PM Sir Keir Starmer speaks on Chagos Islands deal

UK Prime Ministers
23 followers
25 Video Views·May 23, 2025
Follow us on Twitter: / skynews
Like us on Facebook: / skynews
Follow us on Instagram: / skynews
Follow us on TikTok: / skynews
Countries have the right to manage this spectrum as they wish within their borders.
A right that's recognised in regulations and overseen in the International Telecommunication
Union. The use of the spectrum is key to understand and anticipate those who seek to do us harm.
If our right to control it is put into doubt we would lose the first line of defence
against other countries who wish to interfere and disrupt this capability,
rendering it practically useless. In addition if we did not agree this deal
the legal situation would mean that we would not be able to prevent China or any other nation
setting up their own bases on the outer islands or carrying out joint exercises near our base.
We would have to explain to you, the British people and to our allies that we'd lost control
of this vital asset. No responsible government could let that happen so there's no alternative
but to act in Britain's national interest. By agreeing to this deal now on our terms
we're securing strong protections including from malign influence that will allow the base to
operate well into the next century, helping to keep us safe for generations to come.
Other approaches to secure the base have been tried over the years and they have failed.
Boris Johnson failed in his efforts to endlessly delay. Liz Truss then started the negotiations.
We inherited a negotiation in which the principle of giving up UK sovereignty
had already been conceded by the previous Tory government. Our deal has concluded those
negotiations in the national interest. Now there's obviously a cost to maintaining such
a valuable asset. We pay for other military bases. Allies like the US and France do the same.
This cost is part and parcel of using Britain's global reach to keep us safe at home
and it will be less than the cost of running one aircraft carrier for a year.
Today's agreement is the only way to maintain the base in the long term. There is no alternative.
We will never gamble with national security. So we have acted to secure our national interest,
to strengthen our national security and to protect the British people for many years to come.
Thank you. Now let me hand over to the Defence Secretary and then to General Hockenhull
to say a few words. Defence Secretary. Thank you Prime Minister. As the world becomes more dangerous,
the Diego Garcia military base becomes more important. But I want to underline the urgency
and uncertainty over the future control of this UK base. Within weeks we faced new legal rulings
which would weaken the UK's full operational sovereignty over this base. And within just a
few years this irreplaceable military and intelligence base would become inoperable.
That's why we've taken action today. That's why the Prime Minister has signed this treaty today,
securing this base for the next 99 years and beyond. Our allied nations are right behind us
and behind this deal. The US, Australia, New Zealand, India, Canada. Others want to see this
base closed. They want to see this deal collapse. China, Russia, Iran. The value of this deal is
beyond doubt. Full control of Diego Garcia for the next 99 years and beyond. Full control and
protection of the electromagnetic spectrum. That priceless intelligence, communications,
sensors, radar. A strengthened buffer zone so we can control the seas and the skies immediately
around Diego Garcia and wider islands up to 100 miles. An effective veto over any developments or
hostile activities. And with the base in jeopardy, no action was no option. And anyone who would
argue to abandon this deal would abandon this base. So let me be clear, the British people
and our British forces are safer today and into the future because of this deal.
Thank you. Thank you. General Hoppenhal, can I turn to you? Thank you Prime Minister and Secretary
of State. I think it's useful to add a military perspective here. The way we see this is very
simple. Diego Garcia provides a vital capability to the armed forces, to our US allies and for our
shared contribution to global security. The geography offers immense and irreplaceable
global reach, enabling us to pivot forces westward toward Africa and the Middle East
or eastward toward Southeast Asia and the Pacific. Added to that are the facilities on the base.
A deep water port capable of hosting nuclear submarines and aircraft carriers. A runway
capable of operating every type of military aircraft with the logistical support required
for modern operations and the satellite and communications infrastructure that the Prime
Minister mentioned. It is a unique asset for Britain's defence and security. It gives us the
ability to deploy a wide range of capabilities over a huge geography. Now Diego Garcia proved
its worth through the long years of counter-terrorism operations and proves its value today by supporting
our ability to protect maritime trade. It will be of even greater strategic significance in the future.
It helps keep the United Kingdom safe and prosperous and it allows us to work closely
with our international partners. The use of Diego Garcia by US forces is a unique contribution to the
military relationship between our two countries and one that underlines the UK's commitment
to burden sharing. Both our militaries will continue to benefit from our investment in
these facilities for the years to come. Britain projects military power through such alliances
and through assets like this base which give us a global reach. I welcome the long-term
certainty that this treaty brings. It will help the British armed forces in our efforts to support
stability abroad and security at home. Thank you. Thank you very much. We'll now take some
questions from the media. I've got Jonathan Beale from the BBC first please. Jonathan.
So first of all, two Diego Garcia women went to the High Court to try to stop this today.
They've described this as a very sad day. They say they do not want to hand their rights to
Mauritius. What do you say to them? And then isn't it time to level with the British taxpayers as to
how much this is going to cost? I noticed you said it was going to cost the equivalent of the
operational cost of an aircraft carrier. If you could actually spell that out, that would be
helpful. Defence Secretary, is this money that you're going to have to pay to lease back the
base going to come out of the defence budget? And you're not going to get a single bullet,
an extra soldier or even a shell for Ukraine in return for that. So just what's the value of that?
And then General Jim, if I can just quote back to you from Jack Hortley at Roosley.
The UK has ceded strategic ground when it did not have to and has got nothing in return.
Thank you very much. On the Chagossian challenge, obviously the fact there was a challenge
delayed the signing, but in a way it was a good thing because a court has now heard the arguments
for and against and come down conclusively in the High Court in favour of the government
argument that was put forward this morning. So that challenge was made, that challenge has now
been determined in our courts after legal arguments and that's the right way to determine it.
Well, they made their case, there were different views which I understand in different parts of
the community, but the challenge that was put was made in court and the court heard the matter this
morning on legal argument and came to a firm ruling in our favour. On the question of costs,
the cost of this is an average per year cost of £100 million, £101 million a year is the
average cost. The net overall cost is therefore £3.4 billion overall, that's over the 99 years.
That is, as I mentioned a moment ago, the average £100 million per year is about the same or
slightly less than the running cost of an aircraft carrier minus the aircraft. Now given the
significance of this facility, both the geography and the capability, you can see that as again
measured against an aircraft carrier running costs, that this is very good value for money.
I should also say that it's very similar to arrangements made by other allies, the US
and France, in relation to the bases that they lease and make arrangements for as well. So
it's in keeping with those payments. Can I also, just before General Jim comes to this,
just begin to answer the question he puts him, that did we have to do this? The answer to that
is there has already been an advisory opinion against the United Kingdom. All the advice,
and nobody disputes this, is that should there be further legal proceedings, they're going to
go against the United Kingdom. Before that happens, there will be interim measures taken
and orders put in place. And even if the United Government took the view that it would not comply
with its international obligations, which would be a big step, others will. Other countries and
other organisations. And that means, in terms spelt out, that within months there would be
interference with the capabilities of the base. Interference physically, but also interference
with the sophisticated capabilities there, including spectrum as an example. And given
the importance of the base for our safety and security, the safety and security of our allies,
and the relationship that we have with the US, which is just an essential part of it,
no Prime Minister would allow that to happen. And my first duty as Prime Minister is to keep
this country safe and secure. And no Prime Minister, with that duty, would allow this
facility to be at risk, which it would be if we didn't sign this treaty. Thank you very much.
Can I add, the last government recognised the jeopardy of British control over Diego Garcia.
That's why, as the Prime Minister said earlier, they conceded the principle that negotiations
were necessary. They conducted 11 rounds of negotiation before the election. They failed
to do a deal. We picked up the challenge. We picked up the negotiations. We toughened the terms
and the protections and the control that Britain can exercise through this treaty. And within 10
months we've landed this deal that the Prime Minister has signed today. Now on the money,
this is an essential investment in our national security. It's less than 0.2% of the defence
budget. It means that we can invest to strengthen our armed forces to face down the increasing
threats that we face. And I just say to you, as a result of this deal today and in the years ahead,
our armed forces are safer and they're stronger because of what we do on Diego Garcia.
Before I pass to the General, can I just add on this question of why did you have to take
this measure? It is worth reminding ourselves who is in favour of this treaty, this deal,
and who's against it. In favour are all of our allies. The US, NATO, Five Eyes, India.
Against it, Russia, China, Iran. And surprisingly, the leader of the opposition and Nigel Farage
are in that column alongside Russia, China and Iran,
rather than the column that has the UK and its allies in it.
Johnny, thank you for the question. Now I respect Jack Wattling a lot, but I'm afraid on this case
I'm going to have to disagree with him as I believe he's wrong in his view. The value of
Diego Garcia I think has been set out in the remarks that you've heard from all three speakers.
And as the commander responsible for operations on Diego Garcia, any risk to that future operation
to me would be an intolerable risk to take with our national security. And I think that risk would
manifest itself in our capability to operate being eroded in the very near future. I think it would
be degraded significantly over time and ultimately we run the risk of losing control.
Now I think that risk would be intolerable. We must have long-term assurance and control.
There is no other viable option to provide that assurance and control. And the irreplaceable,
vital and in many ways priceless asset that Diego Garcia is, must be guaranteed for us
to be able to continue our operations. It's an essential element of our fighting power.
Prime Minister, what do you say to people who can't understand why you can find 100 million
a year, billions over 99 years, but you can't find money to support people with disabilities.
And you were a human rights lawyer. You're having to make this deal because of an international
legal ruling. But the Chagossians that brought that case last night, that got that temporary
injunction, feel that it breaches their human rights and they're being treated just as shoddily
as when the government booted them out of the Chagoss Islands back in the 60s. What do you say
to them? Well let me take all three parts of that question. In answer to your first question,
the answer is the first duty of a Prime Minister is to keep the country safe and secure. And this
base is vital in that respect. Its location, its physical use and its capability, including the
spectrum capability. That capability has already had huge impact around the globe in relation to
combating and defeating our adversaries. It is vital to keep our armed forces safe in their
operations and it is, as I say, measured against other defence spend. It is year on year less than
the cost of running an aircraft carrier minus the aircraft. And so it is really important that a
Prime Minister doesn't shirk when it comes to national security. That is the number one duty
and responsibility of any Prime Minister. It is a duty and responsibility that I take extremely
seriously. In relation to legal rulings, true there has already been an advisory opinion against
us. And true it is, but for this treaty there would certainly be further legal proceedings
leading to binding judgements with interim orders on the way which would be put in place in a number
of months. Now even if I stood here and said to you the UK government would defy international law,
which would be an extremely unusual position to take, others won't. Other countries and other
organisations. And that means the risk of interference with the capability is there
because of the action of others. And once that uncertainty comes into place, then that means the
ability to control physically interference with the base, to control interference with things like
spectrum, is immediately in place, which risks the capability of the base and puts it at risk within
a matter of months. Nobody knowing the capability of this base and the importance to us and to the
Americans, nobody who's looked at this in any detail, would ever put that capability at risk.
So yes, there's an international law question here, but my decision is actually based on our
national security and the action of others. And faced with advice that that capability
would be lost in a short period of time because of legal uncertainty, and knowing how important
the capability is, that's not a decision that I or any responsible Prime Minister would ever take.
And anybody who argues the contrary, in my view, is not fit to be Prime Minister.
On the question of the Chagossians, look, there are different views amongst the community,
but there was a legal challenge and that argument had to be made. And in a way, I'm glad it's made
because now it has been aired, now it has been heard, now it has been argued in court. But what
happened at 12.30 today is we got the judgment of the High Court having heard the argument,
and that judgment was in favour of the government. Thank you. I've got David Sheppard from the FT.
Thank you, Prime Minister. David Sheppard from the Financial Times.
Forgive me for asking a little bit more on the numbers around this. You've spoken of
101 million average over 99 years and a total cost of around 3.4 billion.
A lot of the journalists here are asking, if you times 101 million,
you get closer to 10 billion. Can I deal with that straight away? That is the net cost,
and the reason it's put in those terms is because that is how the government accounts for it,
it's how the OBR counts the cost, and it's the way public sector projects are measured.
In other words, what's the net cost today? And that is 3.4 billion pounds. Obviously, over time
with inflation, then that is the net cost, but this isn't a way of presenting it for the purposes
of this particular project. That is the way the government presents an account for a public sector
project. It's the way the OBR takes account of them when they're doing their assessments,
and whether it's defence and, in fact, nuclear, that net cost is the cost that's used, which is
why the figures are presented in that way. The 101 million is the average rolling over the period
of the lease, which is 99 years, extendable by 40 extra years. Having got the maths out of the
way, can I ask my actual question? Given the vital importance of this base, not just to the UK,
but to our allies, will we be asking allies like the United States to make additional contributions
towards the payment? Let me deal with that directly, because this is a capability that
is of vital use to both the UK and the US. We obviously have, in relation to the US,
a special relationship on defence and security and intelligence sharing. No two countries
share intelligence in the way that the UK and the US do. In relation to this base, which we
both make huge use of, we are paying under this treaty, in the way I've just set out,
the US is paying the running cost of the base, which are much greater than the cost that we are
paying. Therefore, there are different contributions to different aspects, if you like.
We are paying under the treaty in the way that's set out. The US are paying the running costs of
the base, which are far greater than the cost that we are bearing. Together, there is obviously that
shared interest in the base, a vital capability for both of us. Thank you very much. I've got
Claire Sadler from BFBS. Hi. What would you say to UK military personnel who are either stationed
there or passing through there, who might be concerned about the change in the dynamics
in the region? Also, what guarantees are there that any military operations are going to be
able to continue totally uninterrupted? Well, the message would be, whether it's merchant
personality or any other personnel, is you are safer now as a result of this treaty,
because the uncertainty would have led to a potential compromise of this
facility. So it is really important. In terms of military personnel, this base, this facility,
has been used to protect our forces many times over. By securing this treaty, this deal,
it is now fully in place to protect them for 100 years, generations, with an option to
add another 40 years to that. And as the Defence Secretary set out, not only the base,
but the outer islands come under this treaty, and an ability to control what happens up to 100
nautical miles from the base. So in terms of the protection of our military, our armed forces,
our service personnel, this ensures that they have the maximum protection,
wherever they may be, in just the same way as we've had before. And that is amongst the reasons
that was uppermost in my mind when I took the decision that I did, that this was vital for
our national security. Thank you all very much. Thank you.
