05/19/2025 - Vice Ranking Member Casten testifies in opposition of S.J. Res. 13 at Rules Committee

U.S. House Committee of Financial Services
42 followers
May 20, 2025
Connect with the House Financial Services Committee
» Get the latest news: https://democrats-financialservices.house.gov/
» Follow us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/USHouseFSC
» Follow us on Twitter: https://x.com/USHouseFSC
» Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ushousefsc/
» Follow us on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/ushousefsc.bsky.social
___________________________________
» Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@USHouseFSC?sub_confirmation=1
___________________________________
Chair Fox, Ranking Member McGovern,
members of the committee. Thank you for
having me. Uh, I appear on behalf of
ranking uh member Waters to urge the
committee not to advance SJRES 13 to the
floor. Um, and I would I would observe
in response to Mr. Flood's comment,
America does not actually have a
shortage of big banks. Um, and we don't
have any apparent problem with allowing
them to merge. What we do have, we've
got financial reform experts, consumer
groups, members of Congress who've been
raising concerns for years that banking
regulators have been rubber stamping
bank merger applications and have not
fully scrutinize those applications to
ensure that they require comply with
statutory requirements provide benefit
to affected constituencies and don't
undermine financial stability. The
result has been less competition, more
costly products for consumers, more
banking deserts across the country as
local banks are subsumed into larger
regional and national players. Point of
fact data here, the last time that bank
regulators in America rejected a merger
application was more than two decades
ago in
2003. During that same period, the
number of community banks in the United
States has fallen by 46%. That's 3,600
small banks that are gone since the last
time we reviewed a bank merger
application. Former President Biden
responded to this problem with an
executive order encouraging the
Department of Justice and banking
regulators to update their merger review
procedures, which had not been updated
since
1995. The OC was one of the agencies
that updated its procedures through a
rule issued after a notice and comment
period last year. And I want to
highlight just a couple points of that
rule that are really important. First,
the rule eliminated a prior requirement
that mergers must be automatically
approved within 15 days of the end of
the comment comment period when a target
bank has less than 50% of the assets of
the acquiring
bank. That's really important to the
health of small banks because
effectively it means that it is much
easier for a small bank to raise capital
by selling to a bigger national regional
bank than by merging with a local bank.
um the that that rubber stamp has
contributed significantly to that rapid
decline of those lower community banks.
And I pointed as the St. Louis Fed has
noted, community banks are quote unqued
to meet the challenges of lending to
small businesses as they have deep
insight into the local economic
conditions of business opportunities. So
when we cut community banks, we heard of
small businesses in our communities. I'd
also note given the volume of Doge
driven layoffs at the OC, any mandated
review time coupled with fewer reviewers
means there's going to be less
regulatory scrutiny. So eliminating this
OC rule now will only accelerate the
demise of our community banks to the
detriment of the small businesses on
which our economy depends.
Second, the OC rule brought transparency
by including a new policy statement to
clarify how the OC would evaluate
statutory factors like financial
stability, managerial resources, and
community needs. Given the broader
uncertainties in our economy right now,
we should not be removing a rule that is
designed to make it easier for
businesses to plan with certainty.
Third, the rule ensured that mergers
resulting in banks with more than $50
billion in total assets would receive
more scrutiny potentially by convening
public hearings. It should be in all of
our interest to ensure that limited
government resources are preferentially
and efficiently allocated to the most
significant challenges.
Finally, and most
problematically, this CRA would not
rescend anything because President
Trump's acting controller of the
currency already rescended this rule
last week when he issued an interim
final rule that took effect on May 15th.
So, as a practical matter, while I
disagree with the policy of that
decision, if we bring this to the floor,
we are making no change in the near
term. We are simply assuming that if the
current acting controller of the
currency is not infallible and makes a
mistake, we can't go back and fix this
later. Now, that matters in part because
the OC is not the only bank regulator.
Depending on who you are as a bank, a
merger may be subject to the
jurisdiction of the FDI, maybe just
subject to the jurisdiction of the Fed.
And so by only weakening one of them,
we're creating a regulatory arbitrage
opportunity where banks can seek to
merge with banks that have a charter
where the primary regulator has the
weakest review standards. I would point
out that that happened in 2008. The
weakest banks were trying to get
charters from the weakest regulator, the
office of thrift supervision, and we had
to shut them down in 2008. We should not
be repeating past mistakes.
Fred Khan who was the head of the civil
aviation administration under Ronald
Reagan famously said oversaw the
deregulation of that agency. He famously
said that the process of deregulation
shifts the burden of consumer protection
from rate setting to antitrust
enforcement and it fails when it
abandons the former without implementing
the latter. So, we find ourselves in a
situation now where the weakening of
financial regulators coupled with the
recent recision of this OC rule is going
to create a wild west where only the
biggest and most well-connected survive.
That is not capitalism. That is Mad Max
anarchy. Our job, I'd suggest our
responsibility as the article one branch
should be to check those excesses from
the article 2 branch, not simply act as
a rubber stamp for their actions uh in
the way that they would like the OC to
be for big bank mergers. Um, so in
conclusion, I'd like to emphasize this
committee that our constituents sent us
here to make our economy stronger, to
make our entrepreneurs more successful,
and to prevent financial instability,
not just to defund the white collar
police until a financial crisis comes
that we can try to blame on our
predecessors. That vein, I urge members
to reject the resolution and look
forward to any questions you may have.
