USA Bonds Crisis

Financial Freedom
10 followers
#finance
#financement
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:23 DOWNGRADE
1:27 RATINGS
3:54 COUNTRY COMPARISON
5:10 BOND YIELDS
6:29 NATIONAL DEBT
7:45 INTEREST COSTS
9:26 IMPLICATIONS
10:45 USA BONDS
13:15 SUMMARY & CONCLUSION
Hi, welcome back to Joe Blogs. In today's episode I want to talk to you about what's happening in
the economy in the USA because Moody's, the rating agency, has just downgraded the USA's
credit rating and you might not be thinking that that's a very big issue but actually
that is when you've got 36 trillion dollars worth of debt in the market. This summary here shows
why Moody's have downgraded the US's credit rating and you can see that the number one
reason here at the top is persistent deficits. The USA continues to run large and what's
considered by Moody's to be unsustainable fiscal deficits year after year. They're also concerned
about the rising interest costs on the 36 trillion dollars worth of debt. They're saying interest
payments on national debt has surged now exceeding defense spending. They're also concerned about
the actual level of the debt which has now exceeded 36 trillion with projections showing
further growth in the amount of debt. They've raised political dysfunction as an issue saying
ongoing partisan gridlock hinders meaningful long-term fiscal reform and they're also concerned
about a lack of fiscal action saying policymakers have failed to implement credible plans to reduce
Now in terms of who Moody's are there are basically three main credit rating agencies
and we have a look here you can see that they're called Moody's, Fitch and S&P Global and actually
Moody's is the last of these three rating agencies to downgrade the USA. You can see
that that happened on May the 16th from the previous top rating agent in Moody's the top
score of A, capital A, two small a's quite a strange system. I don't know why they don't
implement exactly the same ratings but they don't they have their own particular flavor.
You can see that Fitch previously were rating the USA triple A or all in capitals but they
downgraded it on the 1st of August 2023 so quite a long time ago and S&P Global actually downgraded
the USA on the 5th of August 2011 so almost 14 years ago. So the current ratings are now sitting
at the second tier for all three of these agencies you might be thinking well does that really matter
does anybody care what Moody's and Fitch and S&P Global are saying well they do in the bond markets
because the bond markets is basically broken down into people who buy bonds and people who do the
research on the bonds and rate them and these three agencies are the ones that are rating
national debt so they're basically saying what the risk is on that debt and the reason why it's
important is because as the risk increases if the rating goes down and it's considered to be more
risky than it was last week for example that's what Moody's are saying about the USA's debt
then the cost of that debt will go up and that's obviously a concern if you've got 36 trillion
worth of debt. Now in terms of what these ratings actually mean this is the definitions that have
been given by the different agencies so you can see that Moody's AA1 which is what the USA is now
rated at is regarded as high grade and it's seen to be very strong credit worthiness but lower than
top tier AAA due to rising debt and fiscal risks. S&P Global's second rating AA plus is also rated
as high grade and it's seen to be very strong capacity to meet obligations but vulnerable to
economic shocks or political dysfunction and Fitts rating of AA plus also high grade says strong
credit quality below AAA due to concerns over governance and long-term fiscal trajectory. Now
in terms of which countries are rated the highest in the world I thought it'd be interesting to have
a look at which countries have maintained the top tier rating with all of the agencies and you
can see that this is in alphabetical order so I'm not saying that Australia is the strongest country
in the world they're just alphabetically at the top of this list but they have a perfect score
with all three agencies. Canada only has a perfect score with Moody's and S&P and has the second
rating the same as the USA with Fitch but still pretty strong and then we've got Denmark, Germany,
Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Singapore, Sweden, Switzerland, Lichtenstein which might be
a surprise to some people certainly surprised to me, the European Union and then we've got the
United States at the bottom of this list just as a comparison to show that they're at the second tier
for all of these different agencies. Now in terms of why this is important as I mentioned earlier
the reason why ratings are critical to investors is because they want to see higher payments in
terms of interest costs for higher risk so now that the USA has been downgraded there is a problem
because they're probably going to see the cost of their debt increasing so I thought it was worth
adding the average 10-year bond yield or the current 10-year bond yield to this list just to
show what countries are paying and clearly just because you're higher rated doesn't mean that
you're going to pay a very low cost you can see that there is a complete spread here in terms of
what these countries are paying so Australia although it has a perfect score its current
10-year bond yield is over 4.5 percent which is actually higher than the USA's around 4.4 percent
but you can see here that Canada's are coming in at 3.2, Denmark 2.3, Germany 2.6, Luxembourg just
over 3, the Netherlands 2.8, Norway just over 4, Singapore 2.5, Sweden 2.3, Switzerland 0.3 so it's
got a perfect score with all three agencies and it's only paying 0.3 percent coupon on its 10-year
bonds. Liechtenstein we don't have any 10-year bonds so I can't give you the data for that and
the European Union 3.1 percent which is quite a lot lower than what the USA is currently paying
for its 10-year bonds. Now obviously when you're looking at national debt you need to look at the
total number but you also need to take into account what the GDP is for that country to
look at the GDP ratio so I thought it was worth showing this table which shows the total amount
of debt that countries have you can see the USA has by far the most in the world over 36 trillion
dollars. Japan has over 10 trillion but interestingly when you compare the two in
terms of debt to GDP ratio the United States is 124 percent Japan's is 216 percent so that is a
much higher ratio that means that its leverage is much higher it's not producing anywhere near as
much GDP as the USA and its ratio is off the scale compared to the US's. We can see for the rest of
the countries here most of them are coming in at less than 100 percent so we've got Germany, Canada,
Australia, Switzerland, Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands and Denmark and Luxembourg in that category and
in Singapore interestingly 173 percent. Now having a look at what's going on with regards to the
interest costs is probably the critical part of this video because as the risk goes up because
the rating has gone down it means that the USA is now likely to have to pay more for any new bond
issuances and that's going to increase the total debt burden so this table shows the total amount
of debt for the countries we just looked at what the current 10-year bond yield is and what each of
these countries is paying on average each year for its interest costs so you can see that the United
States its current 10-year bond yield is 4.4 percent now we'll have a look at the details on
that in a moment and it's paying over 890 billion dollars in interest costs and if you did a
calculation to show 36 trillion times 4.43 obviously it doesn't come out at 892 billion
it would come out at somewhere like 1.6 trillion but because the US has been issuing bonds over a
long period of time it's got a weighted average which is much lower than 4.3 percent and we'll go
on to talk about that in a moment and you can see here that the debt burden for all of these
different countries varies wildly because obviously they've got different amounts of debt
and they're paying a different amount for their bonds but the critical thing here for the US
is that as its old bonds are maturing if you issued a bond 10 years ago and maybe two percent
as that's maturing when you're replacing it with a new bond it's going to cost you 4.4 percent
currently and that's the problem is that this interest bill for the US of currently 890 billion
is going to rise significantly because rates are much higher now but also because of this rating
downgrade it's now likely that the cost is going to increase possibly more than that 4.3 percent
so in terms of looking at the impact of what's going on at the moment with regards to this
rating downgrade you can see as we've said the US has 36 trillion of debt the weighted average
interest rate is currently somewhere in the region of 2.75 to 3 percent so on average that's what the
US is paying on all of its debt but as it goes forward that's going to rise because the current
rate is sitting at more than 4.4 percent and the reason why the overall rate is rising is that
older debt with lower rates is now rolling off and it's being replaced by these higher rates
and the net interest payments will exceed defense spending in 2026 and is likely to hit 1.6 trillion
at some point in the 2030s if things continue at the current level if it continues adding more debt
and also the current cost of that debt stays at around the same sort of level and the implications
of this for the USA are really quite serious because interest is now the fastest growing
federal expense that's what the biggest category is where cash is going it's crowding out spending
of other priorities like health care infrastructure and defense so the USA is having to spend more on
interest than it is on all of those categories and it makes deficit reductions much harder
without tax hikes or spending cuts so that's the reality that you're facing when you've got a rising
interest bill now in terms of what's happening with the 10-year bond yield which is generally
seen as the ballpark metric that you'd want to look at for the cost of your debt you can see
that over the past 10 years there's been a significant increase 10 years ago back in 2015
the US was paying on average around two percent for its new issuance bonds today it's paying
almost 4.5 so the cost of the new bond issuance is more than double what it was 10 years ago now
you can see that in after the COVID-19 pandemic the price actually fell significantly it was less
than one percent so that was a great time to issue a lot of debt because that was very cheap if it's
happy days but the problem that the US has is that it hasn't been paying its debt down and as
those bonds start to mature the two percent bonds the one percent bonds are maturing they're being
replaced by 4.5 percent bonds so the cost of that is going up double possibly as much as four times
higher than it has been historically so that's going to add a further burden to the interest
if we look at what's been happening over the past 12 months you can see that in September of 24
the cost of issuing 10-year bonds was actually down to around 3.6 percent so over the past six
months or so there's been a significant increase so even within that short space of time we've seen
bond costs rising for the USA and this rating downgrade is going to make things worse and if
have a look at this table it shows the overall impact of an increase in the yield on the debt
costs for the USA so you can see that even a 0.1 percent increase when you're talking about 336
trillion dollars worth of debt will cost you an additional 36 billion dollars every single year
if the cost goes up by half a percent 0.5 percent the additional cost is 180 billion and if it goes
up by one percentage point and as we've just seen between September of 24 and now it's gone up by
8.85 percent so almost one percent and that was before this rating downgrade that adds an additional
361 billion dollars to the total interest charge that the USA is having to pay and obviously that's
a major problem so what's the summary and conclusion today well i wanted to post this video because the
the first time since 1919 that Moody's hasn't given the USA its top score rating this is a big
news event because it now means that the USA's debt is ranked at the second score by all three
agencies so they don't see it as being top level credit compared to other countries debt and the
world over 36 trillion dollars so its interest charge is a really critical part of the national
budget and when your rating is downgraded what that means is that it's going to cost you more
to issue new bonds because you no longer have that golden credit rating and just to give you
an indication as to why that's a problem if you're a fund manager if you're managing billions maybe
trillions of dollars you need to have a spread of risk so you'll have a certain portion of your
funds that have to go into triple a gold plated rating countries and debt and bonds and basically
the USA has now fallen off that list it's no longer in the top tier of debt so certain fund
managers will now have to exit from those US bonds because they no longer tick their spread of risk
in terms of where they're investing their money so it'll have an implication from the wider market
but also in terms of the individual cost of new bond issuance the rating is now lower so the cost
will be higher so this is going to add to the USA's debt burden and as we've just seen from the data
the USA has an average cost a weighted average cost of somewhere around 2.75 percent for all of
its bonds so as bonds are maturing as they're being repaid and they'll need to issue new bonds
to replace those existing ones because that's how it works if the USA has issued a hundred billion
dollars worth of debt and that hundred billion is coming up for maturity obviously the US doesn't
want to repay it doesn't want to use cash to give that money back to the holders of those bonds so
what it will do in reality is issue a hundred billion dollars of new bonds and use that cash
that it's just raised from new investors to pay back the old investors so you're basically changing
old debt for new debt but the problem that that represents is that the new debt is going to cost
something like 4.5 percent compared with 2.75 percent weighted average and as we saw in fact
some of the bonds have been issued at two percent and less than two percent so when you're changing
that debt for this new debt it's going to cost significantly more and the reason that that's an
issue is because you only have a limited amount of cash to spend on everything whether it's defense
or health care or interest payments and if interest payments are rising year on year which they are at
the moment because the debt's going up and the cost of the debt is also rising the individual cost
so the cumulative cost of the interest is growing rapidly that means that you have less money to
spend on everything else and that is the crux of the problem here so the overall summary of today's
video is that Moody's have now dropped their rating on the USA to the second tier that's going
to mean that the US has to pay more for its debt going forward and that's a problem when you've got
over 36 trillion dollars worth of debt so hopefully you've enjoyed today's video you found it useful
informative and thought-provoking if you've liked what I've said then please give me a thumbs up
thank you to everyone that's supporting me so thank you to watching this video to the end but also
thank you for everyone that sent me a YouTube super thanks or bought me a coffee or signed up
as a Patreon or a YouTube member or a buy me a coffee member really appreciate that support
and here's something to put a smile on your face
