The MOST advanced CARBON FIBER SHIELD ever made put to the test!

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
3 Video Views·May 20, 2025
Okay, oh that is, that is, I can't get it,
it's not helping, you're in the middle of battle, just a sec, just a sec.
Carbon fiber, some say it is stronger than steel. Hang on, hang on, it's not actually
stronger than steel, although it kind of is. Depends on the use case. Yeah, I mean carbon
fiber has really great tensile strength, and that's why it's interlayered, like cross-hatched,
and that maximizes the kind of angular advantage of it, and so it becomes really stiff. And in
that sense, I think the tensile strength is actually stronger than steel. I'm not sure.
But in terms of holding its structure right, it relies on the resin and other things.
Okay, okay, fine, carbon fiber, in some ways it's stronger than steel,
which raises the really important question, what happens if you were to make armor out of it?
With how powerful carbon fiber is, surely armor made out of it could practically stop anything,
including bullets. Well, we can't actually test that, so. Yeah, we don't, we don't have guns,
we will be testing it against everything else, and I don't think it could stop bullets.
Maybe a .22? May, really? It's Kevlar on the back.
Oh, it does have Kevlar on the back. Okay, so it might be able to stop some
really small caliber of firearms, because it's just that amazing in that tough carbon fiber,
and in this episode of Shatterversity, we are going to be putting it to the test,
by testing an authentic Kai shield. Hang on, no, no, no, it's not a Kai shield,
it's a heater shield. That's the size of a heater shield. Shut up, nerd, it's a shield.
Bloody geeks. This carbon fiber shield is made out of a composite layer of carbon fiber,
soric cores, and even Kevlar, specifically engineered to be as strong and tough as
possible, because this is the question, could you engineer a piece of medieval armor with modern
and advanced materials to be far stronger than anything that you could find in the medieval
period? That is what we will be testing here on Shatterversity. I think our new intro guy's
overdoing it a bit. A little bit.
Yeah. Greetings, I'm Shad.
And greetings, I'm Tyreth. And Tyreth, look, something that the
intro guy did get right, we have something really cool and particularly advanced.
Yes, you guys might know James, we've gone and visited him, he's been helping with the
Titan Sword project, specifically a lot of carbon fiber and Kevlar stuff, and he made this for us.
Yes. So, James actually teaches, what, composite materials in university. He is an absolute legend,
and he, interestingly, he is really intrigued by testing out different strength kind of layering
methods for these advanced materials, and just so happens, the type of people that can test these
kind of, you know, experiments to their breaking point in somewhat valid ways, it's us here on
Shatterversity.
Interestingly enough, he, because this is not the first time he has sent us something
specifically related to armor, he sent us the Kevlar shield. Funnily enough, that video didn't
do, like, that crazy, which is fascinating, because that Kevlar shield for its weight,
its size, and its thickness was incredible.
It was really tough.
Compared to Kevlar, I reckon the carbon fiber is not going to be as good.
Really? Because this is kind of a mix. This is almost, well, it's hard to say if this is an
upgrade or the advanced version, because this is a test of different composite materials,
which include Kevlar. The last shield was just pure Kevlar and resin.
What I mean is, I reckon the carbon fiber in this particular use case isn't going to
add that much. If this was Kevlar instead, this top layer, I reckon it would be way stronger.
I don't know.
Because that Kevlar, like, it almost stopped the back. It was pretty crazy.
I, do you reckon this will stop the back?
I reckon it might, just because it's so thick, and we do have that
last layer of Kevlar on the back. So the carbon fiber might do all right,
simply because it's paired with the Kevlar.
Well, let's talk about the composite materials that this is made out of,
because this is actually a pretty advanced kind of structure right here.
It's not just carbon fiber, and that's it.
To get the best results and performances out of carbon fiber,
you actually specifically layer it and combine it in different methods.
And so you can actually combine it with different weaves.
The weave pattern of a carbon fiber actually does matter.
And then in terms of the layering, one of the things that is incredible about this
is how insanely stiff it is.
This is stiffer. I cannot bend or flex it at all. Stiffer than wood, right?
And what might surprise a lot of people is this looks kind of thick.
It's maybe about like a plywood sheet, kind of that thickness.
But most of this is actually just like a foam soric core.
I mean, it's not really foam anymore because the resin has hardened it,
but there's only like, I would say a one millimeter thick sheet of carbon fiber on the front.
Then we have a maybe three, four millimeter thick soric core.
Then it looks like a Kevlar and carbon fiber weave in the middle.
Then another thin layer of soric core.
And then on the back, maybe one millimeter, 1.5 millimeter Kevlar sheet on the back.
So most of this is foam.
Yeah. And so a soric core is a foam layer that's made to like add a cushioning barrier thickness,
right, between carbon fiber layers.
And they get stuck together really tight because it's the same resin that's holding it all together.
And the resin kind of fills out the soric core, but it's slightly...
It's not aerated, but it's so light.
Yeah.
It's crazy.
Well, this thing, like how much would you say this weighs? Do you want to weigh it?
Okay. So we have a more valid historical analog in my other heater shield here,
and I know it's not perfect.
It shouldn't have this tin, you know, fringe lining.
It does have a cloth cover over top of it.
It's a type of linen that's glued.
And so anyway, in terms of weight, it'll be comparable enough.
And so this shield here, 3.2 kilos as a comparison.
And then the carbon fiber Kevlar mix, 1.7 kilos.
And this is nowhere near as thick as that either.
No.
This is thinner.
It is.
The interesting thing is, because we also have...
This was our last test piece.
This is just a piece of Kevlar.
It's probably about, let's say, 3.5 millimeters thick.
Very thin. 540 grams.
And it held up pretty good for that.
It is about half the size.
It is.
What I'm bringing up now is the issue with something like this,
even though it can stop quite a lot, it doesn't really have any mass,
which means that it's not very good at shock absorption.
So even though it might protect you against something,
it's probably going to break your bones.
So having a little bit more mass on it, a little bit more chunk to it is a good thing.
Okay, then the only thing left is to actually put it to the test.
Predictions?
I'm not sure.
I don't know either.
I don't think we're going to get through with most things.
Yeah, this is going to be a wild card.
I think it's going to come down to the back.
So often it comes down to the back.
If you're not familiar, it's called the Beck to Corbin.
It's a historical type of polearm.
You'll get to see it in this video.
It's one of the most deadly medieval weapons we've ever tested.
Yeah, it's kind of our final boss of weapons.
All right, let's get to it.
Let's do it.
To begin with, we'll be hitting with a nice tough bastard sword.
This is actually the re-hilted Honshu broadsword.
And all right, let's give it a go.
So gosh, the angle of attack, man.
This is tricky.
This one here is the Honshu single-handed broadsword.
Same sort of variety as the last one.
There's also an affiliate link down below if you want to get one of these
because we've tested this thing completely.
So let's see how it goes against some carbon fiber.
Interesting.
All right, just from the sword test, I'm a bit surprised.
Yeah.
So carbon fiber, because it relies on tensile strength,
has pretty good properties in terms of trying to bust through it.
It resists that quite well.
But the strikes on the sides, they dug in deep.
Yeah.
Like I said, I think this is going to perform a little bit worse than the Kevlar one.
I think it will, actually.
And the reason why I think it dug in so deep is the sword core just isn't resistive.
Yeah, it doesn't give it the type of resistive structure that it needs
for this particular application.
Although, that makes me think, if you did have a rim of something really tough around the edge,
that could add a lot of strength.
The thing is, though, this type of penetration
is almost the exact type you do want with a medieval shield.
The reason why this isn't a bad thing, it does stop a strike,
but the weapon then gets trapped in the shield
and you can manipulate the opponent's weapon away.
This is a feature of many historical shields.
Sure, but I think in this particular case, when we make a carbon fiber shield,
we want it to be better.
I think that's the point here, right?
What do you want to move up to next?
Because we have a couple of different things that I think,
before we get into the destruction stuff,
perhaps throwing a spear or firing a bow.
I reckon spear and bow are next.
Interesting.
So the arrows actually penetrated, but we're only talking about like half a centimeter.
They still got through though, which was more than the spear and the swords.
Yes, not enough to injure anyone.
The shield is doing what it needs to do.
At the moment, it is performing easily well enough for a functional shield.
But you've got to remember the interesting thing about this
is it's actually the Kevlar at the back that's doing the heavy lifting.
That's it! You know you're right.
Though there is that Kevlar layer in between that's also towards the back,
which is definitely probably doing something.
But so far, the carbon fiber hasn't done much.
Now, this isn't really a surprise to me because we've done this carbon fiber stuff
and the carbon fiber, as much as you guys love it,
and like everybody seems to really like carbon fiber, it's alright.
We have tested, we have a carbon fiber armor video
where we have multiple different plates of carbon fiber in different grades
where this was specifically engineered to function as a shield
with the sonic core being thicker.
Now, at the moment, it's performing almost about the same
as those thinner carbon fiber plates, don't you think?
Yeah, I'd probably say around the same.
I'm still impressed though for like 1.5 kilos.
That's pretty light.
We're getting good performance for its weight.
Yeah, absolutely.
Strength to weight ratio is good.
Now, we should actually mention that these arrows were shot from this bow,
which is a 110 pound war bow.
It does not look like it because it's so small,
but this thing slaps.
It has a kick to it.
And now this is kind of almost lower end,
but still very much in the war bow, you know, range.
And so it gives good feedback for that.
Different arrowheads could do bring different results.
I mean, these arrowheads are...
They're chunky, but they're not bodkins.
I reckon a bodkin might...
They're still pretty good though.
Pretty good.
Though I reckon that from, what, nearly like 160 pound bow,
you would probably be penetrating by about that much.
That's usually what we see on tests done on medieval level shields.
You do get a chunk of penetration on from a very powerful bow.
It's interesting that this is getting similar results.
Well, keep in mind that if this was like an actual shield,
it should be like double the thickness.
And that thickness will...
That'll stop a lot more.
That is interesting because you should bear in mind that it's thicker...
This is thicker than our Kevlar shield,
but it is about half as thick as what a historical heater shield would be.
And it's offering nearly about the same level of, you know, resistance.
The interesting thing is the actual...
Like a proper shield might be like double the weight.
Yes.
So if you doubled that up...
Double the thickness and then double the weight,
you're probably four times heavier than this and twice as thick.
So this is actually still...
Alright, this is hitting above, you know, above its own weight class, right?
It's all relative.
It is, it is.
Though, now let's see how tough it is against some really damaging, damaging weapons.
Let's do it.
Did you know we are making exclusive full-length episodes just for our supporters?
This week's release is us reacting to more of those McDojo sword delusions.
It actually gets even more crazy if you can believe it.
YouTube is in such a state at the moment that the only way we can continue making this content,
even the free content, is purely thanks to our supporters.
You guys are literally the ones that are comprising most of our revenue,
supporting the business and is able to make this content.
So if you want to help support us continue to make this content,
the stuff that is available for free,
and get access to the exclusive great content.
This is like full-length videos for as little as $1 a month.
You can get access to that content and also help support the channel.
Remember this week's video is a fun reaction to the sword illusion stuff.
It's great.
It's either released or going to be released this week as little as $1 a month
on Subscribestar, Patreon or channel memberships.
And then you get all that backlog content as well.
Like great episodes.
So do support if you're able to and let's get back to the video.
Yeah.
Oh baby.
Just before we move on to the bigger axe,
Shad, can you try and remove that?
Okay.
Oh that is, that is...
So you would have effectively disarmed yourself.
Yes.
There's no way in combat you're wrenching that out.
Like I can get it.
You're in the middle of battle.
Just a sec, just a sec.
It's interesting because I think that all the fibers of the Kevlar...
Oh, it's gripping.
Yeah.
Like I got a half way out and it was still gripping.
Yeah.
So like, look, that is deep penetration,
but that's not enough to kill someone.
No.
I mean, if it hit your hand, it would be, you'd be feeling it.
Yeah.
Low percentage, you would just manage to get the hand.
The problem is getting that out was actually quite difficult.
That was.
That like, that's another kind of feature to the shield, honestly.
Like now, we've loosened the head.
We have, we have loosened the axe head from that.
This was brand new.
Well, we haven't, we haven't swung it that hard at anything, we should say.
Before, since buying it.
And okay.
Like, even though that did good damage, like there's cracking.
Although the structure is still solid in there.
We're still good, we're still good.
But obviously that, that, you know.
Yeah.
That just went through.
I actually think the shield won that even though this got through.
Yes. Because of the context.
The context.
All right, let's get to the Dane Axe.
Big boy.
Though the Dane Axe doesn't have a spike on it.
So I'm nervous now.
All right, I might build up.
Let's go soft.
But holy.
All right, no, no, it's okay.
It handled that fine.
That was like 50%.
Okay.
But the power, the power behind just that 50% hit.
The edge angle was hard to be, like it, it fell a little down on the hit, I reckon.
Oh, dude, that was.
That's fun.
Oh boy.
I don't know how the mics picked that up, but the sound of that is like a gunshot.
It cracks.
And look at the damage we did on this.
Like, this is actually cracked.
And, and like, like if you, I can feel this was so stiff before this is, you can see it.
Oh, look, look, it's delaminated.
Yeah.
Look at this.
This is, this is.
Wow.
Look at that.
That, that has destroyed it.
And not only that, there was so much force smacking into this.
That has the potential to break someone's arm behind the shield.
And if not, that would like dead, make the arm dead.
They would feel pain a lot.
I don't think you would.
I think that would break it.
That would break your arm.
That's yeah.
You're not taking that one.
What do you want to do next?
The Beck is next, but we've kind of, the shield is already at the failing point.
If we aim for the parts, that's still solid.
The Beck spike might be interesting though, because we penetrated with the, uh, the battle
axe spike, you know, the Beck is going to get through it because I've already tested
with what I would almost call a demolition level weapon.
Like this Danax was hitting with more force than the Beck.
We could feel it.
Kind of.
It's, it's definitely in the realm.
But because we have longer leverage is a bit longer than the Beck and the ax head is operating
in a different thing where the Beck's hammer head is smaller.
This was actually impacting.
I could feel it with more force or at least as much, if not more than the Beck.
So that was crazy.
What I think we should do is I reckon the beak of the Beck is just going to get through.
Like it's going to get through all the way.
The hammer is an interesting one because I think we need to hit somewhere here or down
here and the spots that aren't compromised to see how much damage.
If we hit the hammer here, this is already just.
So even though I think we have proven that if this is serious, serious gear business,
you want to see the Beck.
And so we're going to, we're going to throw the Beck against it.
Okay.
Do you want to do the Beck?
Of course I do.
Okay.
All right.
Well, cause I've got to move the cameras around.
So this is the mighty Beck.
A lot of you guys here obviously watched a lot of these episodes.
Know what this is.
This is a monster.
And this is what we call our final boss.
So what I'm going to do is I'm going to use the hammer and try and hit these areas here
that are untouched so we can get some valid results.
Maybe I spoke too soon when I said the Danax can hit harder.
Yeah.
No chance.
The test though.
Yeah.
Has it been, have you been disarmed?
So don't stand there.
Okay.
No.
I couldn't get that out.
That's interesting.
Ready?
Yep.
It's just a different level of destruction.
It is.
So I think I spoke too soon when I said the Danax is hitting harder than the Beck.
And look, it was been a while since we swung the thing.
I kind of forgot.
And the Danax was such a leap up in power from the Battleaxe to this that I was so impressed.
And then I kind of forgot how powerful and dominating the Beck is.
Because when we moved to the Beck, holy crap.
It doesn't mean the Danax was bad.
It was fantastic.
It's just how it transfers the force.
It's just that hammerhead is just...
It concentrates it.
And even though I felt kind of more massive momentum in the Danax,
the fact that this just drives it right onto that small head.
What do you think though?
Because this is interesting.
I think that this isn't as good as the Kevlar one.
Now, when I say that, I mean, if that Kevlar one was the same thickness as this one,
I reckon we wouldn't be able to get through.
I would actually agree with that.
The Kevlar was a third as thick as this.
And it was even lighter.
And honestly, it was performing about equal to what this is at the moment.
And Kevlar is just one of those things where there's a reason why you use it to catch bullets.
It's just good at catching things.
Now, obviously, it's a bit different because there's resin in it.
There's a whole bunch of caveats there, sure.
But it still can trap those blades pretty good.
But in the sense of how well did this perform just on its own,
I actually think it is performing like as an adequate shield,
if not a bit above average for a standard medieval shield.
Well, here's the trade-off because what happened,
and this has happened consistently with a lot of these composite
sort of weapons and shields and whatnot,
is the compromisation of the structural integrity.
When we break through something, it starts to delaminate.
Yes.
This seems to be a common theme.
I'm not really sure how you could fix it.
But that basically renders it useless.
With wood, you don't really have delamination like that.
Yes.
But having said that, shields, like the video game idea,
I actually mentioned this in the misconceptions about video games and stuff, weapons and things.
There's this idea that a shield should be as durable as your armor, as your sword,
when actually, no, they were more disposable items.
Like if you take them into a battlefield,
you kind of expect it to only be top tier for that battlefield.
It's going to get so damaged if you're really engaging in combat
that it's basically done.
You'd throw it away and get a new one for the next battle.
Difference is, this doesn't grow on trees.
No, it doesn't.
This is expensive.
But if you had the money to just reproduce, right?
I think this is about probably a little less destructive.
The delamination is actually the weird part to it.
But in terms of its trapping capacity,
in terms of stopping weapons and catching them,
this is doing more than what a wood shield would be able to do.
And is it the fibers that are gripping?
Yeah, yeah.
I think the biggest issue with all of these sorts of composite stuff
is just dealing with that delamination.
I'm not sure how, but it needs to be dealt with
because it seems to be the common failure in all of these sorts.
We saw that with the carbon fiber sword.
That was one of the issues.
And what I'm kind of seeing,
the sword core is the main weak point in terms of the delamination.
Interestingly enough, though, the one thing that we didn't have delamination on
was the original carbon fiber knife I made.
Because it was just straight carbon fiber, there was nothing to delaminate.
Yeah, it was like more of a solid block.
Wasn't that the case with the Kevlar shield a bit, though?
But that's solid Kevlar, pretty much.
Exactly, but that's what I mean.
It seems like when you are mixing it up with different layers,
like sonic cores, that's a weak point for delamination.
When we say weak point, I mean for most applications that I can think of.
It's tough as hell.
It's fine, but for like shock absorption weapons.
Big impacts.
And especially like with the carbon fiber sword,
the whole use of that is intense impact and shock on the blade.
And as a result, the delamination effect is coming in.
Yeah, I think it's still held up pretty, like it's good.
This is not bad.
It's just, I do think that the Kevlar would be a bit better.
Let us know what you guys think.
In fact, you can check out the Kevlar shield video right there.
And see how well it performs.
Because we test, you know, the Beck against it and similar weapons.
But it was really interesting to see how a different design one,
with different materials.
Because this is more affordable to make than the Kevlar one.
Because Kevlar is more expensive.
But check out the Kevlar shield video right there.
Thanks for watching guys.
Cheers guys.
Did you get that out?
Free shield.
