capturing
your footage and intending to play it back at. So let's talk about each frame rate and when you
want to use them. And so the first frame rate I'm going to talk about, I'm going to lump this all
together, is 23.98, 24, and 25. They're essentially interchangeable. 25 is PAL, that's in Europe and
other countries. This is the classic cinema experience. This is a filmic look, and it would
be used for most scripted and dramatic type of films, kind of anything that's going to theaters
most often. And I would say actually it's a great application for most documentaries, unless it's
perhaps maybe a nature film. Here I am in 29.97. This would be the most common video format that
you would see on TV. This is what you film home videos in. This is what anything that is 59.94
interlaced is actually displayed at, because when it's interlaced, it plays back in 29.97
progressively. Well, sort of. You kind of need to understand what an interlaced field is versus
progressive. Progressive is your whole screen where interlaced is each line of resolution,
one at a time. And some TVs will first display the odd fields, then the even fields, creating
one cohesive image. And here I am in 59.94 for the very first time on this channel. So smooth,
isn't it? Now some of you might be looking at this saying, finally, he's come to his senses.
I'm going to say this, there is no perfect frame rate. And I'm going to tell you why this
is not the right frame rate all the time. This is what's often used for news and sports because it
is so smooth. So then why then, if it's used for news, did I shoot 23.98 for my film that was on
CNN, a news network? Why is there not one frame rate to rule them all? Well, it comes down to
this one simple thing and that's cinematic visual language. So let's talk about that.
Hi there. What's this? Well, you probably think it's today's sponsor. It's not. It's a box
with 80 terabytes of hard drives. And why do I have 80 terabytes of hard drives? Well,
I'm shooting a lot of documentaries right now. And that's actually who's sponsoring today's video.
It's the art of documentary. And if you're not familiar with it, it's our documentary course.
It's the complete guide to telling compelling films. We launched this course about a year ago.
We've had almost a thousand students come through and they are now creating the most amazing films.
It's been so exciting watching people take all of the teaching that we have and apply it to their
careers, to the corporate videos, and most importantly, to their passion projects,
to the documentaries that they want to be creating. And what's really exciting too is
we've created module two, which is our advanced version of the course. There's now over 55
new videos in module two. And we do a deep dive into directing. We do all the behind the scenes
work. We take you on set and into the edit suite showing exactly how we edit and cut our films.
There is so much content in this. We've been working on it for over a year. I couldn't be
more excited for this, but you want to get on the early bird list. We open up for just about a week
or so on September 7th, only open it up about twice a year, only for a couple of weeks. There's
special early bird pricing. If you can get in right away. So get on that wait list on the
art of documentary.com. Again, we don't keep this course open all year. So you don't want to miss
this exciting opportunity to be a part of the art of documentary. It's lifetime access. We don't do
monthly plan. You get it for life. So go check out the art of documentary and set September 7th
in your calendar when we reopen the course. Let's get back to frame rates.
I want to talk quickly about my favorite frame rate and that's 24 or 2398 rather. And now I know
all the people who love video games are going to be very upset that I say it like that because
there's more motion blur and it looks worse and it's not as smooth. And yeah, those are all true.
But why I enjoy that is something I call cinematic visual language. You see, since we were kids,
most of us, we've been watching films at 2398. This is the inherent visual language that we've
come to accept what cinematic films feel like. Departing from that feels like a new language.
It feels awkward. It doesn't feel right. And here's a few reasons why I believe that you see
cinema is about withholding information. It's why we crop in on our images. It's why we shoot
shallow depth of field. It's why we light things with high contrast. This is what cinema is. You're
not seeing the entire world. If you go watch a virtual reality film, it's not necessarily as
cinematic as seeing your favorite latest action film or documentary. That's why I think we watch
films. We want to see the world differently. We want to see it through the eyes of the storyteller.
And 2398 does this. It adds a bit of motion blur. And you know what? In real life, we do see motion
blur. Taking away any motion blur just doesn't feel real. It feels hyper-realistic in a way.
It is kind of jarring. To me, I don't feel more immersed. I always feel like I'm looking at a
video game. To be honest, movies like The Hobbit and Gemini Man, I just didn't enjoy that. It just
felt different. Again, it felt like I was watching a video game and it didn't help me suspend my
disbelief. This is a really important part of 2398 and 24. As I would say, it's easier to accept the
world on camera and you're more willing to participate in the story. When it feels hyper-realistic,
again, you start to feel like you're watching sports or news and it takes you out of that
storytelling universe. I'm purely talking about a philosophical approach here, not technical. I
fully accept that there's less motion blur in 60 frames and 120 frames, but that doesn't necessarily
make it better. That's like saying something that is brighter is better or something that is louder
is better. Just because you have more fidelity, more power, more technology available doesn't mean
it's the right choice. Essentially, how much motion blur we see, they believe is closest to 60 hertz.
There's some give or take there because every human is different, but this is why I want to
watch sports at 60. When I turn on the basketball game, I want it to feel like real life. I want to
think that I'm actually at that game. When it comes to 120 frames, I think it'll always have
place in video games, but I think we're very far off from it being universally adopted. For one,
it's five times the amount of data and also blu-ray caps out at 60 frames. Because 120
frames is so clear and there's so little motion blur, you can start seeing blemishes in the film
like the fact that half these shots here are a stunt actor and it's not actually Will Smith.
The irony is too, YouTube can't even display 120 frames, so you're actually just watching
60 frame playback. This is why I don't think 120 frames is going to be a default format. There's
just not the avenues to show it right now. I still think for a very long time we'll see 23.98
as the universal cinematic language, unless there's a generation that grows up entirely on 120 frames.
So let's compare these frame rates against each other. With 24, you're going to be getting more
motion blur. There's just less frames per second. This is like shooting with a slower shutter.
You'll get more motion blur. So with Blandon doing his jumping jacks here, if I pause it,
you can see his hands have a significant amount of blur. But in comparison to 29.97 and we pause it,
there's a little less motion blur. And then at 59.97, this is progressive, so again it's almost
60 frames per second, you're getting even less motion blur. And this type of motion blur would
be more similar to what we see with our own eyes. Also, side note, motion blur has a lot to do with
your shutter angle, and I have a whole separate video explaining all of that. Just like Marshall
McClellan said, the medium is the message. And the medium of 23.98 is the cinematic message.
And when we want to depart from that, we just have to accept that we're sending a new message
to our audience. I shoot all my documentaries in 23.98, and if you're interested in how I
documentaries and how we go about creating our films, I do have a film course all about this,
and it's opening up September 7th, so you can go check that link down below.
So thanks for watching this video, guys. Please, for all the video game players out there,
come and hate on this video. I welcome to have conversations about this, but let's not take it
personal. It's just frame rates. It's not friendships. All right, I'll see you in the next one.
